Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Eau Claire (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Wisconsin

Best Pizza in Eau Claire (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

329 Views

I’ve been all over the world, from Italy to New York and beyond, tasting some truly remarkable pies. I’m confident in saying that the best pizza in Eau Claire is nestled among the twelve establishments that I recently visited. My travels have proven to me that you don’t have to go far for a delicious slice – sometimes it’s right under your nose.

So join me on my downright hilarious adventure as I explore all of the places vying for the title of Eau Claire’s Best Pizza. From classic thick-crust pies to daringly inventive creations, there’s something for everyone in this charming Midwestern city. Here’s my ultimate list of must-try pizza spots!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Wisconsin

#1 TONY CAPONY PIZZA

Let me tell you, their pizzas are out-of-this-world delicious! The crust is crisp and golden brown on the outside, with a soft and flavorful inside. Toppings are always fresh, plentiful and generously portioned. The cheese is always fresh and never greasy – it’s the perfect combination of creamy and melty.

The atmosphere at TONY CAPONY PIZZA is also top notch. From the welcoming staff to the warm and inviting ambiance, you can’t help but feel right at home while enjoying your meal. Plus they have plenty of TVs around so you can keep up with all your favorite sports teams while dining in.

Overall, I highly recommend checking out TONY CAPONY PIZZA for some of the best pizza in Eau Claire. Their pizzas are second-to-none in taste, quality, and atmosphere! Who knew that Eau Claire was home to such great pizza? I definitely think this restaurant is worth a visit!

If you’re willing to go an extra 65 miles, you can get to 12 more pizza places in Stillwater!

#2 Mancino’s Grinders & Pizza

The first thing I noticed as I entered Mancino’s was the incredible aroma of fresh-baked dough and spices. It made my mouth water with anticipation.

When it came to ordering, I had a hard time deciding what to get—everything looked so delicious! In the end, I decided on a large pepperoni grinder with extra cheese. When it arrived at my table, the presentation was simply drool-worthy. The crust was perfectly golden brown and the toppings were piled high on top.

The taste was out of this world! The crust was buttery, delicate, yet dense enough to hold up against all the tasty toppings. The sauce was incredibly flavorful—I could tell it had been cooked with tomato, garlic and herbs giving it an unforgettable flavor profile. The pepperoni added just the right kick and the extra cheese melted in such an amazing way that I couldn’t stop eating!

To sum things up: Mancino’s Grinders & Pizza is definitely one of the best pizza joints in Eau Claire–I highly recommend it for anyone looking for a really enjoyable pizza experience!

#3 Geno’s Pizza

The atmosphere at Geno’s is lively and inviting. The walls are adorned with memorabilia from previous customers, giving it a vintage feel. The staff are friendly and helpful, always willing to answer any questions I had about their menu or ingredients.

The pizza is the real star of the show here. Each pizza has a light, crisp crust that melts in your mouth as you bite into it. The toppings are fresh and flavorful; you can definitely taste the quality ingredients used to make them.

In my opinion, the best way to enjoy Geno’s Pizza is by trying their unique combinations. They offer fun options like pesto-bacon-onion or jalapeno-sausage-mushroom – each one packed with flavor!

Overall, if you’re looking for great pizza in Eau Claire, I highly recommend Geno’s Pizza! It truly is one of the best places in town for delicious pizzas that won’t disappoint!

#4 Johnny’s Pizza Shop

The place is small and cozy, but bright, and the staff were incredibly friendly. And the pizza? Delicious! I had a slice of their signature pepperoni pizza and I must say it was divine. The cheese was perfectly melted, the sauce had just the right amount of spices, and the pepperoni had that great crunchy texture I love.

Plus, they give you an extra-large slice at no additional cost! Talk about value. But the thing that puts Johnny’s Pizza Shop over the top for me is their crust. It’s so light and airy that it practically melts in your mouth.

In conclusion, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Eau Claire then Johnny’s Pizza Shop is definitely a must visit!

#5 Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza

The pizza is made with fresh ingredients and a unique take-and-bake approach that not only guarantees freshness but also allows you to customize your own pizza. Plus, the prices are incredibly reasonable, so it’s easy to enjoy more than one pie if you’re feeling daring.

My favorite part about Papa Murphy’s is the staff. Everyone is friendly and happy to answer any questions you have. They even gave me a few helpful tips on how to make my pizza extra delicious – which it was! The crust was perfectly crispy, the sauce was flavorful, and every topping was perfectly cooked. In short, this place is a must try for anyone looking for the best pizza in Eau Claire.

#6 Sammy’s Pizza Restaurant & Pub

The first thing I noticed when I arrived was the inviting atmosphere. It felt like a home away from home, complete with wooden paneling and chairs, giving the restaurant a cozy yet modern feel.

The real star of the show, however, is the pizza! Sammy uses only the freshest ingredients to make their pies. The crust is thin and fluffy, just like I like it. When it came out of the oven, it had that delicious golden brown color that every pizza lover craves.

I opted for a classic pepperoni pizza and it was amazing. The sauce was flavorful but not too spicy and the cheese was gooey and perfect. The pepperoni slices were generous in size and gave a nice bite to each slice I ate.

Sammy’s Pizza Restaurant & Pub truly has some of the best pizza in Eau Claire – or anywhere else for that matter! If you’re ever in town, be sure to check them out for a great meal!

#7 Pizza Del Re

I was delighted to find out that they not only serve great pizza, but also offer alcohol, a kids’ menu, and dessert. So not only do you get to enjoy the amazing pizza they make, but you can also have a beverage or two with your meal. Plus, it’s a great spot for tourists – the atmosphere is very inviting and the staff are incredibly friendly.

The only downside of Pizza Del Re is that they don’t offer delivery. While this could be inconvenient for some folks, I think it’s more than worth it to actually go there and experience the amazing pizza!

Overall, I would definitely recommend Pizza Del Re if you’re looking for the best pizza in Eau Claire. The food is amazing and the atmosphere is just as great – plus, with all those other goodies like alcohol and desserts offered up too, Pizza Del Re really stands out from all the other pizza places around town!

#8 Toppers Pizza

The atmosphere was cozy and inviting, with plenty of seating for groups of any size. The spacious layout allows for plenty of room to stretch out and chat about your favorite toppings as you wait for your food.

Speaking of which, the pizza menu at Toppers Pizza is simply divine. With a wide range of traditional options like pepperoni and sausage, plus inventive specials like Mediterranean-inspired pizzas with spicy feta cheese and olives – there’s something to satisfy everyone here. And those crusts… oh my! They’re so light and airy that it almost hurts to take the first bite – in a good way, of course!

In addition to the delicious food, Toppers Pizza also offers a variety of drinks including beer on tap, salads, desserts and other great snacks. Plus they have an awesome rewards program that makes it easy to cut costs on future visits – what more could you ask for?

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Eau Claire, then look no further than Toppers Pizza! Trust me.

If you’re willing to go an extra 68 miles, you can get to 24 more pizza places in Woodbury!

#9 Toppers Pizza

The atmosphere was great, the staff was friendly, and the pizza was out of this world. The crust was perfectly cooked and had a delightful crunch to it. The cheese melted in my mouth as soon as I took a bite. I sampled several of their specialty pizzas and each one had its own unique flavor that delighted my taste buds.

The service at Toppers Pizza is top-notch as well. They made sure my order arrived quickly and efficiently with nothing missing or incorrect. Plus, the wait staff was always happy to answer any questions I had about the menu items and offer suggestions for trying something new.

Overall, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Eau Claire – look no further than Toppers Pizza! You won’t be disappointed!

#10 Jim Bob’s Pizza

I’ve never seen a pizza joint so full of character. From the moment I arrived, I was captivated by the bright, inviting atmosphere. Jim Bob himself greeted me with a friendly smile, and let me know that he takes pride in every dish he serves.

The pizzas were cooked to perfection with just the right amount of char on the crust – it was crunchy yet chewy and delicious! I really enjoyed their unique topping combinations, like their BBQ Chicken Pizza loaded with chicken, onions, cheddar cheese and a tangy BBQ sauce. It was definitely one of my favorite items from their menu!

The staff at Jim Bob’s Pizza were warm, welcoming and genuinely interested in making sure that we had a great experience. I can honestly say that they went out of their way to ensure that we had the best pizza in town.

If you’re looking for an unforgettable pizza experience in Eau Claire, look no further than Jim Bob’s Pizza – you won’t be disappointed!

#11 The Plus

The Plus has several benefits that set it apart from other pizza places. For starters, they not only offer classic beers and wines, but they also have hard liquor! They also offer a kid’s menu so the whole family can join in on the fun. And of course, what kind of pizza place would be complete without dessert? The Plus has plenty of options to satisfy your sweet tooth. Lastly, their great tourist spot makes for an ideal night out for anyone visiting Eau Claire. Oh yeah, and you can watch sports there too!

Unfortunately, The Plus does not have delivery service which is a bit of a bummer. But as long as you don’t mind going there yourself (which I can highly recommend!), then you won’t regret your decision.

All in all, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Eau Claire then The Plus is definitely worth checking out. With its amazing selection of drinks and meal options, plus its great atmosphere and amazing location – it certainly won’t disappoint!

#12 Monkey In the Middle Pizza @ Action City

The atmosphere was lively and the staff were friendly and helpful. It’s definitely the kind of place you’d want to hang out with your friends for a night, or even just to grab a quick slice after school. Plus, they had some great specials going on when I stopped by – two-for-one large pies and a free drink with every purchase!

As for the pizza itself – wow! The crust was thin but still had a good chewiness to it, and the cheese was perfectly melted over top. The toppings were generous and fresh, ranging from classic pepperoni to more creative options like pineapple and prosciutto. The flavors blended together perfectly that by the last bite I was wishing for more!

To sum it up: Monkey In the Middle Pizza @ Action City is arguably one of the best pizzas in Eau Claire, so if you’re looking for a great place to get your fix of Italian comfort food, this is definitely worth checking out. You won’t be disappointed!