It’s been a pizza-filled journey, but I’ve finally narrowed it down to the 12 best pizza places in this small New Jersey town. With an eye for authenticity and a taste for deliciousness, I’m here to put Edgewater’s pizzerias to the test!
My mission? To find the absolute best spot for a slice of cheesy heaven. Whether you’re looking for thick or thin crust, traditional or gourmet toppings, I’m ready to share all my findings with you in my lighthearted and humorous review of the very best pizza in Edgewater NJ.
If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New Jersey
#1 Urban Tomato
- Offers dessert
Having been to Italy, Chicago, and New York City in search of the perfect slice, I can confidently say that this is one of the best spots for pizza. The quality here is great – from the chunky sauce to the perfectly cooked crust.
The atmosphere at this place is awesome too. They have a giant oven in the center of the restaurant making for a very lively environment. Plus, it smells amazing inside! If you don’t believe me come on down and take a whiff yourself.
In terms of toppings, they offer something for everyone. Everything from classic pepperoni and sausage to more creative options like artichokes and sun dried tomatoes. The combinations are endless!
Overall I highly suggest checking out Urban Tomato if you’re ever in Edgewater NJ looking for great pizza. It truly stands out from all the rest – even when compared to the offerings around NYC!
If you’re willing to go an extra 1 miles, you can get to 26 more pizza places in Secaucus!
#2 New Jersey Pizza Truck Culto Italiano Catering
The crust was thin and the cheese was cooked to perfection. The sauce was flavorful and the toppings were fresh and plentiful. I enjoyed every bite and could tell that the ingredients were of excellent quality.
The decor of the restaurant itself was simple but elegant—the perfect backdrop for a great pizza meal. Plus, they had friendly staff who always seemed happy to help.
I highly recommend New Jersey Pizza Truck Culto Italiano Catering for anyone looking for genuine Italian-style pizza in Edgewater NJ—you won’t be disappointed! And if you’re still not convinced, just pay them a visit and try it out yourself—you won’t regret it!
#3 Pizza Club
- Has some vegetarian options
- Offers dessert
The moment I stepped inside, I was transported to a pizza oasis. The restaurant has a warm, inviting atmosphere with a hint of Italian nostalgia that makes you feel right at home.
The menu is extensive, offering an array of delectable pies for even the pickiest of palates. From classic pepperoni and cheese to unique and creative interpretations of traditional favorites like the ‘BBQ Chicken Pizza,’ there’s something to satisfy everyone’s cravings.
But what really sets Pizza Club apart from other pizzerias is their old-school brick oven. After careful inspection, it became obvious that this oven not only gives off delicious aromas, but also imparts a perfect smoky flavor into each pizza that you can taste in every bite.
However, my favorite part about Pizza Club were their friendly staff members. They made sure I felt welcomed and provided helpful recommendations when I asked which pizza I should order – which ended up being their signature ‘Supreme’ pizza! It was SO good; the dough was light yet crisp and the toppings were fresh and flavorful!
Overall, my experience at Pizza Club was one that will be remembered fondly for years to come — they truly have some of the best pizza in Edgewater NJ!
#4 Pizza Side
I recently had the privilege of trying a slice from this restaurant and I can honestly say that it was one of the best slices of pizza I’ve ever had. The crust was thin and crisp, the sauce was bursting with flavor and the cheese melted in your mouth.
What really sets Pizza Side apart from other places is their unique toppings. From freshly chopped peppers to homemade Italian sausage, they offer something for everyone.
The atmosphere at Pizza Side is also great. It’s a cozy little place that’s very inviting. There’s plenty of seating for groups and everyone always seems to be having a good time chatting over a few slices.
To make things even better, their prices are surprisingly reasonable. You won’t have to break the bank when you stop by Pizza Side!
In conclusion, Pizza Side offers some of the best pizza in Edgewater NJ and I highly recommend checking it out if you’re ever in town!
#5 It’s Pinsa
The pizza here is completely unique – they take a classic Italian dish and put their own twist on it. The “pinsa” is made from a blend of rice, wheat and soy flour, with a light and crispy crust. The toppings are also fresh and flavorful – the pepperoni is especially delicious!
The staff at It’s Pinsa are some of the friendliest I’ve ever encountered. They were eager to give me recommendations on what to order; they even let me try some samples (which were great!).
The atmosphere at It’s Pinsa is laid-back yet classy; it’s the perfect spot for a cozy night out with friends. And you can’t beat their prices – my meal was incredibly affordable!
Overall, I’d have to say that my experience at It’s Pinsa was one of the best when it comes to pizza in Edgewater NJ. From the unique pinsa crust to the friendly staff, I would highly recommend this restaurant for anyone looking for delicious and affordable Italian cuisine!
#6 Napoli Wood Fired Pizza & Bakery
- Nice tourist spot
- Offers dessert
- Has some vegetarian options
They have an awesome selection of traditional pizzas, along with some unique specialties that can’t be found anywhere else. The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, and the staff are really friendly. Plus, the wood-fired oven gives the pizzas a delicious smoky flavor like no other!
I had the Italian Sausage pizza last night and it was out of this world. It had a thin, crispy crust with plenty of flavorful Italian sausage and some sweet peppers on top. The balance of flavors was perfect—it was both tasty and aromatic!
And let’s not forget about the desserts! I recommend their ricotta cheesecake—it’s one of the best I’ve ever tried! It had creamy ricotta cheese on top of a light, flaky crust that melted in my mouth. Delicious!
Overall, Napoli Wood Fired Pizza & Bakery is easily one of the best places to find pizza in Edgewater NJ. Whether you’re looking for something classic or a unique specialty pizza, they have something for everyone! Highly recommended!
If you’re willing to go an extra 1 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in New York!
#7 Urban Tomato
- Nice tourist spot
- Has a kid’s menu
- Offers dessert
- Has some vegetarian options
The atmosphere inside the restaurant is laidback, homey, and comfortable. The restaurant’s rustic ambiance was inviting and made me feel right at home.
When it comes to pizza, Urban Tomato really knows what they’re doing. Their crust was perfectly crisp on the outside and soft on the inside; not too thick but not overly thin. The sauce was flavorful with a slight bit of kick that I loved. The cheese was just the right amount – not overwhelming like some places can be. Every bite was full of flavor!
But the real stand out is the toppings. Everything from sausage to mushrooms to goat cheese; you could get it all here! Not once did I feel like my order was missing something, which hasn’t happened often in my travels to different pizza restaurants around the world.
I highly recommend Urban Tomato for anyone who wants to enjoy some of the best pizza in Edgewater NJ!
#8 Anthony GM Pizzeria
- Great place to watch sports
- Offers dessert
Upon walking into the restaurant, I noticed the quaint decor and inviting atmosphere. It’s a little off the beaten path, but worth seeking out.
I immediately ordered one of their signature pies and it was definitely more than worth it. The crust was perfectly cooked to a golden brown, with a crunchy texture on the outside and a chewy deliciousness inside. The cheese was delicious and flavorful, just melted enough to let you know it had been in the oven for some time. Toppings were piled high and fresh, adding great flavor to every bite.
The staff were friendly and helpful throughout my visit – really taking care to make sure I felt at home. I even noticed that they were using high-quality ingredients in their doughs, cheeses, and toppings – something that is rare these days.
Overall, if you’re looking for an amazing pizza experience in Edgewater NJ then Anthony GM Pizzeria is where you need to be! You’ll find some of the best pizza around town here and won’t be disappointed with your meal!
#9 Edgewater Pizza
The atmosphere of the restaurant was warm and inviting, complete with old-school Italian decor. The pervasive smell of freshly baked pizza filled the air and set my taste buds tingling.
It’s not just the atmosphere that sets Edgewater Pizza apart from other pizzerias; their ingredients are truly something special. Everything tasted freshly made – from the flavorful tomatoes in their sauces to their delicious cheese blends and toppings.
And finally, I have to mention the staff – they were friendly, welcoming and clearly passionate about what they do. It’s no wonder why Edgewater Pizza is one of the most popular pizza places in town!
If you want a truly wonderful pizza experience, definitely check out Edgewater Pizza. I guarantee it’ll be one of the best pizza experiences you’ve ever had!
#10 Aumm Aumm
- Nice tourist spot
- Has insanely good dessert
- Serves alcohol (and hard liquor!)
- Has some vegetarian options
The moment I walked in the door, I could tell that this place had something special – from its friendly atmosphere to the huge selection of pizzas on offer. The menu included everything from thin crust to deep dish slabs, as well as a plethora of toppings and sauces to choose from.
The pizza I chose – a classic margherita pie with fresh basil leaves – was truly outstanding! The crust was soft and crunchy in all the right places, and the tomato sauce was flavourful and intense. As for the cheese, it was deliciously creamy with just enough saltiness to bring out the sweetness of the tomatoes. And let’s not forget the basil – it added a lovely herbal note that tied all the flavors together perfectly!
Overall, I can confidently say that Aumm Aumm is home to some of the best pizza in Edgewater NJ! If you’re looking for an unforgettable pizza experience, there’s no better place than here!
#11 Rasco’s
The pizza here is out of this world. It has the perfect thin and crispy crust, and the toppings are cooked to perfection. Plus, their homemade marinara sauce takes it to a whole new level!
The service is always friendly and helpful. The staff are helpful with suggestions on different types of pizzas, and they’ll even let you sample before committing to your order.
In addition to their great pizza, Rasco’s also offers some delicious salads and sides. Their house made garlic knots were especially tasty!
If you want the best pizza in Edgewater NJ, then head down to Rasco’s – you won’t regret it!
If you’re willing to go an extra 1 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Paramus!
#12 Pizza King
- Great place to watch sports
- Offers dessert
The atmosphere at Pizza King is warm and inviting. The staff was friendly, the dining area was nicely decorated, and the music was a great touch.
Now onto the pizza itself. As a seasoned food critic, I can honestly say that it was nothing short of sublime! The crust had a nice crunch to it and the flavor was spot-on. The sauce was flavorful and blended perfectly with the cheese. Best of all, the toppings were fresh and savory!
To top it off, their drinks selection is top notch too! From craft beers to Italian sodas – they’ve got something for everyone’s taste buds. I especially enjoyed their sangria which paired wonderfully with my delicious pizza.
Overall, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Edgewater NJ make sure to check out Pizza King for an unforgettable experience!
