Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Puyallup (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Washington

Best Pizza in Puyallup (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

135 Views

I have sampled 12 of the best pizzerias in the area during my quest, and I am here to report on which one is truly worthy of being crowned the “Best Pizza in Puyallup.” Sure, it’s a highly competitive title to claim, but somebody has to do it!

My journey has been filled with mouthwatering crusts, savory sauces, and ingredients that make you say “yum!” I’ll be honest – I’ve had some bad slices along the way. But for those of you looking for the most flavorful pie in town, have no fear – I’m about to share all that I’ve learned.

So come along with me as we explore together all that Puyallup has to offer in terms of the perfect pizza slice. Who knows? Maybe by the end you might even be convinced to crown your own “best pizza” too!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Washington

#1 Pizza Twist – Puyallup, WA

The atmosphere is inviting and the staff is friendly, which is always key for me. The pizza itself is top-notch. Their pepperoni slices are super thin and crispy, while their cheese slices are so gooey, it’s almost impossible to eat without getting your hands a little messy.

One unique ability that Pizza Twist has is their custom-made pizzas. Whether you want something as simple as a plain cheese pie, or something more complex like a grilled chicken and jalapeno pizza with pineapple chunks, they can make it happen! Sure beats ordering from my local joint back home.

When I told my friends back home that I found the best pizza in Puyallup at Pizza Twist, they all laughed at me… until they tried it themselves! Now even THEY can’t stop raving about this place and how great the pizza tastes.

Trust me: If you’re looking for great pizza in Puyallup, look no further than Pizza Twist. You won’t be disappointed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 10 miles, you can get to 26 more pizza places in Tacoma!

#2 Wicked Pie Pizza

I’m not sure if it’s the freshly made dough, the high-quality ingredients, or just the sheer level of cheesy deliciousness that makes this pizza so good. Whatever it is, Wicked Pie Pizza has got it down pat!

The toppings are abundant, with a wide range of choices to suit all tastes. You can always count on the combinations being flavorful and creatively arranged. I’ve had everything from vegan pizzas topped with roasted vegetables to classic pepperoni pies – every single one was simply divine!

What really makes this place stand out is their friendly atmosphere. No matter what time of day you decide to visit, you’re guaranteed to get a warm welcome from their knowledgeable staff. Plus, everything here is affordably priced – perfect for trying out some truly gourmet cuisine without breaking the bank!

If you’re looking for a restaurant in Puyallup that serves up some of the best pizza around, you owe it to yourself to pay a visit to Wicked Pie Pizza. I guarantee that you won’t regret it – and neither will your taste buds!

#3 Pizza Time Puyallup

The atmosphere is inviting and family-friendly. The décor features props from classic movies and TV shows, offering a unique touch that no other pizza place in town seems to have. But the real highlight of my experience was the pizzas!

I ordered up a medium pepperoni pizza with extra cheese, and it was delicious! The back of the crust was perfectly baked with a crunchy texture that held up well to the rich toppings. The pepperoni had just enough heat to make it interesting, while the cheese had a smooth and creamy texture – definitely some of the best cheese I’ve ever had on a pizza!

The staff at Pizza Time Puyallup also deserves special mention for their friendly service. They knew what I wanted as soon as I stepped up to the counter – impressive for someone who travels around so much!

If you’re looking for great pizza in Puyallup, don’t hesitate to check out Pizza Time Puyallup – you won’t be disappointed!

#4 Giorgio’s Greek Cafe

I’m a pretty tough critic when it comes to pizza, so I was not expecting much as I stepped into Giorgio’s. But I was immediately taken with the atmosphere—it was cozy and inviting, with an old-world vibe.

The pizza itself was outstanding! The crust had that perfect crunch that I look for, and the cheese…oh my goodness, the cheese. It was melted to perfection and loaded with flavor. And let’s not forget the toppings—they were fresh and tasty.

But even more impressive than the delicious pizza at Giorgio’s was the service I received. Everyone who worked there seemed genuinely happy to be there, taking time to chat with me about their amazing recipes and local favorites.

Overall, I’d have to say that Giorgio’s is easily the best pizza in Puyallup! If you’re looking for a great night out or just a delicious slice of pizza, head on over to Giorgio’s Greek Cafe—you won’t be disappointed!

#5 Fat Zach’s Pizza – Downtown Puyallup

I had the pleasure of visiting this pizzeria and it was definitely a unique experience. As soon as I stepped inside, I was greeted with a friendly, laid-back atmosphere. It was like being welcomed into someone’s home.

The pizza is, in short, incredible. Every slice is loaded up with quality ingredients and cooked to perfection. There’s a wide range of creative toppings to choose from and no matter what selection you’re making, it’ll be delicious! I opted for the classic Margherita and it was texturally perfect with just the right amount of crunch and char on the crust.

On top of that, Fat Zach’s Pizza – Downtown Puyallup has great prices; so much so that I could barely believe it! That combined with their excellent customer service and comfortable atmosphere makes this place truly memorable.

If you’re ever in Puyallup looking for some of the best pizza around, be sure to check out Fat Zach’s Pizza – Downtown Puyallup!

#6 Trackside Pizza

I arrived at Trackside Pizza famished and ready for a good meal. The staff were very friendly and welcoming and I immediately knew that I had come to the right place!

The pizza was divine. It was cooked perfectly with the cheese melted just right, the sauce flavorful without being too salty and the crust light but still crispy. All in all, it was the perfect combination of ingredients that made for a great pizza!

The toppings were also top notch with an array of fresh vegetables like mushrooms, red peppers, onions and even artichokes. I found myself marveling at the various combinations they created that tasted like nothing I’ve ever had before.

It’s no wonder why locals consider Trackside Pizza to be the best pizza in Puyallup. In my opinion, it truly lived up to its reputation! If you’re ever in town looking for some delicious pizza, this is definitely a spot you can’t miss.

#7 MOD Pizza

The location is modern and trendy, and the staff are friendly and accommodating. From the moment you walk in, you can tell that it’s a cut above your average pizza joint.

But let’s get to the good stuff – the pizza! MOD Pizza offers an extensive menu of classic pizzas, as well as creative custom-made pies. Whether you’re looking for something traditional or something inspired, MOD Pizza has it all!

I opted for a custom pizza with classic marinara sauce, mozzarella cheese, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, and green peppers. It was a fantastic combination of flavors that I recommend to anyone looking for something truly tasty! The crust was just the right balance between thin and crispy.

Overall, I’m beyond impressed with MOD Pizza. They have some of the best pizza in Puyallup and I would definitely recommend them to anyone visiting this city. It’s definitely worth stopping by – you won’t regret it!

If you’re willing to go an extra 10 miles, you can get to 22 more pizza places in Federal Way!

#8 Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza

The first thing that stands out about Papa Murphy’s is how fresh everything tastes. Every time I come here, the dough is always made right in front of me and it tastes just like it was freshly made. The toppings are always top notch as well – they never skimp on flavor or quality, no matter what toppings you choose.

The pizza cooking process is also uniquely fun. You get to take all your ingredients home and assemble the pizza yourself! Baking it in your own oven makes it all the more special and delicious. Plus, it’s a great way to bond with family or friends as you build your perfect pizza together.

Finally, the prices here are really reasonable for all that incredible flavor you get. With so many options to choose from and customizable pizzas, everyone is sure to find something they will love at Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza.

I’m confident in saying that this place has some of the best pizza in Puyallup, so definitely swing by if you’re hungry for authentic Italian pizza flavors!

#9 The Rock Wood Fired Pizza

The atmosphere is incredible, with some of the most upbeat and welcoming staff I’ve ever encountered. The pizza itself is something out of this world. It’s cooked fresh in their wood burning oven to perfection, giving it a rich, smoky flavor that takes me back to my childhood days spent visiting family in Tuscany.

The crust is thin and crunchy with just the right amount of chewy crispness, while the toppings are always fresh and flavorful. They also have some really unique specialty pizzas that are out-of-this-world creative and delicious – like their Chicken Parmigiano Pizza or the Pie Of The Wagon Wheel – definitely worth a try!

Overall, The Rock Wood Fired Pizza has everything you could want for an amazing meal – friendly service, great atmosphere and mouth watering pizza. After all my travels around the world searching for great pizza, I’m confident when I say that they offer some of the best pizza in Puyallup!

#10 Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza

The setup at this pizza joint is pretty cool. You walk in, pick the dough and toppings that you want, grab some oven mitts, and you’re good to go! I appreciate their commitment to making sure customers have a great experience.

As for the pizza itself, it’s absolutely amazing. The crust has a nice crunch on the outside, but it’s soft and chewy on the inside. And the toppings are fresh and flavorful – not too much and not too little.

In short, I definitely recommend Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza if you’re looking for a great pizza experience in Puyallup. Not only do they make it easy to create your own custom pie, but the quality of the ingredients is top-notch – enough to satisfy even this world-traveling food critic!

#11 Round Table Pizza

The first time I visited Round Table Pizza, I knew I was in for a treat. From their high-quality ingredients to their unique and flavorful toppings, it was clear that they take pizza seriously here.

The crust is light and fluffy with just the right amount of crunch. It’s also dusted with a hint of garlic powder for a unique flavor you won’t find anywhere else. The toppings are always fresh, never frozen, and provide an explosion of flavor with every bite. My favorite is the Hawaiian Supreme: it has just the right balance of salty and sweet and it tastes like an island vacation in a single slice!

The atmosphere at Round Table Pizza is great too. The staff are friendly, welcoming and attentive to all guests. They also have plenty of TVs, which make this spot perfect for game nights or watching the big game on Sundays.

At the end of the day, Round Table Pizza serves up some of the best pizza in Puyallup! Their combination of delectable pizzas, lively atmosphere and top-notch customer service make this place one of my new favorite spots in town!

#12 Casa Mia Italian Restaurant

The atmosphere here is cozy and inviting, with soft Italian music playing overhead. The staff are all friendly and helpful, as well.

Now to the food. The pizza here is delicious! It’s made with fresh ingredients and cooked to perfection. Every bite is flavorful and satisfying. I especially love the pepperoni pizza – it has an amazing blend of flavors that really tantalize the taste buds!

My only complaint is that there could be more topping choices available for a more customized pizza. But even without extra toppings, Casa Mia Italian Restaurant has some of the best pizza in Puyallup. If you’re ever looking for great Italian food, definitely check out this place!