Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Peabody MA (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Massachusetts

Best Pizza in Peabody MA (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

144 Views

I’m no pizza expert, but I’ve been around the world tasting enough pies to know a good one when I bite into it. During my stay in Peabody MA, I had the opportunity to sample 12 different pizzas.

It was a tough job, but somebody had to do it! All kidding aside, of all the delicious dishes I sampled here, these were my top picks for the best pizza in Peabody MA.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Massachusetts

#1 Best Sandwich Company

The atmosphere is great – it’s cozy, inviting and the staff are always friendly. The selection is wide, with something for everyone. I was particularly impressed by their signature peabody pizza! It had a perfect crust – not too thick or thin – and was loaded with delicious toppings. The tomato sauce was flavorful, and the cheese was nicely melted.

I also couldn’t resist trying their other specialty pies. The Sicilian pepperoni slices were thin yet crispy, just like the classic New York style pizza you’d expect to find in Italy; the barbecue chicken pizza had a nice smoky flavor that made me want to order a second one; and their white garlic pizza had an interesting mix of flavors that really set it apart from other pizzas I’ve tried elsewhere.

If you’re in Peabody MA looking for some of the best pizza around, you can’t go wrong with Best Sandwich Company – it’s definitely worth a visit!

If you’re willing to go an extra 5 miles, you can get to 26 more pizza places in Salem!

#2 Plum Tomatoes Brick Oven Pizza

From the hard-crusted pizza dough to the slightly sweet tomato sauce, the flavors are simply out of this world. They also have some delicious vegetarian options, so even my non-meat-eating friends can join in on the party.

The atmosphere is cozy and inviting. The staff is friendly and welcoming, so you’ll feel right at home. Plus, they serve up craft beers and wines to go with your pizza slice!

Unfortunately, they don’t offer delivery services. But it’s worth taking that extra step to go get a pie from Plum Tomatoes Brick Oven Pizza – it’s some of the best pizza I’ve ever had!

#3 Gallo Nero

From the moment I stepped inside, I could tell this place was special. The aroma of freshly baked dough and bubbling cheese was unmistakable. The staff was friendly and welcoming, immediately offering me some complimentary garlic knots before we’d even discussed what kind of pizza I wanted!

When it came to choosing my pizza, the options were dizzyingly delicious. From classic margherita to their signature Gallo Nero with roasted mushrooms and truffles, there were so many amazing combinations to choose from. Everything seemed to be made with love and care – each ingredient was carefully selected for maximum flavor impact!

My pizza arrived hot out of the oven, oozing with melted cheese and fragrant herbs. The dough was pleasantly chewy and flavorful – definitely a cut above your typical fast food pizzeria fare!

I left Gallo Nero feeling completely satisfied, certain that I had just experienced the best pizza in Peabody MA. If you’re ever in town and looking for a superior slice of pie, this is definitely the place to go.

#4 Muntsy’s

The atmosphere is warm, inviting and the staff is friendly. I was seated right away, and my waiter took my order with enthusiasm. The pizza arrived looking like a work of art – perfectly cooked with a golden crust and plenty of melted cheese on top.

The flavors were amazing! The toppings were fresh, the sauce was flavorful and the dough was cooked to perfection. Every bite burst with flavor and left me wanting more.

As a food critic, I also looked into all the details that make up a great pizza as well as any downsides that come with it. Unfortunately there’s no delivery option at Muntsy’s so you have to eat in or take it out, which could be a downside for some people but not for me!

To sum it up: Muntsy’s has some of the best pizza in Peabody MA – excellent atmosphere, attentive staff, delectable toppings, tasty sauce, and perfectly cooked dough! It’s definitely worth trying if you’re ever in the area!

#5 Atha’s Roast Beef & Pizza

I arrived at Atha’s expecting, as the name implies, to just try their roast beef. But I was pleasantly surprised when I noticed the huge selection of pizzas available. From traditional pepperoni and cheese pizza to more adventurous creations like Hawaiian and Fajita pies, there really is something for everyone.

After ordering a classic pepperoni pie that was out of this world, I couldn’t believe the taste – it actually made me take a step back and think “this might be the best pizza in Peabody MA”. The crust was perfectly cooked and golden-brown, the sauce had just enough kick to make it interesting but not overpowering, and the topping distribution was on-point with every slice having an equal amount of Pepperoni goodness.

But what really stood out about Atha’s pizza is how freshly prepared everything was – each element of my pizza tasted like it had been made on demand for me – from the crunchy crust to the tangy sauce. The quality and freshness of their ingredients is second to none!

So if you’re ever in Peabody MA looking for some delicious pizza, look no further than Atha’s Roast Beef & Pizza – definitely one of my favorites places for the best pizza in town!

#6 Brother’s Roast Beef & Seafood

When I first stepped into the restaurant, I was impressed by the atmosphere – it’s modern, yet cozy and inviting. It was clear that this place takes their pizza seriously!

The pizza itself is some of the best I have ever tasted. The crust is thin and crisp and the toppings are flavorful and plentiful. Plus, they offer a variety of specialty pizzas so you can get creative with your order.

The service at Brother’s Roast Beef & Seafood is also top-notch. The staff are friendly and attentive, making sure that you have everything you need to enjoy your meal.

Overall, I would definitely recommend Brother’s Roast Beef & Seafood as one of the best places to get pizza in Peabody MA! If you’re looking for a delicious pizza experience, make sure to check out this spot!

#7 Santoro’s of Peabody

I was amazed at the incredible flavor the pizza had. The crust was thin and crispy, and the sauce was sweet and tangy. The cheese was melted to perfection, and the toppings were so fresh that I could taste their individual flavors. Every single bite transported me to Italy!

The service was friendly and efficient, making my dining experience even better. Everything was served with a smile, and they went out of their way to make sure I had everything I needed. The atmosphere of Santoro’s of Peabody is cozy and welcoming, providing a great setting for my meal.

Overall, my experience at Santoro’s of Peabody exceeded all expectations. The best pizza in Peabody MA can be found at this delicious establishment – highly recommended for any pizza-loving foodie!

If you’re willing to go an extra 5 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Lynn!

#8 Frankie Slice

The first thing I noticed when I stepped into Frankie Slice was the warm and inviting atmosphere. The staff were friendly and welcoming, which is always a plus when it comes to grabbing a bite to eat.

When it comes to the pizza itself, I was completely blown away! The dough was light and fluffy, yet sturdy enough to hold up all the yummy toppings. Each pizza is handmade with care, ensuring that each slice is as good as the last one. The combination of fresh ingredients creates an unbeatable flavor. Every bite was a delight!

I also tried some of their specialty pizzas like the Mac & Cheese Pie, which had just the right amount of cheese oozing out each slice. It’s definitely worth trying if you’re looking for something unique.

Overall, Frankie Slice has earned its title as one of the best pizza places in Peabody MA! With its delicious pizzas and cozy atmosphere, it’s sure to satisfy any pizza lover!

#9 Londi’s of Peabody

My pizza experience began with their signature dish, the Londi’s Special. It was a classic combination of pepperoni, mushrooms, onions and peppers that left me wanting more. The crust was perfectly cooked; it had great crunchy texture without being too tough or chewy. The flavors were well-balanced and created an amazing flavor profile.

The second pizza I ordered was their Mediterranean Delight. It featured a wide variety of vegetables such as spinach, feta cheese, Kalamata olives and tomatoes that complemented each other well. The crust for this pizza was just as perfect as the Londi’s Special – nice and crunchy but still airy enough to not be heavy during digestion.

Every pizza from Londi’s of Peabody is freshly made each day using only the freshest ingredients and traditional cooking methods to provide customers with only the best pizza in Peabody MA. I also believe they have some of the best prices around town; they offer very generous portion sizes while still keeping their prices low and competitive!

There is no doubt in my mind that Londi’s of Peabody is one of the best places to get pizza in Peabody MA — if not THE best. They have all kinds of delicious options to satisfy any kind of craving, plus great quality food at affordable prices! Highly recommended!

#10 Sam & Joe’s Restaurant

Every time I’ve come here, the pizza has lived up to the hype. The crust is thin and crispy, with just the right amount of garlic and herbs in the dough. And the toppings are always fresh. Whether I’m getting classic pepperoni or something a little more adventurous (my favorite is the ‘Veggie Medley’ – roasted peppers, artichoke hearts, onions, mushrooms and olives), every bite is savory perfection.

The atmosphere at Sam & Joe’s is also top-notch. The restaurant itself is cozy and welcoming, with warm lighting, comfy chairs and friendly staff eager to make sure you’re having a good experience.
Plus there are tons of TVs for any sports fans who might be joining you for dinner!

All in all, Sam & Joe’s Restaurant offers an unbeatable combination of great pizza and a relaxed environment – making it my pick for some of the best pizza in Peabody MA!

#11 Santarpio’s Pizza

I had heard a lot of great things about Santarpio’s, so I had to try it for myself. After walking through the door, I was immediately taken aback by the amazing smell coming from their kitchen. The atmosphere was definitely something special – there were old school photos and posters plastered all over the walls that really gave it a unique charm.

The pizza itself did not disappoint. The crust was perfectly thin and crispy, with just enough sauce to taste but not overwhelm your palate. The toppings were incredibly fresh and flavorful -meats, cheese, vegetables all cooked to perfection.

The overall experience at Santarpio’s Pizza was one of a kind. Whenever I’m in Peabody MA and looking for amazing pizza, this will definitely be my go-to spot!

#12 Capone’s Restaurant & Lounge

I was blown away by their selection of unique toppings. Not only did they have the classics, but they also had some unique combinations like mac and cheese and pulled pork! The crust was perfectly cooked with just the right amount of crunch.

The atmosphere was great too. The walls were decorated with photographs of Al Capone and there was a nice jazzy soundtrack playing in the background. You could tell that all the ingredients were top notch and fresh from local vendors.

My favorite part though was the service. Our waiter, who I’m convinced was an actual Mafioso, made sure we got our food quickly without sacrificing any quality whatsoever. He even offered us all free shots of whiskey at the end of our meal!

All in all, if you’re looking for some delicious pizza that has been crafted with care and love in Peabody MA then look no further than Capone’s Restaurant & Lounge! I can guarantee you won’t be disappointed!