Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Cincinnati (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Ohio

Best Pizza in Cincinnati (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

405 Views

I’ve enjoyed slices around the world, from Italy to New York. But here in Cincinnati, I was determined to find the best pie.

So I decided to go on a pizza tour. Over the last few weeks, I ate my way through 12 of Cincinnati’s pizzerias – from independent mom-and-pop joints to international franchises. Now, I’m ready to share my findings with you and declare once and for all which is the ‘Best Pizza in Cincinnati.’

It’s sure to be a lighthearted and humorous ride, so grab your fork and fasten your seatbelt! Let’s get ready to experience some epic pizza!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Ohio

#1 Saint Francis Apizza

The atmosphere at Saint Francis Apizza is cozy and inviting, making it the perfect spot to grab a quick dinner. The menu offers both traditional and vegetarian options so everyone can find something they like. The pizza was cooked to perfection; the cheese melted flawlessly, the dough was fluffy yet crunchy, and the vegetables tasted incredibly fresh.

No delivery is available for Saint Francis Apizza, however many have said that makes their pizza even better because it’s served hot from the oven. Plus, you get to enjoy other aspects of the restaurant during your visit, such as their outstanding service!

Overall, I think Saint Francis Apizza is one of Cincinnati’s best pizza spots. If you are looking for a unique experience and some delicious pizza then add this place to your list!

If you’re willing to go an extra 16 miles, you can get to 24 more pizza places in Mason!

#2 Dewey’s Pizza

Not only does it offer delicious pizza, but it also has some great benefits that make it stand out from the rest. The restaurant serves alcoholic beverages, including hard liquor, for those looking for a night out with friends. They have vegetarian options, so even my vegan friends can join in on the fun! Plus, they offer dessert – a rare find in most pizza spots!

The atmosphere at Dewey’s Pizza makes it a great place to hang out while visiting Cincinnati as well – the walls are decorated with local art and memorabilia. That alone makes it worth going to!

The only downside is that they don’t offer delivery – but that’s not too much of an issue if you’re already there checking the place out.

All in all, I highly recommend Dewey’s Pizza. It’s definitely one of the best places I’ve had pizza in Cincinnati!

#3 Dewey’s Pizza

I’ve had a lot of great pizza in my travels, and Dewey’s stands out among the rest. The crust was perfectly crisp with just enough chew, and the toppings were fresh and flavorful. They also offer creative topping combinations like macaroni & cheese and buffalo chicken that really hit the spot!

The staff was friendly too. I was greeted with a smile when I walked in, and they accommodated my special requests without any problems. Plus, their prices are surprisingly affordable for high-quality pizza.

Overall, if you’re looking for fantastic pizza in Cincinnati then Dewey’s Pizza is your best bet! They have all of the elements that go into great pizza: quality ingredients, delicious flavors, friendly service, and reasonable prices. Go check them out – you will not be disappointed!

#4 Forno Osteria+Bar

Where else can you get pizza, hard liquor, and vegetarian options all under one roof? The answer is Forno Osteria+Bar.

The great atmosphere and staff also set the restaurant apart from its competition. There’s a good vibe around the place and I felt welcomed immediately.

The menu features something for everyone – both meat-eaters and vegetarians alike can find something to their taste. And bless them for it! In addition to the plethora of tasty pizzas, they offer handmade pasta dishes that will make you melt with delight.

And don’t even get me started on the desserts – outrageously good! I’m still dreaming about the Tiramisu I ate there. It practically sent me into nirvana!

The only downside is that there is no delivery option available at this time (although hopefully that will change soon!) but it’s definitely worth taking a short trip to try out this delicious pizza in person. So if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Cincinnati, then make sure to pay a visit to Forno Osteria+Bar – you won’t be disappointed!

#5 Italianette Pizza

From the moment I walked through the doors, I knew I was in for something special. The inviting atmosphere, delicious aromas, and bubbly staff all greeted me with enthusiasm.

The pizza was absolutely amazing! The crust was light and fluffy, the cheese melted to perfection, and the toppings were just right. It seemed like they had put a lot of care into making my pie just right.

To top it off, their signature garlic breadsticks are out of this world! They were hot and fresh out of the oven with just enough garlic flavor to really bring out the flavor of the pizza.

All-in-all, Italianette Pizza is an excellent option if you’re looking for delicious pizza in Cincinnati. You can be sure that your experience will be top-notch – from start to finish!

#6 Goodfellas Pizzeria – OTR

I love the atmosphere of this place – it’s a great spot to watch sports and have some drinks. They serve not only beer, but also hard liquor! So you can really feel like you’re in Italy while enjoying your pizza. Plus, for those of us who are vegetarian, there are several options that make for a delicious meal.

The pizza itself is absolutely amazing. The crust is thin and crispy, and the toppings are cooked to perfection. I usually get the classic Margherita but I’ve tried several of their specialty pizzas too – all equally delicious!

One thing that Goodfellas Pizzeria – OTR could work on is offering delivery. That being said, it’s still worth taking a trip to enjoy the atmosphere, try some tasty pizza, and grab a dessert afterwards.

To sum up my experience – Goodfellas Pizzeria – OTR has earned its place as one of the best places for pizza in Cincinnati!

#7 Adriatico’s

My first visit to Adriatico’s was nothing short of a revelation. I had heard good things about the restaurant, but I was not prepared for the amazing pizza experience that awaited me. The thin crust and flavorful toppings made for a delicious combination that I will never forget.

The menu is full of unique, creative options that are sure to please even the pickiest of eaters. From vegetarian options to classic pepperoni, Adriatico’s has something for everyone. Even better, their prices are very reasonable considering the quality of their pizza.

But what really sets Adriatico’s apart from other pizza places is its charming atmosphere and friendly staff. From the moment you walk in you feel welcomed and at ease. The servers go out of their way to ensure that your experience is pleasant, making it enjoyable to stay and chat with friends while enjoying some great food.

Overall, Adriatico’s is by far one of the best pizza places I’ve visited in Cincinnati! If you’re looking for some delicious pizza without breaking the bank, then look no further than Adriatico’s!

#8 Fireside Pizza

The atmosphere in the restaurant is great and the vibe is perfect. I had a beer while pondering my order. Fireside Pizza has some really nice vegetarian options, so that’s always a plus.

The pizza itself was simply divine! The crust was perfectly thin and crispy, not too doughy. The ingredients were fresh and delicious, truly some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. From classic pepperoni to creative Mediterranean veggie pizzas, they really have something for everyone at Fireside Pizza.

The only downside was that they don’t do delivery (they get busy enough as it is). But if you’re looking for a great pizza experience in Cincinnati, then Fireside Pizza is definitely worth visiting!

If you’re willing to go an extra 16 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Florence!

#9 Ramundo’s Pizzeria

From the moment I stepped foot in this small pizzeria, I was absolutely delighted. The atmosphere was lively and fun – waitstaff were hustling around with a smile on their face, music was playing in the background, and the aroma of pizza filled the air. It felt like a proper Italian joint!

The top-notch service didn’t stop there; everyone from the hostess to the servers were incredibly friendly, making sure that I had an enjoyable experience.

And oh boy, did I ever enjoy my meal – it seemed like all of my travels in search of great pizza had paid off! The crust on each slice was perfectly thin and crispy, while having just enough stretch when picked up. Each bite packed incredible flavor – sauce was savory with a hint of sweet, cheese melted into a thick layer of creamy goodness, and toppings were always fresh and flavorful.

Plus they had unique combinations that blended classic flavors in new ways – everything from pepperoni paired with banana peppers to jalapeno poppers melted into provolone cheese! Can you say yum?!

Overall, Ramundo’s Pizzeria has made me realize why people think Cincinnati is one of the best places to get great pizza. So for anyone looking for amazing slices or someone who wants a fun time out on the town – make sure to check them out! They are certainly one of my favorites now!

#10 Zablong

I arrived at Zablong on a hot summer day and was immediately greeted by friendly staff and the smell of delicious pizza. As soon as I stepped inside, I knew I’d found something special. The interior had the perfect blend of modern decor and cozy vibes that made me feel right at home.

The menu was extensive and featured a wide range of pizzas from classic Italian to specialty creations that I hadn’t seen before. Despite my anticipation, it still took me some time to decide what to get as every option sounded intriguing! In the end, I opted for the classic margherita pizza – which proved itself to be one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had!

The crust was spot-on – not too thick or thin – and it possessed that perfect balance of crunchiness and chewiness. On top of this, the tomato sauce packed an amazing flavor punch while the mozzarella cheese melted perfectly into a bubbly goodness. Then there were generous amounts of fresh basil topping it all off and making this pizza shine even brighter.

This pizza has changed my opinion about Cincinnati and put Zablong high on my list for best pizza in town! I can’t wait to return for more great meals here and would highly recommend it for anyone looking for an unforgettable food experience!

#11 Werkhaus Pizza

The first thing that stands out to me when I enter the restaurant is their artisanal approach to making pizza. Their dough is made in-house and tastes fresh and delicious. They use only the freshest ingredients, like carefully selected tomatoes, mozzarella cheese, and herbs that give their pizzas a unique flavor.

The other thing that really impressed me about Werkhaus Pizza was their atmosphere. The restaurant has a modern industrial vibe coupled with warm lighting that creates a great place to dine in. The staff are friendly and knowledgeable about the menu, which makes ordering an enjoyable experience.

But the best part of my experience at Werkhaus Pizza was definitely their pizza. They make all kinds of classic pies, from Margherita to Meat Lover’s. But what really stood out for me was their specialty pizzas, like the Smokey BBQ Chicken Pizza or Mediterranean Veggie Pie which both featured some amazing flavor combinations — sure to make your tastebuds dance!

All in all, I would absolutely recommend Werkhaus Pizza as the best pizza in Cincinnati!

#12 MOD Pizza

The environment is inviting and cozy, with an open kitchen so diners can watch the chefs prepare their pizzas. The staff are friendly and take time to explain the menu and toppings to customers. The best part is being able to customize your own pizza with all of the delicious ingredients!

I’m no stranger to pizza – I’ve been tasting it from Italy to South America – but MOD Pizza has remained one of my favorites. The quality of ingredients used is superior, and every pizza was cooked perfectly! And for those who are feeling creative, there’s an option to create a completely unique dish that everyone will enjoy.

Overall, MOD Pizza offers some of the best pizza in Cincinnati. It’s perfect for a quick bite or a long night out with friends. Highly recommended!

Best Deep Dish Pizza – TAGLIO Columbia Tusculum

Picture this: You walk into TAGLIO and are immediately greeted by the tantalizing smell of pizza and the sight of a fully stocked bar. Yes, my friends, they serve not only alcohol but hard liquor! It’s like a culinary dream come true. So not only can you have your pizza, but you can also have a nice cocktail to wash it down. It’s a win-win situation.

Now, I know what you’re thinking – what about us vegetarians? Fear not! TAGLIO has some amazing vegetarian options that will make even the most dedicated meat-lover drool. From their classic Margherita to their creative Veggie Supreme, they’ve got all your green, leafy bases covered.

But here’s the best part, folks. TAGLIO doesn’t just stop at pizza. Oh no! They offer dessert too. So after you’ve devoured your pizza masterpiece, you can treat yourself to a decadent dessert. It’s like the cherry on top of an already perfect meal.

And let’s not forget about the atmosphere. TAGLIO is located in a prime tourist spot, making it a great place to get your pizza fix while also taking in the sights. Plus, they have TVs everywhere, so it’s the perfect spot for sports enthusiasts who want to catch the game while enjoying their delicious pie.

Now, the one downside is that TAGLIO does not accept reservations. But trust me when I say that the wait is worth it. So grab a drink, make some new friends in line, and prepare yourself for a pizza experience like no other. TAGLIO Columbia Tusculum is a must-visit for any pizza lover in cincinnati!

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Fireside Pizza

My journey to Fireside Pizza was filled with excitement, partly because I heard they serve alcohol, and not just any alcohol, but hard liquor! As a food critic, I appreciate a nice glass of vodka to wash down my glorious slices of pizza.

Speaking of slices, Fireside Pizza offers a variety of vegetarian options, which is fantastic for those veggie lovers out there. I mean, who needs meat when you have a crispy, thin crust pizza topped with fresh vegetables and gooey cheese? Delish!

Now, let’s talk about the ambiance. Fireside Pizza is not just a restaurant; it’s a tourist spot! You can enjoy your delicious pizza while taking in the sights and sounds of the bustling city. And if you’re a sports fan, rejoice! This place is a great spot to watch your favorite games. How can you beat chewing on a heavenly slice of pizza while cheering for your team? It’s a win-win!

However, let’s address the elephant in the room. Fireside Pizza does NOT accept reservations. As someone who hates waiting, this was a downside for me. But hey, maybe it’s just the universe testing your patience to see if you’re truly worthy of their mouthwatering pizza.

In conclusion, Fireside Pizza is a gem for those seeking the best thin crust pizza in Cincinnati. The combination of great food, alcohol (hard liquor included!), vegetarian options, and a lively atmosphere make it a must-visit. Just remember, be prepared to withstand the trial of waiting because reservations are not on their menu. Bon appétit!

Best Wood Fired Pizza – Catch-a-Fire Pizza – Oakley

From the moment I stepped into the restaurant, I knew I was in for a treat. The smell of the wood-fired oven immediately hit me, and I could feel my taste buds doing a happy dance in anticipation. The decor was funky and eclectic, with pizza-themed artwork adorning the walls and checkered tablecloths giving it that classic pizzeria feel.

Now, let’s get to the good stuff – the pizza. Oh my goodness, where do I even begin? The crust was a crispy, chewy masterpiece. I could tell it had been made with love and a touch of magic. The sauce was tangy and flavorful, and the cheese…oh, the cheese. It was melted to perfection, stretching and oozing with every bite. I may have shed a tear of joy.

The menu offered a variety of creative toppings, from classic pepperoni to unique combinations like fig and prosciutto. I decided to be adventurous and went for the Fire Starter pizza, topped with jalapenos, pepper jack cheese, and a spicy tomato sauce. Let me tell you, my taste buds were on FIRE! It was like a wild party in my mouth, and everyone was invited.

The staff at Catch-a-Fire Pizza – Oakley were friendly and passionate about their craft. They took the time to explain the different pizzas and suggested the perfect wine pairing. I left feeling like I had just made new friends and with a full belly of the most amazing pizza.

So, if you’re in Cincinnati and craving some wood-fired goodness, make sure to check out Catch-a-Fire Pizza – Oakley. Your taste buds will thank you, and you might just find yourself planning your next trip back before you’ve even finished your last slice.