Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Salem OR (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Oregon

Best Pizza in Salem OR (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

221 Views

Having been all over the world in search of amazing pizza, I’m glad to report that Salem OR is a hidden gem when it comes to this delicious dish. I’ve tasted twelve different pizzas here and am pleased to share my findings so you can enjoy some tasty pies as well.

My adventures have proved that seeking out the best pizza does not always involve traveling far and wide – sometimes all we need to do is look at what’s right at home. So grab your favorite slice and join me for an inside look at the best pizzas that Salem OR has to offer!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Oregon

#1 Fiesta Pizza

The crust is the perfect balance of crispiness, chewyness, and flavor. It’s not too hard, but not too soft either. The toppings are fresh and flavorful; my personal favorite is the Italian sausage. The cheese is always perfectly melted and gooey, with just the right amount of grease – never too much that it overwhelms everything else.

The atmosphere at Fiesta Pizza feels like a cozy family dinner spot. They have all sorts of different games on the walls, like dart boards and cornhole. Plus, they always have live music playing in the background that really adds to the fun vibes of the place.

Overall, my experience at Fiesta Pizza was nothing short of excellent! Not only did I get to enjoy some delicious pizza, but I also had a great time with friends and family. If you’re ever in Salem OR looking for a great pizza experience then make sure you stop by Fiesta Pizza – you won’t regret it!

If you’re willing to go an extra 30 miles, you can get to 20 more pizza places in Corvallis!

#2 La Lucciola Pizzeria

The place has a nice atmosphere, with warm colors and a cozy feel that I’m sure most people would enjoy. I can tell they put a lot of effort into making the restaurant inviting.

The pizza was simply amazing! It’s made with fresh ingredients and cooked to perfection in their woodfire oven. The crust had the perfect amount of crispiness and the toppings were flavorful and well-balanced. I could have eaten multiple slices!

I would definitely recommend La Lucciola Pizzeria for anyone looking for delicious pizzas. It’s clear why this has become one of the best pizza places in Salem OR!

#3 Walery’s Premium Pizza

First off, this place is not only a great spot for the tourist crowd, it’s also ideal for anyone who wants to watch the local sports teams. Not to mention, they serve some really decent alcohol too – a nice bonus!

Speaking of bonuses, I was surprised to see that Walery’s Premium Pizza also offers a kid’s menu with some surprisingly tasty options. They even have some vegetarian offerings as well – so everyone can be happy.

The only downside to this restaurant is that there is no delivery option available – you’ll have to eat in or take out if you want their delicious pizza.

Overall, I’d say this place definitely deserves the title of ‘best pizza in Salem OR’! Highly recommend checking them out if you’re passing through town.

#4 MOD Pizza

I will admit I was a bit skeptical at first. But, upon entering the restaurant and taking a look around, I was more than pleasantly surprised. The atmosphere is bright, friendly and welcoming – it made me feel like I had come home.

The staff were incredibly helpful and patient with my many questions about the different toppings and sauces they offer; they really do take the time to explain what each option would add to my pizza.

The best part about MOD Pizza is their create-your-own pizza options! With fresh ingredients such as marinated mushrooms, roasted red peppers, oven roasted artichokes, homemade mozzarella cheese and flavorful meats like sausage and pepperoni – you can truly get creative when constructing your perfect masterpiece.

When my pizza cooked up in the stone-fired oven I could smell all of the delicious flavors mingling together as if they were having a party in my nose! After biting into it, I must say that it exceeded all expectations – even mine! All of those fabulous toppings complimented one another perfectly, making this one of the best pizzas that I have ever tasted.

If you find yourself in Salem OR (or anywhere near it!) then be sure to check out MOD Pizza for an incredible pizza experience that you won’t soon forget!

#5 Straight From New York Pizza (Downtown Salem)

To start, the atmosphere is awesome. The walls are decorated with vintage posters of New York City and the service is always friendly and fast. Plus, the brick oven in the back gives off a wonderful, tantalizing aroma that just draws you in.

The pizza itself is delicious! It has great flavor and the crust is perfectly cooked. The sauce has just the right amount of kick to it and you can taste every topping – from pepperoni to mushrooms, to peppers and onions. And I can’t forget about their signature cheese blend; it’s so creamy and flavorful without being overwhelming.

I also have to mention that they offer gluten-free pizza, which is great for all of my friends who have dietary restrictions. Their menu also includes all sorts of wonderful appetizers like mozzarella sticks and cheesy breadsticks – perfect for sharing with friends while waiting for your pizza!

In conclusion, if you’re looking for some fantastic pizza in Salem OR, then Straight From New York Pizza (Downtown Salem) should definitely be at the top of your list! I’ve never had better pizza anywhere else – it really is the best that the city has to offer.

#6 Christo’s Pizzeria & Lounge

The restaurant itself has a cozy atmosphere, with candles lighting up the tables and the wood-fire oven providing a nice hint of smokiness in the air. It’s definitely one of those places you want to relax and enjoy some quality pizza with your family or friends.

As for the pizzas, let me tell you – they were out of this world! The crusts were thin and crispy, topped with just the right amount of cheese and tomato sauce. But what made them truly special is the signature blend of spices they use to top each slice – it was simply unforgettable.

I tried every type of pizza on their menu (including their famous Meat Lover’s Pie) and I must say that each one had its own unique flavor profile that left me wanting more. And don’t even get me started on their dessert pizzas – they were absolutely divine!

To sum it all up, my experience at Christo’s Pizzeria & Lounge was nothing short of extraordinary and I would highly recommend it to anyone searching for some of the best pizza in Salem OR!

#7 Michelangelo’s

The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, with a large bar area that means that Michelangelo’s isn’t just for kids. They offer hard liquor, as well as beer and wine. So whether you’re looking to relax with a glass of vino or need something stronger to settle an argument over what toppings should top your pizza, Michelangelo’s has you covered.

The menu is huge – there are all the classic pizzas, like Margherita and Pepperoni, but also less common combinations such as Pesto & Asparagus and the carnivore-friendly Bacon & Cheese Pie. The kid’s menu is great too – my son loves their Cheese-only pizza!

And if you have room after devouring your pizza slice (or two) then make sure that save some room for dessert. Michelangelo’s serves tiramisu alongside more traditional options like cheesecake or apple crisp.

My only complaint? No delivery service. That said, it’s worth it to take a trip out to Salem to grab some of Michelangelo’s delicious pizza!

#8 Straight From New York Pizza

From the moment I stepped in to their cozy restaurant, it was clear that they take their pizza seriously. The staff was friendly and eager to share their knowledge on the best pizza choice for me. After much deliberation, I decided on a classic pepperoni and mushroom pie and it certainly did not disappoint!

The crust had a perfect balance of crunch and chewiness – just as any proper New York-style pizza should have. The sauce was also spot on – with a nice zesty kick and lots of flavor, without being overly acidic or heavy. And of course, the toppings were fresh and plentiful!

Overall, Straight From New York Pizza has earned my seal of approval. If you’re ever in Salem OR looking for some great tasting pizza, I can assure you that this is definitely one of the best spots around!

If you’re willing to go an extra 37 miles, you can get to 21 more pizza places in Lake Oswego!

#9 Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza

The dough and crust are incredibly fresh, the ingredients are top-notch and the flavors are out of this world. Not to mention, the staff here at Papa Murphy’s are always so friendly and helpful.

I couldn’t help but smile as I watched them put together my pizza with such care, lovingly placing each ingredient on my pie just so. I still remember that first bite – it was like a flavor explosion in my mouth! The combination of flavors was so delicious and the crust was cooked to perfection.

Plus, the fact that you get to take it home and bake it yourself makes this experience all the more special. What’s not to love?

All in all, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Salem OR, look no further than Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza. I guarantee you won’t be disappointed!

#10 Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza

I was impressed by the quick and friendly service, plus their pizza was piping hot and delicious. I especially enjoyed their customizable pizzas. When I arrived, they had a selection of pre-made pizzas that were pretty tasty – but once I saw how easy it was to mix-and-match toppings and sauces, my experience took a turn for the better!

The crust is always perfectly golden brown on the bottom and fluffy on the inside. It definitely rivals some of the finest Italian pizzerias that I’ve been to! The quality of ingredients was top-notch too; every bite is packed with flavor.

In addition to great pizza, Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza offers several sides, including wings, garlic breadsticks and salads. With great prices and friendly staff, it’s no surprise that this place is one of the most popular pizza joints in Salem OR.
If you’re ever in town looking for the best pizza around, don’t miss out on Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza! You won’t be disappointed!

#11 The Original Padington’s Pizza North Salem

The atmosphere of the restaurant is inviting and cozy, making it a perfect spot for a family meal or date night. The staff are friendly and take their time to explain the different pizzas on the menu, ensuring that you get the one that’s right for you.

As for the pizza itself, I must say: it’s divine! The crust is golden brown, perfectly crunchy but still tender – definitely some of the best I’ve tasted! And when it comes to flavor, I couldn’t be more impressed. Every topping is fresh and full of flavor, from savory sausage to sweet pineapple.

All in all, The Original Padington’s Pizza North Salem surely has what it takes to be crowned “the best pizza in Salem OR”. Delicious pizza with a great atmosphere – you can’t go wrong here!

#12 Basil & Board

I’ve eaten a lot of pizza in my travels, and I can confidently say that Basil & Board has some of the tastiest pies I’ve ever encountered. From the thin-crust classic margherita to their signature deep dish ‘BBQ Bacon Mac’ special, each bite was full of flavor and perfectly cooked.

The atmosphere here is also fantastic: cozy yet chic, with warm lighting, cheerful staff, and a great vibe. Plus, they have some great beer and wine selections to help wash down all that delicious pizza.

But what really sealed the deal for me was just how friendly the folks at Basil & Board were. From the time I stepped in until the time I left, everyone from the servers to the kitchen staff were so kind and accommodating—they even stayed open late one night so I could try it on my way out of Salem!

If you’re looking for great pizza in Salem OR, then Basil & Board is definitely where you should go. It’s easily one of the best places around for some truly delicious Italian-style pizza.

Best Wood Fired Pizza – La Lucciola Pizzeria

Let me tell you, folks, this place is the real deal. As soon as I walked through the doors, I could smell the heavenly aroma of the wood-fired oven. It was as if the pizza gods themselves were summoning me to indulge in their cheesy creations.

Now, let’s talk about the pizza. Oh, sweet mercy! The crust at La Lucciola is a perfect balance of chewy and crispy, with just the right amount of charred goodness. Each bite is an explosion of flavors that will make you question why you ever settled for subpar pizza in the past.

Trust me, I’ve been to a lot of pizza places in my life, and I can safely say that La Lucciola knows their way around a pizza oven. They have mastered the art of creating a perfectly balanced pie that will leave you craving more.

Now, this wouldn’t be an honest review if I didn’t mention the downsides. Unfortunately, La Lucciola doesn’t offer delivery. So, if you’re feeling lazy and don’t want to leave the comfort of your own couch, you’ll have to settle for subpar pizza elsewhere. But let me tell you, it’s worth the trip.

In conclusion, if you find yourself in Salem, Oregon, and you’re craving the finest wood-fired pizza, don’t waste your time anywhere else. La Lucciola Pizzeria is the place to be. Just make sure you’re willing to put in the effort to actually go there. Trust me, it’s worth it.