Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Chattanooga TN (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Tennessee

Best Pizza in Chattanooga TN (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

193 Views

I’ve been lucky enough to have sampled pizza from all corners of the world and, rest assured, I’m a tough critic. During my recent visit to the Chattanooga area I made sure to sample twelve of the very best pizzerias in town.

What makes a great pizza? Well, for me it’s all about the flavors, textures, and toppings. Let me tell you – I was not disappointed by any of these twelve places!

Throughout the article I’ll be rating each pizza place on a five-star scale so you can get an idea of which ones are worthy of your time and attention. So without further ado, let’s explore the best pizza places in Chattanooga TN!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Tennessee

#1 New York Pizza Company, East Ridge

From the outside, this place looks like your typical pizza joint, but the moment I stepped inside the door I knew I was in for something special. The atmosphere was lively and inviting, with a great selection of tables and chairs to pick from.

I decided to dive right into the signature pizza: the East Ridge Special. This pizza has New York-style dough, layered with savory sausage and pepperoni, covered in melted mozzarella cheese and finished with a generous helping of oregano.

The flavor of this pizza is unbeatable – it’s one of those pizzas that you just can’t stop eating! The perfect balance between sweet and spicy makes it perfect for everyone, no matter their preferred taste.

The service at New York Pizza Company is also top notch. The staff is friendly and attentive, always happy to make suggestions or answer any questions you might have. I had a great experience each time I visited this place and will definitely be back soon!

In conclusion, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Chattanooga TN, look no further than New York Pizza Company!

If you’re willing to go an extra 23 miles, you can get to 19 more pizza places in Cleveland!

#2 Community Pie

I was truly impressed with every bite. The crust had the perfect crunch and flavor, while the ingredients were fresh and top-notch. Plus, their menu offers something for everyone – from classic combinations to pies with a little flair.

Aside from the pizza itself, I found the restaurant’s atmosphere to be warm and inviting. The interior decor is modern yet cozy, and you can expect attentive waitstaff and super quick service.

But that’s not all I love about Community Pie. Every time I visited, I had an opportunity to enjoy live music on the patio! It really added to the experience, complementing each slice like a perfectly paired Italian wine.

If you’re looking for excellent pizza in Chattanooga TN, look no further than Community Pie! This place has something special that makes it stand out among so many other places around town – it truly has everything you could want in a pizza restaurant!

#3 Pizza Bros Northshore

The dough is perfectly cooked and the cheese is just melted to perfection. The sauces are flavorful and the toppings are fresh. But what sets this pizza apart from all the others I’ve tried is that they have something called “PBX”–a secret blend of herbs and spices! It makes their pizza so much better than anything else I’ve tasted before.

The atmosphere of Pizza Bros Northshore is warm and cozy, with a wood-fired oven in the dining area that gives off an amazing aroma. And if you’re not up for eating inside, they also offer a take-out service with generous discounts.

I also love how friendly their staff is. From taking my order to serving my food, they always make sure I’m having a great time.

All in all, Pizza Bros Northshore has become my go-to spot for the best pizza in Chattanooga TN! If you haven’t tried it yet, trust me when I say you won’t be disappointed.

#4 Lupi’s Pizza Pies

The dough is the perfect combination of crisp on the outside and fluffy on the inside. The sauce has just enough flavor to make it savory, yet not overpowering. And let me tell you, their cheese! It’s like a party in your mouth!

Their toppings are fresh, which makes each bite burst with flavor. You can really tell that they care about putting quality ingredients into every pie.

But most importantly, their pizza is good – really good! I mean, it’s just plain delicious.

I’d highly recommend Lupi’s Pizza Pies for anyone looking for some of the best pizza in Chattanooga TN. Whether you’re in the mood for traditional favorites or something more exotic, you won’t be disappointed!

#5 Southside Pizza

When I arrived, I knew I was in the right place. The atmosphere seemed like a dream – there was a buzz of activity as people of all ages chatted and laughed with each other while enjoying their slices.

The menu had some really unique options that I had never seen before – like the ‘wood-fired marshmallow sauce’ pizza! And the staff were incredibly friendly and helpful, ensuring that I got exactly what I wanted without any hassles.

But of course, the main attraction is the pizza – and wow, it didn’t disappoint! The dough was light and fluffy, with just enough crispness on the outside. The sauce had an intense flavor – but not too strong – that complemented all of the toppings nicely. And each topping itself was cooked to perfection: juicy meats, crunchy veggies, melted cheese…it all added up to one of the most delicious pizzas I’ve ever tasted!

In short, Southside Pizza is definitely one of my top choices for best pizza in Chattanooga TN! It’s well worth a visit if you’re looking for a great pizza experience.

#6 Crust Pizza

When I first walked in, the smell of fresh baked pizza greeted me. The atmosphere was inviting and comfortable. I could tell right away that this was a place to take the time to enjoy your meal.

The menu offered a nice selection of toppings and sauces from classic options like pepperoni and Italian sausage to more decadent choices like Jalapenos and artichokes. Whatever kind of pizza you’re in the mood for, Crust Pizza has something for everyone.

But that’s not all! As a food critic, I’m always on the lookout for something special when it comes to pizza. And Crust Pizza did not disappoint. They had something they call “Gourmet Pie” which is an 8-inch gourmet pizza with four large slices composed with premium ingredients like mushrooms, feta cheese, spinach, and roasted peppers.

I sampled one slice of their regular pie as well as one slice of their Gourmet Pie. Both were excellent! The regular pie had just enough tanginess from the tomato sauce and the Gourmet Pie had so much flavor it almost blew my socks off (in a good way!). The crust on both was thin yet crisp – everything you want from great pizza crust!

All in all, Crust Pizza is far and away the best pizza joint in Chattanooga TN. If you’re looking for great tasting pizza with quality ingredients at an affordable price then look no further than Crust Pizza!

#7 Mr. T’s Pizza & Ice Cream

The crust was thin and fluffy, while the tomato sauce just the right amount of sweetness. The toppings were fresh and flavorful; I couldn’t believe how delicious it was!

But as if that wasn’t enough, Mr. T’s also has an incredible selection of ice cream. They offer classics like chocolate and vanilla, as well as more unique flavors such as mango and lime sorbet.

The customer service was top notch too; when I asked for extra cheese on my pizza they were more than happy to accommodate me. The staff at Mr. T’s truly go above and beyond to make sure you have a great experience!

If you’re ever in Chattanooga, don’t hesitate to check out Mr. T’s Pizza & Ice Cream – you won’t be disappointed!

#8 Pizzeria Cortile

The atmosphere of the restaurant is perfect for a night out with friends, and they even serve alcohol! Plus, they have some vegetarian options – great news for those looking to go lighter.

The food was delicious and definitely worth the trip. They offer thin-crust, thick-crust, and everything in between – so everyone can find something to love. Plus, there’s a wide variety of toppings to choose from.

On top of all this, Pizzeria Cortile even offers dessert – which is always a nice addition to a good meal.

However, I must note that this place does not offer delivery; you’ll need to come on in if you want to enjoy the fare for yourself.

All in all, I highly recommend Pizzeria Cortile for anyone looking for the best pizza in Chattanooga TN!

If you’re willing to go an extra 52 miles, you can get to 8 more pizza places in Blue Ridge!

#9 FIAMMA pizza company

I stopped at this place after hearing some friends raving about it, and I can see why they were so positive. The pizza was cooked to perfection – the dough was moist, the ingredients fresh and flavorful, and the toppings plentiful.

The atmosphere at FIAMMA pizza company is great too. They have a really fun decor, with cool murals on the walls and retro arcade games in the corner. It’s clear that they take pride in their space, which makes for a much more enjoyable experience.

But what truly set this place aside from others I’ve tried is their unique seasonal pizza flavors. From wild mushroom truffle to smoked salmon pesto, each pie has something unique and special about it that keeps me coming back for more.

Overall, FIAMMA pizza company provides an exceptional dining experience that is sure to please even the most discerning of foodies like myself! Their pizzas are mouth-wateringly delicious and made with care – you can definitely tell when somebody puts love into their craft! If you find yourself in Chattanooga TN looking for some of the best pizza around, look no further than FIAMMA pizza company.

#10 Chattanooga Pizza Co (formerly Home Slice Pizza)

The atmosphere here is fantastic – a cozy, welcoming spot that feels like home. The decorations around the restaurant make it feel like you’re stepping into an Italian village. The staff are friendly and always willing to help with whatever you need.

The pizzas themselves are out of this world! The crust is perfectly baked, not too thick or too thin, and packed full of flavor. The toppings they use are all fresh and tasty, and they really shine when put together on one of their delicious creations. I recommend the Mediterranean pizza; it’s packed with olives, feta cheese, zesty tomatoes, artichoke hearts and more.

Plus, Chattanooga Pizza Co offers delivery and takeout so you can enjoy the best pizza in Chattanooga TN from anywhere! So if you’re ever craving some delicious pizza (who isn’t?), head over to Chattanooga Pizza Co for a slice of Italy that won’t disappoint!

#11 Goodfellas Pizzeria

The atmosphere of the place is great. Not only do they offer a variety of delicious food and drinks, but they also offer hard liquor! The waitress was so helpful and friendly, it was like she was part of the family.

I tried their signature pizza and it did not disappoint. The doughy crust and gooey cheese were cooked to perfection and the sauce had just the right amount of flavor. It quickly became my favorite slice!

I also tried their desserts which were so yummy that I had no choice but to save room for more! They had an especially delicious espresso-flavored cannoli that made me forget all about needing dinner later that night!

The only downside I experienced in my visit to Goodfellas Pizzeria was that they don’t offer delivery. But then again, why would one need delivery when visiting this tourist haven? This place has become a must-visit spot for anyone looking for the best pizza in Chattanooga TN!

#12 Mellow Mushroom Chattanooga

The moment I stepped in, I was quickly impressed by the atmosphere. It had a cool vibe that made me feel like I was right at home. The walls were decorated with funky artwork and the staff was very friendly.

I sampled several styles of pizza, ranging from classic thin crust to extra-large deep dish. Every slice was cooked to absolute perfection and tasted delicious! The combination of flavors was just perfect — it’s not too greasy, but still had plenty of flavor. They also offer vegan options for those with dietary restrictions, which is always appreciated.

Overall, Mellow Mushroom Chattanooga has earned my stamp of approval as one of the best pizza places in Chattanooga TN! Next time you’re looking for some great pizza, head over to Mellow Mushroom and experience what real pizza tastes like!

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Crust Pizza

First off, let me start by saying that this place knows how to keep its customers happy with a side of humor. From the moment I walked in, I was greeted by a sign that said, Pizza: the real reason you’re still friends with your ex. Brilliant!

One of the immediate perks of Crust Pizza is the fact that they serve alcohol. This is a game-changer, my friends. Nothing pairs better with a mouthwatering pizza slice than a cold brewski. Plus, they offer some vegetarian options which is great for those non-meat loving pals tagging along.

And dessert? Oh boy, don’t get me started! The Nutella pizza is the stuff dreams are made of. A warm, gooey, chocolate-filled crust that will have you questioning your life choices. Trust me, save some room for this sweet masterpiece.

Now, not only is Crust Pizza a culinary delight, but it’s also a great tourist spot. The place is buzzing with out-of-towners eager to indulge in a slice of heaven. And if you’re a sports lover like me, this is the place to be. The giant TVs scattered throughout the restaurant ensure you won’t miss a single moment of the game.

But, fair warning, Crust Pizza doesn’t accept reservations. So if you’re a planner like me, be prepared to take a gamble. However, I promise you the pizza is worth the wait. So grab a drink, enjoy the lively atmosphere, and prepare for a thin crust pizza experience like no other.