Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Pittsburgh PA (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Pennsylvania

Best Pizza in Pittsburgh PA (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

662 Views

I’ve tried a dozen pizzerias across the city, sampling every topping and crust imaginable. I’m here to share my findings with you, so if you’re looking for the best pizza in Pittsburgh, you’ve come to the right place!

This isn’t some boring article written by some food snob – it’s a fun and lighthearted take on all the wonderful pizza that can be found in Pittsburgh. So, pull up a seat and join me as I review these twelve delicious slices of heaven!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Pennsylvania

#1 Pizza Lupo

When I arrived at Pizza Lupo, I was immediately taken aback by the mouth-watering smells emanating from the kitchen. The wood-fired ovens create a unique flavor and texture that you can’t get anywhere else.

The service at Pizza Lupo was friendly and efficient, which is something I always look for when dining out. I especially enjoyed the fact that they were willing to customize a pizza just for me!

The pizza itself was delicious! The crust had a perfect combination of crispy yet chewy texture. The cheese was freshly melted with just the right amount of ooey gooey goodness. And the toppings? Let’s just say they stayed on the pizza well beyond my first bite!

In short, if you’re looking for an amazing pizza experience in Pittsburgh PA, make sure you check out Pizza Lupo. You won’t regret it!

If you’re willing to go an extra 2 miles, you can get to 25 more pizza places in Pittsburgh!

#2 Fiori’s Pizzaria

My first impression of the restaurant was great; it’s a nice tourist spot with a historic vibe that gives you a look into an old Italian pizzeria. I was even more impressed when I tasted their pizza. It didn’t disappoint! It had fresh ingredients, a light and crispy crust, and melted cheese that made my mouth water.

The staff were friendly too and it felt like home— almost like being in Italy itself. Unfortunately, they don’t do delivery service so if you are looking for the convenience factor go somewhere else.

But if you’re looking for some of the best pizza around, then Fiori’s Pizzaria is definitely worth checking out!

#3 Driftwood Oven

The pies are lovingly crafted with a special recipe that gives each one a unique flavor. The ingredients they use bring out some wonderfully complex and delicious flavors—from the pepperoni to the cheese, everything just pops!

The atmosphere is also inviting and warm, making you want to stay for another slice or two. Plus, the staff are all friendly and helpful, which helps make your experience even better.

But what really sets this pizza restaurant apart from the rest is the crust. It’s crispy but not too crunchy on the outside, with a fluffy interior that melts in your mouth like butter.

Overall, it was clear why Driftwood Oven holds its title as having some of the best pizza in Pittsburgh PA—this place knows how to do pizza! So if you’re looking for an unforgettable pizza experience then make sure you check it out soon!

#4 Benny Fierro’s

When I first walked in, the atmosphere was quite inviting. There were plenty of tables for diners and a bar for those who wanted to enjoy a beer or two with their meal. For tourists in the area, this is definitely a great spot to check out!

The pizza itself was simply delicious. The thin crust was perfectly crispy and the toppings were flavorful and plentiful. In my opinion, Benny Fierro’s has perfected the art of pizza-making in Pittsburgh PA!

Unfortunately, Benny Fierro’s doesn’t offer delivery services so you’ll have to visit the restaurant itself if you want to try their great pizza. That being said, it’s definitely worth the trip! All in all, I would highly recommend Benny Fierro’s for anyone looking for some of the best pizza in Pittsburgh PA!

#5 Sciulli’s Pizza

I’ve tried some of the most renowned pizza places in Italy and New York, but my experience at Sciulli’s Pizza was truly remarkable. The service was friendly, knowledgeable and attentive.

The pizza dough was freshly made each day, with the perfect combination of crunchy edges and a soft inside. The toppings were fresh and flavorful, making it an irresistible combination!

I particularly enjoyed the sausage pizza – it could be considered a work of art! The tomato sauce was sweet and savory and blended beautifully with the cheese. Everything melted together perfectly to make one delicious pie.

Overall, I had an outstanding experience at Sciulli’s Pizza and can confidently say it has some of the best pizza in Pittsburgh PA!

#6 Spak Brothers

I started off my visit with a slice of the signature double cheese, tomato and pepperoni pizza. The double cheese was gooey and flavorful, while the pepperoni was cooked to perfection – not too burnt, but just crispy enough. The tomato sauce was incredibly rich and had just the right balance of sweetness.

But I didn’t stop there; I moved on to the small specialty pizzas including the margherita and Hawaiian pizzas. Personally, I’m more of a traditionalist so I went with the margherita – it did not disappoint! The crust was wonderfully crunchy and held up well against all the toppings. Additionally, you can really taste freshness in every bite from the sweet tomatoes, creamy mozzarella, and savory basil that were featured.

My dining experience at Spak Brothers would not have been complete without ordering one of their famous calzones. They stuff each one with three kinds of cheese along with a blend of Italian spices like nutmeg and oregano – delicious! Plus it’s served with a side of hearty marinara which provides an extra zing that I absolutely love.

Overall, I’d say that if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Pittsburgh PA then look no further than Spak Brothers! From their large variety of specialty pies to traditional Italian favorites like calzones, there’s something for everyone!

#7 Fazio’s Pizza

When I first arrived at Fazio’s, I was delighted by the quaint Italian decor and the delicious smells wafting from the kitchen. As soon as I took my first bite of their signature pizza, I knew why it’s known as the best in town. The crust was perfectly cooked and had just the right amount of crunch to it. And oh, that sauce! It had a wonderfully bold flavor that will have me coming back for more.

What amazed me most was the variety of topping options available—something you don’t always find in your average pizza joint. Whether you like classic pepperoni or something more exotic like shrimp-avocado, they’ve got it all covered. For anyone looking to get creative with their pizza order (like myself!), they also offer a build-your-own option so you can really customize your meal.

The friendly staff made my visit even better; they were very attentive and knowledgeable about what they serve. Once I stepped out onto the street with my piping hot pie in hand, I realized why Fazio’s Pizza has been voted as some of the best pizza in Pittsburgh PA—the deliciousness speaks for itself!

#8 Badamo’s Pizza – Northside

When I first walked into the restaurant, I was immediately taken aback by its warm and inviting atmosphere. The decor was simple but elegant, and there was a welcoming energy that made me feel right at home.

The pizza itself is out of this world. The crust has a nice crunch on the outside, but is soft and chewy on the inside. The cheese is melty and gooey goodness that just melts in your mouth. And their sauce is the perfect blend of sweet, tangy, and savory — it’s just delicious.

My favorite part about Badamo’s Pizza Northside was their selection of unique toppings. From jalapeno to anchovies, they have something for everyone! But my absolute favorite topping was their homemade spicy sausage — it added an amazing kick to any slice!

Overall, I found Badamo’s Pizza Northside to be one of the best pizza places in Pittsburgh PA (if not the best!). Whether you’re looking for a quick bite or a full meal with friends or family, I guarantee you won’t be disappointed by what they have to offer. Experience it for yourself and taste why they say “Best Pizza in Pittsburgh PA”!

If you’re willing to go an extra 8 miles, you can get to 25 more pizza places in Monroeville!

#9 Michael’s Pizza Bar

When I arrived, the atmosphere was great and cozy, perfect for a night out with friends or family. The staff were friendly and the service was top-notch.

The pizza itself was incredible. The dough was light and fluffy, with a perfectly cooked crisp crust. The cheese was perfectly melted, and their unique blend of toppings left me wanting more! From pepperoni to prosciutto to artichoke hearts, they had all of my favorite toppings.

I also tried some of their side dishes including garlic knots and fried mozzarella sticks. Both were delicious and perfectly cooked.

To top it off, Michael’s Pizza Bar also offers craft beers from all over Pennsylvania in addition to a selection of local wines. Can’t beat that!

Overall, Michael’s Pizza Bar definitely deserves its reputation as one of the best places for pizza in Pittsburgh PA!

#10 Proper Brick Oven & Tap Room

I’ve had pizza everywhere from Rome to New York, and none of them compared to this place. The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, with a rustic brick oven in the corner that gives off an inviting smell as soon as you walk in.

The specialty here is wood-fired pizzas crafted from homemade dough and the freshest ingredients. There’s something for everyone—from classic pepperoni to inventive toppings like figs and prosciutto. Trust me—you won’t be disappointed!

The staff was friendly, professional, and attentive. They even brought out samples of some of their specialties so we could try before we ordered. And speaking of ordering, if you’re looking for value for money, you won’t find better anywhere else in Pittsburgh. Their prices are reasonable, and everything tastes amazing!

It’s safe to say that Proper Brick Oven & Tap Room has become my go-to spot when I’m in Pittsburgh searching for the best pizza around!

#11 Joe Cestone’s Pizzeria

Upon entering the restaurant, I was met with an atmosphere of warmth and hospitality. The staff were eager to help, and genuinely interested in my experience with their food.

The aesthetic of the restaurant is perfect – a blend of modern and rustic design elements that create an inviting environment.

As for the pizza, it’s simply divine! Every bite was a flavor explosion – fresh tomatoes, rich mozzarella cheese, and Joe’s famous secret sauce all combine to deliver perfection. The crust was just the right thickness – crisp on the outside and airy in the middle. And they offer various toppings to choose from so you can make your pizza as unique as you wish!

Overall, I highly recommend Joe Cestone’s Pizzeria for anyone looking for some truly delicious pizza in Pittsburgh PA! It’s definitely one of the best I’ve had – anywhere in the world!

#12 Iron Born Pizza & Pasta

When I stepped into the cozy restaurant, I felt like I had been transported to an Italian pizzeria. The delightful aromas of baking crust and fresh tomato sauce brought a smile to my face. I knew right away that this place was special.

The friendly staff welcomed me with open arms and handed me a menu full of mouth-watering options. After looking through each one, I decided to go for their classics: one regular-crust pizza and one thick Italian-style pie.

It wasn’t long before the pizzas were ready, and it was time to dig in! The regular pizza was fantastic – the dough was light and fluffy, yet still thin enough to have great crunch. The toppings were generous and flavorful; no skimping here! The thick pizza had all the same qualities but with an extra layer of cheese on top that really kicked it up a notch.

I never leave Iron Born without trying some pasta dishes, too – after all, they specialize in them! My server recommended the spaghetti carbonara, which had a creamy sauce that coated each strand perfectly. It tasted just like how my grandma used to make it – comforting perfection!

If you’re ever in Pittsburgh PA looking for some of the best pizza around, don’t hesitate to stop by Iron Born Pizza & Pasta. They’ve got something for everyone – from classic pies to unique Italian dishes – all served with love and care. You won’t regret it!

Best Deep Dish Pizza – Pizza Bosa

Now, let’s talk about the benefits of this joint. First off, they offer dessert. And oh boy, their chocolate lava cake is a dream come true! It’s like a molten explosion of sugary goodness in my mouth. I may have shed a tear of joy when I took my first bite. And let’s not forget about their cannoli, it’s so good that I had to resist the urge to stuff my pockets with them before leaving.

Another great thing about Pizza Bosa is that it’s a nice tourist spot. The place has a quirky and colorful atmosphere. The walls are covered in funny pizza-themed cartoons, and the staff is always cracking jokes and making you feel welcome. Plus, their outdoor seating area is perfect for people-watching and enjoying a slice of heaven.

However, there is one downside to Pizza Bosa that I feel obliged to mention. They do not accept reservations. Now, you might think this is not such a big deal, but trust me, when you’re a pizza enthusiast like me, waiting in line can feel like an eternity. I had to distract myself with pictures of pizzas on my phone to make it through the wait.

But hey, the wait was totally worth it. Pizza Bosa serves up a deep dish pizza that’s so divine it could convert even the most loyal thin-crust lovers. The crust is flaky and buttery, and the cheese is gooey beyond belief. Each bite is a symphony in your mouth, and all your worries just melt away.

All in all, Pizza Bosa is the place to be if you’re on the hunt for the best deep dish pizza in Pittsburgh. Just make sure you have a good book or some games on your phone to keep you entertained while you wait.

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Spak Brothers

From the moment I walked in, I could tell that this place was the real deal. The aroma of freshly baked dough mixed with the tantalizing scent of bubbling cheese greeted me at the door. I could practically hear my taste buds doing a happy dance.

Now, let’s talk about the crust. Oh, the crust! It was so thin and crispy, it was like biting into a cloud made of pizza perfection. Each bite was a crunchy symphony of flavors that danced on my palate. I couldn’t help but wonder if Michelangelo had some sort of hand in crafting this masterpiece.

As for the toppings, they didn’t skimp on those either. I ordered a classic Margherita, and let me tell you, it was a work of art. The fresh tomatoes blended magnificently with the creamy mozzarella, and the basil added just the right touch of freshness. Each bite was like a little slice of heaven.

But it wasn’t just the pizza that impressed me. The service was top-notch, and the atmosphere was cozy and inviting. The staff was friendly and attentive, making me feel like I was part of a big, pizza-loving family.

So, if you find yourself in Pittsburgh and craving some thin crust pizza that will transport you straight to pizza paradise, do yourself a favor and head to Spak Brothers. Trust me, your taste buds will thank you.

Best Wood Fired Pizza – Proper Brick Oven & Tap Room

Upon arriving at Proper Brick Oven & Tap Room, I was immediately drawn in by the heavenly aroma of pizzas cooking in their wood-fired oven. As a self-proclaimed pizza connoisseur, I knew right away that I was in for a treat. And boy, was I right!

Let’s start with the pizza itself. The thin, crispy crust was perfectly charred and had just the right amount of chewiness. It was like biting into a slice of heaven. The toppings range from classics like margherita and pepperoni to more adventurous options like brie and pear. They even had a delicious vegetarian option with an assortment of fresh veggies and gooey cheese. It was so good, even the meat lovers at the table didn’t miss their usual toppings.

Now, onto the fun stuff—alcohol! Proper Brick Oven & Tap Room not only serves beer, but they also have a selection of hard liquor. This is a pizza place that knows how to keep the good times rolling! And let’s not forget about dessert. Their sweet creations are out of this world. I indulged in a warm and gooey Nutella pizza that had me singing its praises for days.

There is one downside to Proper Brick Oven & Tap Room, though—they don’t accept reservations. So if you’re planning on visiting during peak hours, be prepared to wait. But trust me, it’ll be worth it. Plus, while you wait, you can entertain yourself by gazing at the tourist spots surrounding the restaurant.

All in all, Proper Brick Oven & Tap Room is the place to go if you’re looking for the best wood-fired pizza in downtown Pittsburgh. With its incredible pizza, wide selection of drinks, and entertaining atmosphere, you can’t go wrong. Just make sure to arrive early or be prepared for a wait, but I promise you, it’s well worth it!