Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Westerly RI (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Rhode Island

Best Pizza in Westerly RI (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

190 Views

I recently conducted a thorough review of 12 pizza places in the area and am pleased to share my findings.

My pizza palate has been developed by sampling pies from all over the world so, I bring an extensive knowledge of what makes a great pizza to this article.

Now, it’s time for you to sit back, relax, and enjoy the read as I take you on a tour of the best pizza in Westerly RI.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Rhode Island

#1 Mr. Pizza

My goodness, the crust was so light and airy that it almost melted in my mouth! The cheese was so gooey and delicious, perfectly complimenting the zesty pizza sauce. I haven’t had a better combination of flavors anywhere else in the world!

The restaurant itself is quite impressive as well. It’s a great tourist spot with a nice atmosphere and friendly service. They also have some unique options like vegan pizzas and gluten-free crusts for those who are looking for something special.

Unfortunately, Mr. Pizza does not have delivery options which can be a bit of an inconvenience for some customers. But if you take the time to visit the restaurant in person, you won’t be disappointed! I certainly wasn’t!

All in all, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Westerly RI, Mr. Pizza will definitely satisfy your craving!

If you’re willing to go an extra 4 miles, you can get to 12 more pizza places in Mystic!

#2 Limiro’s Pizza & Catering

The first thing I noticed was the inviting aroma of freshly cooked pizza. It was like a warm hug on a cold winter’s day. I figured if the smell could be that good, then the taste must be even better!

I opted for their signature pie – the Pesto Shrimp Pizza – and it definitely did not disappoint! The pesto sauce was perfectly flavorful, and combined with sweet shrimp and gooey cheese, created an unforgettable taste experience. The crust had a crunchy bite to it, which gave amazing texture to every bite.

The service at Limiro’s Pizza & Catering was top-notch; my server was friendly and attentive throughout my whole meal. Not only did they make sure all my needs were met, but they also provided me with helpful suggestions on what toppings would go well with my pizza.

For those of us seeking out quality pizza in Westerly RI, Limiro’s is definitely worth checking out! Their delicious pizzas are sure to please even the most discerning palettes – mine included!

#3 Rhode Island Pizza Co

I arrived at this charming little spot tucked away in Westerly and was immediately taken aback by the aroma of freshly baked pizza. I knew right away that I had to try it.

The first thing that caught my eye were the incredible array of pizzas on their menu. From classic Italian style margherita, to unique creations like bacon jalapeno cheese, there’s truly something here for everyone.

The crust was the perfect balance between crunchy and chewy, and the sauce was excellent. The toppings were all fresh and flavorful, adding a delicious flavor to each slice. But what really made this pizza stand out from the rest was the cheese – it had a creamy texture and a wonderfully sharp taste that made every bite just delicious!

Overall, Rhode Island Pizza Co is definitely one of the best places in Westerly RI for pizza. In addition to fantastic food, their friendly staff make going there an absolute pleasure. If you’re looking for great pizza with exceptional flavor and texture, then look no further!

#4 Stonington Pizza Palace

Upon entering, I was immediately impressed by the wide range of pizzas on offer. From simple cheese and pepperoni to more adventurous concoctions like eggplant and pesto, they had something for everyone!

The pizza itself was delicious. The crust was perfectly thin and crispy, while the sauce was rich and flavorful. The toppings were generous and well-cooked, with each bite packed full of flavor.

I particularly enjoyed their signature ‘Stonington Supreme’ pizza – a combination of pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions and olives that worked together perfectly! It’s definitely one of my favorite pies in Westerly RI.

For those with a sweet tooth, Stonington Pizza Palace also offered a selection of desserts including tiramisu and cannoli. They were creative interpretations of classic Italian desserts that made for an indulgent end to the meal.

All in all, Stonington Pizza Palace is definitely at the top of my list for great pizza in Westerly RI. If you are ever in town I strongly suggest you give them a try – you won’t be disappointed!

#5 Buon Appetito Ristorante & Pizzeria

The pizza is supremely delicious, with just the perfect amount of cheese and a unique blend of spices. The crust is crispy and chewy, just how I like it. On top of that, they have some great vegetarian options, a kid’s menu, and an insane selection of desserts.

But what really sets Buon Appetito apart from other pizza places is their selection of adult beverages. Not only do they serve wine, but they have hard liquor too! It’s the perfect place to meet up with friends after work or to take your date out for dinner.

The only downside I can find to this restaurant is that they don’t offer delivery service; you’ll need to eat there in person. But all in all, I’d definitely recommend Buon Appetito Ristorante & Pizzeria if you’re looking for one of the best pizzas in Westerly RI!

#6 Vittoria’s NY Pizza

I recently visited Vittoria’s NY Pizza and was incredibly impressed. The atmosphere is warm and inviting; their counter staff was friendly and knowledgeable, making the process seamless.

The pizza itself really stands out. They make a great thin crust pizza with the perfect balance of cheese and sauce that had me coming back for more. I especially love their Wisconsin White pizza – the combination of mozzarella, cheddar, parmesan and garlic is delectable!

Overall, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Westerly RI, look no further than Vittoria’s NY Pizza. Their pizzza will leave you wanting more each time!

If you’re willing to go an extra 15 miles, you can get to 23 more pizza places in New London!

#7 Pod’s Pizza

The decor inside Pod’s is hip and modern, with plenty of TVs playing classic game shows to keep things interesting. The employees at the counter were friendly and helpful.

But enough about atmosphere – let’s get to what matters most: the pizza! Pod’s is your local neighborhood pizzeria with an incredible selection of delicious pies. I tried the pepperoni, cheese, and sausage pies and all were up to snuff with minimal grease. The crust was perfect – not too thick or thin – and baked just right. The toppings were generous without being excessive. It was a near-perfect pizza experience!

I also had a chance to try the garlic breadsticks. They were warm, salty, cheesy, and absolutely scrumptious!

In summary, if you’re in town looking for a fulfilling pizza experience then you can’t go wrong with Pod’s Pizza. I’ve been all over the world tasting pizza and this is definitely one of the best slices I have ever had!

#8 Casa Della Luce

First, the pizza is truly out of this world. The crust is perfectly crisp and chewy, with a wonderfully flavorful blend of herbs and spices. I’ve had my share of “greasy pizzas,” but not here – every single bite of pizza was loaded with flavor!

The toppings are also amazing. All the vegetables were fresh and full of color, while the combination of cheeses added an extra level of complexity to each bite. Whether you like plain cheese or something more intricate, Casa Della Luce has you covered!

I have to give props to the staff for their service as well. Everyone at Casa Della Luce was incredibly friendly and helpful. From taking my order to answering all my questions about local ingredients, they were always willing to help out in any way they could.

All in all, I’m convinced that Casa Della Luce serves up some of the best pizza in Westerly RI – if not the entire country! So if you’re ever in town, be sure to check it out – you won’t regret it!

#9 The Pizza Lady

The crust was delightfully thin and crunchy, and the cheese was deliciously gooey. The sauce was tasty and just the right amount of tanginess.

But the real star of this show is the toppings! They have a wide selection of delicious combinations that I couldn’t get enough of. From classic pepperoni to mouth-watering meat lover’s to heavenly Hawaiian, it seems like all my pizza cravings can be satisfied here.

Combined with their friendly service and pleasant atmosphere, The Pizza Lady is an unbeatable choice for any pizza night. I highly recommend them if you’re in Westerly RI – they really are the best around!

#10 PizzaPlace

I recently visited PizzaPlace and was welcomed with a huge smile by their staff. The restaurant was clean, inviting and smelled like freshly made pizza. They had a variety of options ranging from classic New York style to deep dish Chicago-style, as well as gluten free and vegan options.

My first bite of the classic New York style pizza blew me away! The crust was perfectly thin and crispy, the sauce flavorful, and the cheese melted just right. The toppings were all fresh, and the ultimate combination resulted in a superbly delicious pie.

The other pizzas I tried at PizzaPlace also impressed me. From their signature BBQ chicken to their veggie supreme, each slice was packed full of flavor in every bite. Their salads, sides, and desserts were also top-notch – especially the cheesy garlic breadsticks!

In conclusion, PizzaPlace has some of the best pizza in Westerly RI – no doubt about it! With its cozy atmosphere, excellent service and mouth-watering pizzas that keep you wanting more, it’s no wonder why this place is quickly becoming one of my go-to spots for great pizza!

#11 Vetrano’s Restaurant

From the moment I walked in, I was welcomed with open arms and a delightful smell of baking dough. The staff were friendly and eager to make sure that my visit would be a pleasant one.

The pizza at Vetrano’s Restaurant is truly something else! It has the perfect ratio of crispy crust to fresh tomatoes, cheese, and top-notch ingredients like pepperoni, olives, pineapple, and whatever else your heart desires. Not to mention their signature wood-fired oven that gives it an amazing smoky flavor.

In addition to the great taste of their food, Vetrano’s also offers an atmosphere unlike any other. With its comfortable seating area, dim lights and classic Italian music playing in the background – no wonder it’s a popular spot among locals!

I’m confident in saying that Vetrano’s Restaurant is hands down the best pizza in Westerly RI! If you’re ever in town – make sure to check them out for some truly exceptional pie!

If you’re willing to go an extra 20 miles, you can get to 18 more pizza places in Narragansett!

#12 Supreme Pizza of Westerly

I rolled up to the restaurant and immediately knew that I was in for a treat. The warm and inviting atmosphere made me feel right at home. The welcoming staff were eager to answer any questions that I had about the menu, and were happy to help out when it came time to order.

The pizza itself was just as excellent as it looked. It was cooked perfectly, with a nice crunchy crust and a delicious sauce. The toppings were fresh and flavorful, making each bite an absolute delight. And the cheese! Oh my goodness the cheese was exquisite – it was meltingly creamy and utterly delicious. I’m sure I will be dreaming of Supreme Pizza’s pizza for days to come!

I wasn’t able to sample every item on the menu – but what I did try definitely hit the spot. The garlic bread had a nice crispiness on its outside while still being fluffy in the middle; the salads were bursting with flavor; and the desserts simply melted in my mouth!

In conclusion, Supreme Pizza of Westerly is by far one of the best pizza restaurants in Westerly RI. If you’re looking for great food in a relaxed setting then this is definitely where you need to be!