Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Melbourne FL (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Florida

Best Pizza in Melbourne FL (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

200 Views

After trying out 12 different pizza places in the area, I’m ready to share my findings. If you’re wondering where you can find the best pizza in Melbourne FL, read on and find out what I have to say!

I was quite impressed with what this city had to offer; there’s a good selection of classic pizzas as well as some unique creations that will make your mouth water. In my experience, the locals sure know how to make a delicious pizza.

So let me take you on a pizza eating journey around Melbourne FL, and let’s see if we can find the absolute best pizza!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Florida

#1 Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza Melbourne

From the moment I set foot in the restaurant, I could tell that this place was something special. The ambiance was upbeat and casual, with an energetic staff eager to make sure my experience was nothing short of extraordinary.

But then it came time to order: that’s when my mouth started salivating! The menu offerings were abundant and creative, from traditional Neapolitan-style pizzas to more inventive options like Buffalo Chicken and Pulled Pork.

I ultimately decided on their signature Mister O1 pizza, topped with fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers, sun-dried tomatoes, pepperoni and mushrooms. The blend of flavors united in perfect harmony as I took my first bite – it truly is one of the best pizzas I’ve had in Melbourne!

The crust was cooked to perfection – thin yet sturdy enough to hold all the toppings in place. And the handmade sauces served on the side added even more deliciousness and texture.

In short, Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza Melbourne has become my top pick for the best pizza in Melbourne FL! If you’re up for a great dining experience coupled with some seriously good pizza, this is the place to be!

If you’re willing to go an extra 18 miles, you can get to 14 more pizza places in Sebastian!

#2 Manny’s Cucina Napoletana

I must admit, I was a bit skeptical when I first arrived at Manny’s. The interior was cozy and quaint, but nothing terribly flashy. That all changed when I took my first bite – the crust was perfectly cooked and wonderfully flavorful!

The toppings were also truly amazing. Every pizza was made with fresh ingredients that complemented each other perfectly. Whether it was a margherita or a pepperoni, every bite tantalized my taste buds in just the right way.

The service at Manny’s Cucina Napoletana is also top-notch. The waitstaff is friendly and knowledgeable, and they always delivered our pizzas in record time!

Overall, I’d highly recommend Manny’s Cucina Napoletana to anyone looking for delicious pizza in Melbourne FL. It truly is some of the best pizza I’ve had – anywhere!

#3 Slices Pizza & Italian Kitchen

When I arrived at the restaurant, I was charmed by the cozy atmosphere and delicious aromas. I could barely contain my excitement for what was about to come!

The menu offered a wide range of pizzas, pastas, and deserts – all made with fresh ingredients. So it didn’t take me long to order the best of them all: their classic margherita pizza.

As soon as it arrived at my table I took a deep breath and inhaled its tantalizing scent. The dough was perfectly cooked and had just the right amount of crunchiness. The tomatoes were bright red, juicy, and oh-so-flavorful – like if they were just picked from the garden. And to top it off, the cheese melted in my mouth like butter making every bite unbelievably delicious!

I can confidently say that Slices Pizza & Italian Kitchen serves up some of the best pizza in Melbourne FL. In fact, it’s so good that after one slice I wanted more (but refrained myself due to food critic standards). Regardless, this restaurant gets an A+ rating from me!

#4 Doghouse Pizza-Melbourne

The atmosphere at Doghouse Pizza-Melbourne is amazing. It feels like a classic pizza joint with a modern twist. The seating is comfortable, the walls have fun quotes and pictures, and the music playing in the background sets the perfect vibe.

But what really sets Doghouse Pizza-Melbourne apart from other pizza places is their unique and delicious pizzas. I particularly enjoyed their signature Deep Catcher – it was full of flavor, with a crunchy crust and gooey cheese. Their non-traditional options like the Mac Daddy were equally delicious, if not even better!

To top it all off, the staff at Doghouse Pizza-Melbourne are some of the friendliest people I’ve ever encountered. They make you feel welcome and more than happy to answer questions or chat about different topping options.

So if you’re looking for great pizza in Melbourne FL, look no further thank Doghouse Pizza-Melbourne! It’s my firm opinion that they make some of the best pizzas around!

#5 Genna Pizza Company

The crust was perfectly thin, crisp and slightly flavored with herbs. The sauce was tangy but not overwhelming and the cheese was ooey-gooey delicious.

I had the pleasure of trying many of their specialty pizzas and they did not disappoint. From the Thai-style pizza with a creamy peanut sauce to their classic Margherita pizza, I couldn’t decide which one tasted better. Even their veggie pizza made me forget there were no meat toppings!

At Genna Pizza Company, you can be assured that you will get your money’s worth: each pie is loaded with topping ingredients. And when it comes to presentation, it’s definitely Instagrammable-worthy!

All in all, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Melbourne FL, Genna Pizza Company is definitely worth a visit. You won’t regret it!

#6 N.Y. Pizza Spot

I’m not exaggerating when I say that this place truly does have some of the best pizza I’ve ever tasted. The crust was perfectly crunchy and not too thick, the sauce was super flavorful, and the cheese was just melted to perfection.

What really blew me away though were their toppings. From bacon to pepperoni to peppers and onions, they had it all! And each topping tasted fresh and delicious.

To top it all off (pun intended), the staff at N.Y. Pizza Spot were delightful in every way. They greeted us with a smile upon entering, gave us helpful suggestions for our order, and answered our questions about the ingredients without hesitation. Not only that, the atmosphere was cozy and relaxing – perfect for a night out with friends or family.

Overall, I would highly recommend N.Y. Pizza Spot as one of the best pizza places in Melbourne FL! If you’re looking for a great slice of pie or an entire pizza, this is definitely the place to go!

#7 Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza

I had the pleasure of paying a visit to Papa Murphy’s recently, and I must say, their selection is impressive. They have a wide variety of pizzas that can accommodate any dietary preferences, including vegetarian options.

The highlight of my experience was the pizza itself! The crust was perfectly cooked and fluffy, with just enough crunch and flavor. The sauce was rich and flavorful, and the toppings were plentiful. Each bite was filled with cheesy deliciousness.

The only downside I found was that they don’t offer delivery – you have to go in-store or order online for pick-up. But honestly, it was totally worth it! This pizza is so good that it’s worth making an effort to get your hands on it.

If you’re looking for great pizza in Melbourne Florida, then look no further – Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza has got you covered!

#8 The Pizza Place MLB

The restaurant has a cozy atmosphere, with the smells of their delicious pizzas wafting through the air. They offer different types of pizza, like classic cheese and pepperoni, as well as some unique variations such as the Hawaiian Delight or the Spicy Fish Fry.

The crust is perfectly crispy and light, while still being able to hold all of its toppings without getting soggy. It’s definitely not like those cardboard-style crusts you get from some places!

The toppings are always fresh and flavorful, ranging from typical ingredients like onions and bell peppers to interesting choices like pineapple or jalapeno peppers. Plus, they offer vegan options for those who don’t eat animal products!

The prices are also reasonable for what you get — great pizza at an affordable cost. And let me tell you, it’s worth every penny!

In short: If you’re ever in the area looking for a good slice of pizza, The Pizza Place MLB should be your first stop. I’m pretty sure it’s the best pizza in Melbourne FL!

If you’re willing to go an extra 19 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Melbourne!

#9 Your Pie Pizza

As soon as I entered the restaurant, I was struck by the inviting atmosphere. The décor was modern and cozy, and the staff were exceptionally friendly.

The menu definitely impressed me: they had so many creative topping combinations! From BBQ chicken to fig and prosciutto pizza–I could tell that these pies were made with love.

When my pizza arrived, I was blown away! The crust was perfectly cooked, the cheese was melty and gooey, and the toppings were fresh and flavorful. I could tell that this pizza was made with high-quality ingredients — it certainly didn’t taste like anything I’d tasted before.

In conclusion, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Melbourne FL then Your Pie Pizza is definitely worth a visit!

#10 Lombardis New York Pizza

The first time I stopped into this pizza joint, I was a bit skeptical – after all, there’s no way that the pizza in Melbourne FL could compare to what I’d had in Italy and New York City. But wow, was I ever wrong!

The crust is perfectly light and thin, with a hint of garlic. The sauce is flavorful and thick without being too heavy or overpowering. On top of all that, they aren’t scared to pile on the toppings – pepperoni and sausage are generous and plentiful!

I’m also quite impressed with their selection of specialty pizzas – from vegan pizza to buffalo chicken pies! There’s something for everyone at Lombardi’s New York Pizza.

All in all, Lombardi’s New York Pizza has some of the best pizza in Melbourne FL, hands down! I would highly recommend it to anyone looking for an unforgettable culinary experience.

#11 Leaning Tower of Pizza

When I arrived at the restaurant, I was surprised by how quaint and cozy it was. The interior had a rustic vibe complete with brick walls and indirect lighting – giving the place an old-world charm that’s hard to replicate.

The pizza itself was nothing short of incredible. The crust was light and crispy – not too thick like most places tend to do it. The sauce had a nice balance between sweet and savory, while the cheese melted perfectly on top of everything else. But what really made this pizza stand out were the toppings! They were so fresh and vibrant in flavor – you could taste each ingredient individually but also as a whole when it all came together in your mouth.

I’m always hesitant to call something “the best”, but after my visit to Leaning Tower of Pizza, I think it’s safe for me to say that this is one of the best pizzas I have tasted anywhere in the world! If you’re ever in Melbourne FL, make sure to check it out for yourself – you won’t be disappointed!

#12 Fm Pizza Oven

It’s no secret that the locals love Fm Pizza Oven, and after one bite of their signature pizza, I could understand why. It was a heavenly combination of just the right amount of cheese, sauce and dough. The flavor was out of this world!

The service at Fm Pizza Oven is top notch as well. Our server was friendly and attentive to all our needs. They even accommodated our large group with ease.

Overall, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Melbourne FL, look no further than Fm Pizza Oven! Highly recommended