Having sampled pizza all over the world, I decided to take on the challenge of finding the best pizza in this small town in Indiana. With a little sleuthing and plenty of taste testing, I’ve narrowed it down to twelve top contenders. In true food critic style, I’ll present them to you with humorous and lighthearted commentary about each place’s offerings.
So without further ado, let’s get this party started as we discover who has the best pizza in Noblesville!
If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Indiana
#1 Pies & Pints – Noblesville, IN
- Nice tourist spot
- Offers dessert
- Has a kid’s menu
- Has some vegetarian options
- Serves alcohol
The atmosphere is inviting and fun, with plenty of seating to accommodate small or large groups. The staff is friendly and attentive, making sure you always have a great experience.
The selection of pizzas on the menu is quite impressive. From the classic pepperoni to their signature pies topped with specialty ingredients, there’s something to please everyone in your party. I had the chance to try the Mexican Chorizo Pizza and it was truly delicious! All their pizzas are made with fresh ingredients, expertly cooked in their wood-fired oven for that authentic flavor.
I was also pleasantly surprised by Pies & Pints’ drink selection. They have some excellent craft beers and wines from around the world available. Additionally, they have some unique cocktails that easily rival any cocktail bar I’ve been to.
Overall, this place has earned its spot as one of the best pizza places in Noblesville! If you’re looking for an excellent night out or just want some tasty eats, I highly recommend checking out Pies & Pints – Noblesville!
If you’re willing to go an extra 6 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Fishers!
#2 Pizza by the Harbour
- Has some vegetarian options
The menu has an impressive selection of gourmet pizzas, including all the standards plus some specialty creations. I had the pleasure of trying out their popular seafood pizza and it was absolutely delicious. The combination of garlic, lemon, shrimp, and herbs was a delightful contrast to the traditional marinara-based pizzas I’m used to eating.
The atmosphere of Pizza by the Harbour is cozy yet upscale – definitely great for a date night or evening get-together with friends! And if you want to bring home a slice for later, they offer convenient takeout pizza boxes so you can easily bring it wherever you go.
But the true star of Pizza by the Harbour has to be their signature wood-fired ovens. These bad boys create a unique charred flavor that really elevates their pies above most other places in Noblesville. So if you’re looking for the best pizza in town, look no further than Pizza by the Harbour!
#3 Marco’s Pizza
- Offers dessert
- Has some vegetarian options
- Has a kid’s menu
The crust is perfectly cooked, giving it a great crunchy taste. The cheese and toppings are always fresh and delicious. And the sauce? Out of this world! They have some unique combinations, but even their classic pepperoni and mushroom pies are delicious.
The atmosphere at Marco’s Pizza is also worth noting. Dim lighting, cozy booths and great music playing in the background – it’s perfect for an intimate evening or a casual meal with friends. The staff is friendly and efficient too.
I highly recommend stopping by Marco’s Pizza for the best pizza experience in Noblesville!
#4 Chicago’s Pizza
- Has a kid’s menu
- Nice tourist spot
- Great place to watch sports
- Has some vegetarian options
- Serves alcohol
- Offers dessert
The restaurant has a cozy atmosphere with exposed brick walls and deep red booths that create a warm and inviting environment. The Chicago-style pizza they make is absolutely incredible. It’s light, sweet, and has the perfect crunchy crust. Even after I had ordered the largest size of their signature pie, I still wanted more!
The service at Chicago’s Pizza was top-notch too. Our waiter was friendly and knowledgeable, which made our visit even more enjoyable. Plus, the prices were surprisingly reasonable for such a high quality meal.
I would highly recommend Chicago’s Pizza as some of the best pizza in Noblesville! They offer delicious food at an affordable price that will have you coming back for more!
#5 New York Pizza Garden
- Offers dessert
- Has a kid’s menu
- Has some vegetarian options
I’m pleased to report that their pies are every bit as good and delicious as the ones I’ve sampled in New York City. From the crust to the sauce, everything is perfect.
The staff at New York Pizza Garden is friendly and helpful, which is a big plus for me when eating out. The atmosphere of the restaurant itself has a fun energy and the music playing in the background adds a nice touch.
The best part about New York Pizza Garden is, of course, their pizza! The classic cheese pie is my favorite – it’s not too greasy but full of flavor. And don’t get me started on their pepperoni slice with extra thin crust – simply divine!
If you’re looking for the best pizza in Noblesville, look no further than New York Pizza Garden!
#6 Maestro pizza
The staff is incredibly knowledgeable and friendly, making sure that every customer’s experience is top-notch. When I ordered a margherita pizza, they suggested the perfect topping combination to make it truly mouthwatering. And boy, was it good! The crust had just the right ratio of crunch to chewiness, topped with an ideal amount of cheese and tomato sauce – no wonder why this place has been around for so long!
The atmosphere at Maestro pizza also adds to its charm. With classic Italian decor lining the walls and wooden booths for seating, you’ll feel like a true pizza connoisseur as soon as you walk in. Plus, the spot offers plenty of specials and discounts throughout the week to help you get even more bang for your buck – how could you not love it?
All in all, if you’re looking for great pizza in Noblesville, Maestro is definitely the place to be. Whether you’re dining in or taking out, this should be your go-to destination for delicious pies!
#7 Greek’s Pizzeria
- Has a kid’s menu
- Offers dessert
- Serves alcohol
- Has some vegetarian options
The atmosphere was what really sold me. It had a cozy, homey feel that almost made you forget that you were in a restaurant and not at Grandma’s house for dinner. The staff was amazing – they were warm, friendly, and always willing to answer any questions I had.
The pizza itself was absolutely divine! The crust was spot-on; the perfect combination of crispiness and softness. The tomatoes were flavorful and the cheese? Oh my goodness! It was so creamy and delicious I wanted to eat ten slices!
I’m happy to say that Greek’s Pizzeria has earned a spot on my list of favorite pizzerias – it has some of the best pizza in Noblesville! If you’re ever looking for an authentic Greek pizza experience, look no further than Greek’s Pizzeria!
If you’re willing to go an extra 10 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Carmel!
#8 Pizza Hut
The crust was light and crispy, and the generous layer of cheese was flavorful. The choice of toppings was just right – there were enough to make the pizza interesting without overwhelming it.
Even better, the staff at Pizza Hut was super friendly. They made sure my order was taken correctly and even asked about my travels! It felt like a home away from home, with all the warmth and hospitality of a family gathering.
When it comes to pizza, I can confidently say that Pizza Hut is one of the best places in Noblesville – and they even have delivery options! No matter where you are in town, you can get some delicious ‘za thanks to Pizza Hut.
#9 Pizza Hut
For starters, I was greeted by the friendly staff at Pizza Hut. As soon as I stepped inside, I knew this was going to be a great experience. The ambiance was calm and inviting, and the scent of delicious pizza filled the air!
When it came to the menu, they had an impressive selection of mouthwatering pizzas. From classic favorites like pepperoni and cheese to creative combinations like buffalo chicken and barbecue pork, there really is something for everyone here.
The wait wasn’t too long before my order was up- each pizza was cooked to perfection with a crispy crust and gooey cheese that made me fall in love with every bite. Even better were the generous toppings- each one complemented the flavors perfectly and really added something special to each slice.
Overall, I can confidently say that Pizza Hut offer some of the best pizza in Noblesville- even after traveling around the world tasting different types of pizza! If you’re looking for delicious slices that won’t break your budget, then Pizza Hut is definitely worth a visit!
#10 Monical’s Pizza of Fishers
- Has a kid’s menu
- Great place to watch sports
- Offers dessert
Their menu is impressive and their ingredients are top notch. The crust was the perfect combination of crunchy and chewy goodness that I’ve come to expect from an authentic Italian pizza. And the toppings were fresh, generous and flavorful – making for an unforgettable eating experience!
I have to admit that my favorite item on the menu was their signature Garlic BBQ Chicken Pizza. It featured succulent grilled chicken, zippy barbecue sauce, onions, bell peppers and a special garlic butter spread that had me licking my fingers like they were made of spun sugar!
The atmosphere at Monical’s was also spot-on. The restaurant interior was brightly lit and inviting, with family friendly booths and even a few arcade games in the corner! The staff were friendly and courteous throughout our meal – ensuring that we had everything we needed in order to enjoy our evening out.
All in all, Monical’s Pizza of Fishers definitely lives up to its reputation as one of the best pizzerias in Noblesville. If you’re ever looking for an unforgettable pizza experience then Monical’s should be your go-to place!
#11 Bella Pizzeria – Noblesville
- Has a kid’s menu
- Has some vegetarian options
- Offers dessert
From the first slice I tried, I knew this place was something special. The crust was perfectly crispy and the toppings were freshly prepared. Plus, they offer unique and delicious flavor combinations that make it a truly exceptional pizza experience.
The atmosphere at Bella Pizzeria – Noblesville is also remarkable. It’s a cozy little restaurant with a friendly staff and warm decor that makes you feel right at home. My wife and I had a wonderful time enjoying our pizza in such an inviting environment.
But let’s not forget the main attraction: the food! We ordered two pizzas, one pepperoni and one veggie, plus some wings on the side. Everything tasted amazing; it felt like we were eating pizza in Italy! We even got several complimentary samples of their unique specialty flavors like “Taco Pizza” and “Hawaiian BBQ.”
It’s no wonder why Bella Pizzeria – Noblesville is widely known as having the best pizza in Noblesville! From its top-notch ingredients to its charming atmosphere and friendly staff, there really isn’t anything bad to say about this place. If you’re ever in Noblesville looking for great pizza, don’t hesitate to check out Bella Pizzeria – you won’t be disappointed!
#12 Pizza King
- Has a kid’s menu
- Nice tourist spot
- Offers dessert
- Serves alcohol
Their crust is always perfectly thin and crispy, allowing the delicious flavors of their sauce and toppings to truly shine. Every bite was like a little bit of heaven!
I ordered the Deluxe and it was a real treat – it had pepperoni, sausage, peppers, mushrooms, onions, and olives. The combination of all these ingredients really made for an amazing flavor experience. The pizza also came with some extra cheese on top that just sealed the deal – wow!
The service was friendly too – they even sent out some free samples for me to try before I ordered. That’s something you won’t find at many places. All in all Pizza King is a great place for pizza lovers. If you’re ever in Noblesville I’d definitely recommend giving them a shot – you won’t be disappointed!
