Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Greenville NC (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in North Carolina

Best Pizza in Greenville NC (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

265 Views

After trying 12 different pizzerias in the area, I’m here to report on the top spots for a delicious pie. With my critical eye and adventurous palate, I’m confident that I can steer you towards an amazing pizza experience.

Writing this article was not a task to be taken lightly – I’ve tasted some of the best pizzas around the world and take food seriously! That said, I’m also up for a bit of fun. So let’s go on a culinary journey through Greenville NC, discovering some exceptional pizza in the process. Roll up your sleeves – it’s time to get our hands greasy!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of North Carolina

#1 Cucinella’s Pizzeria & Italian Ice

The atmosphere of the restaurant is perfect for a relaxing evening spent with your favorite people. The décor is classic, simple Italian and the staff is incredibly friendly.

But the best part about Cucinella’s, as I’m sure you already guessed, is their delicious pizza. From their classic Cheese Pizza, to their outrageous Meat Lover’s Pizza with every meat imaginable, it’s all simply amazing. I think my favorite part was the unique Sicilian Style option they offer – almost like a deep dish on steroids!

One word of warning though – prepare to be stuffed! These slices are huge and will fill up even the hungriest of stomachs.

All in all, if you’re ever in Greenville NC and looking for some great pizza – look no further than Cucinella’s Pizzeria & Italian Ice!

If you’re willing to go an extra 52 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Jacksonville!

#2 Luna Pizza Cafe

I visited Luna Pizza Cafe on a hot July day, and the restaurant was stocked with some of the most delicious-smelling pizza I’d ever encountered. The staff was incredibly friendly, recommending some of their best pies for me to try. I chose their classic margherita pie and wow – it was amazing! The pizza had an ultra-thin crust that was soft and crunchy in all the right places, and the tomato sauce was tangy but not overpowering. The toppings were fresh, colorful and flavorful. Plus, the serving sizes were generous yet affordable.

All in all, it’s no wonder why this place is so popular – it’s easily one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had! If you’re looking for the best pizza in Greenville NC, then be sure to check out Luna Pizza Cafe!

#3 Marabella Pizza Winterville

The atmosphere when you walk in is amazing. The cozy Italian decor invites you in, and the smells of fresh-baked pizza bring a smile to your face.

The pizza itself is absolutely amazing! Their thin crust pizza has a unique flavor that cannot be found elsewhere. Every bite tastes like you’re eating a piece of Italy. The best part is that they offer a variety of toppings from traditional pepperoni to artichoke hearts and portobello mushrooms. I recommend trying their signature White Pie – it’s packed with flavor and delicious!

The staff is friendly and accommodating too. They ensured my order was exactly what I wanted and even offered recommendations for other items on their menu that I may be interested in trying.

I highly recommend Marabella Pizza Winterville if you are looking for the best pizza in Greenville NC!

#4 Mellow Mushroom Greenville

The atmosphere was delightful – I felt right at home with all the funky artwork, great music, and unique decor. The staff was friendly and welcoming, which made the experience even better.

But let’s get to the most important part – the food! Mellow Mushroom Greenville has some of the tastiest pizza I’ve ever had. The combination of their fresh ingredients, unique sauces, and unique crusts make for a truly amazing pizza experience.

I tried several different types of pizzas while I was here, but my favorite was definitely the “Memphis Soul Pie”. It had a perfect mix of flavors and textures that blended together perfectly in every bite. Not to mention that it is absolutely huge – enough to feed an entire family with leftovers to spare!

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Greenville NC then look no further than Mellow Mushroom Greenville – trust me on this one!

#5 Basil’s Restaurant & Pizzeria

The pizza itself was amazing. The crust was crunchy, with just the right amount of chewiness. The toppings were fresh, flavorful and perfectly layered. The cheese melted oh-so-perfectly and the sauce was tangy and delicious!

The service at Basil’s Restaurant & Pizzeria was outstanding. From the moment we stepped in, our friendly servers made us feel right at home. They had great recommendations for our pizzas, which we appreciated immensely!

The atmosphere at Basil’s Restaurant & Pizzeria was pleasant and inviting, but also managed to remain casual and comfortable. Music played softly in the background and there were plenty of televisions to watch sports on if that’s what you’re into!

Overall, I definitely think Basil’s Restaurant & Pizzeria serves some of the best pizza in Greenville NC. If you’re ever in town looking for a delicious slice of pizza, I’d highly recommend you check it out!

#6 Michaelangelo’s Pizza & Subs

The restaurant itself is small and cozy, and the service is friendly and fast. The pizza comes out hot and fresh every time, with a perfect balance of crispy crust and juicy toppings. And the selection of different types of pizzas is impressive – there’s something for everyone here!

My favorite pizza here has to be the Supreme Pizza; it’s loaded with all sorts of great ingredients like olives, mushrooms, peppers, onions, sausage, pepperoni, and more. The flavor combination is unbeatable! And don’t forget about the cheese – it’s the best cheese in Greenville NC!

Overall, I highly recommend Michaelangelo’s Pizza & Subs for anyone looking for great pizza in Greenville NC. They have some of the best pizza around – trust me when I say that!

#7 Jet’s Pizza

First of all, I have to say the staff at Jet’s Pizza was absolutely delightful. They were incredibly friendly and went out of their way to make sure my experience was amazing.

Second, the pizza itself was delicious! I had the Deep Dish Deluxe with both pepperoni and sausage toppings plus extra cheese and it was a work of art! The crispy crust, melted cheese and succulent toppings were absolutely heavenly.

Finally, the atmosphere at Jet’s Pizza is always vibrant and welcoming. Whether you’re visiting for a casual meal or celebrating a special occasion, you’ll feel right at home there. Plus, they always have TVs playing your favorite sports teams so that’s an added bonus!

In conclusion, if you want the best pizza in Greenville NC then Jet’s Pizza is definitely the place to go! From their hospitable staff to their delicious pizza, this restaurant is truly one-of-a-kind.

If you’re willing to go an extra 65 miles, you can get to 14 more pizza places in Emerald Isle!

#8 Michaelangelo’s Pizza on Evans

From the moment I walked in, I could tell this was no ordinary pizza joint. The atmosphere was inviting, with Italian music playing in the background and the smell of freshly baked pizza wafting through the air.

The menu is huge and filled with an array of options for all kinds of pizza lovers – thin crust, deep dish, vegetarian, meat lover’s – you name it! After much deliberation, I settled on ordering a classic Margherita pizza.

The pizza arrived hot out of the oven and it was outstanding! The dough had just the right chewiness to it and the sauce was flavorful with a hint of garlic. As if that wasn’t enough, they put extra cheese on top which really made it over-the-top delicious!

I’ve been all over Greenville trying every type of pizza imaginable but I can honestly say that none compare to Michaelangelo’s Pizza on Evans. It truly is some of the best pizza in Greenville NC!

#9 Marabella Old World Pizza

When I first arrived to Marabella Old World Pizza, I must admit, I was a bit skeptical. The restaurant is nestled away in a brick building and not exactly the most “happening” spot. But then the aroma of freshly baked pizza wafted through my nose and I knew I was in for something special.

I decided to go with the classic Margherita, made with fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, basil and olive oil. As soon as it arrived at my table, I couldn’t help but be impressed with its presentation – a perfect blend of cheese and sauce with just enough charred spots from the oven.

One bite later, I had to admit that Marabella Old World Pizza makes one of the best pizzas around! The olive oil added a nice richness to this classic dish while the tomato mixture provided a great acidic balance. The crust was cooked perfectly – crispy on the outside while still maintaining its chewy texture on the inside – truly perfect.

Overall, if you’re looking for some seriously delicious pizza in Greenville NC, look no further than Marabella Old World Pizza!

#10 Michaelangelo’s Pizza on Memorial

As a food critic, I’m always looking for the perfect slice, and Michaelangelo’s has it. The atmosphere of the restaurant itself was inviting and warm; there were plenty of tables to accommodate our large group of friends.

When it came to ordering, we knew right away that we wanted to try a variety of toppings. We went with classic pepperoni and cheese, as well as some more exotic options like artichokes and feta. Our taste buds were delighted when each piece arrived because all the flavors meshed together beautifully – even the unique ones!

Another thing that truly impressed me was how quickly our order was filled; I didn’t have to wait too long for my pizza. Plus, the prices are very reasonable for such high-quality pizza.

In conclusion, I must say that Michaelangelo’s Pizza on Memorial is definitely one of the best pizza places in Greenville NC. From its great atmosphere to its delicious pizzas made with top-notch ingredients, this restaurant is sure to satisfy any hungry individual or group looking for an amazing meal at a great price!

#11 Little Caesars Pizza

My experience with Little Caesars Pizza was far beyond what I could have ever imagined. The staff was incredibly friendly and attentive, making sure my order was perfect every time.

The pizza itself was simply divine. The crust had the perfect amount of crunch and the sauce was savory and flavorful. To top it off, they didn’t skimp on the toppings! Every slice had just the right amount of cheese and pepperoni so I could taste all of those wonderful Italian flavors with each bite.

My favorite part though? The price. Talk about bang for your buck! Little Caesars Pizza is one of the most affordable pizzerias around, so you get to enjoy a delicious pizza without breaking the bank.

All in all, if you’re looking for some great pizza in Greenville NC then look no further than Little Caesars Pizza!

#12 Little Caesars Pizza

On my visit, I was welcomed with open arms and could already smell the delicious aroma of their perfect Heavenly Pies. The crust was thin and airy, but still somehow managed to hold together all of the toppings without sagging. The sauce had a rich tomato flavor that was complemented nicely by a generous amount of cheese and fresh-tasting toppings.

Little Caesars Pizza also offers an array of extras, like garlic parmesan twists and bread sticks that you can dip in marinara sauce or chocolate hazelnut spread. Trust me – it’s worth it!

I have to say, I’m always looking for something new and unique when I travel, so if you’re looking for the best pizza in Greenville NC (or anywhere else for that matter), Little Caesars Pizza is definitely worth your time. Put on your stretchy pants and get ready for a pizza extravaganza!