In the last few months, I’ve ventured across the city tasting pizza and searching for the very best White Plains has to offer. After trying twelve different places (with plenty of extra cheese, of course), I’m finally ready to share my results with you!
My journey has been a lot of fun, and I’m excited to tell you all about it. I hope this article will give you an entertaining look at some delectable pies while sharing my tips on where to find the best pizza in White Plains. So let’s get started – it’s time for us to go on a cheesy adventure!
If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New York
#1 Utica Pie Co.
- Serves alcohol
From the minute I stepped inside the restaurant, I knew I was in for a treat. The atmosphere is warm, inviting, and absolutely delicious. The staff was incredibly friendly and knowledgeable – they even gave me some helpful tips about which pizzas to try!
The pizzas are made from fresh ingredients and cooked to perfection. I especially enjoyed their signature cheese pizza, which had a perfectly crispy crust and just the right amount of sauce and toppings. They also have a great selection of specialty pizzas like their white pizza with spinach and garlic or their pepperoni lovers’ pizza.
The highlight of my visit was definitely the tiramisu for dessert! It’s hands down the best tiramisu I’ve ever tasted – light yet creamy with just the right amount of sweetness. It totally hit the spot after such a delicious meal!
In conclusion, Utica Pie Co is definitely one of my top spots for the best pizza in White Plains. Delicious food, great service, and an amazing ambiance- what more could you ask for?
If you’re willing to go an extra 3 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Scarsdale!
#2 Melo’s Pizzas
The atmosphere of the restaurant is cozy and inviting, but the main attraction here is the pizza. The dough is well-made and the toppings are fresh and flavorful. I’ve had a variety of pizzas from plain cheese to pepperoni to everything in between – all delicious!
The staff at Melo’s Pizzas also make your experience enjoyable. They’re always friendly and accommodating, quick to answer any questions you may have about the menu or even suggest one of their favorite specialties.
Overall, I’d definitely recommend Melo’s Pizzas if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in White Plains. It was definitely worth my trip around the world to get a taste of their amazing pies!
#3 J-Joe kosher pizza & berrylicious
- Offers dessert
- Nice tourist spot
I visited the restaurant on a particularly hot day, but the air conditioning and inviting atmosphere were a pleasant surprise. The decor was simply delightful – it had obvious Italian influences that reminded me of a charming pizza parlor in Rome.
The menu was full of delicious options with an emphasis on what they call “Kosher-style” pizza, something I hadn’t encountered before in my travels. I ended up ordering the signature topping: ham, pineapple, bell peppers and olives.
When it arrived at my table I couldn’t help but appreciate its fine craftsmanship – the thin crust was perfectly crisp and airy while still maintaining a hearty texture. The toppings were fresh and flavorful, each bite filled with an abundance of flavor.
The service was also top-notch! Everyone from the hostess to the servers were friendly, helpful and made sure that I had everything I needed.
There’s no doubt that J-Joe kosher pizza & berrylicious serves some of the best pizza in White Plains – if you’re ever in town make sure to stop by for a slice!
#4 Abatino’s
- Serves alcohol (and hard liquor!)
- Offers dessert
- Has a kid’s menu
The atmosphere at Abatino’s is very cozy, with friendly service and a bright, inviting dining room. The welcoming staff quickly put me at ease, making it easy to savor every bite of the delicious pizza.
Speaking of which, the pizza I had was divine! The crust was fluffy yet crisp and the sauce was flavorful without being overwhelming. The combination of cheese, tomato, meat toppings, and herbs were just perfect. I could tell that all the ingredients were fresh, giving each slice its own unique flavor profile.
Of course, no good pizza experience would be complete without some great side dishes. Abatino’s offers several options including garlic knots, salads, and even desserts! All of these complemented my main course perfectly.
Aside from their excellent pizza and sides, one thing that really sets Abatino’s apart is their commitment to sustainability. All of their ingredients are locally sourced whenever possible in an effort to reduce their environmental footprint. This is something that I can definitely appreciate as a food critic!
In short: if you’re looking for the best pizza in White Plains – look no further than Abatino’s!
#5 Broadway Pizzeria of White Plains
- Has a kid’s menu
- Has some vegetarian options
The crust is perfect; not too thick, not too thin. The cheese had just the right amount of meltiness and was so flavorful. Plus, the toppings were fresh, and that made it taste even better.
Plus, the restaurant has a laid-back vibe which I just love. It’s like you’re in some small village in Italy enjoying a delicious slice of pizza with family and friends – except you’re actually in White Plains! The staff are friendly and welcoming, too.
I highly recommend Broadway Pizzeria of White Plains to anyone who loves pizza. You won’t be disappointed!
#6 Venice Pizza & Trattoria
- Offers dessert
- Has a kid’s menu
- Has some vegetarian options
- Great place to watch sports
- Nice tourist spot
The ingredients are all top-notch, and you can tell that the dough is made fresh daily. I had a classic Margherita pizza and it was cooked to perfection. The cheese was just gooey enough, the tomato sauce was robust and flavorful, and the dough was light and airy.
The atmosphere at Venice Pizza & Trattoria is also great! It’s a cozy Italian restaurant with an intimate, romantic setting. The décor features rustic accents like exposed brick walls, wooden beams, and vintage furniture. The service is friendly and attentive; my waiter made sure he checked in on me throughout my meal without being too intrusive.
Overall I’d highly recommend Venice Pizza & Trattoria if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in White Plains. They truly have something to satisfy every pizza lover out there!
#7 TVB by: Pax Romana
- Serves alcohol (and hard liquor!)
- Has some vegetarian options
- Has insanely good dessert
The crust was flaky and had just the right amount of crunch, while the sauce and toppings were flavorful and perfectly cooked. The cheese was melted perfectly and had an amazing flavor that complemented the other ingredients perfectly. The best part? Despite being so delicious, the pizza was still incredibly affordable!
Speaking of ingredients, there are a ton of great options at TVB by Pax Romana. You can pick from classic pepperoni or some more unique choices like broccoli rabe and sweet Italian sausage. I personally opted for the classic margherita pizza with roasted garlic – it was simply divine!
Plus, the atmosphere at TVB by Pax Romana is unbeatable. Not only did I get to enjoy my pizza in a cozy corner booth, but I also got to chat up the friendly staff who work there. This is certainly one place you don’t want to miss if you’re ever in White Plains looking for a tasty slice!
#8 Famous Famiglia
- Nice tourist spot
When I walked into the restaurant, I was immediately struck by the Italian ambience. From the red tablecloths to the vintage posters on the walls, it felt like I had stepped into a pizzeria in Italy.
The service was top notch, and the waiters were friendly and passionate about their job. Not to mention they were super knowledgeable about their menu items and could answer any questions I had. But of course, the real star of this show is the pizza.
I ordered a classic Margherita pie and it did not disappoint! The freshly made dough was light and airy, with a perfect crispness on the edges. The tomato sauce was rich and flavourful without being overwhelming, while the melted mozzarella combined with basil leaves added a subtle depth of flavour to every bite. In short, it was probably one of the best pizzas I’ve ever tasted!
So if you’re ever in White Plains looking for some great pizza, Famous Famiglia should be your first stop. It’s got an amazing atmosphere and serves up some tasty pies that will leave you wanting seconds!
If you’re willing to go an extra 7 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in North White Plains!
#9 Nonna’s Pizza
- Has a kid’s menu
- Has some vegetarian options
- Offers dessert
The first thing I noticed when walking into Nonna’s Pizza was the smell: a tantalizing blend of oregano, garlic, and tomato sauce. My mouth started watering instantly!
The menu offered a great selection of classic Italian favorites, but I knew I had to try one of their pizza pies. So I decided to order the “Signature White Pizza”: mozzarella cheese, sliced tomatoes, and basil with a white sauce instead of red sauce.
When it arrived at the table, it looked amazing! The dough was perfectly crisp – not too thick or thin – and the flavors blended together marvelously. It was hands down one the best pizzas I’ve ever tasted!
To top it all off, the restaurant even has a cozy atmosphere and friendly staff that made my dining experience even more enjoyable.
If you’re ever in White Plains looking for some quality pizza, definitely check out Nonna’s Pizza! You won’t be disappointed!
#10 Ernesto’s Pizza Cucina
- Serves alcohol
- Has a kid’s menu
- Offers dessert
The smell of pizza draws me in as soon I enter the restaurant. As soon as I take a seat, I’m presented with a menu full of delicious options.
I try the Margherita Pizza – it’s loaded with fresh, melted mozzarella, tomatoes, and herbs. It’s cooked to perfection with nice charring on the crust and all the flavors melt together perfectly. The portion size is just right for one person and definitely bigger than your typical slice from other places.
The service here is top-notch too. All my needs were easily taken care of – from corkage fee for my own bottle of wine to a special request for extra sauce.
Ernesto’s Pizza Cucina is definitely one of White Plains’ crowning jewels when it comes to pizzas! Highly recommend this spot for anyone looking for a great slice!
#11 Lombardo’s White Plains
- Nice tourist spot
- Great place to watch sports
- Serves alcohol (and hard liquor!)
- Has a kid’s menu
- Has some vegetarian options
- Has insanely good dessert
The atmosphere of the restaurant is welcoming, with a cozy indoor seating area and a lovely terrace with ample outdoor seating. The decor was simple yet attractive, and the staff was friendly and attentive.
When it came to the pizza, this place really knocked it out of the park! The crust was perfectly cooked – golden brown on the outside, fluffy and light on the inside. The sauce was rich and flavorful, and the cheese was just right – melted to perfection! Every bite was savory and delicious. The toppings were fresh and generous – from pepperoni to mushrooms, everything tasted amazing!
All in all, Lombardo’s White Plains offers some of the best pizza in White Plains. Absolutely worth a visit if you’re in town.
#12 Papi’
- Offers dessert
- Serves alcohol
- Has a kid’s menu
- Has some vegetarian options
I can confidently say that the chefs at Papi’ know their way around a pizza. The crust was perfectly crispy yet light enough to fully enjoy all the toppings on each pie. Not too thick, not too thin – it had just the right thickness.
The ingredients were fresh and flavorful, resulting in a pizza that tasted like it had been cooked in an authentic Italian oven! And I have to mention the sauce. It was rich, smooth and had just the right amount of sweetness that made me want to polish off every single slice – and I did!
I definitely recommend Papi’ to anyone who’s looking for some of the best pizza in White Plains. It’s worth every penny spent!
