Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in East Nashville (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Tennessee

Best Pizza in East Nashville (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

171 Views

But I was determined to find the best! After tasting more than a dozen different pies, I’m now ready to declare which pizzeria offers the tastiest pizza in East Nashville.

I’m not one to take things too seriously, so don’t expect a stuffy review. Instead, you can expect my honest opinion on each place I visited and enjoy some lighthearted musings along the way.

So without further ado, let’s get down to business and find out who makes the best pizza in East Nashville!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Tennessee

#1 Five Points Pizza East

I stopped in for lunch, and man was it worth it. I started with the traditional margherita pizza: fresh tomatoes, mozzarella, basil, and olive oil – simply delicious! Then I followed that up with a classic pepperoni pizza – the perfect blend of spicy and salty.

But what really put Five Points Pizza East over the top was their specialty pies. They have a great variety of options, both traditional and innovative. My favorite was their ‘Nashville Heat’ pie with spicy smoked sausage, jalapeños, onions, and a sweet habanero sauce. Delicious!

If you’re looking for great pizza in East Nashville, look no further than Five Points Pizza East! It’s the best of the best – you won’t be disappointed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 2 miles, you can get to 26 more pizza places in Nashville!

#2 TailGate Brewery East Nashville

The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, but it still has a bit of a ‘party’ vibe. From the moment I walked in, I felt right at home.

My favorite part was their menu – they had an amazing selection of pizzas to choose from! Everything looked delicious and smelled even better. I decided to go with the Margherita pizza with fresh basil. It came out promptly and it was delectable! The crust was perfectly thin and crispy yet chewy at the same time, while the toppings were so flavorful that I’m already craving my next pizza from TailGate Brewery East Nashville.

Aside from the fantastic food, their service is also worthy of praise. Every staff member I encountered was friendly and helpful throughout my meal – always making sure that I wasn’t missing out on anything special or unique about TailGate Brewery East Nashville’s pizzas.

I highly recommend TailGate Brewery East Nashville for anyone looking for some excellent pizza in East Nashville – it’s definitely one of my favorite spots in town now!

#3 Manny’s House of Pizza

As soon as I walked in, the energetic atmosphere and friendly staff made me feel right at home. The menus were filled with unique specialty pizzas that had my mouth watering. After debating over which pizza to get, I settled on the classic pepperoni, since you can’t go wrong with a classic.

I was absolutely blown away by the quality of this pizza! The crust was perfectly crisp – not too crunchy and not too soggy – and the sauce had just the right amount of spice to it. But what I was most impressed by were the evenly-cut pepperonis which were juicy and oh-so flavorful. It was as if every single bite was created for a true connoisseur such as myself!

Overall, I highly recommend Manny’s House of Pizza for anyone looking for a great pizza experience in East Nashville. You won’t be disappointed!

#4 Urban Cowboy Public House

When I arrived at the restaurant, I was instantly entranced by the delightful Western-style decor and friendly atmosphere. The staff were very accommodating as I made my way to a cozy table in the corner.

The pizza menu selection had a great variety of unique options from margherita to buffalo chicken and vegan options, so there was something for everyone. As soon as my order (a classic pepperoni) arrived, the mouthwatering aroma filled the air and it was love at first bite!

One look and you can tell this is no ordinary take-out pizza. The dough was perfectly thin yet firm enough to hold all of its delicious toppings. Each slice was generously topped with flavor-packed pepperoni slices accompanied by melted cheese that both looked and tasted fantastic!

Urban Cowboy Public House is a must-visit destination for any pizza enthusiast looking for their next great slice anywhere near East Nashville. This place has some of the best pizza in town, and whatever topping you choose, it’s sure to hit the spot!

#5 Smith & Lentz Brewing and Pizza

The atmosphere of the restaurant is inviting and relaxed, with its exposed brick walls, rustic wooden tables, and open kitchen. I’m sure the excellent selection of craft beer didn’t hurt either! The staff was friendly and knowledgeable in explaining the menu items.

To start off my meal I sampled some of their delicious beer-cheese dip. A great appetizer to get me ready for the main course – pizza! And oh boy did they deliver! The classic margherita pizza was my favorite. The cheesy goodness with a hint of garlic created that perfect balance between sweet and salty flavors. Not to mention the amazing crispy crust that had just enough char from the oven.

In conclusion, I have to say Smith & Lentz Brewing and Pizza makes some of the best pizza in East Nashville and definitely worth a try for anyone looking for an enjoyable evening filled with good food. Enjoy!

#6 Desano Pizzeria

I stopped in to try a slice what I found was an unexpectedly enjoyable experience. The atmosphere was laid-back and inviting, perfect for both tourists and locals alike. Plus, the service is prompt and courteous!

As far as the pizza itself goes? Delicious! They offer a wide selection of delicious pies with something to please everyone. From traditional Neapolitan-style pizzas to specialty pies such as the Bianca al Rucola, every slice has it’s own unique flavor and texture. And don’t even get me started on their range of toppings – they truly have something for everyone here!

The only downside is that they don’t offer delivery – you’ll have to eat there or take it away with you. But trust me, it’s worth it! I highly recommend Desano Pizzeria for anyone looking for an amazing pizza experience in East Nashville.

#7 Emmy Squared Pizza: The Gulch – Nashville, Tennessee

The atmosphere of the restaurant is inviting and lively, with a great selection of craft beers to go along with my pizza. The staff was friendly and attentive, which made me feel right at home.

But what really made Emmy Squared Pizza stand out for me were the mouth-watering pizza creations that featured a variety of unique toppings and flavorful crusts. I went for the classic Margherita, but it was elevated to a whole new level with its balanced blend of fresh tomatoes, melted cheese, and fragrant basil. It’s no wonder why Emmy Squared pizza has become one of the most popular places in East Nashville!

If you’re looking for top-notch pizza in East Nashville, then look no further than Emmy Squared Pizza: The Gulch – Nashville, Tennessee! With its delicious pizzas and warm hospitality, you won’t be disappointed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 3 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Nashville!

#8 Emmy Squared Pizza: East Nashville

To start, I tried their popular Detroit-style square pizza. It was delicious! The thick, crunchy crust with light layers of cheese and flavorful tomato sauce make it a winner in my book.

The other star of the show was their East Village Pie. This pizza is a spin on classic NYC pizza with toppings like soppressata and hot honey. The combination of flavors is simply heavenly!

What really sets Emmy Squared Pizza: East Nashville apart from other pizzerias though, is the atmosphere. It’s a cozy spot with friendly staff and a lively buzz that always makes me feel welcome.

If you’re looking for the best pizza in East Nashville, you have to try Emmy Squared Pizza: East Nashville! Hands down, it’s one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had!

#9 Italia pizza and pasta

When I first arrived, I was taken aback by the atmosphere – the friendly waitstaff, cozy interior and soft Italian music only added to my anticipation. As soon as we were seated, the delicious aromas of Italian spices wafted from the kitchen and it was all I could do not to jump up and run back there!

The pizza was simply amazing. The thin crust, made with a recipe passed down through generations in Naples, tasted light yet crisp. The cheese seemed like it had been hand-picked from a local farm and paired perfectly with their fresh vegetables and savory tomato sauce. And don’t even get me started on those heavenly slices of salami!

I can confidently say that Italia pizza and pasta has some of the best pizza in East Nashville. From the quaint atmosphere to the delightful flavors, it’s an experience you won’t want to miss out on!

#10 Mellow Mushroom

I’m not exaggerating either. The ingredients were incredibly fresh, the crust was perfectly crispy yet chewy, and the sauce had just the right amount of sweetness. Plus, the toppings were generous and gave each slice of pizza an amazing flavor profile.

But what really sold me on Mellow Mushroom was their commitment to flavor. They offer unique combinations like pesto with roasted garlic, as well as classic options like pepperoni and sausage. No matter what you’re craving, they have something for everyone!

Moreover, I must applaud their staff for being so attentive and helpful throughout my meal. They truly understand how to make a guest feel welcome – whether it’s suggesting a special or just offering up friendly conversation!

Finally, Mellow Mushroom is great value for your money. The portions are large enough that you won’t go away feeling hungry yet affordable enough that both students and tourists can enjoy delicious pizza without breaking the bank.

In short, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in East Nashville then look no further than Mellow Mushroom – it will not disappoint!

#11 Bella Nashville Pizzeria

I was immediately impressed at the thought that went into the restaurant’s design. The interior is welcoming and warm with a rustic, country-style vibe. The delicious smell of wood burning from the oven creates an incredibly inviting atmosphere.

As for the food, I couldn’t be more pleased. The crust was perfectly crunchy and full of flavor. The tomatoes were juicy and just the right amount of spicy and sour. And the topping selections are vast, including pepperoni, sausage, veggie lovers and even some vegan options!

Overall I’d give Bella Nashville Pizzeria a solid 5 out of 5 stars! If you’re ever looking for great pizza in East Nashville this is definitely the spot to go!

#12 Slim & Husky’s Pizza Beeria

As soon as I stepped in the restaurant I could smell the deliciousness! The unique decor and atmosphere made me feel like I’d been transported to a pizza paradise.

The menu was full of delicious options, however, what really stands out is their signature pizzas. From the classic Margherita to the zesty “Supremo”, each one was bursting with flavor. Even though all of them caught my eye, the one that stood out most was their “Truffle Shuffle” – it had a garlic truffle sauce topped with mushrooms, peppers and onions. It’s definitely one of the best pizzas I’ve had!

But Slim & Husky’s isn’t just a pizza joint – they also have salads, wings and calzones for those looking for something different. The portions were generous with quality ingredients that really elevated each dish.

Overall, if you’re looking for top-notch pizza in East Nashville then Slim & Husky’s Pizza Beeria should be your go-to spot! With their unique flavors and lively atmosphere it’s sure to please all taste buds!

Best Deep Dish Pizza – 312 Pizza Company

Now, I know what you’re thinking. Nashville? Deep dish? Are you out of your mind, Edward? But trust me, I was just as skeptical as you. I mean, Nashville is known for its hot chicken, not its pizza. But oh boy, was I in for a delicious surprise.

Walking into 312 Pizza Company, I was immediately greeted by the mouthwatering aroma of freshly baked dough and melted cheese. The place had a cozy, Chicago-style feel to it, complete with sports memorabilia and a jukebox that played everything from Sinatra to Taylor Swift.

Now, let’s talk about the main event: the pizza. Each slice is a glorious mountain of crust, filled to the brim with gooey cheese and your choice of scrumptious toppings. I opted for the classic pepperoni because sometimes you just can’t beat a classic. And wow, was it a cheesy delight! The crust had the perfect balance of crispiness and chewiness, and the sauce was tangy and full of flavor.

But it wasn’t just the pizza that won me over. The staff at 312 Pizza Company were an absolute riot. They had me laughing so much that I almost forgot I was there for the food. They even let me try their hilarious Doughnut Pizza, which sounds crazy but surprisingly worked. Who knew that pizza and doughnuts could be such a great combo?

So, if you find yourself in Nashville craving a taste of the Windy City, head on over to 312 Pizza Company. It truly is a slice of pizza heaven in Music City. Trust me, I’m an expert.

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Slim & Husky’s Pizza Beeria

What’s not to love about a place that combines my two favorite things: pizza and beer? I walked into Slim & Husky’s with high hopes, and boy, did they deliver (pun intended).

The moment I stepped in, I was hit with the smell of freshly baked dough and the sound of laughter from happy customers. The rustic ambiance and friendly staff made me feel like I was at a cozy neighborhood joint rather than a tourist spot.

Now let’s talk about the pizza. Oh, the pizza! The crust was so thin and crispy, it practically melted in my mouth. The toppings were generous and the sauce was packed with flavor. I could taste the love and dedication that went into making each pie.

As a vegetarian, I was delighted to find a decent selection of veggie options on the menu. The Garden Party pizza was a delightful mix of fresh veggies and tangy cheese. I scarfed it down faster than you can say mozzarella.

And if that wasn’t enough, they even had dessert! I indulged in their decadent Nutella calzone, and trust me, it was worth every calorie.

Now, here’s the downside: they don’t accept reservations. So if you’re a planner like me, be prepared to wait. But hey, good things in life are worth waiting for, right?

So if you find yourself in Nashville, make sure to stop by Slim & Husky’s for a slice of heaven. Your taste buds will thank you, and your waistline might hate you, but hey, YOLO.

Best Wood Fired Pizza – Bella Nashville Pizzeria

The aroma hits you as soon as you walk in the door, and it’s like being hugged by a warm, doughy embrace. Trust me, this place is no crusty disappointment. Their wood-fired oven, which I suspect is fueled by magical pizza-making unicorns, creates a crust so perfectly charred and chewy that I seriously contemplated stealing the chef’s secret pizza dough recipe and making millions.

Now, let’s talk toppings. Bella Nashville Pizzeria knows how to cater to vegetarians. They have an impressive selection of fresh, locally sourced vegetables that would make any herbivore weep tears of joy. I could almost hear the veggies saying, Thank you for not just offering us as a sad side salad option, Bella. You recognize our true potential!

But, here’s the catch: Bella Nashville doesn’t accept reservations. So, if you don’t want to sit around twiddling your thumbs for hours, you better arrive early or be prepared to fight off other pizza enthusiasts for a spot at the table. I suggest bringing a distraction, like a deck of cards or a puppet show, to entertain yourself while waiting.

Overall, Bella Nashville Pizzeria is a must-visit for pizza lovers and city explorers alike. Just be ready to battle for a seat and revel in the taste of wood-fired deliciousness. Anyway, I’m off to hunt down a pizza unicorn, wish me luck!