Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Oklahoma City (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Oklahoma

Best Pizza in Oklahoma City (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

146 Views

After sampling over a dozen pizzas from various eateries across the city, I’ve settled on the top-rated pizza places for all to enjoy. From thin crust to something a bit more substantial, there’s something here for everyone who loves great pizza.

This list is the result of countless hours of investigative work, along with ample helpings of delicious slices. I hope you get as much enjoyment out of eating these pizzas as I did in researching them! Read on for my picks for Oklahoma City’s best pizza.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Oklahoma

#1 Heavy D’s pizzaria

The crust is perfect – crispy on the outside, yet fluffy on the inside. And when it comes to toppings, Heavy D’s really knows how to pile them on! From pepperoni and olives to spinach and artichoke, my taste buds were in for a real treat.

But what really stands out about this place isn’t just the quality of ingredients, it’s also the atmosphere. The staff is incredibly friendly and makes you feel right at home as soon as you walk through the door. Plus, they have an impressive selection of craft beers to choose from that pair perfectly with your slice.

If you’re looking for a pizza spot in Oklahoma City that delivers both flavor and fun, then Heavy D’s pizzaria is the place for you!

If you’re willing to go an extra 13 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Norman!

#2 Empire Slice House – Plaza

The atmosphere was great for tourists, and I loved being able to sit around with a cold beer or hard liquor and watch sports. The menu had just enough vegetarian options to please everyone in my party.

My favorite part of the restaurant was the pizza, of course! There were so many delicious flavors and crusts to choose from – spicy margarita, classic pepperoni, BBQ chicken, you name it! Every slice was cooked perfectly with a light crisp on the bottom that just melted in your mouth.

It’s too bad they don’t offer delivery – otherwise I’d be ordering it every night! But that’s OK because Empire Slice House is such a great destination spot. Not only can you get excellent pizza here, but they also have dessert. Talk about indulging yourself!

All things considered, Empire Slice House – Plaza deserves a five-star rating for the best pizza in Oklahoma City. Highly recommended!

#3 The Hall’s Pizza Kitchen

The first thing I noticed when I arrived was the cozy atmosphere of the restaurant, with dark wood decor and warm lighting. It felt like you were stepping into a pizza parlor in Italy!

I decided to start off my experience with one of their classic pizzas – a thin crust margherita with mozzarella, basil, and extra virgin olive oil. The crust was light and crispy, the sauce flavorful and aromatic, and the cheese melted perfectly in my mouth!

Next, I tried The Hall’s own specialty – the “Speedy Gonzales” with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, and jalapenos. This was definitely a spicy slice – full of flavor that left me wanting more!

Other house specialties include Buffalo chicken pizza with hot sauce and blue cheese, a vegan-friendly mushroom medley option, and a “Big Kahuna” loaded with shrimp, capers, and sun-dried tomatoes.

Overall, I think The Hall’s Pizza Kitchen is an amazing place for great pizza at an affordable price. From traditional options to unique creations – there’s something for everyone! After dining here multiple times now, I can confidently say it really is the best pizza in Oklahoma City!

#4 Falcone’s Pizzeria

The crust is the perfect balance of crunchy and chewy, with a hint of garlic that really enhances the flavor. The sauce is very flavorful, with just the right amount of sweetness. As for the cheese – it’s absolutely delicious – creamy, melty, and full of flavor.

Speaking of toppings, Falcone’s offers an extensive selection, including classic favorites like pepperoni, sausage and mushrooms as well as unique creations like basil pesto and vegan options. No matter what you choose, each ingredient is fresh and flavorful.

Falcone’s also offers a variety of specialty pizzas that showcase their skill in combining flavors. I highly recommend their signature “Oklahoma City Special” – it’s simply sublime!

In conclusion, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Oklahoma City (or anywhere!), Falcone’s Pizzeria should be your first stop!

#5 Eagle One Pizza

The first time I visited, I was blown away by the deliciousness of their pepperoni pizza. The crust was light and perfectly cooked, the sauce had a wonderful balance of sweet and spice, and the amount of toppings was outrageous. It was one of the best pizzas I’ve ever tasted!

The other pies were just as impressive. Their Philly cheesesteak pizza features tender steak bits and melted cheese, while their veggie pizza is filled to the brim with colorful, flavorful veggies. The Meat Lovers pizza is a carnivore’s dream come true with sausage, bacon, and several types of cured meats.

But what really sets Eagle One Pizza apart from other places is their unique selection of specialty pizzas. From white pizzas like Alfredo with Garlic to Mexican-style pizzas like Jalapeno Popper Supreme to classic favorites like Margherita, there’s something for everyone here!

And don’t forget about dessert! Their signature S’mores Pizza is especially delicious – it’s got slices of melted marshmallows on top that give it an extra sweetness and crunch. Yum!

At Eagle One Pizza, you can expect quality ingredients and amazing flavors served up in generous portions at great prices. If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Oklahoma City (or anywhere!), be sure to check out Eagle One Pizza!

#6 Hideaway Pizza

The atmosphere was exactly what I expected for such a great restaurant – dark and intimate. The walls were adorned with sports memorabilia, making it the perfect place to watch the game. Plus, they serve alcohol (including hard liquor!), so you can really kick your pizza night up a notch!

The menu had something for everyone – from kids to dieters to vegetarians, there was an option for everyone! Even better, dessert is on the menu too – talk about making one’s evening complete!

The wait staff was friendly and attentive and my meal came out super quickly. All in all, it was a great experience.

Perhaps my only complaint is that Hideaway Pizza doesn’t offer delivery service; otherwise I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend it to anyone looking for the best pizza in Oklahoma City.

#7 Village Pizza

The first thing that I noticed when I walked in was the aroma of freshly made dough, tomato sauce, and cheese; it immediately made my mouth water! The decor was inviting and the staff, who greeted me warmly, all seemed to share a real passion for pizza.

The main attraction for me was the pizza. The menu has something for everyone — a variety of delicious topping combinations as well as some truly unique flavor profiles. My personal favorite was the BBQ Chicken Pizza; the sweetness of the BBQ sauce combined with the savory flavors of chicken and cheese created an unbeatable combination. My companions raved about their selections as well, so we all left satisfied.

A visit to Village Pizza is an absolute must if you want to experience some of the best pizza in Oklahoma City. The atmosphere is cozy and friendly, while the food quality is top-notch. There’s no doubt that this place deserves its reputation as one of Oklahoma City’s favorite pizza joints!

#8 Great American Pizza

On my first visit, I was astonished at the breadth and quality of the menu. They had a variety of specialty pizzas, as well as classic recipes like ‘The Works’ and ‘Meat Lover’s’. I went with the ‘Spinach and Feta Pizza,’ which had an amazing combination of flavors that left me wanting another slice!

I also tried some of their sides and desserts, all of which were equally delicious. The garlic knots were amazing, and their homemade cheesecake was to die for.

The atmosphere at Great American Pizza was typical of a great Italian restaurant – friendly and welcoming. The staff was attentive and helpful in deciding which pizza would be best for me. They even let me sample several slices before ordering one!

The price for the pizza was surprisingly reasonable considering it was some of the best pizza I’ve ever tasted! All said and done, I’d definitely recommend Great American Pizza as a top-notch option for anyone in Oklahoma City looking to enjoy some truly delicious pizza. In my opinion, they’re easily the best pizza spot in town!

If you’re willing to go an extra 19 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Edmond!

#9 Eastside Pizza House

I’ve been all over the world, but I’m always happy when I find great, authentic pizza in the US. Eastside Pizza House certainly fits that bill. The pizza here is incredibly delicious and uses only the freshest ingredients. The crust was thin and crispy, and the toppings were so rich and flavorful!

The atmosphere of the place is cozy and comfortable, with a wood-burning oven in the corner that makes it feel like you’re stepping right into Italy! The service is friendly and attentive without being intrusive or overbearing. It’s perfect for anyone looking to grab a quick slice of pizza or sit down for a full meal.

Overall, Eastside Pizza House really stands out from other pizzerias in Oklahoma City by producing some of the best pizza around! If you’re ever in town, definitely make sure to stop by for an unforgettable experience!

#10 Pizzeria Gusto

Sure, they don’t offer delivery but that’s really not a big deal – this place is worth the trip. You can start with a beer or a hard liquor and cool down in the relaxed atmosphere.

As far as the food goes, their menu has quite a few vegetarian options – which are all quite tasty! But for those of us who enjoy meat-filled pizzas, worry not – those are also plenty delicious. The crust was just perfect – crispy and delectable.

Finally, if you have any room left after your meal, try their insanely good dessert. From what I heard, it changes regularly but whatever it is will be worth it!

I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend Pizzeria Gusto for anyone looking for some great pizza in Oklahoma City – you won’t regret it!

#11 Hideaway Pizza

From their kid’s menu to their vegetarian options, they’ve got something for everyone. And if you’re interested in having a few drinks while you eat, they serve alcohol and hard liquor–a huge plus!

Hideaway is also a great tourist spot. The atmosphere is fun and upbeat, perfect for a night out or watching your favorite sports team. Plus, they offer desserts like tiramisu and cannoli, which make the experience even more special.

The only negative I can think of at Hideaway Pizza is that they don’t deliver. But that doesn’t take away from the quality of their pizza–it’s still some of the best in Oklahoma City, hands down!

#12 Luigi’s Pizza

The atmosphere was inviting and welcoming, and I could tell right away that Luigi’s was passionate about creating pizzas with only the freshest ingredients. When my order arrived, the pizza was hot – and delicious! The crust was perfectly crunchy on the outside and soft on the inside, and the layer of cheese melted to perfection. Even more impressive than the taste were all of the topping options available; each one looked even better than the last!

I found Luigi’s Pizza to be attentive to their customers’ needs; when I requested extra sauce for my pizza they happily obliged. Plus, they offer delivery, so I never have to worry about a late night longing for some of their scrumptious slices.

Overall, I would give Luigi’s Pizza five stars! If you’re ever in Oklahoma City looking for great pizza – this is definitely a spot not to miss!

Best Deep Dish Pizza – Birra Birra Craft Pizzeria

Now, I’m not saying I’ve tried every deep dish pizza in the city, but I’ve sampled enough cheesy, saucy goodness to know when I’ve stumbled upon something special. And boy, did I stumble upon a goldmine at Birra Birra.

First of all, let’s talk about the crust. This thing is a masterpiece. It’s buttery, it’s flaky, it’s crispy on the outside and perfectly doughy on the inside. I couldn’t help but do a little happy dance after my first bite. It’s like a symphony of dough and delight in my mouth.

And the toppings, oh the toppings! They don’t skimp here, that’s for sure. I loaded mine up with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, and every other delicious thing they had to offer. Each bite was a flavor explosion, a party in my taste buds. I could practically hear them singing Hallelujah!

Now, let’s address the elephant in the room. Yes, deep dish pizza is known for being a gut-buster. But guess what? I didn’t care. I was in pizza heaven, and a few extra pounds were a small price to pay for such king-sized satisfaction. Besides, with every bite, I could feel my metabolism going into overdrive, preparing itself for the inevitable food coma.

So, if you find yourself in oklahoma city and craving some deep dish pizza, don’t even bother looking elsewhere. Birra Birra Craft Pizzeria is the place to go. Trust me, I’ve been around the pizza block, and this place is a little slice of cheesy, saucy heaven.

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Pizzeria Gusto

Let me start by saying that Pizzeria Gusto knows how to keep their patrons happy. How, you ask? Booze. Glorious booze. Not only do they serve alcohol, but they also have hard liquor! It’s like they know the secret to making a perfect pizza is a little liquid courage. As a food critic, I appreciate a place that understands my need for a well-rounded dining experience.

Now, let’s talk about their pizza. The thin crust at Pizzeria Gusto is so thin, it’s practically invisible. I swear, it’s like eating pizza on a cracker. And you know what? It’s absolutely delicious. The crust is crispy, the cheese is gooey, and the toppings are fresh and plentiful. They even have some vegetarian options for my non-meat eating friends. Way to go, Pizzeria Gusto, for being inclusive to all pizza lovers!

But wait, there’s more! Pizzeria Gusto has the best dessert you can find in town. Their tiramisu is a divine revelation. It’s like an Italian grandmother sneaked into the kitchen and sprinkled it with magic. I would come here just for the dessert alone.

The only downside to Pizzeria Gusto is that they don’t offer delivery. I mean, come on! I’m a food critic, not an Olympic athlete. Sometimes I just want to enjoy their mouthwatering pizza from the comfort of my couch in my sweatpants. But hey, I guess it’s a good thing they’re located in a nice tourist spot. At least I have an excuse to put on real pants when I visit.

Best Wood Fired Pizza – Upper Crust Wood Fired Pizza

Let me just start by saying that Upper Crust Wood Fired Pizza knows how to make a pie that’ll make your taste buds explode with joy. As soon as I walked in, the delicious scent of fresh dough being baked in the wood-fired oven hit me like a punch in the face, but in a good way.

The menu is filled with so many mouthwatering options, it’s like trying to choose a favorite child. Should I go for the classic Margherita or take a walk on the wild side with the Bacon and Gorgonzola? Decisions, decisions! Thankfully, the staff was super friendly and patient as I weighed my delicious options.

When my pizza arrived, my eyes widened like a kid in a candy store. The crust was perfectly crispy and had just the right amount of char from the wood-fired oven. I could tell that each ingredient was carefully selected, because every bite was bursting with flavor. And let me tell you, I’ve had my fair share of pizza, but none quite like this.

Now, I should probably mention the huge plus of Upper Crust Wood Fired Pizza: the atmosphere. The place has a rustic, yet modern charm that makes you feel like you’ve stepped into a little slice of pizza heaven. And the best part? It’s not pretentious at all. You can come in wearing your sweatpants and a sauce stain on your shirt, and still feel like you belong.

So, whether you’re a pizza connoisseur like me or just a casual pizza lover, do yourself a favor and head to Upper Crust Wood Fired Pizza. Your taste buds will thank you, and your stomach will be forever grateful. Trust me, it’s a slice above the rest!