Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Myrtle Beach SC (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in South Carolina

Best Pizza in Myrtle Beach SC (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

554 Views

I’m always on the lookout for the perfect slice, and decided to put Myrtle Beach SC’s best pizza places to the test. For this review of twelve places, I used my own unique taste and style palette to rate each one.

My challenge was to find the best place that can provide me with a delicious pizza experience; something that will make me forget all the other pizzas I’ve tried around the world. So buckle up – let’s take a mouth-watering journey together through Myrtle Beach SC and see if I can find that perfect pizza!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of South Carolina

#1 Coast Pizza

The signature pizza here is their “Coast Pizza” – featuring a unique blend of Italian herbs, gourmet cheeses, and a perfectly cooked crust. The combination of flavors is absolute perfection!

The restaurant itself has a friendly and laid-back atmosphere where locals and tourists alike can feel comfortable. The staff are always smiling and willing to answer any questions you may have about the menu.

In addition to the classic pies, Coast Pizza also offers creative options like “Bananarama.” This delightful dish features banana slices, macadamia nuts, chocolate chips, and ganache melted over a thin crust pizza. It’s so good!

To top it off (literally!), Coast Pizza is surprisingly affordable. You can get two pizzas for the price of one at other places in Myrtle Beach SC. You won’t find better bang-for-your-buck than that!

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Myrtle Beach SC, look no further than Coast Pizza. You won’t be disappointed with their delicious selection of classic pies and inventive specialties!

If you’re willing to go an extra 7 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in North Myrtle Beach!

#2 AJ’S Pizza Myrtle Beach

To start, the atmosphere in AJ’s is friendly and inviting. The staff immediately greeted me with a warm welcome and were eager to answer any questions I had. It almost felt like I’ve known them all my life!

The pizza selection at AJ’s was impressive, with something for everyone. From classic pepperoni to more adventurous toppings such as artichoke hearts, there was no shortage of options available. I went for a combination of bacon and pineapple, which was one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had. The crust was perfectly crisp and the cheese had just the right amount of gooeyness.

AJ’s has also mastered the craft of timing – pizzas come out consistently hot and fresh every time. You don’t have to worry about waiting too long or eating cold pizza here!

All in all, it’s easy to see why AJ’s Pizza Myrtle Beach has earned its spot as one of the best pizza places in Myrtle Beach SC! If you’re ever in town make sure to stop by for an amazing pizza experience!

#3 Toffino’s Italian Bakery Deli Pizza

From the first bite of their amazing crust, I knew I’d found something special. It was crunchy and airy in all the right places, and still managed to be pillowy soft throughout. The toppings were so flavorful and fresh, I almost forgot that this was only “regular” pizza.

The marinara sauce was the perfect complement to my cheeses and other toppings – it brought out all their flavors without being too overwhelming. And when paired with a sprinkle of hot pepper flakes or grated parmesan cheese – oh boy! Delicious!

The service at Toffino’s is also top notch. All their staff are friendly and attentive, always making sure you get your food in a timely manner and that everything is up to your satisfaction. Not to mention, they’re always willing to share a slice of pizza from their own kitchen with me whenever I come in for lunch or dinner. Now that’s hospitality!

All in all, I highly recommend stopping into Toffino’s Italian Bakery Deli Pizza for some of the best pizza you’ll find in Myrtle Beach SC!

#4 Little Italy

The first thing that struck me upon entering the restaurant was how fresh and inviting it smelled. I could tell this place takes pride in making fantastic pizza, and they do it well!

The menu is filled with delicious specialty pies like their famous “Mountain of Cheese” and their unique twist on a classic, the “Fusion Pizza”. The staff was very knowledgeable and helped me select the perfect pizza for my palate.

The crust of the pizza was light and crispy, yet substantial enough to hold all of the toppings without getting soggy. I went with their signature combination which was loaded with flavorful meats, vegetables and cheeses. The taste was simply amazing – not too greasy, salty or cheesy – just perfectly balanced flavors that exploded in my mouth.

I’d give Little Italy five stars for being absolutely delicious! I’m sure if I ever find myself back in Myrtle Beach SC, I’ll be sure to visit Little Italy again in search of the best pizza around!

#5 Mellow Mushroom Myrtle Beach

The restaurant has a great atmosphere- it’s warm and inviting with lots of interesting décor. And the food? Well, it’s simply amazing! From their signature pies, to their custom pizzas, to their appetizers and sides, everything is consistently delicious.

The chefs clearly know how to craft a perfect pizza; the crust is perfectly cooked – not too hard and chewy, but not too soft either. And the toppings are always fresh and flavorful! I particularly enjoy all the unique topping combinations they have here, like their “Mighty Meaty” pizza or their “Funky Q Chicken” – both of which pack in tons of flavor.

Plus, the staff are always friendly and attentive. They go out of their way to make sure you have a great experience each and every time you visit!

In conclusion, Mellow Mushroom Myrtle Beach is definitely one of my favorite places for pizza in Myrtle Beach SC. It’s tasty, it’s consistent and the atmosphere is always welcoming and relaxing. So if you’re ever in town looking for some delicious food – be sure to check out this fantastic spot!

If you’re willing to go an extra 13 miles, you can get to 21 more pizza places in Conway!

#6 Vicini’s Italian Restaurant And Pizzeria

The great thing about Vicini’s is that it offers a bit of something for everyone – there’s an extensive beer list to keep the adults happy, a kid’s menu with pizza options for the littles, and even some vegetarian options. And if you’re looking for something sweet after your meal, they offer delectable dessert options too.

Unfortunately, Vicini’s doesn’t offer delivery service – so if you’re in the mood for pizza but can’t make it out of the house, this may not be your best option. That being said, the restaurant itself is a great place to visit – especially if you’re on vacation as Vicini’s has become somewhat of a tourist spot!

In conclusion, I would definitely recommend Vicini’s Italian Restaurant And Pizzeria to anyone looking for tasty pizza in Myrtle Beach SC – it’s got something for just about everyone and is sure to leave you feeling full and satisfied!

#7 Capriccio

The atmosphere is relaxed and inviting to all kinds of people. They serve alcohol, as well as hard liquor, so it’s perfect for adults. But they also have a great kid’s menu, which is a nice change of pace. For the vegetarians in the group, there are several delicious options to choose from.

But that’s not even the best part: their desserts! I’m not exaggerating when I say Capriccio has some of the most insanely good desserts I’ve ever had. From classic favorites like cheesecake to chocolate mousse and everything in between, you can’t go wrong.

The only downside? No delivery. But if you’re in Myrtle Beach, it’s definitely worth the trip out for an amazing pizza experience. Highly recommended!

#8 Mozzarella’s

My first experience with Mozzarella’s was the night I visited for their legendary Margherita pizza. The crust was absolutely delicious – thin and crunchy, with a nice golden-brown color on top. The sauce was savory and full of flavor, and the mozzarella cheese was melted to perfection. To top it all off, they added some lovely basil leaves that provided a hint of freshness. Once I took my first bite, I knew I had to order another one!

The rest of my meal at Mozzarella’s was just as delightful as the pizza. I tried several of the appetizers, including their famous garlic breadsticks, which were especially amazing. They also had an impressive selection of salads and sandwiches that all looked very tasty.

I can honestly say that this restaurant has some of the best pizza in Myrtle Beach SC – so if you’re ever in town and looking for a good meal, be sure to check out Mozzarella’s!

#9 Extreme Pizza Myrtle Beach

I’d heard rumors about this small little pizza parlor, but I never expected it to be so good. As soon as I walked in, the mouthwatering smell of dough and cheese filled the air, and I knew I was in for a treat!

The inside is simple but inviting, with bright yellow walls and wooden tables. The staff is friendly and welcoming, rising to the challenge of creating some truly amazing pizzas.

And what can I say about the pizzas themselves? They’re simply superb! The dough is cooked to perfection, crispy on the outside yet still light and fluffy on the inside. And then there’s the toppings – you can choose from a variety of fresh ingredients, including veggies like mushrooms and peppers or any number of meats. But my favorite were the specialties like their “Tsunami” pizza which has pepperoni, Italian sausage, bell peppers and lots of cheese – delicious!

Overall, Extreme Pizza Myrtle Beach has proven to be one of my favorite pizza places in Myrtle Beach SC! If you’re ever in town looking for an unforgettable pizza experience then make sure you check them out! You won’t regret it!

If you’re willing to go an extra 16 miles, you can get to 18 more pizza places in Surfside Beach!

#10 Ultimate California Pizza

The atmosphere is definitely a selling point – it’s cozy, warm, and inviting. And the staff was top notch – they were attentive and knowledgeable about their menu.

When it comes to the pizza itself, I’m happy to say that Ultimate California Pizza did not disappoint. The crust was spot-on – perfectly crunchy and chewy at the same time. The sauce had real depth of flavor! And the cheese? Oh my god…it was practically oozing off the slices!

Overall, I would definitely recommend Ultimate California Pizza for anyone looking for an enjoyable dining experience with absolutely delicious pizza. In my opinion, this place is easily one of the best places to get pizza in Myrtle Beach SC!

#11 Ducatis Pizzeria & Trattoria

I don’t usually find myself in Myrtle Beach, but when I do, Ducatis Pizzeria & Trattoria is a must-stop. They make their pizzas with the freshest ingredients, from local farmers and purveyors, which makes all the difference.

The crust was perfect – it was crunchy on the outside yet soft and fluffy on the inside. The cheese and sauce were equally flavorful, creating pizza perfection. The toppings were extensive as well – from pepperoni to sausage to veggies galore – every last bite was delicious!

The staff at Ducatis Pizzeria & Trattoria were exceptionally friendly, making sure that everything met our expectations (which it did!). And talk about atmosphere – who can resist Italian music playing in the background while feasting on bona fide Italian style pizza? We couldn’t!

If you’re ever in Myrtle Beach SC and looking for some of the best pizza around, look no further than Ducatis Pizzeria & Trattoria. You won’t regret it!

#12 Michael’s Pizza, Pasta and Grill

The place is cozy, but casual with a really inviting atmosphere. I was warmly greeted as soon as I walked in and the staff was incredibly friendly and helpful.

The pizza at Michael’s Pizza, Pasta and Grill definitely lived up to my expectations. The crust of the pizza was perfectly cooked – crispy on the outside while still nice and fluffy on the inside. The toppings were flavorful and well-seasoned, making for a delicious combination of tastes.

I tried their specially-made grilled pizzas which were amazing! They come out piping hot and with just the right amount of gooey cheese. The various sauces they offer make it great for customizing to your individual tastes.

Overall, my experience at Michael’s Pizza, Pasta and Grill was satisfying beyond belief. It’s no wonder why this place is so popular – it offers some of the best pizza in Myrtle Beach SC! Whether you want something simple or something unique, you won’t be disappointed with what you find at Michael’s Pizza, Pasta and Grill!

Best Deep Dish Pizza – Hungry Howie’s Pizza

Picture this: you’ve just spent the day lounging on the beautiful beaches of Myrtle Beach, working up quite the appetite. You stumble upon Hungry Howie’s Pizza, and let me tell you, it’s like finding a hidden treasure amidst the sandcastles.

Let’s start with the main attraction: the deep dish pizza. Oh boy, it’s a gastronomic work of art. The crust is so thick and fluffy, it’s like biting into a cloud made of pizza. The cheese stretches for miles, and the toppings are so plentiful, you’ll wonder if they’ve mistaken your order for a deluxe buffet. It’s the kind of pizza that makes you cancel your gym membership and embrace your newfound love handles.

But here’s the funny thing about Hungry Howie’s – they offer dessert! Yes, you heard me right. Who needs a beach bod when you can sink your teeth into their gooey, chocolatey brownies? It’s a beautiful collision of sweetness and regret, and trust me, it’s worth it.

Now, I must warn you, hungry traveler, that Hungry Howie’s does have one downside: they don’t accept reservations. So expect to arrive and wait for a table, just like every other pizza lover drawn to this heavenly wonderland. But take my word for it, it’s worth the wait. Plus, it’s a great opportunity to bond with your fellow pizza enthusiasts and perhaps even exchange some secret topping combinations.

In conclusion, if you’re looking for a pizza joint that offers the best deep dish pizza in Myrtle Beach, look no further than Hungry Howie’s Pizza. Just be prepared to indulge in some mouthwatering goodness, and leave your reservations (both literal and metaphorical) at the door.

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Ducatis Pizzeria & Trattoria

Myrtle Beach, known for its gorgeous beaches and stunning views, may not be the first place that comes to mind when you think of pizza. But let me tell you, Ducatis Pizzeria & Trattoria is here to change your mind – and your taste buds!

As I walked into the restaurant, I was greeted with a warm and inviting atmosphere. The staff was so friendly, I couldn’t help but get excited about the delicious pizza they were about to serve me. And boy, did they deliver!

The first bite into their thin crust pizza was like a taste explosion in my mouth. The crust was perfectly crisp, just the right amount of chewy, and beautifully topped with a generous amount of cheese and flavorful toppings. It was like the pizza gods themselves had crafted this masterpiece specifically for me.

But it wasn’t just the crust that made Ducatis stand out. The sauce, oh the sauce! It was tangy, zesty, and had just the right amount of spice to make my taste buds dance with joy. And let me tell you, the toppings were not to be overlooked either. From the classic margherita to the more adventurous buffalo chicken, each slice was bursting with flavor.

So, if you find yourself in Myrtle Beach and craving some amazing thin crust pizza, make a beeline straight for Ducatis Pizzeria & Trattoria. Your taste buds will thank you, and you may find yourself booking a return trip to Myrtle Beach just for another slice of their heavenly pizza.