Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Mishawaka (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Indiana

Best Pizza in Mishawaka (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

192 Views

I’m happy to report that after tasting and reviewing 12 pizza joints in the area, I’ve found some amazing pies. So if you’re looking for an awesome slice of pizza in Mishawaka, then look no further!

These 12 places, while not all being in the same league, have unique qualities which make them special. Whether it’s a secret sauce or a homemade dough recipe, Mishawaka really shines when it comes to pizza.

I must admit it was delicious journey getting to sample each one, so I hope you enjoy my findings as much as I did!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Indiana

#1 Rossini Carry-Out

The atmosphere at Rossini Carry-Out is casual and relaxed. The staff are friendly and welcoming and the kitchen is clean.

But, of course, I was here for the pizza. The ingredients were all fresh and the flavor was incredible! It’s clear that a lot of care and attention to detail goes into each pie. The crust was perfectly crisp without being too thin or easily soggy, which I love. In addition to the classic cheese and pepperoni pies, they also have some innovative creations that really made me take notice. My favorite was their ‘Supreme Delight’ – it had every topping imaginable!

Overall, Rossini Carry-Out has earned its title as one of the best pizza places in Mishawaka. Their pies are delicious and it’s a great spot for an informal gathering or just a quick bite for one. I’ll definitely be coming back for more!

If you’re willing to go an extra 5 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in South Bend!

#2 Hop Station

This restaurant has great ambiance. They have plenty of TVs to watch sports, and they even serve alcohol–including hard liquor, if you’re feeling extra festive!

The pizza is delicious. Whether you’re a fan of classic pepperoni or creative creations like BBQ-chicken-bacon-ranch, they have something for everyone. The crust is always cooked perfectly, so the slices are both crispy and light.

The only downside of Hop Station is that it doesn’t offer delivery. Hopefully this won’t be a problem if you live close enough to go pick up your pizza in person!

Overall, Hop Station serves some of the best pizza in Mishawaka and makes it easy to enjoy your meal with cold beer or cocktails. If that sounds good to you, then swing by for a slice (or three!)

#3 PASQUALE RULLI’S

Unlike most pizza places, PASQUALE RULLI’S comes with unique benefits. Not only can you enjoy a cold brew while eating your pizza, they also offer a kid’s menu that little ones will love! And if you have room left after all the delicious pizza, you can top it off with some decadent desserts.

However, there is one downside – they do not offer delivery services (which is unfortunate). But don’t let that stop you! Visiting PASQUALE RULLI’S is worth the trip and you won’t be disappointed. The pizza and atmosphere make it an unforgettable experience that’s sure to keep calling you back for more of the best pizza in Mishawaka.

#4 Cosimo & Susie’s A Bit-Italy

The decor was simple but inviting, an authentic Italian pizza restaurant that immediately puts you at ease. I was met with a warm welcome from Susie and her cheery personality as she took my order.

The menu was extensive, with a variety of delicious pizzas, salads and pastas to choose from. But I went straight for the Gold-Standard: The Neapolitan Margherita, made with the freshest tomatoes, creamy mozzarella, olive oil and rich pesto sauce.

The pizza itself arrived piping hot with a charred crust that could only have been cooked by their wood burning oven. The flavor was just out of this world – sweet tomatoes balanced perfectly by salty olives and garlic – simply divine!

I must admit that I was in a bit of disbelief when I tried it – how can one find such amazing pizza so far out in Mishawaka? It’s truly something special and I would highly recommend anyone looking for the best pizza in Mishawaka to make their way over to Cosimo & Susie’s A Bit-Italy!

#5 Hall’s Kitchen Pizza And Subs

From the moment I stepped into this delightful restaurant, I knew things were heading in the right direction. The warm atmosphere had a comforting feeling that put me right at ease. As soon as I sat down, the friendly staff brought me some delicious breadsticks to munch on while I decided what pizza to get. It was hard to choose, but eventually I settled on a classic pepperoni and sausage pie.

I don’t know what kind of magic they use in their kitchen, but it must be work of sorcery because this pizza was absolutely divine! The golden-brown crust was crunchy and full of flavor, while the sauce was slightly sweet with just enough herbs to give it that extra bit of zing. Of course, no good pizza is complete without great toppings – Hall’s Kitchen Pizza And Subs passed that test with flying colors! The pepperoni and sausage provided a smoky flavor that complimented the cheese perfectly.

The whole experience was amazing from start to finish – from the service to the food. If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Mishawaka then look no further than Hall’s Kitchen Pizza And Subs – you won’t regret it!

#6 Bruno’s Pizza Osceola

I mean honestly, where else are you going to find a crust that’s so light and fluffy that it practically melts in your mouth? And the sauce! It’s like a heavenly symphony of flavors with just the right amount of sweetness to make your taste buds leap with joy.

But the real star of the show has got to be their toppings. Every time I visit Bruno’s Pizza Osceola, I’m overwhelmed by the sheer variety of toppings they have available. From classic pepperoni to spicy jalapenos and everything in between, you’re sure to find something that appeals to your taste buds.

And if that wasn’t enough, their service is top-notch! Everyone working there is so friendly and always willing to go above and beyond to make sure you have an enjoyable experience.

At the end of the day, I’m confident in saying that Bruno’s Pizza Osceola is one of the best pizza spots in Mishawaka. If you’re looking for an unforgettable pizza experience, look no further than this amazing restaurant!

#7 Luigi’s Pizza

My experience at Luigi’s was truly one to remember. As I stepped through the door, I was immediately hit with the fragrant aroma of freshly baked crust that sent me over the edge.

When it came time to order, I knew exactly what I wanted: The Ultimate Pizza with sausage and pepperoni. It was everything I hoped for! The flavors were rich and savory, and the crust was unbelievably light and fluffy.

I also sampled some of their other menu items including their famous garlic knots, which were a delightfully tasty treat. All in all, Luigi’s delivers an amazing pizza experience that can’t be found anywhere else in Mishawaka. If you’re looking for the best pizza in town, this is definitely a restaurant you won’t want to miss!

#8 Yummy Pizza

The restaurant itself is warm, inviting and always bustling. I was lucky enough to get a table on my first visit, and the server was super friendly and provided great service.

As for the pizza itself, it’s delicious! The wood-fired oven gives their pies a distinctive, smoky flavor that I’ve never encountered anywhere else. Even better, they offer a wide variety of traditional and creative topping options – from vegan cheeses to spicy chorizo. No matter what type of pizza you’re in the mood for, Yummy Pizza has something that will hit the spot.

Their crusts are also top notch: light and crisp but still chewy enough to hold up under all those toppings. Plus, their prices are super reasonable – especially considering the high quality of their ingredients.

In short, if you’re ever looking for some of the best pizza in Mishawaka (which you should be!), then look no further than Yummy Pizza! You won’t regret it!

If you’re willing to go an extra 11 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Elkhart!

#9 Jimmy’s Pizza and Ribs

The atmosphere of the restaurant is friendly and inviting, and it’s obvious the staff takes great care to ensure each customer has a great experience.

When it comes to their pizza, Jimmy’s truly stands out from the crowd. The crust of their pizzas are some of the best I’ve ever tasted, with a crunchy exterior and a soft interior. As for toppings, they’re generous with their portions and you can tell they use fresh ingredients that really add depth of flavour to their pies. If you’re feeling extra hungry, you can even grab one of their signature combo pizzas!

Finally, let’s not forget about the ribs! These succulent morsels fall off the bone and are one of my favourites on Jimmy’s menu. Just make sure to bring an extra napkin!

In conclusion, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Mishawaka then look no further than Jimmy’s Pizza and Ribs. I highly recommend checking them out!

#10 Mimmo’s Pizza

I visited the restaurant a few weeks ago and it was nothing short of amazing. The crust was thin, crunchy, and oh-so delicious. It had a subtle yet distinctive flavor that made it stand out from the others I had tried. The toppings were fresh, flavorful, and just the right amount. It was one of those rare pizzas that you can barely put down until the plate is empty!

The service at Mimmo’s Pizza was also outstanding. The staff was friendly, knowledgeable, and attentive. They took their time with me to explain the different types of pizza before I made my selection.

All in all, my experience at Mimmo’s Pizza exceeded my expectations! If you are ever in Mishawaka looking for some great pizza, I highly recommend stopping by Mimmo’s Pizza – you won’t be disappointed!

#11 Oliva’s Bar & Restaurant

The atmosphere at Oliva’s was welcoming and inviting. The best part is that they also serve alcohol, including hard liquor, so you can enjoy a few cold drinks with your delicious pizza.

I ordered their classic Margherita pizza and it did not disappoint! The dough was cooked to perfection, just the right amount of cheese, and all the right herbs and spices. It was easily the highlight of the evening.

I’m usually a bit hesitant to try dessert after having such great pizza but I’m glad I did because their desserts were insanely good. They had something for everyone in our group, from a carrot cake to tiramisu.

The only downside is they don’t offer delivery, which would be really convenient if you’re in a rush or feeling lazy. However, if you can make it there in person, then you’ll be rewarded with some of the best pizza in town!

If you find yourself looking for great pizza in Mishawaka then look no further than Oliva’s Bar & Restaurant – it’s one of the best spots around for an amazing meal!

#12 Mishawaka Barnabys

The surprise began the moment I stepped into the restaurant. It had a charming rustic atmosphere that made me feel like I had been transported to a small Italian village.

I decided to try their signature pizza, and I wasn’t disappointed. The crust was thin and crispy, with just the right amount of char for flavor. The sauce was garlicky and full of herbs that made it both savory and slightly sweet. Topped off with plenty of fresh vegetables and cheese, it was quite an amazing experience!

The service I received at Mishawaka Barnabys was also top-notch. Everyone from the wait staff to the cooks seemed genuinely committed to providing the best experience possible.

In short, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Mishawaka, then you should definitely pay a visit to Mishawaka Barnabys!