Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Peoria IL (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Illinois

Best Pizza in Peoria IL (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

87 Views

I’ve been around the world to find delicious pizza, and I’m excited to share my findings for the best pizza in Peoria. After eating my way through twelve pizza places in the area, I’m ready to give you an honest review and reveal who has the best slice in town!

Get ready for some mouth-watering descriptions of crusts, sauces, and toppings as well as some hijinks on the journey. While this is a serious inquiry into good, quality pizza, I try to keep things lighthearted and fun. Let’s get eating!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Illinois

#1 Fedora’s Pizza & Gyro’s

The service was outstanding – friendly and helpful without being intrusive. The atmosphere was cozy and inviting, with cheerful music in the background.

As for the pizza, wow! I can honestly say that I have never had a pizza as flavorful as Fedora’s. The crust was thin, crunchy but not greasy, and the cheese and other toppings were perfectly balanced. The Gyros were also outstanding. Juicy, finely-spiced and flavorful, they melted in my mouth.

I am not exaggerating when I say that this is the best pizza I have ever tasted, bar none! Of course, you must try it to believe me, so go to Fedora’s Pizza & Gyro’s soon, before all of Peoria finds out what a gem they have in their midst!

If you’re willing to go an extra 38 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Bloomington!

#2 Leonardo’s Pizza

From the moment I walked in, it was obvious that Leonardo’s is serious about their pizza. The atmosphere of the restaurant was festive and inviting, with colorful decorations and a friendly staff.

The pizza itself did not disappoint. It arrived quickly, still hot and cheesy from the oven. The crust was light and fluffy, while the sauce had just the right amount of spice. Toppings were freshly picked and plentiful!

I can sincerely say that Leonardo’s Pizza has some of the best pizza I’ve ever tasted. Even after visiting many other pizzerias all over the world, nothing compares to what I experienced here at Leonardo’s Pizza. If you’re in Peoria IL and you want to experience some of the best pizza around, look no further than this gem!

#3 Nick-N-Willy’s Pizza Peoria

From the moment I stepped through their doors, I knew this place was special. From the vibrant atmosphere to the friendly staff, my expectations were exceeded as soon as I arrived!

The pizza itself was incredible! The crust was light and crispy, with just enough cheese and toppings to make it extra flavorful. Not to mention that their selection of sauces is out of this world; a perfect compliment for any pizza craving.

Altogether, Nick-N-Willy’s Pizza Peoria is the best spot in the area hands down – especially if you’re looking for true gourmet pizza. Don’t just take my word for it though; give them a try and experience it for yourself!

#4 Fat Jack’s Pizza LLC

The pizza crust was perfect. It had a delicious, crunchy, golden brown texture that was just right. The sauce was flavorful and tangy and complimented the toppings perfectly. Every bite of this pizza was filled with flavor and zest.

The topping selection at Fat Jack’s Pizza LLC is vast. You can choose from a variety of fresh vegetables like mushrooms, onions, bell peppers, and more! And if you’re a carnivore like me, there’s pepperoni, sausage, ham, bacon… I could go on for days about all the amazing options they have!

I also had the chance to sample some of their desserts–which were equally as delicious as their pizzas! Their homemade cinnamon sticks were out-of-this world! They were steaming hot when served and topped with a generous helping of sweet icing.

Overall, Fat Jack’s Pizza LLC takes the cake for having some of the best pizza in Peoria IL! From their delicious pizzas to the mouthwatering desserts they offer–these folks know how to make a great meal. If you’re ever in Peoria IL and looking for some tasty pizza…look no further than Fat Jack’s Pizza LLC!

#5 Agatucci’s Restaurant

When I walked into Agatucci’s, I was pleasantly surprised by the atmosphere. The place was bustling but still had that cozy, family-friendly vibe I love. They also serve alcohol so it’s great for adults who want to relax with a beer or glass of wine – plus they even have hard liquor if that’s your drink of choice.

The menu at Agatucci’s is also impressive. Along with all kinds of delicious pizza options, they also offer a kid’s menu and several desserts. What more could you ask for?! Their pizzas are made with locally sourced ingredients and freshly baked dough – there’s nothing quite like it!

But despite all the great food and atmosphere, Agatucci’s does have one downside: no delivery service. That means if you want to get your hands on this delicious pizza, then you’ll have to come pick it up yourself!

All in all, Agatucci’s Restaurant is one of the best places in Peoria IL for pizza and well worth a visit when you’re in town. Between the great selection of food, drinks, and desserts – plus its tourist-friendly location – what more could you ask for?!

#6 Chicago Pizzeria

When I walked in the door, I was immediately hit with the amazing smell of freshly baked pizza. The staff was friendly and welcoming, and they were happy to answer any questions I had about their menu.

My first impression of the pizza was very positive. The dough was light and fluffy, the topping selection was generous and flavorful, and the crust had a perfect crunchy texture. It’s no wonder they’ve been voted as having some of the best pizza in Peoria IL!

The atmosphere of Chicago Pizzeria was cozy yet modern. The seating area was comfortable and the staff provided excellent service throughout my visit. As I munched on pizza slices, I felt like I’d stepped into a bustling Italian kitchen with my taste buds on full alert!

In conclusion, if you’re ever in Peoria IL looking for some really delicious pizza then look no further than Chicago Pizzeria! This place has proved to me why it’s one of the best places to get pizza in town – from its mouth-watering toppings to its inviting atmosphere – it doesn’t get better than this!

#7 Veterans Pub & Pizza

The atmosphere at Veterans Pub & Pizza is top-notch. You can watch your favorite sports team on the big screen TVs and wash down whatever pizza you choose with a glass of beer, wine, or hard liquor. What more could one ask for?

As for the pizza itself – the crust was thin, crunchy and flavorful; the sauce was wonderfully balanced. Topped with colorful vegetables and a plentiful amount of cheese – this is a pizza experience to remember!

Unfortunately, Veterans Pub & Pizza doesn’t deliver, so you’ll have to go there in person to get your hands on one of their delicious pies. Trust me though – it’s worth it! A trip to Veterans Pub & Pizza makes for an unforgettable night out in Peoria IL.

#8 460° Pizza

Everything from the atmosphere to the staff to the food, was top-notch. The restaurant itself has a cozy, inviting ambiance. I love how they made me feel welcome from the moment I set foot in the door.

The staff at 460° Pizza was also great. Everyone had a positive attitude and was knowledgeable about their products. They were more than willing to answer any questions I asked and helped me make decisions about what to order.

But really, it’s all about the pizza! As soon as you take your first bite of one of their signature pies, you know that this is something special. The crust is light and fluffy – perfect for loading up with all kinds of toppings! Speaking of toppings, they have an incredible variety available – so it’s easy to find something to satisfy every craving.

Overall, 460° Pizza is definitely one of my top spots for pizza in Peoria IL. If you haven’t checked them out yet, I highly recommend giving them a try!

If you’re willing to go an extra 64 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Springfield!

#9 Rizzi’s Italian Restaurant

I was so impressed with the experience I had here. The atmosphere was inviting and warm, filled with great music and the smells of traditional Italian cooking.

The pizza itself is what really stands out. They use fresh, high-quality ingredients in all their recipes like homemade dough, vine-ripened tomatoes, and a variety of delicious cheeses. Their signature cheese blend adds an outstanding flavor and texture to their thin crust pizzas that you won’t find anywhere else.

The toppings are amazing too! From classic pepperoni to flavorful combinations like fennel sausage, prosciutto, and figs with goat cheese – Rizzi’s has something for everyone.

The service is also top notch! Each time we visited the staff was friendly and helpful. They took the time to explain all our options and were willing to make any special requests we had.

In conclusion, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Peoria IL – look no further than Rizzi’s Italian Restaurant!

#10 Godfather’s Pizza Express

The atmosphere was cozy and inviting – the perfect spot to eat a delicious meal. The staff were friendly and attentive, and they made me feel like part of their family.

The food was phenomenal! This was some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. The crust was perfectly cooked and had just the right amount of crunchiness. The sauce was flavorful and tangy, and the cheese melted in my mouth. And let’s not forget the toppings – from pepperoni to olives, it was all incredibly fresh.

If you’re looking for great pizza in Peoria IL, Godfather’s Pizza Express is definitely worth a visit! I highly recommend it for anyone seeking an unforgettable culinary experience!

#11 Weaver’s Fresh Food and Drink

The restaurant itself was warm and inviting, with a cozy atmosphere that made me feel at home. I immediately noticed the variety of liquor options they had behind the bar – my kind of place!

They also had a surprisingly robust kid’s menu considering the casual, local vibe. The portions were generous too – perfect for when you’re eating with young ones! What really impressed me was their impressive selection of desserts – an area that many restaurants often overlook.

On to the pizza: Thick and overloaded with toppings yet still cooked evenly throughout, Weaver’s completely delivered. Their signature cheese blend was bold and flavorful, and their sauces were spot on.

My only complaint is they don’t offer delivery – but I’m fine with making the short drive to this gem of a restaurant! All in all, Weaver’s Fresh Food and Drink earns my highest marks for their delicious pies and overall dining experience.

#12 Oliver’s Pizza & Pub North

The atmosphere at Oliver’s could best be described as cozy and inviting. The walls are adorned with pictures of Peoria landmarks, which was a nice touch. As soon as I entered the restaurant, I was hit with an aroma of melted cheese and spices – it was a sign that this pizza is going to be nothing short of spectacular!

I ordered one of their specialty pies and wow – right off the bat, it was clear that this pizza had been made with care and precision. The dough was perfectly cooked so that it had just enough crunch on the outside yet still remained soft inside. The sauce was flavorful and zesty, and the combination of toppings blended together perfectly – each bite was blissfully delightful!

Overall, my experience at Oliver’s Pizza & Pub North was one for the books! This place definitely deserves its title as having some of the best pizza in Peoria IL. If you find yourself in town, do pay them a visit – you won’t regret it!

Best Deep Dish Pizza – Chicago Pizzeria

Let me start by saying that this place is a hidden gem. Tucked away in a nondescript corner of town, it’s like finding the tastiest slice of heaven in a sea of lackluster pies. And let me tell you, the deep dish here is like a little piece of Chicago in Peoria.

First things first, they serve alcohol. This is important because let’s face it, who doesn’t enjoy a nice cold beer or a refreshing cocktail with their pizza? It’s like a match made in cheesy, saucy heaven.

And speaking of heaven, let’s talk about the desserts. Chicago Pizzeria knows that after indulging in their epic deep dish, you’re going to need something sweet to balance it out. And boy, do they deliver. From gooey chocolate lava cake to creamy tiramisu, they’ve got it all. It’s like a culinary trip to dessert paradise.

Now, I do have to mention that they don’t accept reservations. But honestly, that’s part of the charm. You walk in, put your name on the list, and patiently wait for your pizza masterpiece to arrive. It’s like a delicious version of waiting for Christmas morning.

In conclusion, if you’re on the hunt for the best deep dish pizza in peoria il, look no further than Chicago Pizzeria. With their mouthwatering pizzas, delightful dessert menu, and the perfect beverage lineup, it’s a pizza experience that will leave you wanting more. Just remember to bring your appetite and your sense of humor because this place is an absolute hoot!

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Hoops Pub & Pizza

Now, let me start by saying that Hoops Pub & Pizza is not your run-of-the-mill pizza joint. It’s a place where you can grab a slice of heaven and wash it down with a frosty brew. And let me tell you, the beer selection here is extensive! They even have hard liquor for those looking to take their pizza-eating experience to the next level. So, if you’re tired of boring pizza places that don’t serve alcohol, Hoops is the place to be.

Not only is the pizza top-notch, but Hoops also boasts a killer atmosphere. It’s a great spot for tourists who want to experience the local scene. You can catch a game on one of their many TVs while chowing down on a delicious slice. It’s like eating your way through Italy while cheering for your favorite sports team.

Now, I have to admit, there are a couple of downsides to Hoops. First, they don’t deliver, which means you’ll have to get off your couch and head on over if you want a taste. Secondly, they don’t accept reservations, so be prepared to wait for a table. But hey, good things come to those who wait, right?

So, if you find yourself in Peoria and craving the best thin crust pizza around, make your way to Hoops Pub & Pizza. Trust me, you won’t regret it. Just be sure to bring your appetite and a thirst for delicious pizza and cold drinks!