Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Central Jersey (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in New Jersey

Best Pizza in Central Jersey (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

67 Views

I’ve been all over the world tasting pizza and I’m here to help guide you to twelve of the best pizza places in Central Jersey.

I’m about to share with you my sagely insight on the pizza scene in Central Jersey, so if you’re ready for a humorous and lighthearted take on pizza then please, read on!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New Jersey

#1 Massa Roman Square Pizza & Italian Specialties

I was immediately impressed with the interior of the restaurant; the bright, inviting atmosphere and brick oven definitely set the tone for a delicious experience.

The pizza I tried was some of the best I’ve had. The dough was cooked to perfection, with just the right amount of crunch. The sauce was sweet and savory, and the toppings were fresh and flavorful. It’s clear they use top quality ingredients here!

But what made this meal even more memorable was their great service! Our server was friendly, knowledgeable, and attentive — she really made sure our night out went off without a hitch. Every question we asked about the menu or ingredients got an answer quickly.

If you’re looking for great pizza in Central Jersey, Massa Roman Square Pizza & Italian Specialties is your spot! They keep up their standards consistently, so you know you’ll get great food every time you visit.

If you’re willing to go an extra 3 miles, you can get to 22 more pizza places in Westfield!

#2 Arturo’s

From the moment I pulled up outside, I could tell this was going to be a unique experience. The restaurant itself is quaint and inviting, with a wonderful atmosphere that makes it a great tourist spot.

When it comes to the food, Arturo’s really shines. They have an incredible selection of pizzas and toppings — so much that even vegetarians like myself are sure to find something tasty! What really caught my attention, though, was the dessert options. With their gelato and other sweet treats, Arturo’s is truly a place where everyone can find something delicious.

The only downside I found at Arturo’s is that they don’t offer delivery. While I didn’t mind since I wanted to get the full restaurant experience, this could be an issue for those who can’t make it out there in person.

In conclusion: if you’re looking for the best pizza in Central Jersey — look no further than Arturo’s! It offers great food with excellent service in a charming atmosphere — definitely worth checking out!

#3 Pete & Elda’s Bar / Carmen’s Pizzeria

The first thing that hits you when you step into Pete & Elda’s is the smell – a delicious combination of freshly baked crust, bubbly cheese, smoky pepperoni and herby pesto. I don’t think there’s an easier way to put it: the smell alone makes your mouth water.

The pizzas here are cooked to perfection, with the crust just the right texture – crispy on the outside and chewy on the inside. The toppings are always fresh, and they use some really zesty sauces that really bring out the flavor in their dishes. Not to mention, they have quite a selection of unique ingredients like artichoke hearts and spicy sausage that spice up any pie!

The best part about Pete & Elda’s is their secret ingredient for each pizza: love! It’s amazing what a difference a little extra love can make in each pizza. You can taste it in every bite!

If you’re looking for one of the best pizzas in Central Jersey, look no further than Pete & Elda’s Bar / Carmen’s Pizzeria!

#4 Federici’s Family Restaurant

The first thing I noticed when walking in was how cozy the restaurant was. It had a really inviting atmosphere that made me feel like I was part of the family. The service was friendly and attentive and the menu had something for everyone, including vegetarian options, a kid’s menu, and even hard liquor! And then came the pizza which truly blew me away. It had the perfect balance of cheese and sauce, the crusts were cooked to perfection – not too crispy or too chewy – and it was loaded with all my favorite toppings.

I’m usually an ice cream person but Federici’s Family Restaurant also has some insanely good desserts on offer that are worth trying out as well! And considering they have alcoholic beverages on offer, it’s definitely a great spot for a night out with friends or family.

The only downside I could find with this place is that they don’t deliver – you’ve got to go there yourself – but otherwise I would highly recommend this place for anyone looking for some of best pizza in Central Jersey!

#5 Papa’s Tomato Pies

I’ve had a lot of pizza in my life, but Papa’s Tomato Pies is something special. They have an unbeatable crust that’s crispy and perfectly balanced between savory and sweet. Their sauce is absolutely mouthwatering, with just the right amount of spices blended together to make something truly unique.

Their toppings are fresh and flavorful, offering interesting combinations such as feta and kalamata olives or bbq chicken and bacon. No matter what combination you choose, it’ll be delicious!

But what really sets Papa’s Tomato Pies apart is their commitment to using only the freshest ingredients locally sourced from Central Jersey farms. The combination of local ingredients with their handcrafted doughs and sauces make this one of the tastiest pizzas I’ve ever had.

If you’re looking for a great pizza experience, look no further than Papa’s Tomato Pies. It has easily earned itself a spot on my list of the best pizza in Central Jersey!

#6 Vic’s Italian Restaurant

The restaurant itself is small and charming, with a cozy atmosphere perfect for enjoying a slice of pizza. The service was also top-notch – the staff were friendly and attentive, always asking if I needed anything else.

The food was truly amazing – the crust had a nice crunch to it, and the toppings were fresh and generously applied. Not only that, but the pepperoni had an incredible smoky flavor that reminded me of some of my favorite pizzas in Italy!

I would definitely recommend Vic’s Italian Restaurant to anyone who loves pizza. It’s easily one of the best pizzas I’ve ever tasted, not just in Central Jersey but anywhere in the world!

#7 Brooklyn Boys Pizza & Deli

When I arrived at this quaint pizzeria, I was immediately taken aback by how fantastic the interior looked. The walls were adorned with pictures of classic Italian dishes, and it created a warm, inviting atmosphere.

The staff were really friendly and accommodating to my needs, which made me feel right at home. When it came time to order my pizza, they had an extensive menu to choose from. I ended up getting a classic Margherita pie with extra cheese, and let me tell you – it was delicious! The dough was perfectly crispy on the outside while still chewy on the inside, and the toppings were fresh and flavorful.

I also had the chance to try some of their unique topping combinations like their Buffalo Chicken pizza which was out of this world!

Overall, Brooklyn Boys Pizza & Deli stands as one of the best pizza places in Central Jersey with its inventive menu options and cozy atmosphere. This place is definitely worth checking out for anyone looking for delicious artisanal pizza!

#8 Nomad Pizza

I’m thrilled to be able to say that – after all my travels and experiences, Nomad Pizza is now one of my top stops for a slice of pizza perfection.

The first thing I noticed was how fresh the ingredients were – everything from the cheese to the herbs and tomatoes are so flavorful. The crust isn’t like anything you’d find at your average pizza joint – it’s cooked perfectly and has a nice crunch without being overly hard.

The sauces they use are delicious, and they have an extensive list of toppings to choose from so you can really customize your pizza according to your tastes. The staff is super friendly, too – always going out of their way to make sure you get exactly what you want.

And talk about presentation! The pizzas here look like gourmet masterpieces with all the different colors and textures enticingly arranged on top. Even if you’re not hungry, just looking at one of their pies will make your mouth water!

All in all, Nomad Pizza is truly the best pizza in Central Jersey. If anyone ever asks me where they should go for great pizza in this area, I’ll definitely point them towards Nomad Pizza!

If you’re willing to go an extra 5 miles, you can get to 20 more pizza places in Cranford!

#9 De Lorenzo’s Tomato Pies

I arrived at the iconic Trenton eatery with a grumbling stomach and expectations soaring. From the moment I stepped inside, it was clear why De Lorenzo’s has been a local favorite since 1932 – it had a friendly, nostalgic vibe that made me feel right at home.

One look at the menu and I knew I was in for something special: they serve over 20 varieties of unique and inventive pizzas, from the classic Margherita to the gourmet Funghi. With so many choices, my mouth started watering!

Once my order arrived, though, I knew this wasn’t just any pizza. The crust was soft yet crispy with an unmistakable crispness; it practically melted in my mouth. And the hearty tomato sauce was beautifully balanced against the gooey cheese – as if they’d been married in heavenly harmony!

If there’s one thing that stuck out most about De Lorenzo’s Tomato pies, it’s that their pizza is simply delicious. From its flavorful topping selection to its lusciously chewy crust – all of which are lovingly crafted using only the freshest ingredients – this is some of the best pizza I’ve ever had anywhere in Central Jersey!

#10 Giddy’s Pizzeria

My recent visit to Giddy’s was one of the most enjoyable pizza-eating experiences I’ve ever had. The atmosphere was warm and inviting, and the waitstaff was friendly and helpful. As for the pizza itself, it was amazing! The crust was cooked to perfection – crispy on the outside yet soft in the middle. The toppings were fresh, flavorful, and plentiful. Every bite melted in my mouth and made me want more!

To top it all off, Giddy’s offers an extensive selection of craft beers to help wash down your slice. They also have a wide variety of desserts so you can indulge after you’re done with your meal.

Overall, Giddy’s Pizzeria is definitely one of the best places to grab a slice in Central Jersey. If you’re ever in the area, make sure to stop by – you won’t regret it!

#11 Talula’s

The atmosphere is great, the staff is friendly and knowledgeable. The pizza itself was out of this world – so good that I could have stayed for a second slice (or third!). The crust was perfectly thin and crispy, the sauce was sweet and flavorful, and the cheese was rich and creamy.

I’m no stranger to great pizza and I can confidently say that Talula’s compares favorably to my favorite spots in New York City, Rome and Naples. In fact, I would go as far as to say that if you’re looking for top-notch pizza in Central Jersey, look no further than Talula’s!

#12 Rosie’s Pizza

I had the pleasure of visiting this quaint spot a few weeks ago, and can honestly say that it has much to offer. For one, they have some great vegetarian options for those not interested in pepperoni and sausage. And they’re conveniently located right off the highway as a tourist spot- perfect for visitors looking for a convenient place to eat good pizza!

The downside? They don’t deliver. But trust me, it’s worth going there and experiencing the delicious slices in person!

Overall, I give Rosie’s Pizza five stars! It’s definitely one of the best pizza joints I’ve ever visited- not just in Jersey, but anywhere!