Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Sarasota FL (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Florida

Best Pizza in Sarasota FL (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

444 Views

I’m on a quest to find the best pizza in Sarasota, and I’m about to share my findings with you! I set out to try 12 different pizza places in the city and after tasting slices from each one, it’s time to rate them on a scale of one-to-five.

If you want something that will hit the spot and make your taste buds tingle, then read on for my fun and lighthearted reviews.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Florida

#1 RomanSQ | artisan pizza

What sets RomanSQ | artisan pizza apart from other pizzerias is their unique spin on an age-old classic. From the care and creativity that goes into their dough and sauces to the wide selection of vegetarian options, RomanSQ | artisan pizza has something for everyone.

The atmosphere at RomanSQ | artisan pizza is also top notch. The staff is friendly, the decor is welcoming and the restaurant itself makes for a nice tourist spot. Plus, they serve alcohol so you can enjoy a beer or wine with your meal!

The only downside is that they don’t offer delivery which can be a bit of a bummer. But in my opinion, it’s worth taking the trip down to the restaurant just for their delicious pizza.

All in all, I’d highly recommend checking out RomanSQ | artisan pizza if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Sarasota FL. You won’t be disappointed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 13 miles, you can get to 24 more pizza places in Lakewood Ranch!

#2 La Mucca Ballerina

The first thing that caught my eye was the unique decor. From the cow-patterned wallpaper to the vibrant colors and cozy seating, it creates a warm and inviting atmosphere. The staff are incredibly friendly and helpful, ensuring that your experience is nothing short of perfect.

When it comes down to the pizza, I was absolutely blown away! They have a wide selection of toppings and flavors to choose from, creating an endless array of delicious combinations. Every slice was cooked perfectly – thin and crispy without being too greasy or heavy. The sauce is excellent; just enough zestiness without overpowering the flavors.

I’m not exaggerating when I say this is some of the best pizza I’ve ever had in my life! If you’re in Sarasota FL and you’re looking for a great place to grab some pizza, La Mucca Ballerina is a must-visit spot!

#3 Village Pizzas By Emma

On my recent trip, I had the pleasure of trying their signature Sicilian pizza, and it was out of this world. The crust was crunchy and chewy at the same time, the sauce had a perfect balance between sweet and savory, and the cheese was gooey and delicious.

The atmosphere at Village Pizzas By Emma is just as amazing as their food. The staff are friendly, fun, and always eager to offer suggestions on what to order. I also appreciated that they have vegan options available for those with dietary restrictions.

If you’re looking for a great spot to grab a slice of pizza in Sarasota FL (or if you’re just passing through), I’d highly recommend checking out Village Pizzas By Emma! It’s hands-down the best pizza I’ve found in town!

#4 Atmosphere

The atmosphere of the restaurant is casual yet inviting. The walls are adorned with pictures of the owner’s family, giving it a homey vibe. The staff was friendly and personable, making my experience even more enjoyable.

The pizza was incredible! I had the Peggy’s Supreme and it was delicious. It had a perfectly thin and crispy crust that held up to the toppings well. The cheese was flavorful and gooey, while the pepperoni and sausage were perfectly cooked.

I also tasted their lasagna, loaded with ricotta and mozzarella cheese, Italian meats, herbs, and spices. It was amazing! Not only did it have great flavor but all the layers stayed together nicely when served on the plate.

All in all, Atmosphere is definitely worth checking out if you’re ever in Sarasota FL looking for some amazing pizza!

#5 Lucile Pizza & Wine Bar

The dough was light and fluffy, with just the right amount of char from the oven – it was genuinely delicious. The toppings were fresh, flavorful, and abundant. Even though I had to wait a few minutes for my pizza to be served, it was well worth it!

And then there’s the wine selection – heavenly! They had both reds and whites that complimented any pizza perfectly. I especially enjoyed some of their specialty wines – a Merlot that paired perfectly with one of their signature pizzas.

To top things off, the service at Lucile Pizza & Wine Bar was friendly and helpful. The servers knew the menu inside and out, so they were able to recommend dishes that would please my palate.

So if you’re in Sarasota FL and looking for great pizza (and wine!), make sure you make a stop at Lucile Pizza & Wine Bar – it’ll be worth your while!

#6 Origin Craft Beer & Pizza Cafe

I’ve been to some highly-rated pizza places, but none of them can stand up to the delicious pies that Origin Craft Beer & Pizza Cafe serves. The crust is perfectly crisp and chewy, the ingredients are fresh and flavorful, and the sauce is just spot on.

Not only do they make some of the best pizza in Sarasota FL, they also have a great selection of craft beer on tap. I’m partial to their IPAs and lagers, which pair especially well with their pizzas. And don’t get me started on the desserts they offer! Their tiramisu was easily one of the best I’ve ever tasted!

If you’re looking for a great pizza experience in Sarasota FL, don’t miss out on Origin Craft Beer & Pizza Cafe. You won’t regret it!

#7 The Fountain Kitchen & Wine Bar

The pizza dough here is thin and crispy yet thick enough to give you the perfect bite. Toppings are generous, with a variety of vegetarian options – great for everyone in the family.

Their desserts are something else! Chocolate lovers rejoice – The Fountain has some insanely good dessert choices. There’s no way you can leave this place without having some of their sweet creations!

The atmosphere of this restaurant is also pretty great; it’s a nice spot for tourists who want to experience some local Sarasota pizzas. Oh, and did I mention that they serve alcohol?

Unfortunately, there’s one downside – no delivery service. This means that you must visit their restaurant in person if you want to get your hands on the best pizza in Sarasota FL. But trust me, it’s worth the trip!

If you’re willing to go an extra 13 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Venice!

#8 Ripfire Pizza & BBQ

The restaurant itself is a cozy spot with a warm atmosphere. The front of the house staff was friendly and made us feel right at home.

When it came time to order, I decided to take their advice and try the BBQ Chicken Pizza. BOY, WAS IT AMAZING. The pizza was full of flavor and their house-made sauce really brought out the tangy BBQ flavor of the chicken topping! The pizza crust was cooked perfectly, just a little crispy on the outside with a soft chew inside – exactly how I like it!

I will definitely be recommending Ripfire Pizza & BBQ as one of my top picks for best pizza in Sarasota FL! If you’re in town, do yourself a favor and stop by for some delicious eats. Trust me when I say you won’t regret it!

#9 Demetrio’s Restaurant & Pizza

From the moment I entered the restaurant, the warm atmosphere and smells of freshly baked pizza set an inviting and comfortable tone. Then when I tasted my first bite, it was clear why this place has such a great reputation for amazing pizza!

The crust was crispy on the outside, yet soft and fluffy on the inside–just as a perfect pizza crust should be! And, each topping was perfectly balanced with just enough sauce, cheese, meats and vegetables to give it a delightful flavor. It had been a while since I had tried a pizza that could satisfy all my taste buds in one bite, but Demetrio’s certainly delivered!

All in all, it’s clear to me why Demetrio’s Restaurant & Pizza is considered to be some of the best pizza in Sarasota FL. The friendly staff and excellent food make this place something special. If you’re ever in town looking for delicious pizza–look no further than Demetrio’s!

#10 Rico’s Pizzeria

The atmosphere was great, with cheerful staff and an inviting, cozy atmosphere. The decor had a definite Italian theme; lots of cool posters and art.

When I tasted the pizza itself, I knew that all my travels had been worth it! This was by far the best pizza I’ve ever had outside of Italy! The crust was perfectly thin and crispy – not too much, but just enough. The sauce was flavorful and slightly sweet; it reminded me of my last trip to Rome. The cheese was fresh and flavorful – definitely worth every bite.

It wasn’t just about the pizza either; Rico’s also offers delicious salads, sandwiches, and appetizers to accompany your meal. Plus, there’s a great selection of wine to pair with all those delicious slices!

All in all, Rico’s Pizzeria is definitely one of the best places for pizza in Sarasota FL. If you’re looking for great food and an enjoyable atmosphere – this is it!

#11 Rico’s Pizzeria

The atmosphere here is impeccable. It’s almost like I’m in downtown Rome! From the decorations to the staff, the vibes are consistently welcoming and the authenticity shines through in everything they do.

The pizza crust is perfection – thin and crunchy with just enough cheese on top. They make all their sauces fresh, using only the freshest ingredients and traditional recipes for an amazing flavor experience every time I visit. The size of their pizzas is generous as well – big enough for a party or large family gathering. I can’t even begin to tell you how delicious this pizza tastes.

One of my favorite items on the menu is their pepperoni calzone – it’s like biting into a pillow of gooey goodness! Perfectly seasoned and piled high with toppings, this dish stands out among Rico’s other creations.

Rico’s Pizzeria has earned its title as one of the best pizzerias in Sarasota FL, and I would strongly recommend it to any pizza lover out there!

#12 New York Slice Company

The atmosphere is great, with a modern yet cozy feel that makes you feel right at home. The menu has something for everyone, whether you’re looking for a classic cheese and pepperoni or an adventurous take on vegan pizza. And the pies they serve up? Out of this world!

The crust is perfectly cooked, with just the right amount of crunch, and the sauce is flavorful without being overly acidic or sweet. Toppings are plentiful – from their famous sausage and onion to olives, jalapenos, mushrooms, spinach, and so much more! Plus, the generous portion sizes mean there’s plenty to go around.

In short: New York Slice Company serves up some of the best pizza in Sarasota FL. If you’re in the mood for extraordinary pie, this is one spot you won’t want to miss!

Best Deep Dish Pizza – Joey D’s Chicago Style Eatery & Pizzeria

The moment I walked into Joey D’s, I knew I was in for a treat. The aroma of bubbling cheese and sizzling toppings filled the air, and my stomach rumbled in anticipation. As I sat down, the overly-enthusiastic waiter, who seemed as if he was auditioning for a role in a pizza-themed Broadway musical, welcomed me like a long-lost relative. His energy was contagious, and soon I found myself tapping my feet to an imaginary pizza beat.

I decided to go for the classic deep dish pizza, which arrived at my table like a towering masterpiece. The crust was as thick as a brick, but oh-so-flaky and buttery. Each bite felt like a warm embrace from a doughy cloud. And let’s not forget about the cheese! It stretched and pulled like a cheesy acrobat, and the tangy tomato sauce added a delightful punch.

As I devoured the slice, I couldn’t help but have a moment of revelation. This pizza was so thick, it could double as a flotation device on a lazy river! I pondered the possibility of Joey D’s partnering with a water park to serve pizza life rafts – talk about innovation! But I digress.

Overall, Joey D’s Chicago Style Eatery & Pizzeria is a true gem in Sarasota. It’s the type of place that will put a smile on your face and expand your waistline. If you’re hankering for the best deep dish pizza in town, look no further – Joey D’s is where it’s at. Just don’t forget to bring your appetite and a sense of humor because this place is as quirky as it is delicious.

Best Thin Crust Pizza – IL Panificio Pizzeria

Let’s start with the benefits. First of all, they serve alcohol. And let’s be honest, what better way to enjoy a truly thin and crispy piece of heaven than with a cold beer or a glass of wine? It’s pure bliss. Secondly, they offer dessert! Who doesn’t love a sweet treat after devouring a whole pizza? IL Panificio understands that pizza and dessert are a match made in heaven and they deliver on that front.

Another great thing about this place is that it doubles as a nice tourist spot. The ambiance is rustic and charming, and it’s located in the heart of the city, making it a perfect stop for both locals and visitors. You can enjoy your delicious pizza while soaking in the sights and sounds of the bustling city.

Now, let’s address the downsides. IL Panificio does not accept reservations. I mean, seriously? Do they not know how much people love their pizza? It’s like they’re asking for a mob of hungry patrons to storm their doors, desperate for a table. But hey, I guess they like to keep things spontaneous. So, my advice would be to go early or be prepared to wait, because trust me, it’s worth it.

In conclusion, IL Panificio Pizzeria is my go-to spot for the best thin crust pizza in sarasota. The combination of great pizza, alcohol, and dessert, along with its prime location, makes it a must-visit for any pizza lover. Just make sure you have some patience and a growling stomach when you go, because this place can get crowded. Happy eating!