Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Greenville SC (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in South Carolina

Best Pizza in Greenville SC (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

345 Views

I had the opportunity to sample 12 pizza places in the area, and I have to say they pretty much have it all covered. From classic Italian-style pies to New York-style slices, there’s something for everybody in this town.

But which one takes the (pepperoni) crown as THE best pizza in Greenville SC? Read on and find out – I promise it’s a fun and delicious journey!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of South Carolina

#1 Belladina’s Pizzeria of Greenville

The atmosphere was cheerful, thanks to the boisterous Italian music and the friendly staff. The pizza selection is also varied, so I had a tough time deciding which one to get! I ended up getting a classic Margherita Pizza, which did not disappoint. The ingredients were incredibly fresh and the sauce was full of flavor.

The only problem I noticed during my visit was that the pizzas took a bit longer than usual to cook. But upon tasting it, I can now see why! Each slice was cooked to perfection with just the right amount of crunchiness in the crust.

In summary, Belladina’s Pizzeria of Greenville is probably the best pizza place in Greenville SC. They use only fresh ingredients, have an inviting atmosphere and serve delicious pizzas that are cooked with precision. If you’re looking for great pizza in this area, make sure to drop by Belladina’s Pizzeria – it won’t disappoint!

If you’re willing to go an extra 13 miles, you can get to 26 more pizza places in Simpsonville!

#2 Coastal Crust

The atmosphere was perfect. With brightly painted walls and exposed brick, the restaurant was portrayed as both a tourist spot and a cozy local favorite. I was even able to enjoy my meal with a cold beer, something which is always appreciated in a pizza joint.

The menu offered lots of delicious options for everyone, from meat-lovers to vegetarians. There were even some delicious dessert choices for when you’re feeling indulgent! And kids had their own section of the menu – an unexpected bonus!

Although Coastal Crust does lack delivery services, it more than makes up for that with its undeniably good pizza. The crust was crunchy and golden brown; the cheese melted perfectly into the sauce; and the toppings were fresh and flavorful. It is definitely worth the trip to Greenville SC to try out Coastal Crust’s fantastic pizza!

#3 World Piece Pizza

The first thing I noticed was the aroma of herbs and spices that wafted through the air as soon as I walked in. The restaurant is decorated with colorful Italian artwork, giving it an authentic feel.

The menu has something for everyone – from classic marinara pizzas to more exotic flavors like wild mushroom or four cheese. I opted for a classic pepperoni pizza and it did not disappoint! The crust had a nice crunch while the dough was light and airy. The sauce had the perfect balance of acidity and sweetness, and the toppings were fresh and flavorful.

To top it all off, the staff at World Piece Pizza are really friendly! They took their time to explain each item on the menu and even provided helpful suggestions for side dishes. All in all, I had an exceptionally enjoyable experience here and would highly recommend it to anyone looking for great pizza in Greenville SC.

#4 Myles Pizza Pub

I had the King Pie and it was every bit as majestic as the name implies. It had a golden, crunchy crust that was just big enough to hold all the delicious toppings they piled on there – pepperoni, sausage, bacon, and cheese. I am usually a fan of thin-crust pizza but Myles Pizza Pub definitely changed my mind!

The atmosphere was also incredibly inviting; it felt like I was sitting in a pub back in Europe. The wait staff was friendly and knowledgeable about the menu, which made me feel even more welcome. I could tell this place cares about their customers because they’re so committed to quality and flavor.

As you can probably guess from my review, this is hands-down the best pizza restaurant in Greenville SC! In fact, I’m already planning my next trip back for another savory slice of king pie!

#5 Todaro Pizza GVL

The first thing that I noticed when walking in the door was the wonderfully inviting atmosphere. From the friendly staff to the classic decor, it felt like I’d stepped into a pizzeria from my childhood.

The pizza, of course, is what I’m here for and Todaro definitely did not disappoint! The crust was perfectly crisp and delicious, and their selection of sauces and toppings were top notch. Everything was fresh and flavorful, which made every bite just perfect.

What really set Todaro Pizza GVL apart from other places though was the service. Not only were they incredibly friendly and helpful, but they also served up piping hot pizzas with lightning speed!

I’ve had some incredible pizza around the world, but Todaro Pizza GVL takes my vote for some of the best pizza in Greenville SC!

#6 Basilico Greenville

The pies here are made with the freshest ingredients, giving them a flavor you won’t find anywhere else. The dough is perfectly crafted and the sauce is just the right amount of spicy – it really stands out in comparison to other pizzas I’ve had.

What really drew me in was their unique blend of toppings. You’ll find everything from pepperoni and sausage to peppers and onions. They even offer vegan options for those who want something lighter or a little less traditional.

Plus, I’m all about atmosphere. Basilico Greenville is bright and airy, with plenty of seating for all your friends and family. Even better? They have an outdoor patio so you can enjoy your pizza under the stars!

All in all, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Greenville SC, look no further than Basilico Greenville. You won’t be disappointed!

#7 Pizza Parcheggio

From their unique take on the classic Margherita, to the exotic flavors in their Hawaiian special, there’s something for everyone here. The crust is always perfectly thin and crispy, and the toppings are always fresh and delicious.

I’m partial to the spaghetti pizza – topped with a generous helping of cheese, sauce, pepperoni and Italian sausage, it’s both hearty and flavorful. It also doesn’t hurt that it comes with garlic knots on the side!

The staff is friendly and welcoming, making sure you feel like family as soon as you walk in the door. The best part is that they offer free soda refills with every order!

My only complaint (if you can call it a complaint) is that they don’t offer delivery service. But honestly, it’s easy enough to just swing by and pick up your order – then you get to enjoy all of Pizza Parcheggio’s atmosphere while you wait!

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Greenville SC, look no further than Pizza Parcheggio! You won’t be disappointed!

#8 Sidewall Pizza Company

No matter what flavor you’re looking for, Sidewall Pizza Company has it. From their classic margherita pizza to their more adventurous options, like the Cajun Chicken and Sausage pie, this place has something for everyone.

The crust is perfectly thin and crispy – not too thin, not too thick – and the fresh ingredients really make it stand out from other pizzas I’ve had around the world. The marinara sauce is rich and flavorful, and easily holds its own against any of Italy’s best. And the cheese…the cheese! It’s so creamy and delicious – definitely a winner!

I also have to give props to their staff, who always provide friendly and helpful service. They’re always willing to answer my questions about different pies or tendencies in the area.

In short, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Greenville SC, you’ll have a hard time finding better than Sidewall Pizza Company!

If you’re willing to go an extra 24 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Spartanburg!

#9 Pizza City New York Style

I was so excited to try the pizza here and wasn’t disappointed. The New York style thin crust with a generous helping of cheese, delicious toppings like pepperoni, peppers, mushrooms and more, and their zesty sauce was out of this world!

My favorite part was the way they mix up their ingredients to create unique flavors. For example, they combine traditional Italian herbs, spices, fresh vegetables and meats all together to make the perfect pizza. The flavor combinations really set them apart from other pizzas in the area.

The atmosphere at Pizza City is cozy and inviting which makes it perfect for a night out or just hanging out with friends. The staff was also very friendly and accommodating which added to my great experience there.

At the end of the day I am confident that Pizza City is hands down one of the best places for pizza in Greenville SC. They have truly mastered the art of pizza making!

#10 Tito’s Restaurant Pizzeria

The crust is perfectly cooked, and the toppings are tantalizingly fresh. I’ve tasted pepperoni and mushrooms, bacon and jalapenos, Hawaiian – you name it. Every time, the pizza has been delicious!

And if you have a sweet tooth like me, you’ve got to try Tito’s infamous Nutella dessert pizza. Oh man! That stuff takes me to another world!

I’ve been blessed with the opportunity to taste pizzas from all corners of the globe, but I must say that my experience at Tito’s definitely stands out in my memory. The staff members are friendly and accommodating, while giving off a high-end restaurant vibe – which makes sense considering they have won various awards for their pizza!

In conclusion, whether it’s on your lunch break or for a special occasion – I highly recommend Tito’s Restaurant Pizzeria for what I believe is the best pizza in Greenville SC!

#11 Trio – A Brick Oven Cafe

From the moment I stepped in, it was obvious that this pizza joint had something special going on; the smell, the atmosphere and of course, the pizzas. Everything about this place just screamed “quality”.

The menu had a wide variety of options – you could get classic pies like the Margherita or go all-in with toppings such as pineapple and jalapenos. I decided to go for the latter and it definitely didn’t disappoint – every bite was bursting with flavor! The crust was thin yet surprisingly crispy and each topping complemented each other perfectly.

My friends decided to opt for other options from Trio’s selection and were similarly impressed. We actually had a bit of an argument at one point over whose pizza tasted better!

If you’re in Greenville SC and looking for great pizza, then look no further – Trio is definitely one of the best pizza joints around.

#12 Frodo’s Pizza

The atmosphere is warm and inviting, with cozy booths and soft music playing in the background. The staff was friendly and helpful, recommending me some of their top favorites. I’m not one for being told what to eat, so I decided to order a custom pizza.

The first thing that stood out to me was the amazing crust. It had a nice crispiness that wasn’t too hard or too soft. Next came the sauce, which was sweet yet savory. Then they added the toppings; everything from pepperoni to pineapple-onion medley! Each one bursting with flavor yet complimenting each other perfectly.

Finally, the finale: the cheese. Oh boy, was it ever good! Mozzarella, Parmesan, Asiago – truly all of my favorite cheeses in one pizza! And an excellent dusting of oregano on top sealed the deal for me.

All in all, Frodo’s Pizza offers some of the best pizza in Greenville SC! Even this world-traveling food critic will be returning for another slice (or two!) soon enough.

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Antonino Bertolo’s Pizza & Wine Bar

First and foremost, let me say that this place knows how to keep its patrons happy. I mean, they serve alcohol, and not just any kind – we’re talking hard liquor! Who needs just a regular old glass of wine when you can have a Moscow Mule with your pizza? That’s what I call a win-win situation!

But the fun doesn’t stop there. Antonino Bertolo’s also offers dessert. Yes, you heard that right. Dessert. Pizza and sweets? Sign me up! I can already taste the succulent combination of Nutella, marshmallows, and graham crackers on their famous dessert pizza. It’s like a culinary campfire in your mouth!

And let’s not forget that this place is a fantastic tourist spot. Not only do you get to experience the mouth-watering delights of Antonino Bertolo’s, but you also get a lovely view of Greenville. It’s like dining in the heart of a postcard. Perfect for those Instagram-worthy moments.

Now, while all of this is amazing, there is one downside – they don’t accept reservations. But hey, who needs to plan ahead when you can just show up and enjoy the best pizza in town? Plus, it adds a little suspense to the dining experience. Will there be a table available? Will we have to wait? It’s like a pizza roulette!

Overall, Antonino Bertolo’s Pizza & Wine Bar is a must-visit for all pizza enthusiasts. With its stellar thin crust pizza, a variety of alcohol options, delightful desserts, and stunning views, it’s a fantastic spot for locals and tourists alike. So go ahead and treat yourself to a slice – or three!