Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Middlesex County NJ (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in New Jersey

Best Pizza in Middlesex County NJ (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

280 Views

During my travels, I’ve eaten some of the best pizza in the world – from Rome to Naples. But Middlesex County NJ promised something special. So I decided to embark on a quest – tasting and rating 12 pizzerias throughout the county!

I’m ready to share my findings with all you pizza lovers out there. From downtown hot spots to chain restaurants, this article will guide you to the best places for pizza in Middlesex County NJ in a humorous and lighthearted way. Let’s get started!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New Jersey

#1 Jozanna’s

From the moment I stepped inside, it was evident that Jozanna’s takes great pride in their pizza. The oven is made of Italian brick—you can just see and smell the authenticity! The staff was friendly and knowledgeable, and when I asked about the ingredients going into each pizza, they had all the answers.

The pizzas themselves were delicious—every bite was packed with flavor. The crust was crispy and light, and the toppings were fresh and perfectly balanced. The sauce had a unique taste to it that I couldn’t quite put my finger on, but it definitely added something special to each slice.

Overall, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Middlesex County NJ, Jozanna’s should be your destination of choice. With its authentic atmosphere and flavorful pizzas, there is something for everyone here!

If you’re willing to go an extra 4 miles, you can get to 23 more pizza places in Hillsborough Township!

#2 Tino’s Artisan Pizza Co.

Upon walking into Tino’s, I was immediately greeted by a friendly staff who wanted to make sure I felt like I was eating pizza as if I were in Italy. From the authentic Italian décor to the delicious smells of fresh dough and sauce emanating through the restaurant, I couldn’t help but be transported to another country!

The pizza itself is some of the best I’ve had. Tino only uses fresh ingredients, which gives their pizzas that extra special something that you just don’t get from other places. The mozzarella melts in your mouth and their house-made sauces are simply divine. They also offer a wide array of specialty pies with toppings like gorgonzola and habanero peppers, which makes for an interesting combination!

I’d highly recommend Tino’s Artisan Pizza Co. for anyone looking for delicious pizza in Middlesex County NJ. It’s truly one of the best pizzas you’ll ever have! Pass up this place at your own risk!

#3 Rome Pizza

I have to admit, I came in a bit skeptical. The outside of the restaurant didn’t look like much, and I was worried about what I’d find inside. But once I opened the door, the smell of freshly made pizza hit me like a wave, and all doubts vanished from my mind!

The staff was friendly and accommodating—they even allowed me to try some samples of their amazing pizza! Every single slice was filled with delicious toppings and had just the right amount of cheese. It was clear they put a lot of love into each pie they make.

But it wasn’t until I got my own personal pizza that I knew Rome Pizza was something special. The crust was perfectly crispy on the outside while still being surprisingly light and airy on the inside. And every bite was filled with delicious flavors that danced across my taste buds—it definitely tasted like one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had!

All in all, Rome Pizza deserves its reputation as one of the best pizzas in Middlesex County NJ for sure… If you’re ever in town and looking for a great place to get a slice (or two), this is definitely the place to go!

#4 Brooklyn Boys Pizza & Deli

I recently had the pleasure of visiting this gem of a restaurant and I must say, it was an experience to remember. You can just tell that the folks at Brooklyn Boys make sure everything is perfect when they’re crafting their pizza pies.

The atmosphere was inviting and friendly, with the sound of classic Italian music playing in the background. The smell of garlic and basil filled in the air, making my mouth water!

Once my order arrived, I couldn’t contain my excitement. The blend of flavors that make up their signature Brooklyn-style pizza was amazing – a perfectly balanced mix of olives, meats, cheese, garlic and herbs all melding together perfectly on top of a delicious crust. It’s no wonder why this pizza is so popular!

One thing I especially liked about Brooklyn Boys Pizza & Deli is that they don’t take shortcuts; every ingredient is fresh and carefully selected to ensure quality. The end result? A flavorful, perfectly cooked pizza – one that will have you coming back for more!

If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Middlesex County NJ, look no further than Brooklyn Boys Pizza & Deli. You won’t be disappointed!

#5 Giddy’s Pizzeria

The pizza is delicious – the toppings are fresh, the crust is crisp and flavorful and the sauce is just the right amount of tangy. They have a great selection of topping options for you to choose from, so whether you’re looking for something classic or something more creative, Giddy’s Pizzeria has got you covered!

But that’s not all – the customer service here is top-notch too. The staff are friendly, helpful and always willing to make sure your pizza experience is a pleasant one. That includes speedy delivery and friendly attitudes when ordering in-house. I’ve never been disappointed!

Overall, Giddy’s pizzeria serves up some of the best pizzas in Middlesex County NJ – and does it with a smile! Highly recommended for any lover of great pizza. You won’t regret it!

#6 Mr Assante Pizza

The atmosphere is so inviting, with a colorful mural of pizza art on the wall and a friendly staff that greeted me upon my arrival.

I ordered their special – a pepperoni and jalapeno pizza, and it was amazing! The crust was perfectly cooked – crunchy on the outside, but chewy on the inside. The sauce was flavorful, with just the right amount of spice. And the toppings were generous – plenty of pepperoni and jalapenos to give it some kick.

The service at Mr Assante Pizza was great too – my server knew exactly when to leave me alone to enjoy my pizza and when to check back in to see if I needed more drinks or another slice.

Overall, Mr Assante Pizza is easily one of the best pizzas I’ve had in Middlesex County NJ! If you’re ever in town looking for a fantastic pizza experience, this is definitely the place to be!

#7 Villa Laura Restaurant

When I first walked into the restaurant, I was immediately impressed with the cozy atmosphere. The decor is classic Italian and the warm colors make it feel like you’re walking into a Tuscan villa.

The best part of course is the pizza. As soon as they brought out my pizza, I knew I was in for a treat. The crust was crunchy and chewy, with just enough salt and herbs to make me salivate. Topping it off were generous portions of freshly cooked pepperoni and their secret-recipe marinara sauce that added an extra layer of flavor that elevated it above other pizzas in the area.

I’ve had pizza all over the world, but Villa Laura Restaurant’s has to be one of my favorites. It’s not only delicious, but it’s also affordable which makes it a great option for anyone looking for amazing pizza without breaking the bank!

If you’re ever in Middlesex County NJ, don’t miss out on what I would consider to be some of the best pizza around – go visit Villa Laura Restaurant!

#8 Round Pie Pizza Company

The first thing I noticed when I walked in was the atmosphere. The interior had a warm, inviting vibe that made me feel right at home. The staff was also super friendly and accommodating, making sure I felt comfortable while I waited for my pizza to arrive.

The menu itself was quite expansive, with options ranging from classic Margherita pies to a delicious White Pizza with Shrimp and Garlic oil. After much deliberation, I decided to order the Butcher’s Blend Pizza which came topped with sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms and onions.

When the pizza arrived, my taste buds were immediately overwhelmed by its deliciousness! From the perfect amount of tangy sauce on top of the perfectly-cooked crust to all of the delightful toppings on top – this pizza had it all! All throughout my meal I couldn’t help but think how lucky I am to have stumbled upon this little gem in Middlesex County NJ!

In short, Round Pie Pizza Company has some of the best pizza in Middlesex County NJ and is definitely worth checking out if you’re ever in town!

If you’re willing to go an extra 4 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Bridgewater Township!

#9 Strawberry’s Pub & Pizza

On my first visit, I was welcomed into the cozy atmosphere by a friendly staff. One of them immediately recommended their specialty pizza – the “BBQ Poblanos”. Now, trust me when I say that I’m no amateur when it comes to pizza. But this pizza absolutely blew my mind! It was perfection. Perfectly cooked crust and juicy barbecue sauce paired with the perfect amount of melted cheese topped off with poblano peppers – the flavors were out of this world!

Of course, if you’re looking for something different you won’t be disappointed either. The menu has an array of creative pizzas like “The Gardeners Delight” (tomato, spinach, mushroom) and “The Greeko” (feta, olives, garlic). They also serve some phenomenal wings and sandwiches. Everything is made fresh-to-order and all ingredients are locally sourced whenever possible.

I would highly recommend Strawberry’s Pub & Pizza to anyone looking for the best pizza in Middlesex County NJ!

#10 Stan’s Chitch’s Cafe

On my last visit to Stan’s Chitch’s Cafe, I was amazed by the atmosphere. The smell of the freshly made dough mixed with the aroma of their delicious pizza had me mesmerized! Not to mention that the staff is friendly and accommodating, which made for a great dining experience.

One of my favorite things about Stan’s Chitch’s Cafe is that they serve alcohol! Not only do they have beers on tap, but they also have a top-shelf liquor selection, which really sets them apart from other pizza restaurants in Middlesex County NJ.

The only downside to eating at Stan’s Chitch’s Cafe is that they don’t offer delivery service – you have to eat there in person or take your order with you. But trust me, it’s worth it. The pizza at Stan’s Chitch’s Cafe is some of the best I’ve ever tasted – and since I’ve visited countless places around the world – that means something!

#11 Ferraro’s Pizzeria & Pub

I had the chance to sample the margherita pizza and it was absolutely amazing. The crust was thin and crispy, the sauce was full of flavors and herbs, and the cheese was perfectly melted and gooey. Despite being thin, this slice of heaven held up to every bite!

The atmosphere at Ferraro’s is great as well! It has a cozy pub feel and a relaxed vibe that I can imagine would be perfect for spending an evening with friends. The staff were welcoming, friendly, and efficient – everything you’d want from a pizzeria.

If there’s one thing I’ve learned after tasting pizzas all across the world is that not all pizza places are created equal. Ferraro’s Pizzeria & Pub stands out among its competitors – they have some of the best pizza in Middlesex County NJ! So don’t miss out on your chance to try it – you won’t be disappointed!

#12 Francesco’s Pizzeria & Restaurant

I stopped by the restaurant last week and knew I was in for a treat right away. The comfortable, inviting atmosphere had me relaxed from the start. But then the pizza came out – wow! The thin, crunchy crust with savory tomato sauce was like nothing I’d ever tasted before! Their specialty pizza is even better – packed full of fresh vegetables and covered in melted cheese that’s just begging to be devoured. I don’t think I’ve had a pizza this good since my travels in Italy!

The staff were incredibly friendly and were more than happy to answer any questions we had about their menu. Plus, they have some fantastic wines and beers on offer too!

If you’re ever in Middlesex County NJ, do yourself a favor and check out Francesco’s Pizzeria & Restaurant – you won’t regret it!