Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Greeley (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Colorado

Best Pizza in Greeley (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

223 Views

I’m absolutely no stranger to the infinite pizza possibilities a global gauntlet of cities has to offer, but this town certainly surprised me! After taking 12 Greeley pizzerias for a spin, I’ve narrowed it down to the crème de la crème.

This won’t be your everyday run-of-the-mill pizza review – I’m here to bring you a humorous and lighthearted account of my (delicious) journey through some of Greeley’s most tantalizing pies. Let’s dig in…

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Colorado

#1 MOD Pizza

First off, I’m a huge fan of the wide variety of topping options they have. You can go crazy with your toppings and create something truly unique that you’ll love! The atmosphere is also very relaxed and family-friendly, so it’s perfect for a night out with the kids or a quick bite between errands.

The pizza itself was delicious! It was cooked to perfection – not too chewy and not too crispy. The crust was flavorful and crunchy, while the cheese melted nicely over the toppings. To top it all off (literally!), their customer service staff were friendly and helpful throughout my visit – always happy to suggest new pizza topping combinations.

So if you’re looking for an excellent pizza in Greeley, MOD Pizza should be at the top of your list! Hands down some of the best pizza I’ve had anywhere.

If you’re willing to go an extra 19 miles, you can get to 23 more pizza places in Loveland!

#2 Santeramo’s Pizza House & Italian Food

My recent experience at the restaurant was nothing short of amazing, and I have to admit that my expectations were pleasantly exceeded. From the moment I stepped in, I could already smell the delicious aroma of freshly-baked pizza.

The pizzas they offer are absolutely delicious! The crust is soft yet crunchy, and the ingredients come together to form an amazing medley of flavors. Their homemade marinara sauce and fresh mozzarella cheese add a flavorful flair that truly elevates their pies. And the menu is extensive, so you can find something for everyone.

The ambience at Santeramo’s Pizza House & Italian Food is also great. The place looks clean and well kept, and the staff is friendly and helpful. They are always willing to help you pick out just what you need from their menu.

Overall, my experience at Santeramo’s Pizza House & Italian Food tested all of my expectations! They surely have some of the best pizza in Greeley!

#3 Fonta’s Pizza Restaurant

The crust is the perfect balance between soft and crunchy, and the sauce used is definitely some of the best I’ve ever tasted. The cheese too is top-notch; it melts just right, making for a truly delicious experience.

The toppings used at Fonta’s are also top-notch, particularly for their grilled veggie pizza. You can tell that every ingredient used has been carefully selected to bring out maximum flavor with each bite.

Overall, Fonta’s Pizza Restaurant easily tops my list of best pizzas in Greeley! Go there if you’re looking for an amazing meal or if you just want to enjoy a great pizza pie!

#4 Bravos Philly’s & Pizza

The atmosphere is inviting and welcoming, not to mention the incredible scent of garlic and melted cheese that hit you when you walk through the door. I was immediately hooked.

My favorite pizza on the menu is the Philly Cheese Steak Pizza. The crust is thin and crispy, with a perfect blend of Parmesan and oregano seasonings. Topping it off is plenty of steak, onions, mushrooms and peppers that creates a savory masterpiece.

I sampled one of their pizzas with my partner in crime- his favorite- Ricotta & Spinach with Roasted Garlic Almond Pesto. This was also delicious! The crust was slightly thicker than the Philly Cheese Steak one and had a nice crunchy texture which made it great for carrying all of those flavors without getting soggy.

Lastly, we tried their famous New York style pizza, loaded with provolone cheese! It was an instant classic! The cheese was melty and gooey just like it should be, and the pepperoni had just enough spice to really add some extra zip to this already tasty pie.

Overall, Bravos Philly’s & Pizza has definitely earned its reputation as having some of the best pizza in Greeley, if not all of Colorado! If you’re ever in town looking for deliciousness on a plate- make sure to check them out!

#5 Bulldog Pub & Grub

The atmosphere at Bulldog is unbeatable. It’s part pub, part pizza joint, with the perfect combination of bright neon signs, a jukebox in the corner and an energetic atmosphere that make it one of Greeley’s great gathering spots.

The pizza is where Bulldog really shines. The crust is light and crispy; the sauce has just the right balance of sweet and savory; and their signature toppings are creative and always delicious. My favorite personal combination is sausage, mushrooms and olives. I also suggest that you try their specialty pizzas, like the BBQ Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza or their Chicago Deep Dish; they’re both amazing!

Whether it’s for a quick bite with friends or for a family dinner, I can’t recommend Bulldog Pub & Grub enough—it truly serves up some of the best pizza in Greeley!

#6 Donatos Pizza

The crust was the perfect blend of chewy and crispy, the sauce was delightfully flavorful, and the toppings were fresh and succulent. The cheese had an amazing flavor that elevated everything to the next level. I was particularly impressed with the pepperoni as its savory flavors made it a standout among other pizzas I’ve had elsewhere.

I also appreciated their commitment to quality ingredients as well as collaborations with local farmers for seasonal produce. The service was also outstanding—quick, friendly, and professional.

Overall, Donatos Pizza is not only one of the best places for a delicious slice in Greeley but also one of my top pizza joints anywhere around the world!

#7 Godfather’s Pizza Express

I ate there for lunch today, and the experience was nothing short of delightful. The deep dish pizza was especially good – it was cooked to perfection with a crispy crust and flavorful sauce. There were plenty of toppings to choose from, and my choice turned out great – it was freshly made, right down to the last sprinkle of Parmesan cheese.

The restaurant also has some unique side dishes that will definitely make your meal stand out. My favorite part was the garlic buttery bite that came with every slice – it added just the right amount of flavor to my pizza slice.

Most importantly, the service at Godfather’s Pizza Express is renowned in Greeley- everyone who works there is friendly and accommodating. Even though the restaurant was packed, I felt special because I got VIP treatment.

All in all, I can confidently say that Godfather’s Pizza Express serves some of the best pizza in Greeley! If you’re looking for a great pizza experience with unbeatable customer service, this is definitely the place to go!

#8 Empire State Pizza

My first experience at Empire State Pizza was unforgettable. I ordered their classic cheese pizza, expecting it to be standard fare. What I got instead was a masterpiece – the perfect blend of sweet sauce, tangy cheese and a crispy crust that left me wanting more!

The other items on the menu are just as good – the pepperoni pizza is packed with flavor and their buffalo chicken pizza combines two of my favorite flavors for one delicious dish. But what sets Empire State Pizza apart from its competitors is how fresh their ingredients are. Every bite you take is full of flavor and quality – you can tell that they use the best possible ingredients.

Furthermore, the atmosphere at Empire State Pizza is welcoming and laid-back. The friendly staff create a great vibe throughout the restaurant which makes it a great place to bring friends or enjoy some alone time while enjoying some of the best pizza in Greeley.

All in all, Empire State Pizza has become my go-to spot for great pizza in Greeley! Whether you’re looking for a classic slice or something more adventurous like their buffalo chicken pizza, there’s something to please everyone’s palate here. Highly recommended – don’t miss out!

If you’re willing to go an extra 23 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Fort Collins!

#9 Blackjack Pizza & Salads

The atmosphere was cozy and inviting and the staff greeted me with a friendly smile. From the moment I walked in, I could tell this place had something special to offer.

My order consisted of their signature pizza – The Blackjack Supreme. With generous portions of pepperoni, sausage, ham, onions, mushrooms, green peppers, and olives it was an absolute delight! The crust was cooked to perfection and the cheese was melted and gooey – just how I like it.

I sampled a few other items from their menu too – the salads were fresh and tasty and the cheesy breadsticks were oozing with deliciousness!

In conclusion, I can say without hesitation that Blackjack Pizza & Salads is easily one of the best pizzas in Greeley! If you’re ever looking for a delicious pizza to satisfy your cravings, then look no further because you’ll find it at Blackjack Pizza & Salads!

#10 Roma West

The ambiance was excellent, with its cozy candlelit atmosphere. The waitstaff was friendly and always happy to offer up great suggestions.

But the real star here is the pizza! I had the Palermo pie; it was cheesy and savory, with a nice crunchy crust. The sauce was full of flavour, and the toppings were plentiful. It’s no wonder why Roma West has become so popular!

Their other menu items didn’t disappoint either – their salads were fresh and light, and their sandwiches were big enough for two meals.

No visit to Roma West would be complete without having one of their delicious desserts. Their Italian cream cake was absolutely divine – it melted in my mouth with each bite!

Overall, Roma West is definitely worth a visit if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Greeley. Enjoy your stay while visiting Roma West – you won’t regret it!

#11 Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza

I was so delighted to try their pizzas for myself and I was not disappointed. From the first bite, I could tell that Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza put a lot of love in every slice. The dough was light and airy and the toppings were fresh and flavorful.

What really set this pizza place apart from others is their unique baking method. Instead of baking it in the oven at the store, they have you take it home and bake it fresh in your own oven — which guarantees that you get an amazing pizza every time!

The staff was also extremely friendly and helpful. They answered all my questions about different topping combinations and were able to give me some great advice on cooking times and how to get a perfectly crispy crust.

In conclusion, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Greeley, then head over to Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza for an unforgettable experience!

#12 D.P. Dough

First of all, the sauce is outstanding. It’s packed full of flavors like garlic and oregano, that make every bite a flavor explosion. The cheese is melted to perfection, and the toppings are so fresh they dance on my tongue.

The crust rounds out the pizza in an unexpected way. It has a crispy exterior, but it’s still chewy on the inside – just like I prefer! Plus, with their calzones and garlic knots, D.P. Dough makes sure there’s something for everyone in your party.

I highly recommend D.P. Dough if you’re looking for delicious pizza in Greeley!