Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Midtown Manhattan (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in New York

Best Pizza in Midtown Manhattan (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

2126 Views

I’m here to tell you all about the best pizza in this bustling area, although of course finding the best pizza is a matter of personal preference. After a thorough review of 12 different spots, I can confidently declare which pies I enjoyed most!

My hope is that my humorous and lighthearted take on this quest for deliciousness will inspire you to try them for yourself; Midtown has something for everyone so who knows what pizza-related surprises await. Here goes nothing!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New York

#1 Carnegie Pizza

The staff was friendly, the atmosphere was inviting, and the pizza was amazing. The crust had a perfect crunch when I bit into it, and the toppings were fresh and flavorful. Every slice of pizza melted in my mouth!

I especially loved their signature Carnegie Pizza – a classic Italian style with mozzarella cheese, pepperoni, and red peppers. The flavor combination went perfectly together and complemented each slice perfectly.

At first glance, you might think Carnegie Pizza is just like any other pizzeria in the area. But trust me; this place stands out from the rest for its great taste and excellent service. Plus, their prices are surprisingly affordable for such high-quality pizza!

I can honestly say that Carnegie Pizza has been one of the most enjoyable places I’ve visited on my pizza journey around Midtown Manhattan!

If you’re willing to go an extra 1 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in New York!

#2 NY Pizza Suprema

When I first walked in I was immediately hit with the delicious smell of fresh-baked pizza. The atmosphere was friendly and cozy – they even had old school hip hop playing in the background.

The staff was super friendly, and were more than happy to chat with me about their special recipes as I waited for my order. 

Of course, I had to try a slice of their signature pie – it certainly lived up to expectations! It was one of the most delicious New York-style pizzas I’ve ever tasted. The crust was perfect – thin but with enough crunch, baked on a hot brick oven for just the right amount of time.

To top it all off, the cheese was gooey and loaded with flavor. The tomato sauce added a nice tangy sweetness that complemented the overall flavor profile perfectly.

It’s no wonder why NY Pizza Suprema is considered one of the best pizza places in Midtown Manhattan! With its delicious pies, friendly atmosphere, and knowledgeable staff – this place is definitely worth a visit if you’re ever in town!

#3 My Pie Pizzeria Romana

I’d heard about this place from a friend who lives nearby, and I’m so glad I took his advice! The pizza was delicious – the crust was light, airy, and flavorful. It held up through delivery too – even though it had been sitting in a box for a while.

The toppings did not disappoint either. Fresh mozzarella, roma tomatoes, prosciutto, and basil really brought out the flavors of the pizza. It made my mouth water with every bite!

The staff were all friendly and welcoming as well. They greeted me by name when I arrived (thanks again for the tip, pal!) and were always happy to answer any questions I had about their pizzas.

I could go on about how tasty My Pie Pizzeria Romana’s pizzas are but you would probably just have to take my word for it. Go give it a try yourself – you won’t be disappointed! This place has become one of my new favorite spots in Midtown Manhattan for sure!

#4 B Side Pizza Bar

I was absolutely delighted by the cozy atmosphere of the restaurant. The wood-fired, brick oven lends a rustic charm to the environment that is especially inviting, and I was impressed by their diverse beer selection.

The pizza is truly special at B Side Pizza Bar. They use high-quality ingredients, carefully crafting each pie with tender love and care. Their mushroom and olive combination was a particular favorite of mine – each bite was truly remarkable!

I can’t recommend this spot enough for anyone seeking an incredible pizza experience in Manhattan. Whether you’re looking to relax with some friends over a few beers or treat yourself to an amazing slice of pizza (or two), you simply can’t go wrong with B Side Pizza Bar!

#5 Capizzi

The atmosphere of Capizzi is quaint and inviting, much like the pizzas they serve. As soon as I stepped inside, I was instantly drawn to the delicious aromas coming from the kitchen.

I ordered their classic margherita pizza with fresh basil and tomato slices on top. The crust was light, yet crisp and had a delightful crunch to it. The sauce was both sweet and savory, making every bite a delight. The cheese melted perfectly onto the pie, adding even more flavor to this already amazing dish.

To finish off my meal, I decided to try some of their famous garlic knots. They were soft and buttery on the inside, with a golden crisp on the outside. The garlic flavor was strong but not overpowering, which made for a wonderful side dish.

I would highly recommend Capizzi for anyone looking for some of the best pizza in Midtown Manhattan! Their ingredients are always fresh and their prices are very reasonable. With great service and spot-on flavors, you won’t regret indulging in this delicious eatery!

#6 99 Cent Fresh Pizza

Upon entering the restaurant, I was instantly taken aback by the smell of baking cheese and fresh dough. The atmosphere was incredibly inviting, with smiling staff ready to take my order. I decided on a slice of classic margherita pizza, and it did not disappoint. From the first bite, I could tell that this pizza was made with fresh ingredients and lots of love.

The crust was pleasantly crisp while still being fluffy and airy. The marinara sauce had hints of garlic and oregano, adding great flavor to the overall pie. Topped off with delicious mozzarella cheese, each slice had just enough gooeyness to hold everything together perfectly.

99 Cent Fresh Pizza has truly earned its title as one of the best pizzas in Midtown Manhattan! A perfect combination of quality ingredients and excellent cooking skills make this pizza stand out from any other spot in town. If you are ever looking for a delicious slice of pizza at a good price – look no further than 99 Cent Fresh Pizza!

#7 Joe’s Pizza Broadway

From the moment I stepped into Joe’s Pizza Broadway, I knew I was in for a great treat. The atmosphere was warm and inviting, with a rustic Italian vibe. And then there’s the pizza itself… Wow! For me, it was love at first bite! The crust was cooked to perfection and had just the right amount of crispiness. The sauce was full of flavor, and all of their toppings were fresh, providing an amazing flavor combination.

Speaking of toppings – Joe’s has quite a selection! From classic pepperoni to exotic varieties like artichoke hearts or pineapple, they have something to satisfy even the pickiest pizza eater. And all at really reasonable prices too!

In addition to amazing pies, Joe’s also offers up some great appetizers such as garlic breadsticks and stuffed mushrooms. Again, everything is made with fresh ingredients and lots of love for quality food.

All in all, Joe’s Pizza Broadway is a fantastic place for both lunch or dinner – or even just take out if you’d rather enjoy your pie from home. They really go above and beyond when it comes to making delicious pizza that will leave you wanting more!

#8 Marta

To start, their classic Margherita pizza is to die for. The crispy hand-stretched crust is full of flavor and the perfect balance of crunch and chewiness. The San Marzano tomatoes taste like they were picked straight from the vine and the mozzarella is unbelievably creamy and smooth.

Next up, their specialty pies are just as good if not better! Their Sausage & Onion pie has a unique yet delicious combination of flavors that come together perfectly. The smoked sausage adds an amazing smoky flavor while the caramelized onions give it a subtle sweetness that works nicely with the mild cheese blend.

Finally, you can’t ignore their build your own option which gives you complete control over your pizza experience. With dozens of toppings to choose from, you can create anything your heart desires!

In short, Marta definitely deserves its title as the best pizza spot in midtown Manhattan! I would highly recommend them if you’re ever looking for an authentic Italian pizza experience!

If you’re willing to go an extra 1 miles, you can get to 26 more pizza places in New York!

#9 Vezzo NYC Thin Crust Pizza

The pizza here is remarkable – the dough is perfectly thin and crispy, not too greasy, but still with a hint of buttery flavor. The sauce has a great balance of sweet and savory, and the cheese is stringy and gooey. To top it all off, the toppings are always fresh and flavorful.

The atmosphere at Vezzo really adds to the experience as well – the staff is friendly, outgoing, and always ready to answer any questions you may have about their menu. There’s also some great music playing in the background that pairs perfectly with a slice (or three).

In conclusion, if you’re looking for an amazing pizza joint in Midtown Manhattan then look no further than Vezzo NYC Thin Crust Pizza. It’s hands down one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had!

#10 Sacco Pizza

The restaurant offers a great variety of pizza options, and what really impressed me was the fact that their pizzas are cooked in a traditional wood-burning oven. Each bite is full of flavor and has a crunchy, yet soft texture.

The atmosphere at Sacco Pizza is also incredible – it has an old-world charm and certain ‘je ne sais quoi’ that I haven’t found elsewhere. The owners are friendly, attentive and incredibly passionate about their craft.

Overall, I’d say Sacco Pizza is one of my top picks for the best pizza in Midtown Manhattan! If you’re looking for great pizza with an added touch of class and quality ingredients, then this is definitely the place to go.

#11 Uncle Paul’s Pizza NY

I had the privilege of visiting this beloved pizza parlor, and I was not disappointed. The vibe there was cozy, yet inviting – like dining with family. I was immediately drawn in by the smell of fresh baking dough, and the sight of bubbling cheese. The staff were incredibly friendly and knowledgeable about their pies.

The pizza itself was delicious! From the deep-dish to thin-crust varieties, Uncle Paul’s Pizza NY has something for everyone. I’d suggest their signature Pie: a classic combination of pepperoni and sausage on a bechamel base with a light dollop of ricotta in each slice – definitely the best pizza I’ve ever had!

Overall, I’m thrilled to have eaten at Uncle Paul’s Pizza NY and highly recommend it for anyone looking for the best pizza in Midtown Manhattan. If you’re looking for an amazing pizza experience, look no further than Uncle Paul’s Pizza NY!

#12 PizzArte

The service was great. The moment I walked in, the hostess greeted me with a warm smile and got my table ready in no time.

Speaking of the table, I have to commend PizzArte for giving me one of the best seats in house! I was right next to the wood-fired oven, which meant I could watch their skilled pizzaiolos at work while I waited for my order.

My pizza arrived piping hot and fragrant with smoke. The combination of flavors were out of this world – freshly made tomato sauce, carefully cooked Italian sausage, handpicked mushrooms and fragrant oregano made this pie truly special.

I paired it up with an ice cold beer from the bar and savored every bite. When it came to dessert, their selection didn’t disappoint either – the Nutella calzone was like a dream come true!

In conclusion, PizzArte is definitely worth a visit if you’re ever looking for some of the best pizza in Midtown Manhattan.

Best Deep Dish Pizza – Emmett’s

Stepping into Emmett’s is like stepping into a time machine that takes you back to the old-school pizzerias of yesteryear. The smell of melted cheese and freshly baked dough wafts through the air, causing my taste buds to dance in anticipation. As a self-proclaimed pizza connoisseur, I take my job very seriously. So naturally, when I heard about the best deep dish pizza in downtown, I had to put it to the test.

Let me tell you, the moment that golden, cheesy heaven arrived at my table, it was love at first bite. The crust was perfectly crispy on the outside but oh-so-soft on the inside, resembling a fluffy cloud of deliciousness. It held up to the mountain of toppings like a champ, without sacrificing its integrity. I mean, who needs a plate when you have a slice of Emmett’s pizza?!

The combination of gooey, melted cheese and tangy tomato sauce was like a symphony in my mouth. Each ingredient played its part and came together harmoniously. And don’t even get me started on the generous toppings! From juicy chunks of sausage to fresh vegetables, every bite was an explosion of flavor.

But be warned, this pizza is not for the faint of heart. It’s a commitment—a glorious, cheesy, and utterly satisfying commitment. So if you find yourself craving the epitome of deep dish pizza, head to Emmett’s and prepare to have your taste buds blown away. Your stomach may never be the same again, but trust me, it’s a risk worth taking.

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Vezzo NYC Thin Crust Pizza

From the moment I walked in, I knew I was in for a treat. The smell of fresh dough being rolled out filled the air, and my stomach growled in anticipation. The staff greeted me with a warm smile and a delightful introduction to their pizza creations.

As I perused the menu, I couldn’t help but chuckle at the variety of toppings they offered. From classic margherita to inventive combinations like prosciutto and figs, Vezzo NYC Thin Crust Pizza takes pizza to a whole new level of deliciousness.

When my pizza arrived, I couldn’t believe my eyes (or my taste buds). The crust was thin and crispy, with the perfect amount of chewiness. It was like a symphony of flavors exploded in my mouth with each bite. I couldn’t help but do a little happy dance in my seat, much to the amusement of the neighboring tables.

To top it all off, the service was exceptional. The waitstaff was attentive and knowledgeable. They even recommended some locally brewed craft beers to pair with my pizza, and boy, did they hit the spot!

So, if you find yourself in midtown manhattan and craving some incredible thin crust pizza, Vezzo NYC is a must-visit. Just be prepared to have your taste buds blown away and your funny bone tickled. Trust me, this place is truly a slice of pizza heaven!

Best Wood Fired Pizza – Arturo’s Coal Oven Pizza

First of all, let’s talk about the crust. Oh, the crust! It’s like biting into a cloud that’s been infused with the essence of a thousand Italian grandmothers. It’s crispy on the outside, yet delightfully chewy on the inside. I even contemplated stealing a few extra slices to use as pillows on my flight back home.

And the toppings! They are a work of art, hence the name Arturo’s. From the classic margherita to the wild and wacky combinations they come up with, each pizza is a masterpiece in its own right. I had a pizza topped with prosciutto, arugula, and balsamic glaze, and let me tell you, it was like a tastebud tango. The flavors danced and twirled on my tongue, leaving me in a state of pizza bliss.

The atmosphere at Arturo’s is like a cozy Italian trattoria, with red checkered tablecloths and charming, gesticulating waiters. You can almost hear the faint strains of an accordion playing in the background. It’s the perfect setting to enjoy a piping hot slice of pizza and imagine you’re sitting in a quaint little piazza in Naples.

So, if you find yourself in Buffalo, do yourself a favor and head straight to Arturo’s Coal Oven Pizza. It’s the kind of place that will make you want to throw all your travel plans out the window and stay in Buffalo forever, just so you can indulge in their wood-fired pizzas every day. Trust me, you won’t be disappointed. Bellissimo!