Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Point Pleasant (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in New Jersey

Best Pizza in Point Pleasant (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

244 Views

I’m not just picking pizza places at random; I’ve gone all over the world trying pies and know what to look for. And with a dozen pizzerias in this small town, you know there had to be some good ones.

So don my food critic hat and hold onto your forks, because I’m taking you on a journey through Point Pleasant’s pizza offerings! Let’s see which restaurant reigns supreme and have some fun along the way.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New Jersey

#1 Maria’s Pizza Point Pleasant

The atmosphere was inviting and friendly, with a warm and cozy decor. The staff was very helpful in helping me find the perfect pizza for my taste.

I ordered their signature Maria’s Pie and it did not disappoint! The crust was perfectly thin and crunchy, the cheese perfectly melted, and the toppings were to die for. It was one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had in my life! Even if you’re not a fan of thin crusts like I am, this pizza is sure to please everyone – it had just the right amount of crunch without being overly crispy.

The other dishes they offer are also amazing – from salads and sandwiches to delicious calzones. No matter what you decide to order at Maria’s Pizza Point Pleasant, you’ll be sure to have an unforgettable experience. They truly make some of the best pizza in Point Pleasant!

If you’re willing to go an extra 3 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Brick Township!

#2 DiMatteo’s Pizza & Pasta

From the moment I entered the restaurant, I was intoxicated by the smell of freshly baked pizza. The interior of DiMatteo’s Pizza & Pasta is modern and inviting. It looks like a perfect spot to enjoy a delicious slice of pizza and chat with friends.

The menu at DiMatteo’s is extensive, ranging from classic pepperoni pizzas to unique creations like their Tomato Rabe and Gorgonzola pie. I took advantage of their generous portion sizes and ordered a few different slices for sampling – including their signature Buffalo Chicken Pizza! And boy was it good!

The crust was perfectly crisped on the outside yet still airy and chewy on the inside – just how it should be. Not only that, but they also use only fresh ingredients with no preservatives or artificial flavors. As if that wasn’t enough, they also offer homemade pasta dishes that are simply divine!

After trying out almost every menu item, I can confidently say DiMatteo’s Pizza & Pasta serves up some of the best pizza in Point Pleasant! So don’t wait another minute…get down to DiMatteo’s for an amazing Italian experience you won’t soon forget!

#3 Oakwood’s Point Pizza

The atmosphere was cozy and inviting, and the staff was friendly. I made sure to arrive with an empty stomach as I knew I’d be trying a wide variety of menu items.

To start, I had to try their signature pizza. It was delicious! The crust was perfectly cooked with both a soft center and just the right amount of crunch on the edges. Plus the toppings were perfectly balanced – each bite had savory sausage, sweet onions, and creamy cheese all in one.

Next up, I sampled their deep dish garlic bread. This wasn’t your average garlic bread – it had layers of rich buttery goodness that melted in my mouth! And don’t even get me started on how amazingly flavorful the garlic oil was – so good!

Finally, for dessert I indulged in some Nutella calzones. The warm Nutella oozing inside each pocket of dough was absolute perfection.

Overall, Oakwood’s Point Pizza provided me with an amazing experience that will be hard to beat! It’s no wonder why locals call it the best pizza in Point Pleasant – you’ve got to check it out if you haven’t already!

#4 Little Mia’s ll Pizza

The first thing that caught my eye was the beautiful, authentic Italian decor. Red and white checkered table cloths, tons of family photos hanging on the walls and a large wooden pizza oven in the corner. What more could a food critic ask for?

Next, I noticed an impressive variety of pizza options on the menu- from classic slices to more unique speciality pies. I tried a little bit of everything and was not disappointed! The Margherita pizza was as good as any I’ve had in Naples and the Calzone, stuffed with fresh mozzarella, basil and prosciutto was simply heavenly.

It’s easy to see why Little Mia’s ll Pizza has earned its reputation of being some of the best pizza in Point Pleasant. It has excellent atmosphere, great service (this is coming from someone who has visited many restaurants around the world) and most importantly, truly delicious food. If you ever have a chance to visit this place – don’t miss out!

#5 Pat’s Pizza

As soon as I walked in I could smell the heavenly combination of garlic, tomato sauce, and cheese. From the first bite, I knew this was something special. The pizza had a perfect crust that was golden brown and crunchy on the outside and chewy on the inside. Topped with savory tomatoes, flavorful sausage, and a generous amount of cheese, it was just how a great slice of pizza should be.

I also sampled some of Pat’s specialty pies – their deep dish stuffed with pepperoni was an absolute delight! Not too greasy, but cooked to perfection with just enough crispness to keep everything together. And the topping combination was amazing!

The service at Pat’s Pizza is second-to-none too. All my questions were answered courteously and promptly and they even gave me some complimentary samples while I waited for my order. Everything arrived hot with no fuss or mess – a testament to the skill of their cooks!

In conclusion, after tasting some of the best pizzas from around the world, I’m convinced that Pat’s Pizza serves up some of the best pizza in Point Pleasant! Delicious toppings combined with perfect dough and expert cooking make this a must-try if you’re ever in town!

#6 Rosie’s Pizza

Although there are no delivery options, I’m more than happy to brave the journey and make my way down to the city. In exchange, I get to soak up some of the lovely sights and sounds of Point Pleasant while enjoying some tasty pizza. That’s a fair trade-off as far as I’m concerned.

With a menu that caters to vegetarians with plenty of veggie options, Rosie’s Pizza will have something for everyone! Plus, their pizzas are just so delicious that you won’t be able to resist ordering a few slices more than you initially planned. It’s all worth it though, because once you take your first bite you’ll be instantly transported into pizza heaven!

In conclusion, if you want one of the best pizzas in Point Pleasant then look no further than Rosie’s Pizza!

#7 Esposito’s Pizza

The atmosphere was amazing; they have outdoor seating under strings of twinkle lights and the indoor seating has a cozy, rustic feel that I just love. Not to mention, it is the perfect spot for people watching in the summer.

The pizza itself was outstanding! The crust was perfectly thin and crispy and the sauce had a nice kick to it. The toppings were plentiful and made for some of the best combinations I’ve ever eaten. Plus, their selection of craft beers was surprisingly good as well.

Furthermore, the service at Esposito’s Pizza was top notch too. The servers were friendly, knowledgeable about the menu options, and went above and beyond to make sure we were happy with our dining experience.

Overall Esposito’s Pizza deserves all 5 stars! If you’re ever looking for some of the best pizza in Point Pleasant, be sure to check this place out – you won’t regret it!

If you’re willing to go an extra 8 miles, you can get to 20 more pizza places in Belmar!

#8 Vesuvio Pizza

The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, and you can’t help but smile as soon as you enter. The servers are friendly, the drinks are plentiful, and the food is amazing. And let’s be honest: we’re all here for the pizza!

Vesuvio Pizza’s pies are cooked perfectly in their wood-fired ovens, creating a sublime combination of crisp crusts and juicy toppings. The combinations of unique ingredients create an unparalleled flavor that will have your taste buds shouting for more.

As I sipped my drink and bit into each slice, it became clear to me that Vesuvio Pizza truly has some of the best pizza in Point Pleasant. I mean it when I say that no other pizza establishment comes close to being this amazing! So if you’re ever in town, be sure to stop by Vesuvio Pizza and see what all the fuss is about!

#9 Joe Spano’s Tomato Pies

When I walked into the restaurant, I was struck by the robust aroma of tomatoes and freshly-baked pizza. The interior is cozy and inviting, and Joe himself was there to greet me with a smile. His enthusiasm for pizza-making was evident—it’s clear he takes his craft seriously.

The menu offers all kinds of options that cover classic flavors as well as some more creative pies. After doing some extensive research (read: tasting every single one), I can confidently say that the combination of crust thickness, quality ingredients, and just the right amount of spices make Joe Spano’s pizzas stand out from the competition.

I’m happy to give my stamp of approval to Joe Spano’s Tomato Pies—they’ve risen above all others in Point Pleasant for having truly delicious pizza!

#10 Pizza Express

I was welcomed by their warm and friendly staff, which made me feel right at home. The first thing I noticed was the delicious smell that was emanating from the restaurant. After being seated, I got to look over their extensive menu which boasted a variety of pizzas – including some vegetarian options – as well as sandwiches, salads and desserts.

I decided to try the pizza with extra cheese and pepperoni, and it did not disappoint! The crust was perfectly crisp on the outside yet still fluffy on the inside. The sauce was flavorful but not too spicy, and the cheese and pepperoni combination was just perfect.

The portions were generous yet still enough for us to be able to try out other pizzas from the menu. We had a few others – supreme, margherita, Hawaiian – all delicious! We finished off the meal with an order of garlic knots which were heavenly!

If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Point Pleasant then Pizza Express is definitely worth checking out! Their friendly staff, mouth watering pizzas and delectable desserts make this one of my favorite spots when I’m in town.

#11 Graziano’s Italian Restaurant

When I first walked in, I was immediately greeted by the delicious and inviting aromas of pizza. A smiling server welcomed me to my table, adding an extra touch that made me feel welcome and important.

The menu was full of mouthwatering selections. I finally decided to go with a classic pepperoni pizza, but after seeing all the other delicious options I almost changed my mind! The pizza came out piping hot and smelled like heaven. The thin crust was cooked perfectly and had a nice crunch when you bit into it. The sauce was sweet and tangy, while the cheese melted in your mouth. The toppings were fresh and added just the right amount of flavor to this masterpiece.

I washed down the pizza with an ice-cold beer — bliss! On top of the great food, Graziano’s Italian Restaurant also offers a pleasant atmosphere that adds to its charm. Soft music plays in the background while patrons chat amicably over their pizzas.

Overall, Graziano’s Italian Restaurant is definitely worthy of my seal of approval — it’s easily one of the best pizza places in Point Pleasant!

#12 Papa V’s

I was especially impressed with their unique flavor combinations. The crust was so light, yet still crispy and savory, that it melted in my mouth. The toppings all brought something special to the experience – the pepperoni had a perfect balance of sweet and spicy; the mushrooms were juicy; and the peppers provided a nice pop of color.

What truly set Papa V’s apart from other pizza places, however, was how fresh the ingredients were. Everything tasted amazing and I could tell that they put plenty of love into every slice.

The service at Papa V’s was also top-notch. The staff had great attitudes and went out of their way to make sure I enjoyed my meal. Plus, the prices were affordable – especially given all of the outstanding food on offer.

All in all, Papa V’s is hands down some of the best pizza in Point Pleasant! Whether you’re looking for a casual lunch or an evening out with friends, this place will deliver!