Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in New Haven CT (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Connecticut

Best Pizza in New Haven CT (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

43 Views

I’ve sampled pies in cities from Italy to Tokyo, but I was curious to see what the pizza scene was like in this Connecticut college town. After much deliberation and eating, I have taste-tested 12 popular pizza places in New Haven.

For me, the perfect pizza has a balance of a delectably chewy crust, fresh ingredients, and a tasty sauce – and that all-important element of surprise! With all that said, let’s get down to business. These are my picks for the best pizza in New Haven CT.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Connecticut

#1 Zeneli Pizzeria e cucina Napoletana

This place has it all: the atmosphere is cozy and inviting, the staff are friendly and helpful, and then of course there’s the food. Everything on the menu tastes amazing! I particularly enjoyed their vegetarian options. They even had a dessert that was to die for.

Plus, unlike many other pizzerias, Zeneli also serves alcohol which makes it great for a night out or gathering with friends. The only thing missing is delivery – so you’ll have to go pick it up yourself.

All in all, I would highly recommend a visit to Zeneli Pizzeria e cucina Napoletana if you’re looking for the best pizza in New Haven CT. You won’t be disappointed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 2 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in West Haven!

#2 Pasta Eataliana Trattoria Napoletana

I’m no stranger to pizza – I’ve been to Italy, France, and all around the United States, trying out different pizzas. But Pasta Eataliana Trattoria Napoletana has some of the best pies I’ve ever tasted. The crust was just right – not too thick and not too thin. The sauce was flavorful and perfectly balanced, while the cheese was freshly melted and gooey.

The toppings were mouth-watering too – the sausage was seasoned just right, while the pepperoni had a hint of spice that really kicked it up a notch. They even had unique toppings like artichoke hearts, roasted peppers, and more!

Overall, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in New Haven CT, look no further than Pasta Eataliana Trattoria Napoletana! Highly recommended!

#3 Modern Apizza

The restaurant has a great atmosphere, with plenty of seating and a lively crowd who all seem to appreciate the delicious pizza. It’s also a nice tourist spot in New Haven – my friends and I had an amazing time here!

As for the food, Modern Apizza serves up some incredible pizza. The crust was just the right amount of thick and chewy, while the toppings were perfectly savory. Even better, there are some vegetarian options so everyone can enjoy! And to top it off, they offer dessert – what more could you want?

The only downside is that there’s no delivery service which can be annoying if you don’t feel like going out. But overall it’s totally worth it for the amazing pizza experience. Plus, the restaurant serves alcohol so you can really make a night out of it!

If you’re in New Haven CT looking for some seriously good pizza then look no further than Modern Apizza – best pizza in New Haven CT!

#4 One 6 Three

The atmosphere is great—it kind of reminds me of a classic Italian trattoria. The wait staff are friendly and welcoming, not to mention knowledgeable about the pizzas on offer. I was particularly impressed with how they were able to describe each item in terms of its ingredients and flavor profile.

When I ordered the margherita pizza, I could already tell that One 6 Three takes their pizzas seriously. The crust was perfectly cooked—golden brown and crisp on the outside, fluffy on the inside. Plus the tomato sauce had a nice umami kick to it, which really brought out the flavors of the cheese and basil garnish. Delicious!

I also sampled some of their other offerings, like their mushroom and pepperoni deep dish pizzas. They tasted just as good as they smelled coming out of the oven! All in all, I have to say that this place has some of the best pizza in New Haven CT—if you haven’t tried it yet, do yourself a favor and pop by sometime soon!

#5 Family Mediterranean Pizza

The first thing I noticed when I walked through the door was the cozy atmosphere and friendly staff. The decor is tasteful, yet understated. It felt like a little slice of pizza heaven.

The menu had some really unique options, so it took me a while to decide what to get! But in the end, I chose their signature Mediterranean Pizza—a combination of feta cheese, olives, tomatoes, spinach and delicious garlic sauce!

I have to say—it was one of the best pizzas I have ever enjoyed! Each bite burst with flavor and texture. The feta cheese was creamy and just salty enough–but not too much. And the olives gave it an amazing tanginess.

The service was also top-notch –the waitstaff were attentive and happy to answer any questions about menu items or specials.

In short, Family Mediterranean Pizza offers some of the best pizza in New Haven CT! I would recommend them to anyone looking for a delicious meal that won’t break the bank!

#6 RAWA Mediterranean Fusion, Middle Eastern Food, Pizza Place

I had the pleasure of visiting this establishment on a recent trip to Connecticut. I was astounded at the variety they offer; kabob pizza, Mediterranean fusion pizza, and even hummus pizza! I tried every single one and was thoroughly impressed with each flavor. One thing that stuck out to me in particular was how all my pies were cooked perfectly. The crusts were crispy and the toppings melted in your mouth with just enough kick.

The staff here are also very friendly and accommodating. They quickly answered any questions I had, walked me through the menu, and even gave me samples of their signature dishes.

And if you’re looking for an amazing selection of drinks to accompany your meal, RAWA has you covered there too! My personal favorite was their kombucha, which went perfectly with my meal.

All in all, if you’re looking for an unforgettable pizza experience while in New Haven CT, look no further than RAWA Mediterranean Fusion! Their extensive menu offerings and friendly staff will have you coming back time and time again.

#7 Zuppardi’s Apizza

The atmosphere at Zuppardi’s Apizza was welcoming and inviting, making it an ideal spot for tourists who want to get a taste of the area. Plus, they serve alcohol, which is definitely a plus.

I decided to try some vegetarian options while I was there and they had some delicious options! The BBQ pizza and broccoli pizza were both deliciously flavorful with plenty of toppings. Even better than the vegan options was the meat-based pizza. From pepperoni to sausage to meatball – I sampled them all and can confidently say that this is some of the best tasting pizza I’ve had anywhere in the world!

As great as Zuppardi’s Apizza highly recommend you plan your visit accordingly as they don’t offer delivery. But let me tell you one thing: it’s worth it! They also have a wonderful selection of desserts, so you certainly won’t leave hungry or unsatisfied.

All in all, if you’re ever in New Haven CT make sure you swing by Zuppardi’s Apizza for their exceptional pizza. A great dinner place for anyone whether vegetarian or not, this is certainly one of the best places around for true Italian pizza!

#8 Grand Apizza New Haven

I arrived at Grand Apizza New Haven a few weeks ago and received a friendly welcome from the staff. I was immediately taken aback by the delicious smell of pizza that filled the air. After ordering my favorite style of pizza, a thin-crust pepperoni, I had to try their signature New Haven-style white clam pizza. Wow – it was truly an amazing experience!

The crust of my thin-crust pepperoni pizza was cooked perfectly and had just enough crunch while remaining light and fluffy. The topping combinations were very unique and flavorful without being overwhelming. It took all my self-control not to eat the entire pie! As for the white clam pizza, their signature dish really did not disappoint! The combination of fresh clams and spices on top made for an unforgettable taste sensation.

My overall experience at Grand Apizza New Haven left me completely satisfied. The portions are generous and prices are more than reasonable for such excellent quality. If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in New Haven CT, then look no further – Grand Apizza is definitely worthy of your time and money!

If you’re willing to go an extra 5 miles, you can get to 25 more pizza places in Hamden!

#9 Ernie’s Pizzeria

I mean, where else can you get a New Haven pie with just the right amount of garlic and herbs? This place really knows how to dial in the flavors. The crust is just the right thickness and never gets soggy.

The pizzas here are definitely worth the price – you get what you pay for! And let me tell you, it’s worth every penny. I was especially impressed by their selection of topping combinations, especially the one they call “Ernie’s Special”. It’s a delicious blend of pepperoni, sausage, peppers, and onions that will make your mouth water.

But what really sets Ernie’s Pizzeria apart from other pizza joints is the atmosphere. From the warm red walls adorned with framed Italian artworks to friendly staff that serve up each pie with a smile – this place has great vibes all around!

So if you’re looking for some great pizza in New Haven CT – look no further than Ernie’s Pizzeria! You won’t be disappointed.

#10 Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana

The restaurant itself looks like it’s been around for years and provides a cozy, quaint atmosphere. When I walked in to try their pizza, I was greeted by friendly staff that was more than willing to give recommendations.

The pizza itself was out of this world. The crust was light and crunchy and the cheese melted in just the right way. Toppings were plentiful, but not overwhelming – they let the fresh flavors of the pizza shine through.

All-in-all, my experience at Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana was a great one! If you’re ever in New Haven CT searching for the best pizza there is – make sure to stop by this place – you won’t regret it!

#11 Clemente’s Pizza & Grill

The crust is chewy, flavorful and cooked to perfection. The sauce is tangy and delicious, and the cheese is so stringy and gooey that it’s almost a pleasure just to pull it off the pizza slice.

The toppings are fresh, plentiful and full of flavor. From savory sausage to salty anchovies to spicy pepperoni; whatever you choose on your pizza will be sure to satisfy your taste buds!

But what really takes Clemente’s Pizza & Grill over the top is their delicious homemade marinara sauce. It’s like nothing I’ve ever tasted before: thick, rich, bursting with flavor—the perfect way to bring all the flavors of the pizza together in one delicious bite.

I’m usually hard to please when it comes to pizza but Clemente’s Pizza & Grill truly blew me away with its high-quality ingredients and skillful cooking techniques! If you’re ever in New Haven CT looking for some of the best pizza around, look no further than Clemente’s Pizza & Grill!

#12 Sally’s Apizza

As soon as I walked into the restaurant, I knew the pizza was going to be delicious. The atmosphere of Sally’s Apizza was warm and inviting; it reminded me of an Italian pizzeria from back home.

I ordered a pepperoni pizza with extra cheese and I definitely wasn’t disappointed! The pizza had a perfectly crisp crust that was packed with flavor. Even better, the toppings were plentiful and fresh, and each slice had just the right amount of melted cheese. The sauce was also amazing, not too tart nor too sweet – it blended perfectly with all the flavors on top.

In short, if you’re looking for the best pizza in New Haven CT then look no further than Sally’s Apizza! Not only was the food top notch, but so was their service and hospitality – they made my dining experience such a pleasure!