Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Ocean City Nj Boardwalk (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in New Jersey

Best Pizza in Ocean City Nj Boardwalk (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

629 Views

I recently spent some time in Ocean City, sampling 12 different pizzerias on the boardwalk. From classic pizzas to more creative pies, I explored every corner of the boardwalk looking for the best pizza this beach town has to offer.

My journey was full of surprises and delicious discoveries, all with a humorous and lighthearted tone. I’m excited to share my findings with you and help you decide which restaurant is worthy of your next trip to Ocean City Nj Boardwalk for a pizza treat.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New Jersey

#1 Chelsea Pizza

From the moment I arrived at Chelsea Pizza, I was instantly greeted by an incredibly friendly staff. The decor inside was modern yet cozy and inviting, with the aroma of freshly baked pizzas wafting through the air.

The pizza itself was fresh and delicious – my only regret is that I couldn’t try more kinds! Every slice was perfectly cooked to perfection, with a thin yet crunchy crust, loaded with gooey cheese and perfectly seasoned toppings. The variety of topping choices makes it easy to find something for everyone’s tastes.

But what really sets Chelsea Pizza apart from other pizza places is their commitment to quality ingredients – you can definitely taste the difference! They use only the freshest vegetables and cheeses, never skimping on portion size or flavor. Plus, they offer a great selection of craft beers and other beverages – perfect for washing down each delicious bite.

In conclusion, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Ocean City NJ, Chelsea Pizza is your place! With top-notch ingredients, great customer service, and some seriously tasty pies – it’s no wonder it is one of this city’s most popular destinations.

If you’re willing to go an extra 10 miles, you can get to 21 more pizza places in Brigantine!

#2 Roma Pizza

I recently stopped by this quaint pizzeria and was blown away by the variety of menu options. Not only did they have delicious, authentic Italian-style pizzas, but they also had a kid’s menu and some vegetarian options for those looking for something a bit different. Of course, who could forget about dessert? Roma Pizza offered several delicious desserts to choose from to pair along with their impressive selection of beverages.

What stood out to me the most at Roma Pizza was their helpful and friendly staff. From the moment I walked in they treated me like family – it made my visit even more enjoyable! As a food critic I often go places that have great atmosphere but not-so-great service, so it was nice to get such great hospitality here.

My only complaint is that they don’t offer delivery, although there are benefits to eating in – you get to enjoy their cozy restaurants atmosphere and make sure your food is cooked perfectly every time! In any case, if you’re searching for the best pizza in Ocean City NJ make sure you don’t pass up on Roma Pizza – you won’t regret it!

#3 Bennie’s Bread & Italian Market

I recently had the pleasure of visiting this charming establishment and I can happily report that I was not disappointed. On walking in, I was immediately taken aback by the delicious aroma of fresh baked bread and herbs which wafted through the air.

The decor is typical of an Italian market: rustic and homey with charming touches here and there. The atmosphere gives off a warm, comforting vibe, like you’re visiting a family member’s kitchen.

And now to the star of my review – the pizza! With one bite, I could tell why Bennie’s has been highly acclaimed by locals as well as critics alike – it’s simply delicious! The crust is perfectly thin yet crispy, while the toppings are just right; not too much or too little. Even if pizza isn’t your thing, you’ll love the variety of other Italian dishes on offer – from pasta to calzones and more!

My kids were delighted when I took them to Bennie’s for dinner; they devoured their pizza with glee! And with prices that won’t break the bank, it makes for a great value meal for families on a budget.

All in all, Bennie’s Bread & Italian Market is definitely worth trying out if you’re ever in Ocean City NJ looking for some of the best pizza around. You won’t be disappointed!

#4 Three Brothers From Italy Pizza

The pizza is mouthwateringly delicious and you can choose from vegetarian options which is a plus. The atmosphere is inviting, making it a great tourist spot to stop on your travels.

I do have one complaint: they do not offer delivery! That being said, the quality of the pizza more than makes up for this minor inconvenience.

I’ve been all around the world tasting pizza, and Three Brothers From Italy Pizza stands above the crowd when it comes to taste and presentation. I highly recommend this restaurant – and make sure you bring an appetite because their slices are HUGE!

#5 Preps Pizzeria & Dairy Bar

The pizza was perfection, with the perfect amount of sauce, cheese, and toppings. The crust was cooked to a golden-brown perfection and went perfectly with the flavors of the toppings. Even better, the staff was incredibly friendly and helpful during my visit!

The restaurant itself is also quite charming. It’s decked out in classic diner decor that gave it an old-school feel. The bar stool seating always made it easy to grab a quick bite or have dinner with friends!

I’m telling you— Preps Pizzeria & Dairy Bar is definitely one of the best places for pizza in Ocean City NJ! If you’re ever in town, be sure to pay this place a visit— I guarantee you won’t be disappointed!

#6 Mario’s Pizzeria & Restaurant

I had the pleasure of trying several items on their menu and I must say, they do pizza right! Their thin crust is simply delicious, made with fresh ingredients and always cooked to perfection. The sauce is rich and flavorful with just the right amount of spices. We even tried a few specialty pizzas that were outstanding, like their signature Pizza alla Romana.

Besides pizza, they also offer an impressive selection of Italian dishes such as lasagna and linguine. Everything we had was cooked perfectly and the portion sizes were generous. Even the salads were creative and tasty!

The restaurant itself has a cozy atmosphere with friendly staff that are eager to make sure you have a great experience. Lastly, the prices are reasonable compared to other restaurants in Ocean City NJ which makes Mario’s Pizzeria & Restaurant one of my top picks for dining out!

If you’re willing to go an extra 10 miles, you can get to 36 more pizza places in Atlantic City!

#7 Manco & Manco Pizza

The restaurant itself is a bit of a no-frills establishment, but their pizza more than makes up for it. Upon my first visit, I decided to go with the classic margherita, and the flavor was out of this world! The crust was perfectly crispy and chewy, the marinara had just the right amount of tanginess and garlic, and the cheese melted in my mouth.

The toppings were also spot on: The pepperoni had a delightful spice that sparked all over my tongue, while the mushroom provided a subtle earthiness that perfectly complemented the other flavors.

I even tried their dessert pizza which was an absolute delight. It featured creamy dark chocolate chips, lightly glazed strawberries and toasted almonds on a sweet dough crust. Needless to say it was delicious!

All in all, I’d recommend Manco & Manco Pizza to anyone who wants some of the best pizza in Ocean City NJ – you won’t be disappointed!

#8 Express Pizza & Subs

I can confidently say that this is one of the best pizza places I’ve ever visited. The pizza crust was perfect—light and crispy, with a nice layer of sauce and cheese. The ingredients were all fresh and flavorful, too.

And the toppings! Oh my! Express Pizza & Subs had a wonderful selection, from classic pepperoni to pineapple, bacon, and even some interesting combinations like artichoke hearts, broccoli rabe and feta cheese. Every topping tasted amazing.

The subs at Express Pizza & Subs were delicious as well. You can’t go wrong with their Italian Cold Cut Sandwich—a real winner!

On top of all that delicious food, the customer service here was outstanding—friendly smiles, helpful staff who went above and beyond to make sure our orders were accurate and ready on time.

All in all, I’m convinced that Express Pizza & Subs has some of the best pizza in Ocean City NJ. If you’re ever there looking for a great slice or sandwich, definitely stop by this place!

#9 Sack O’ Pizza & Pasta

I arrived at this classic pizza joint on a Sunday afternoon, and I was immediately taken aback by the charming atmosphere. The warm red and yellow vines on the walls were inviting, and the smell of fresh-baked dough immediately made my mouth water.

The staff was friendly and hospitable, which made my experience even better. And when it came time for me to try the pizza, I knew I was in for a treat.

The crust was light yet crisp and the toppings were plentiful – from the standard pepperoni to an amazing selection of creative gourmet toppings including Argentinian chimichurri sauce and feta cheese! Each bite was bursting with flavor.

And it wasn’t just about the pizza – their pasta dishes were excellent too! The fettuccine alfredo was creamy, cheesy, and had just the right amount of garlic; while their lasagna was layered with perfection – not too soggy like some places – adding an extra element of texture.

To top it all off, Sack O’ Pizza & Pasta offers one of the best deals in town: two slices of pizza and a soda for only $5!

If you’re looking for great pizza without breaking your budget, look no further than Sack O’ Pizza & Pasta in Ocean City NJ! It’s definitely one of my new favorites!

#10 Randazzo Pizzeria & Family Restaurant

I’m a pizza connoisseur, so I know good pizza when I taste it. After trying the brick oven pizzas at Randazzo, I can confidently say that they make some of the best pies in all of Ocean City. The crust is like a perfectly baked Italian breadstick with just enough crunch and chewiness to offer a fantastic texture. And the sauces and toppings range from classic to creative, offering something for everyone.

What really sets Randazzo apart, though, is their unique ingredients. From tasty chipotle ranch-infused crumbled sausage to roasted garlic and fresh spinach, there’s always something new and delicious on the menu! Plus, their prices are very reasonable considering the quality of food you get—it’s truly a great value.

All in all, if you’re ever in Ocean City NJ looking for an amazing pizza experience, Randazzo Pizzeria & Family Restaurant should be your first choice. I guarantee you won’t be disappointed!

#11 Manco & Manco Pizza 12th Street

I arrived at the restaurant, and I was immediately taken aback by the lively atmosphere and bustling staff. This is definitely a place that respects pizza-making as an art form!

The menu was filled with all kinds of options, from classic Italian pizzas to creative new creations. I opted for the “Forza Italia” pizza, which featured a flavorful combination of savory Italian sausage, roasted onion and mushrooms, tomato sauce, and mozzarella cheese. Of course, no great pizza can be complete without carefully sourced ingredients – the crust was perfectly thin and crispy.

The greatest testament to Manco & Manco’s commitment to quality was in the taste – my pizza was absolutely delicious! The flavors combined flawlessly, giving me a delightful experience with every bite.

In short: Manco & Manco Pizza 12th Street offers some of the best pizza in Ocean City NJ that you’re sure to love! If you’re after a great slice of pie, this is the place to go!

If you’re willing to go an extra 11 miles, you can get to 16 more pizza places in Avalon!

#12 Piccini Wood Fired Brick Oven Pizza

The atmosphere here is great. The restaurant has a rustic, cozy vibe that is perfect for enjoying a slice or two. Every table is made from industry-grade wood that lends an authentic feel to the entire place.

When it comes to the pizza, I have nothing but good things to say. The thin and crispy crust complemented by a slightly charred taste was definitely something I’ve never experienced before. Additionally, they use high-quality ingredients on top of their pizzas which adds complexity and depth to the flavor profile while still allowing the doughy goodness to shine through.

The staff here is also wonderful; everyone is friendly and helpful in making sure you get your order quickly and accurately.

All in all, Piccini Wood Fired Brick Oven Pizza is definitely one of the best places in Ocean City for pizza. It won’t disappoint!