Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Hershey PA (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Pennsylvania

Best Pizza in Hershey PA (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

153 Views

I’ve tried a bunch of different places over the years and have come up with my top 12 pizzas in Hershey. I’m excited to share my findings with you.

From thin crust to Chicago-style deep dish, there’s something for everyone! It was hard to decide, but with all of my worldwide pizza experience, I think I can make some recommendations here.

So if you’re wondering where you should go for pizza in Hershey PA, I’ve done the research and am ready to share my findings. Let’s get into it – here are the best pizzas in town!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Pennsylvania

#1 Palermo’s Pizzeria

The atmosphere is warm and inviting, with a hint of Italy in the air. It’s clear that they take pizza seriously here, as the scent of fresh-baked pies waft through the restaurant.

The menu offers a wide selection of classic and modern pizzas, from the classic margherita to a vegan white pizza. I decided to try the Palermo Pie and it was delicious! The crust was perfectly thin and crispy and the toppings were flavorful and plentiful.

The service was also top notch. Our server was friendly, attentive, and knowledgeable about their menu options. She even suggested some unique flavor combinations for me to try next time!

Overall, I found my experience at Palermo’s to be nothing short of amazing! I highly recommend them if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Hershey PA!

If you’re willing to go an extra 8 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Harrisburg!

#2 Bartolo’s Pizza

The restaurant has a nice decor and it’s a classic tourist spot to check out. And if you have little ones with you, the kid’s menu is definitely a bonus.

When it comes to the pizza itself, it’s clear that Bartolo’s has perfected their craft. The dough is cooked to perfection with just the right amount of chewiness. Not to mention the topping choices! I’m usually partial to pepperoni but they offer a wide variety of classics and some unique options too which means there’s something for everybody.

Unfortunately, Bartolo’s doesn’t offer delivery services which is a bit of a bummer, but that didn’t stop me from giving them five stars! If you’re ever in Hershey PA looking for great pizza, be sure to check out Bartolo’s Pizza. You won’t regret it!

#3 Palermo’s Pizza of Hershey

My recent visit to Palermo’s Pizza of Hershey was a pleasurable one, where I could truly feel the passion that the chefs had for their craft. Upon entering the restaurant, I was greeted by a friendly staff and a delightful aroma of freshly cooked pizza that filled the air.

The atmosphere is warm and inviting with rustic brick walls and dimly lit tables. The servers were friendly and attentive, making sure we were well-taken care of throughout our dining experience. And of course, let’s not forget about the pizza itself!

I tried several different specialty pizzas – all equally as delicious as each other – from cheese pizzas to pepperoni pies to white pizzas with pesto. Every bite melted in my mouth and I found myself wanting more! Even after having multiple slices, I still couldn’t get enough of their amazing pizza!

What really sets Palermo’s Pizza of Hershey apart is its commitment to using only premium ingredients right down to the dough. The homemade crusts are light and fluffy with a crunchy exterior. I felt like I was eating at an Italian Pizzeria right in my own backyard!

I’m confident in declaring that Palermo’s Pizza of Hershey has some of the best pizza in Hershey PA, if not beyond! A few tastes and you’ll be convinced too!

#4 Piazza Sorrento

From the first bite, I was absolutely in awe. The crust was light and fluffy yet with a great crunch to it, the sauce had just the right balance of spices, the cheese was creamy and full of flavor, and the toppings were fresh and flavorful.

The atmosphere was also top notch. With its faux-Italian decor and warm ambience, Piazza Sorrento gave me a feeling of being in Italy rather than Hershey PA!

Service wise, Piazza Sorrento gets top marks as well. The wait staff are knowledgeable, friendly and accommodating – they certainly made me feel like family!

To sum it up – if you’re looking for the best pizza in Hershey PA then look no further than Piazza Sorrento! Trust me when I say that you won’t regret it.

#5 Dafnos

I was so impressed with the thin, crispy crust and the exquisite combination of sauces, seasonings, cheeses and fresh toppings. The pizza was cooked to perfection in their wood fired ovens which provided a smoky flavor that can’t be beat.

The atmosphere at Dafnos is great too! It’s a cozy eatery with a nice open dining area. The staff are friendly and they always look delighted when I order. Plus, they offer tons of specialty pizzas as well as classic Italian favorites like rigatoni or eggplant parmesan.

I usually order the “special of the month” which comes loaded with zesty flavors and creative combinations. I’ve also sampled the Sicilian style pizza there – it has a thick crust topped with an incredible blend of perfectly spiced tomato sauce and cheese!

In sum, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Hershey PA then Dafnos should be your go-to place. From my frequent visits I can assure you that it’s worth every penny and everything on the menu will tantalize your taste buds!

#6 Lazzaro’s Italian Bistro

Seriously, I’m not just saying that. The pizza here is insanely good. The crust is nice and crisp, with the perfect amount of flavor. The sauce is also top-notch – perfect for dipping your slices!

What really sets Lazzaro’s apart from other pizza places in the area is their kid’s menu options. They even have a few gluten-free options for those with dietary restrictions. It’s great that Lazzaro’s makes sure to keep the little ones happy!

But let me tell you, if you’re visiting Hershey PA and are looking for a great place to eat some serious pizza, look no further than Lazzaro’s Italian Bistro. Not only do they serve delicious pizza, they also have one of the best desserts I’ve ever tasted in my life. Really, it could put most other bakeries to shame!

Unfortunately, there is one downside – they don’t deliver. You’ll have to come into the restaurant to experience this culinary wonderland for yourself. But trust me when I say it’ll be worth your time!

Overall, Lazzaro’s Italian Bistro offers some of the best pizza in Hershey PA and should definitely be your go-to spot for a tasty meal out on the town!

If you’re willing to go an extra 15 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Mechanicsburg!

#7 My Way Pizza & Grill

The aroma wafting through the restaurant was inviting and made my mouth water as soon as I stepped inside. The decor was nice but unassuming – letting the pizza speak for itself!

I ordered a pepperoni pizza with extra cheese, and it sure did not disappoint. The crust was perfectly thin yet still had that chewy texture that I love in good pizza. The sauce was full of flavor and sweetness, and the cheese melted perfectly on top – creating that perfect stringy effect that you know means you’re in for a treat. To top it off, even the pepperoni had great flavor to it.

In all, My Way Pizza & Grill is an excellent spot to get some of the best pizza in Hershey PA! With great service and delicious food, this place never disappoints. Highly recommended!

#8 Jojo’s Pizza Hummelstown PA

The atmosphere of the restaurant is lively and inviting. The staff was friendly and knowledgeable, eager to answer my questions about the different toppings they offer. I also appreciated the wide selection of specialty pizzas they have on the menu.

The pizza itself was out of this world! It had a perfect combination of crunchy crust, cheesy goodness, and delicious meats and vegetables that made it unlike anything else I’ve ever tried before. Even more impressive was how quickly it arrived at my table – only minutes after ordering!

If you’re ever in Hershey PA looking for some good pizza, Jojo’s Pizza Hummelstown PA is definitely worth a visit. You won’t be disappointed – their pizza is truly the best around!

#9 Fabio and Joe’s

I had heard about the legendary pizza of Fabio and Joe’s from friends and colleagues, so I decided to go check it out for myself. After eating there, all I can say is wow! This place lives up to its reputation!

The atmosphere at Fabio and Joe’s was welcoming, lively and had a great Italian vibe. The pizzas were something else – the crusts were perfectly crispy yet fluffy; the sauce was flavorful and not too sweet or salty; and the toppings were incredibly fresh.

The staff at Fabio & Joe’s were knowledgeable, friendly, and attentive to our needs. They even gave us some suggestions on what we should try that we hadn’t considered trying before.

All in all, if you’re ever in Hershey PA looking for delicious pizza, look no further than Fabio & Joe’s! It’s definitely one of the best places around for pizza.

#10 Primanti Bros. Restaurant and Bar Hershey

The atmosphere of the restaurant was warm and inviting. The staff were friendly and welcoming, making for a pleasant dining experience.

When it comes to the pizza itself, you can’t go wrong with Primanti Bros. The crust is perfectly thin and crispy, creating an ideal base for the delicious toppings. The cheese was melted to perfection and there was plenty of it! Additionally, all of the toppings were plentiful and flavorful—a great balance between savory and sweet.

And let’s not forget about their delightful selection of sauces! From tangy marinara to cream garlic or pesto, they have something to please every palate.

Overall, Primanti Bros. Restaurant & Bar Hershey has some of the best pizza in Hershey PA! Whether you’re a local or visiting from out-of-town, be sure to check them out!

#11 Phillip Arthur’s Cafe

When I walked into the restaurant, I was immediately greeted with a warm atmosphere and delicious aromas. The staff was friendly and accommodating, setting me up with a perfect table for my experience.

I went for their classic pepperoni pizza, which not only looked amazing but tasted even better! The crust is thin and crispy, the sauce is flavorful without being overpowering, and the cheese is perfectly gooey. Every bite was pure bliss!

And that’s not all; Phillip Arthur’s Cafe has options for vegetarians as well. Their veggie pizza is loaded with fresh toppings like peppers, mushrooms, and onions. The combination of texture and flavors make it one of a kind.

Phillip Arthur’s Cafe not only has some of the best pizza in Hershey PA but also great atmosphere and service to match. If you’re ever in town looking for a great pizza experience, this should be your first stop!

If you’re willing to go an extra 22 miles, you can get to 16 more pizza places in Lititz!

#12 Brother Joe’s Pizza

I recently had the chance to sample Brother Joe’s mouthwatering pizza and it was truly an experience I won’t soon forget. The crust was cooked to perfection, with just the right amount of crunch, and topped with a delightfully tangy pizza sauce that was bursting with flavor. On top of that, the cheese was not stringy or dry but gooey and delicious. To compliment, their selection of toppings ranged from fresh vegetables like mushrooms and peppers to savory meats like pepperoni and sausage.

Overall, the combination of flavors blended together perfectly, making for a heavenly bite every time! Not only that, but their prices are really reasonable too – it’s hard to find quality pizza at such low prices!

If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Hershey PA, then do yourself a favor and check out Brother Joe’s Pizza. You won’t regret it!