Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Mystic CT (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Connecticut

Best Pizza in Mystic CT (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

119 Views

I’ve tasted my share of pizza from all over the world, so I’m excited to bring you some reviews of the best pizza in Mystic CT! With 12 different restaurants to choose from, I’ll help you narrow down your search and find a delicious slice to satisfy your taste buds. Get ready for a humorous journey as I dig into the local pies!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Connecticut

#1 Stonington Pizza Palace

I’m no stranger to pizza, so I know good pizza when I taste it. From the moment I stepped into Stonington Pizza Palace, I knew that this was a special place. The smells of tomato sauce and cheese drifting through the air were mouthwatering and made my stomach rumble with anticipation.

The decor at the restaurant is cozy yet modern and the staff are friendly and inviting. When my pizza arrived, I was immediately impressed by how beautifully presented it was – golden-brown cheese bubbling on top of a thick crust topped with fresh vegetables and herbs. But what really caught my attention was the flavor – each bite bursting with juicy tomatoes, subtle herbs, and perfectly melted cheese. It truly is some of the best pizza in Mystic CT!

I highly recommend visiting Stonington Pizza Palace – you won’t be disappointed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 4 miles, you can get to 22 more pizza places in Westerly!

#2 Pizzetta

I was so excited to find a place that made great, authentic pizza – and even more delighted when I realized they offer alcohol (including hard liquor!) to wash it all down. Plus, the kids menu is great for families looking to satisfy their little ones’ cravings, and the vegetarian options mean everyone in my party could enjoy themselves.

The atmosphere is really nice too; another plus for those of us looking for a tourist spot to hang out with friends or family. And who can top off a meal like pizza without a delicious dessert? Pizzetta’s selection of sweet treats added an additional layer of decadence that sealed the deal.

Of course, there are some downsides – no delivery, for one – but you wouldn’t want to miss out on that atmosphere I mentioned earlier! All-in-all, Pizzetta was a great experience and I highly recommend it for anyone looking for the best pizza Mystic CT has to offer.

#3 Mango’s Wood-Fired Pizza Co.

This restaurant has something for everyone. They serve alcohol, have a kid’s menu and offer some vegetarian options. Plus they offer dessert! It’s the perfect spot for tourists to get their pizza fix without having to go too far.

Speaking of pizza, it certainly is the star of this show. Their wood-fired pies are authentic and packed with flavor. And the aroma in the restaurant is amazing.

The only downside I can think of is that they don’t do delivery, so you’ll have to visit in person if you want to enjoy this masterpiece. But it’s worth it! All in all, Mango’s Wood-Fired Pizza Co. offers an excellent dining experience that shouldn’t be missed by any pizza lover.

#4 Mystic Pizza

The moment I stepped in the door, the fresh aroma of their secret pizza sauce hit my nose and I knew this was a place to remember. The atmosphere is warm, inviting, and full of laughter. The staff was friendly and accommodating and made sure every detail was perfect.

Now let’s talk about the pizza. It was amazing! They use the freshest ingredients, from locally-sourced vegetables to homemade dough, so you know it tastes great. The pies are cooked to perfection with a crunchy crust that melts in your mouth with each bite. And their signature Mystic Pizza Special? My taste buds have never been happier!

Mystic Pizza is truly a classic experience and I highly recommend it if you’re in Mystic CT looking for the best pizza around. It’s the kind of meal that will leave you full but wanting more at the same time!

If you’re willing to go an extra 11 miles, you can get to 23 more pizza places in New London!

#5 Angies Pizza & Pier 27 Lounge

It’s a really hip spot, with great music and beautiful views of the harbor. The atmosphere alone is worth the trip! But it’s the pizza that takes center stage.

The pies here are huge so one could easily feed two people. The dough is crisp on the outside but chewy on the inside which helps hold the toppings in place.

I tried their classic pepperoni which had plenty of thick slices atop – just enough to give it a nice crunchy texture. The tomato sauce was just acidic enough to balance out all of flavors from the other ingredients. It was definitely a hit! I also tried one of their specialty pizzas, a white pie with ricotta, roasted garlic, and oregano – and oh wow was it tasty!

If you’re looking for something unique, Angies Pizza & Pier 27 Lounge has got you covered. There’s something on this menu to satisfy everyone’s craving – from Chicago deep dish to Sicilian style slices. I have yet to find better pizza in Mystic CT than this place!

#6 Ignazio’s

My recent trip to Ignazio’s was a delightful surprise. From the moment I walked in, I was warmly welcomed by the staff and offered a freshly cooked slice of their brick oven-baked goodness!

The crust was thin and perfectly crispy, but still chewy in just the right way. Toppings were fresh and flavorful, with plenty of creative combinations to choose from. Every bite was truly delicious.

Unfortunately, they don’t offer delivery service – so you have to go to enjoy the experience. But that didn’t stop me from savoring every last morsel! The atmosphere was inviting and cozy, adding to the already amazing food experience.

In conclusion, Ignazio’s is easily my favorite pizza spot in Mystic CT. It may not deliver, but it certainly delivers when it comes to flavor!

#7 184 Pizzeria

The pizza here is incredibly fresh and has a great doughy texture. The crust is made to perfection with a great crisp on the outside while still remaining light and airy on the inside.

The toppings are equally as delicious as the crust. They have some really unique topping combinations like truffle mushrooms, pickled onions and sun-dried tomatoes that make their pizzas truly stand out from the rest.

My favorite thing about 184 Pizzeria is how friendly and knowledgeable the staff are about their food. Every time I’ve visited, the waiters were more than happy to take their time and explain each pizza to us in detail so that we can make an informed decision about what we want.

Overall, if you’re looking for some of Mystic CT’s best pizza, look no further than 184 Pizzeria!

If you’re willing to go an extra 22 miles, you can get to 10 more pizza places in Montauk!

#8 Christo’s Pizza Mystic

From the moment I stepped in the door, I knew this place was special. The ambience is cozy and inviting, like a real Italian pizzeria. Plus, they offer an impressive selection of hand-crafted pizzas with unique toppings such as prosciutto, goat cheese, and kalamata olives.

The pizza is definitely worth writing home about! The thin crust is flavorful and light, yet still holds up under the weight of the delicious toppings. And the sauce is simply superb – it’s fresh and flavorful, with just the right amount of sweetness (and a hint of garlic).

But what really sets Christo’s Pizza Mystic apart from other pizza places is their dedication to quality ingredients. They only use top-notch mozzarella cheese, freshly chopped vegetables and herbs, and high-grade cured meats. The result? A truly phenomenal pie!

If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Mystic CT, look no further than Christo’s Pizza Mystic! After tasting their amazing pies, I can confidently say that they are indeed some of the best pizzas I’ve ever tasted in my travels – both here in Mystic CT and around the world!

#9 Woodfellas Pizza & Wings

I was instantly impressed by the atmosphere of the restaurant. The staff was so friendly and welcoming, and the decor was inviting. It definitely had that small-town pizza joint vibe that I love.

When it came time to order, I opted for one of their signature pizzas: a classic pepperoni with extra cheese. When they brought it out, I could tell right away that this pizza was something special. The sauce was sweet, the crust just crispy enough, and the cheese melted in my mouth like butter!

I also had a chance to sample a few of their wings. They were cooked to perfection and tossed in a delicious mix of spices that really made them stand out from other wings I’ve tried.

Overall, Woodfellas Pizza & Wings was everything I hoped for and more. If you’re looking for some truly delicious pizza in Mystic CT, then look no further than Woodfellas!

#10 Domino’s Pizza

My most recent visit to Domino’s was nothing short of amazing. The restaurant had a wonderfully rustic atmosphere, with some modern touches that added to the overall pizzeria experience.

The pizza itself was incredible! I sampled several of their pies and savored every bite. Each one had an incredibly flavorful combination of toppings, from pepperoni and sausage to mushrooms and greens. The crust was perfectly baked too – not too thick or thin, but just right! And the topping selection was varied enough to give each slice a unique flavor experience.

To accompany our meal, we tried some of Domino’s signature sides. Their garlic knots were fluffy and delicious – just the right consistency for a finger-licking good snack. The cheesy bread sticks were also outstanding; they were full of gooey cheese sandwiched between two crunchy slices of bread. Both dishes paired perfectly with our pie selections!

On top of everything else, the service at Domino’s Pizza is always friendly and prompt. Our wait staff did an excellent job accommodating our large party and made sure there were no delays in getting us our order so we could dive into the deliciousness as soon as possible!

To sum it up, Domino’s Pizza is definitely my new favorite spot for a delicious pizza night out in Mystic CT!

If you’re willing to go an extra 24 miles, you can get to 18 more pizza places in Narragansett!

#11 Bravo Bravo

When I walked in, I was immediately taken aback by the atmosphere. The lighting was nice and cozy, yet not too dim – perfect for a night out with friends. Not only that, but they were fully stocked with a wide selection of alcoholic beverages, including hard liquor! That alone solidified my decision to stay and dig into some delicious pizza.

One of the best things about Bravo Bravo is their incredible dessert selection. They’ve got something for everyone – from simple cookies to decadent cakes – all cooked to perfection. I tried their famous chocolate lava cake and it was so good it almost felt like heaven in my mouth!

My one issue with Bravo Bravo is that they don’t offer delivery service; however, this could be troublesome if you’re looking for a quick bite after work or school. For me, though, it’s no problem because I had plenty of time to enjoy the meal without having to rush away!

In conclusion, Bravo Bravo has great pizza and is quite possibly the best spot in Mystic CT for tourists looking to get some delicious food and drinks while taking in the sights. The lack of delivery service is slightly inconvenient, but the fantastic atmosphere, booze selection, and amazing desserts more than make up for it!

#12 Anthony J’s Bistro

Their thin-crust pizza is a delicious delight that can satisfy even the most demanding food critic. The toppings are always fresh and delicious, and you can customize your own pie to your heart’s content.

But it’s more than just the pizza at Anthony J’s Bistro: they also serve alcohol, including hard liquor! This makes them an ideal spot for tourists who are looking for a place to grab drinks, dinner, and dessert all in one go. Speaking of which, their insanely good desserts are not to be missed – I mean literally insanely good!

The only downside to Anthony J’s Bistro is that they don’t offer delivery service. But let’s be honest – it’s worth the trip over there just to try their amazing pizza!

Overall, I highly recommend trying out Anthony J’s Bistro if you’re ever in Mystic CT – it truly does have some of the best pizza in town!