Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Wilmington NC (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in North Carolina

Best Pizza in Wilmington NC (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

936 Views

After tasting over 12 different pizza places in Wilmington, I’ve gained some insight on which ones are the best. I’m excited to share with you the results of my extensive research! But first— a short disclaimer: Everyone has different opinions on pizza, so your perfect pie might not be exactly what I found in North Carolina. With that said, I’m confident that these reviews will help you find a delicious option.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of North Carolina

#1 Wheelz Pizza of Wrightsville Beach

From the moment I stepped through the door, it was clear that Wheelz Pizza takes their pizza making seriously. Not only did they have an array of fresh ingredients to choose from, but the staff was extremely knowledgeable and helpful in guiding me on my perfect pie.

The pizzas themselves were out of this world. The dough was freshly made, and had a crisp and light texture. The toppings were flavorful and perfectly presented, while still maintaining consistency throughout each slice. And the cheese! Oh my goodness, the cheese! It was silky smooth with just enough ooey-gooey goodness. All around a great experience!

Do yourself a favor – if you’re ever in Wilmington NC and looking for some delicious pizza, don’t hesitate to stop by Wheelz Pizza of Wrightsville Beach. You won’t be disappointed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 9 miles, you can get to 10 more pizza places in Carolina Beach!

#2 Pizzeria Don Luca

The restaurant itself is nothing to write home about, but that matters very little with pizza. It’s nothing fancy, but it gets the job done.

My favorite thing about Pizzeria Don Luca is the crust. The dough is freshly made each day and baked perfectly so it’s crunchy on the outside and soft inside. The sauce is always tangy and flavorful, with loads of grated cheese melted on top—you can definitely tell it’s homemade!

The toppings are all freshly cut vegetables, so they have a nice flavor that really elevates the pizza experience. I like to get my pies extra loaded up with pepperoni, mushrooms, peppers and onions; everything always tastes fresh and delicious.

I have yet to find a better pizza in Wilmington NC and highly recommend this place if you’re looking for a great pie. It might not look like much from the outside, but Pizzeria Don Luca makes some of the best pizzas around!

#3 Pie’s On Pizzeria & Grill

I’m a huge fan of the classic margherita pizza and I was delighted with how flavorful and simple it was here. The crust was crispy on the outside yet light, chewy and delicious inside. The cheese was bubbly and just melted in my mouth. It was definitely one of the best margheritas I’ve ever had!

My next favorite pizza is their white clam pie, which is loaded with delicious clams cooked to perfection, plus garlic and thyme for an extra kick of flavor. Again, the crust held up nicely, providing a great crunchy base for this unique pizza. This is definitely something that needs to be tasted to be believed!

The restaurant itself is cozy and cheerful, with friendly staff who are happy to answer any questions or recommendations you might have. Plus, they have a great selection of craft beers if you’re looking to wash down your pizza!

All in all, Pie’s On Pizzeria & Grill really lives up to its reputation as having some of the best pizza in Wilmington NC. Highly recommended!

#4 Cugino Forno Wilmington

I am so lucky to have stumbled across this little hidden gem! From the moment I stepped into Cugino Forno Wilmington, I was impressed. The ambiance was inviting and warm. Everywhere I looked there were smiling faces and amazing smells of pizza cooking.

When it came to the pizza itself, all I can say is WOW! They combined some of the best ingredients and flavors to create a truly unique pizza experience. Not only was the crust light and crispy, but the topping combination was spot-on too. From mushrooms and pepperoni to olives and onions, they had something for everyone to enjoy.

The service here at Cugino Forno Wilmington is top-notch too! Everyone from the hostess to the waiters and waitresses gave me an unforgettable dining experience. They knew just when to check on us without being intrusive or overwhelming.

If you’re ever in Wilmington NC looking for some good pizza, look no further than Cugino Forno Wilmington! It’s hands down some of the best pizza in town!

#5 Your Pie Pizza

From the moment I walked in, I knew I was in for a treat. The inviting atmosphere with its bright colors and eclectic decor made me feel right at home. Plus, the friendly staff were more than happy to explain the different pizzas and help me select the perfect one.

When my pizza arrived, it looked and smelled amazing! The crust had a nice crunch with just the right amount of charring, while the sauce had a light sweetness that perfectly balanced out the flavors of the cheese and toppings. And as for those toppings – everything from zucchini to roasted garlic was cooked to perfection.

Bottom line: Your Pie Pizza is definitely worth visiting if you want to taste some of the best pizza in Wilmington NC!

#6 Agostino’s Pizza & Pasta

I’ve had some pretty amazing pizza from all over, but none quite like the pies here. The crust is perfectly crunchy, the sauce is flavorful and bright, and the toppings are fresh and plentiful. I don’t even know where to start when it comes to describing my favorite pizza combinations.

The house special margherita – fresh mozzarella, tomato sauce, basil, and olive oil – is absolutely divine! I also love their classic pepperoni pie with a double helping of melted cheese on top. But that’s not all – Agostino’s also offers a variety of specialty pizzas like the Sicilian pie with prosciutto & figs, or the calzone stuffed with ricotta & sausage!

No matter what your pizza craving may be, I’m certain that Agostino’s has something for everyone. Plus they have an excellent selection of appetizers and desserts too. Definitely worth a visit if you’re looking for the best pizza in Wilmington NC!

#7 I Love NY Pizza

The atmosphere is inviting and cozy, and the staff are welcoming and friendly. But the big draw of I Love NY Pizza is, of course, the pizza. The thin crust is crisp but still flexible enough to hold the toppings without turning into a soggy mess. The tomatoes in the sauce were sweet and juicy, yet still well-seasoned with oregano, basil, garlic and olive oil.

My favorite topping at I Love NY Pizza was their sausage – it’s homemade using a secret recipe that’s been passed down for generations! My other favorite topping was their pepperoni, which had just the right amount of spice.

Although I love almost everything about this place, my only complaint would be that you can’t get carryout orders here – so I guess it’s back to packing up my suitcase whenever I’m in Wilmington NC looking for great pizza!

All in all though, I Love NY Pizza lived up to its name – it truly is some of the best pizza in Wilmington NC!

#8 Artisano Pizza and Gelato

The atmosphere is classic Italian style, with soft lighting, brick ovens, and inviting smiling faces. The staff were attentive to all my needs and very helpful in helping me decide what pie I should try.

I tried the house favorite ‘Margherita’ – it was absolutely delicious! It had just the right amount of cheese and a perfect balance between sweet tomatoes and fragrant basil which was fresh from the garden. The crust was thin and crispy yet still pliable enough to soak up all that delicious sauce without becoming soggy.

The gelato here was also absolutely divine! They offer a wide selection of flavors including chocolate, stracciatella, hazelnut, nocciola, pistachio and more – so everyone can find something they love. Even I have to admit I found it hard to choose just one flavor!

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Wilmington NC then look no further than Artisano Pizza and Gelato. Its great atmosphere combined with its masterful pizzas make it a must-visit destination for any traveler who loves Italian food!

If you’re willing to go an extra 36 miles, you can get to 14 more pizza places in Ocean Isle Beach!

#9 Wheelz Pizza of Midtown

The decor of the restaurant is a bit dated, but the pizza they serve more than makes up for it. The crust was perfectly cooked and flavorful, with just the right crunch. I especially enjoyed the classic pepperoni-mushroom combination, but their own special Wheelz flavor really blew me away. The sauce was rich and robust, with a hint of oregano that elevated the flavors above your typical pizzeria fare.

I also had some of their garlic bread which came served in a nice basket. Talk about fresh! It was hot out of the oven, slathered in butter and sprinkled with Parmesan cheese – talk about delicious! I could have made a meal out of that alone.

All in all, Wheelz Pizza of Midtown has some of the best pizza in Wilmington NC! If you’re ever looking for an amazing slice (or two!), this is definitely worth checking out.

#10 Nicola’s Italian Restaurant

The atmosphere and décor at Nicola’s is warm & inviting. The staff is friendly, knowledgeable and know exactly what to recommend when you’re feeling indecisive.

The pizza is truly out of this world! It has a perfectly golden-crust that almost melts in your mouth. Every bite is filled with fresh ingredients that burst in flavor. Truly one of the best pizzas I’ve ever experienced!

I also had a chance to sample some of the other items on the menu such as Italian Beef Subs, Calzones and Baked Ziti. Everything was superbly delicious – all made with top-notch ingredients that were prepared with great care.

If you’re ever in Wilmington NC and looking for some great pizza, head over to Nicola’s Italian Restaurant – you won’t regret it! Trust me – this food critic gives it two big thumbs up!

#11 Mellow Mushroom Wilmington

I was blown away by the flavorful crust and delicious toppings. From the classic pepperoni and cheese to the wild feta artichoke, it seems like there is something to satisfy everyone’s pizza cravings. The crust was just the right balance of crispy and soft, while the sauce was rich and flavorful.

The atmosphere was laidback and friendly – perfect for grabbing a slice with friends or sharing a large pizza as a family. The service was prompt and courteous, making for an enjoyable experience overall.

If I had to pick one favorite thing about Mellow Mushroom Wilmington, it would be their specialty pizzas – they truly stand out from the competition! I highly recommend trying the “Carolina Reaper,” with slices of spicy pepperoni hidden under melted mozzarella cheese. Be warned though: it’s seriously hot!

Overall, Mellow Mushroom Wilmington lives up to its name – providing mellow vibes and some of the best pizza in Wilmington NC. Give it a try and you won’t be disappointed!

#12 Ledo Pizza

After carefully tasting their pies, I can honestly say they make a mean pizza! The crust was deliciously crispy and the toppings were all cooked perfectly.

The restaurant also has some great benefits to it. They serve alcoholic beverages (including hard liquor!), so you can enjoy a glass of wine while you chow down on your favorite pie. They also have a kid’s menu, making them a great family restaurant, as well as several vegetarian options. If you’re in need of some sweetness after your savory meal, Ledo Pizza also offers dessert for those with a sweet tooth. As an added bonus, this tourist spot is also a great place to watch sports and hang out with friends!

Unfortunately, they don’t offer delivery services, but if you don’t mind taking the time to stop by and pick up your order–it’s worth it!

All in all, Ledo Pizza is one of the best pizza restaurants in Wilmington NC and I would definitely recommend it for anyone looking for great pizza or just trying to find a good place to spend time with friends or family!

Best Deep Dish Pizza – Benny’s Big Time Pizzeria

Upon entering Benny’s, the first thing that caught my eye was the size of the pizzas. These things were bigger than my ego! And believe me, that’s saying something. As soon as I took my first bite, I was transported to a land of cheesy bliss. It was like biting into a cloud made of mozzarella, mixed with the tears of angels who had finally tasted true perfection.

The crust was thick and doughy, just the way deep dish pizza should be. It was like a fluffy hug from a doughy Italian grandmother. And the toppings? Don’t even get me started. Benny’s is not afraid to pile on the good stuff. I had a pizza with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, and enough cheese to feed a small village. It was a flavor explosion in my mouth, like a fireworks show conducted by a master chef.

The atmosphere in Benny’s was lively and fun, with pizza-inspired decorations plastered all over the walls. They even had a statue of a giant pizza slice in the corner, which I’m pretty sure winked at me as I walked by. The staff were friendly and accommodating, and they didn’t even bat an eye when I asked for a second pizza. They must have sensed my overwhelming hunger for more deep dish goodness.

In conclusion, Benny’s Big Time Pizzeria is a must-visit for any pizza lover in Wilmington, NC. They serve up the best deep dish pizza in town, and maybe even the world. So what are you waiting for? Grab your stretchy pants and head on over to Benny’s. Your taste buds will thank you. And your waistline? Well, that’s a problem for another day.