Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in The Triangle (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in North Carolina

Best Pizza in The Triangle (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

148 Views

I’ve been to places all over the world in search of the best pizza, but I think The Triangle can hold its own against anywhere.

Ready to dive into my findings? After careful consideration, and taste-testing 12 different pizzerias here in the Triangle, I’m about to reveal who has the best pizza around. It’s time for my due diligence to finally pay off — get ready for some cheesy, glorious results!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of North Carolina

#1 Cugino Forno Durham

The atmosphere is inviting and the staff are friendly. It’s clear that they really care about their customers. The pizza here is made with great skill and attention to detail, resulting in fantastic flavor.

I love the fact that they offer a variety of options, both classic and creative. You can get a simple margherita or opt for something more experimental with toppings like artichokes, olives, and jalapenos. Each time I’ve visited, I’ve been impressed by how perfectly cooked the crust was – crispy on the outside but airy inside. The cheese melts just right too!

I’d also like to mention their delicious dessert pizzas which I think are underrated! The Nutella pizza is a must-try – it’s sweet but not too heavy on the palate. To top it all off, all the ingredients used at Cugino Forno Durham are fresh and high quality so you know you’re getting your money’s worth!

If you’re looking for great pizza in The Triangle, then look no further than Cugino Forno Durham – it will definitely be an unforgettable experience!

If you’re willing to go an extra 1 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Durham!

#2 Vicino’s Pizza

The atmosphere is so inviting, you can’t help but relax and enjoy every bite. The staff is always friendly and welcoming, which makes it a great place to take a break from my hectic travel schedule.

The pizza itself is simply unbeatable. It’s made with the freshest ingredients and cooked in their brick oven to perfection. Every single bite of the silky dough and flavorful sauce will have you coming back for more. I’d recommend trying their margherita pizza if you’re looking for something classic, or their pepperoni pizza if you want something a bit bolder.

My only complaint is that they don’t offer delivery service, so I had to come here in person. But it was definitely worth the effort! Vicino’s Pizza has some of the best pizza in all of The Triangle, so don’t miss out!

#3 Hutchins Garage

My first visit to Hutchins Garage was a delightful surprise. The atmosphere is welcoming, with an industrial edge that made for a unique dining experience.

I started my meal with the house salad, which was full of fresh ingredients and had a delicious balsamic vinaigrette dressing. Then came the pizza. I opted for the four-cheese blend, and let’s just say I cleaned my plate! The flavors combined perfectly and each bite was simply divine.

The quality of the ingredients used in their pizzas is exceptional; Hutchins Garage certainly knows how to make an extraordinary pie! I also sampled some of their speciality dishes, including Italian sausage and red peppers – which were both cooked to perfection – as well as scrumptious garlic knots.

If you’re looking for the best pizza in The Triangle, look no further than Hutchins Garage. Highly recommended!

#4 Oakwood Pizza Box

As soon as I walked in, the sweet smell of freshly-baked dough and melted cheese wafted through the air. I immediately knew that I had found a winner. The owners, Stan and Karen, greeted me with kind words and a smile that let me know that they take great pride in their restaurant.

The menu was extensive, varied and full of fresh ingredients all sourced from local farmers in the area. The menu featured delectable pizzas such as: the classic pepperoni pizza, Hawaiian pizza with pineapple on top, and the Oakwood special – a white garlic cream sauce topped with ricotta cheese and spinach.

The crust was perfectly thin yet crunchy; not an easy feat! It was also cooked to perfection – not too burnt or raw – just right! The sauces were flavorful and full of spices that complemented each other perfectly. Every ingredient tasted like it had been picked (or made) just minutes before being placed on the pizza.

The stars of the show were definitely the toppings though! From succulent Italian sausage to premium quality cheeses, every topping added something unique yet complimentary to its accompanying neighbor.

I have tasted many pizzas all over the world but none compare to Oakwood Pizza Box’s creations! I recommend anyone who is looking for THE best pizza in The Triangle pay them a visit!

#5 Pizzeria Toro

The first thing that struck me was the atmosphere – it’s cozy, casual and inviting. The staff are super friendly and welcoming, and always willing to answer any questions you might have about their food.

The pizza itself is incredible. Whether you like light and airy or extra-thick crusts, Pizzeria Toro has something for everyone. I’m a fan of the margherita pizza – there’s just something about the combination of fresh tomatoes, mozzarella cheese and basil that takes my taste buds on a wild ride! The flavor combinations they offer up will knock your socks off.

And while we’re talking toppings – Pizzeria Toro knows what they’re doing when it comes to topping their pizzas! From classic favorites like pepperoni and mushrooms to more inspired topping choices like roasted garlic cloves, Prosciutto crudo, or even Grana Padano cheese – each bite is a party in your mouth.

I think the best thing about Pizzeria Toro though is the price – considering the quality of ingredients used and flavour on offer, it’s clear that you can get way more bang for your buck here than almost anywhere else in The Triangle!

Overall, I can confidently say that Pizzeria Toro is serving up some of the best pizza in The Triangle – so treat yourself as soon as possible; after all, why wait?

#6 Randy’s Pizza

I have to admit, I was skeptical at first. A pizza joint located in a small North Carolina town–how good could it be? But I was surprised. From the moment I stepped in the door, it felt like I’d been transported to a pizzeria in Italy. The decor is unique and charming, with brick walls and vintage photos hanging around.

The pizza is just as amazing as the atmosphere. Their crust is thin and perfectly crisp, while still maintaining a doughy flavor. The toppings are fresh and flavorful, with a great variety of options available to choose from. They also offer creative specialty pies that really stand out compared to your typical pizzerias.

All in all, Randy’s Pizza is one of the best pizza places I’ve ever visited! If you’re ever passing through The Triangle region, you should definitely stop by for some of the best pizza you’ll ever taste!

#7 Sofia’s Pizza

The first thing I noticed when I walked in was the amazing atmosphere. The restaurant had a warm, inviting vibe that made me feel like I was right at home.

Next, I ordered their signature dish: the classic Margherita pizza. The pizza was cooked to perfection with a nice, crunchy crust and flavorful sauce. To top it off, the mozzarella cheese had just enough flavor and creaminess to make each bite delightful!

The standout dish from my experience at Sofia’s Pizza has to be their garlic knots. The knots were so garlicky and buttery – they melted in my mouth! Needless to say, I went back for seconds (or thirds!).

Overall, if you’re looking for the best pizza in The Triangle, Sofia’s Pizza is absolutely your go-to spot! Their food is delicious and their atmosphere is delightful – not mention affordable too! Highly recommended.

#8 Pie Pushers

I was immediately taken with the house-made dough and their rotating selection of locally sourced, fresh ingredients. The sauces used are top-notch, and they have a wide selection of toppings to choose from—making it easy to create a truly unique pizza experience.

Their signature pies like “The Three Amigos” (it’s got chorizo, jalapenos, and cilantro) are especially delicious. However, if you don’t want to get too wild with your order, there’s still something for you here: Pie Pushers’ Margherita pie is simply sublime!

In addition to the great pizza, I must give special mention to the extraordinary atmosphere at Pie Pushers. It’s the perfect fusion of pizzeria meets dive bar. The staff make it feel more like “hanging out with friends” than picking up food from a restaurant. It really adds to the overall comfort-food vibe they provide.

I can safely say that Pie Pushers has earned its place among the best pizza places in The Triangle! Whether you’re looking for an adventurous or classic pizza experience—Pie Pushers delivers!

If you’re willing to go an extra 12 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Chapel Hill!

#9 Pompieri Pizza

The first thing I noticed upon entering the restaurant was the smell of freshly baked pizza dough. The atmosphere inside was cozy and inviting; the wait staff were friendly and attentive, which certainly enhanced my experience.

The menu had a variety of delicious pizzas to choose from; everything from classic margheritas to more adventurous creations like their spicy pepperoni. After careful consideration, I opted for the ‘Pie of Heaven,’ which included fresh mozzarella, tomatoes and basil – it was truly divine!

The crust was thin and perfectly charred on the edges while the interior of the pizza had just enough chewy texture. The sauce was savory and robust and the toppings were plentiful. Even after eating half a pizza, I still wanted more!

To top off my visit, I decided to try their garlic knots – they were warm, buttery, garlicky perfection! All in all, dining at Pompieri Pizza was an absolute delight. I’d highly recommend it to anyone looking for a great pizza fix in The Triangle!

#10 Babymoon Cafe

The atmosphere of the restaurant is great. From the moment you walk in, you get a warm and inviting feeling. The staff was friendly and helpful, and they really made us feel welcomed.

The pizza menu offers some really unique options that are sure to please everyone. We ordered two different pies – one with tomato sauce and pepperoni, and the other with pesto and chicken. Both were cooked to perfection! The crust was perfectly crispy, the cheese was gooey and flavorful, and the toppings tasted great together.

The prices are reasonable too. A large pie will cost you around $14-15, which is about what you should expect for good pizza in this area.

Overall, I can’t say enough good things about Babymoon Cafe! If you’re looking for a delicious slice of pizza in The Triangle – look no further than this spot!

#11 Rosati’s Pizza

The cheesy, gooey goodness just melts on your tongue and its authenticity really rings through. As a self-proclaimed pizza connoisseur, I can honestly say that Rosati’s Pizza is delicious! It’s not the greasiest pizza I’ve ever had, but it definitely has enough flavor to satisfy me.

The service was also impressive; the staff were friendly and accommodating from start to finish. We were in and out of the restaurant in no time!

All in all, if you’re looking for great pizza in The Triangle then give Rosati’s Pizza a try – you won’t be disappointed! The best pizza I’ve had outside of Italy!

#12 Trophy Brewing & Pizza

The atmosphere alone is worth the visit. With its vibrant colors and cozy seating, Trophy Brewing & Pizza adds a modern twist to traditional pizzerias. Plus, they have a wide selection of craft beers that pair perfectly with their delicious pizza pies.

Speaking of which, they offer quite a variety of flavors that are sure to please anyone’s palette. From the classic Pepperoni to the unique BBQ Chicken Marinara, every option is delectable in its own way. I tried several slices during my visit and couldn’t decide on just one favorite. The crust is always cooked to perfection and never too thick or soggy.

I am still dreaming about Trophy Brewing & Pizza’s amazing desserts! Their homemade tiramisu was light yet decadent and the Nutella Calzone was out-of-this-world good.

I would highly recommend this spot for anyone looking for great pizza in The Triangle. After all, I have tasted some of the best pizzas from all over the world but nothing comes close to Trophy Brewing & Pizza!