Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Middletown NY (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in New York

Best Pizza in Middletown NY (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

251 Views

I’m no stranger to pizza; I’ve had some of the best all around the world. But, after trying 12 different spots in this small town, I’m confident that I have found the absolute best pizzas in Middletown.

Prepare yourself for a hilarious and lighthearted journey through some delicious options. I’m here to serve up only the finest toppings and take you through some real cheesy stories!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New York

#1 Bella Lena’s

The first thing that impressed me about this place was the atmosphere. It’s like stepping into an Italian pizzeria, with their red and white checkered tablecloths and vintage posters adorning the walls.

The second thing that blew me away were the tasty pies coming out of their ovens! They offer a variety of different pies from traditional Neapolitan-style to thick and crispy Sicilian-style. I opted for one of each and have to say they both hit all the right notes. The crust was perfectly charred with just the right amount of chewiness, while the toppings were bursting with flavors.

The staff at Bella Lena’s are also top notch. From our hostess who greeted us warmly to our server who made sure we had everything we needed, it’s clear why Bella Lena’s has such loyal customers.

All in all, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Middletown NY, then you have to try Bella Lena’s!

If you’re willing to go an extra 21 miles, you can get to 25 more pizza places in Newburgh!

#2 Camila’s Pizzeria & Restaurant

I was pleased to find that their pizza had a flavor unlike any other I’ve tried. The tomato sauce tasted so fresh and the cheese complimented it perfectly – not too greasy, but still just cheesy enough! And the crust – now that was something special! It had the perfect crunch and texture, making the overall experience of eating the pizza top-notch.

The atmosphere of Camila’s Pizzeria & Restaurant is also worth noting. From the moment I stepped through the door, I felt like I was in Italy! The decor is beautiful, with cozy booths along the walls and plenty of seating for groups. Additionally, their staff were incredibly friendly and helpful when it came to recommending certain pizzas.

If you’re looking for great pizza in Middletown NY, check out Camila’s Pizzeria & Restaurant. It’s without a doubt one of my favorite pizza places on earth!

#3 Cuginos

The first thing that strikes you as soon as you walk in is the wonderful smell of freshly baked pizza. The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, with a well-stocked bar that serves up some delicious drinks. The waitstaff are incredibly friendly and knowledgeable about the menu, so ordering your meal will be a breeze!

Once the main event arrives – the pizza – it’s clear why this establishment has been around for so long. Every slice is cooked to perfection, with enough cheese and sauce to make a real difference without overpowering the flavor of other ingredients. The crust is soft yet crunchy in all the right places, while still managing to maintain its integrity throughout eating.

In truth, I’ve probably been to better pizzerias elsewhere in the world, but Cuginos still stands out amongst its Midtown competition as one of the best places for pizza. If you find yourself in Middletown looking for quality pizza, don’t miss out on this place!

#4 Pellegrino & Son’s Pizzeria

As soon as I walked into the restaurant, I knew that this was a place where good things were happening. The smell of the wood-fired oven combined with the warm atmosphere transported me to Italy, which is no small feat! Even more impressive was their selection of fresh ingredients and toppings – they definitely put some love and thought into their offerings.

The pizza itself was an absolute delight. The crust was paper thin but still held up against all the beautiful toppings that were piled atop it. All my favorite Italian flavors were present – from sausage and peppers to mushrooms, olives, and garlic. It was cooked perfectly in the wood-fired ovens adding an amazing flavor that can only come from this kind of cooking.

The staff were also incredibly friendly and helpful, helping me pick out just the right combination for my taste preferences. They went above and beyond not just with their service but with their hospitality as well; it felt like eating pizza with family!

All in all, Pellegrino & Son’s Pizzeria definitely deserves its place among the best pizzas in Middletown NY. For anyone looking to enjoy a truly delicious Italian experience, this is your spot!

#5 Cosimos Brick Oven

The restaurant itself is a charming little spot with an old-world vibe. I felt like I was stepping back in time as soon as I walked in. The staff were all extremely friendly and accommodating, which made my experience even better.

Now, let’s get to the pizza! As soon as it came out of the oven, it smelled delicious and had a perfect golden brown crust. The toppings were fresh and flavorful, not to mention beautifully presented. Everything about it was on point – from the crunchy crust to the melted cheese – it was truly one of the best pizza pies I’ve had in years!

I also ordered some other dishes that knocked my socks off. The chicken parmesan was cooked to perfection, and their lasagna had the perfect balance of flavor between each layer.

Overall, if you’re looking for amazing pizza in Middletown NY, then look no further than Cosimos Brick Oven! They definitely have some of the best pizza around and will not disappoint!

#6 Alfonso’s

I was immediately struck by the sheer size of their pies; these are not your typical small slices! Their jumbo slices are definitely worth the trip. After placing my order, I waited eagerly for my pizza to arrive. And boy was it worth the wait. The combination of fresh ingredients and a perfectly crisp crust made this pizza a real treat.

The sauce had just the right amount of spice, and the cheese melted in my mouth. The vegetables were cooked to perfection and the toppings were plentiful! Even better, they offer different types of pie (such as gluten-free or vegan options), so everyone can enjoy Alfonso’s deliciousness.

All in all, I’d highly recommend any pizza lover in Middletown to visit Alfonso’s for true Italian-style goodness. It’s easily one of the best pizzas in town!

#7 Brother Bruno’s Pizzeria Middletown

The first thing I noticed when I stepped in the door was the delicious waft of dough and cheese that made my mouth water. I knew immediately that this place had to be good.

The staff were friendly and attentive, which was the perfect way to kick off my experience. They suggested I try their signature Bronx Bomber Supreme – a classic combination of pepperoni, sausage, onions, peppers, and mushrooms – and it did not disappoint! The pizza had a wonderfully chewy crust with just the right crunch at the edges. The sauce was rich and flavorful, while the toppings balanced perfectly with each other.

Overall, Brother Bruno’s Pizzeria Middletown lived up to its reputation as some of the best pizza in Middletown NY! From its welcoming atmosphere to its delicious food, this is definitely a place I’ll be coming back to again soon – after all, a man can only travel so far before he needs his pizza fix!

If you’re willing to go an extra 23 miles, you can get to 11 more pizza places in Beacon!

#8 Caputo’s Pizza

From the moment I walked in, I could tell I was in for a treat. The smell of freshly made dough and melted cheese was enough to make my mouth water. The atmosphere was cozy, with a vinyl booth to one side and wooden tables to the other – perfect for a Tuesday night dinner!

Once I ordered, I realized that Caputo’s Pizza doesn’t skimp on quality ingredients. You can tell the sauce is homemade, and the toppings are all freshly prepared. As for the pizza itself…it was delicious! The crust had just the right amount of crunch, and the cheese was flavorful without overpowering everything else.

Overall, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Middletown NY, look no further than Caputo’s Pizza! It may be small, but it has big flavor!

#9 Colandrea Pizza King

It’s hard to find authentic Italian pizzas in the heart of America, but Colandrea Pizza King has nailed it. Their crust is perfectly thin and crispy, with a delicious flavour that only comes from an old-fashioned wood burning oven. I also love their traditional toppings – because there’s nothing better than a classic pepperoni pizza!

My favourite part about Colandrea Pizza King though? They make all their dough fresh every day. That means you get the best ingredients for maximum flavour! Plus, they have a range of different toppings and sauces, so you can try something new every time you visit.

I’ve tried pizza everywhere from Rome to New York City and I can confidently say that Colandrea Pizza King serves up some of the tastiest pies around! If you’re ever in Middletown NY looking for the best pizza around, look no further – this place is definitely worth a visit!

#10 Pizza E Birra

From the moment I entered the restaurant, I was amazed by the welcoming atmosphere. The staff were friendly and helpful, answering all my questions and ensuring that my experience was nothing short of awesome.

As for the food, I can honestly say that it blew me away! From thin to thick crusts and an array of delicious toppings, Pizza E Birra has something for everyone. They also have a great vegan option which caters to those with dietary restrictions.

The pizza itself was cooked to perfection: crispy on the edges but soft and chewy in the middle. The toppings were fresh and flavorful, making this the perfect pie for any pizza lover! And to top it off, the prices are very reasonable, making it easy to indulge without breaking the bank.

If you’re looking for some truly delicious pizza in Middletown NY then look no further than Pizza E Birra! My stomach is still full from eating there so if that’s not a sign of satisfaction, I don’t know what is!

#11 Carlos’ Pizzeria and Bar

On my visit to Carlos’ Pizzeria and Bar, I sampled the pepperoni pizza – hands down one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had! The crust was perfectly crispy with bits of tasty charred goodness around the edges. The toppings were plentiful and full of flavor. Plus, the cheese was stringy and delicious.

Beyond their fantastic pizza, I also enjoyed the homemade sauce that accompanies every slice. It had a light hint of garlic and herbs which really added a flavorful kick to each bite.

When it came time for dessert, I went for the cheesecake pizza – talk about an explosion of flavor! The pastry base was warm and buttery, while the cream cheese topping was creamy with just enough sweetness.

All in all, Carlos’ Pizzeria and Bar served up some of the best pizza in Middletown NY! If you’re looking for a tasty night out with friends or family, then this is definitely the place for you.

#12 Franco Di Roma

The first thing I noticed as I walked up to the restaurant was the pleasant aroma wafting from the oven. The wood-fired smell reminded me of some of the best pizzerias in Italy. Upon entering, I was met with a warm welcome from the staff. They quickly showed me to my table and brought out a warm basket of freshly-baked focaccia bread.

I decided to go for one of their signature pizzas, which came with a thin crust and just enough cheese and toppings. The pizza was cooked perfectly – the crust was crispy on the outside, yet soft on the inside, making for an enjoyable bite every time. And when it comes to flavor, Franco Di Roma’s pizza really stands out! Every bite packed a punch of deliciousness that made this pizza stand out from any other pizza I’ve tried over my travels!

Overall, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Middletown NY, make sure you stop at Franco Di Roma – you won’t be disappointed!

Best Wood Fired Pizza – Pizza Star

Let me start by saying that Pizza Star offers the perfect balance for pizza enthusiasts like me who have a mix of carnivorous and herbivorous friends. With its array of vegetarian options, even my vegan friend was able to munch on a delicious Margherita pizza while the rest of us devoured meaty masterpieces.

But let’s get to the main attraction – their wood fired pizza. Oh, baby, that crust! It’s crispy yet chewy, perfectly charred with that smoky flavor that can transport you straight to Naples. I swear, if I close my eyes while taking a bite, I can almost hear the gondolas floating down the canals.

Now, let’s talk dessert. Pizza Star knows how to satisfy a sweet tooth. Their Nutella calzone is like a heavenly gift from the pizza gods themselves. Picture warm, melted Nutella nestled inside a fluffy pizza dough pocket, sprinkled with powdered sugar. Have mercy!

But here’s the catch – Pizza Star doesn’t accept reservations. Now, this may not be an issue for the spontaneous types, but for those of us who like to plan our pizza feasts in advance, it can be a real bummer. I mean, who wants to risk their chance of getting a slice of their mouthwatering wood fired magic?

Nevertheless, if you’re willing to brave the no-reservations policy and embrace the unpredictability, Pizza Star is an absolute must-visit for anyone seeking the best wood fired pizza in middletown. Trust me, your taste buds will thank you.