Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Allentown PA (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Pennsylvania

Best Pizza in Allentown PA (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

293 Views

I’ve sampled a dozen of the best pizza places in the area and I’m now ready to fill your belly with all the pleasant details. So, grab a slice of your favourite pizza topping and settle in for my complete rundown on Allentown’s best pies.

Come along as we venture on a cheesy journey together to discover who serves up the most delicious pizza in town. And don’t forget to bring your appetite!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Pennsylvania

#1 Mama’s Famous Pizza and Grill

The first thing I noticed when entering the restaurant was its cozy atmosphere and friendly staff. The walls were covered with family photos and memorabilia, making it feel like home.

Next came the food, and Mama’s Famous Pizza is a definite winner! The crust was cooked perfectly, not too thin or thick, just right for the perfect slice. The cheese had the perfect amount of stretchiness and flavor. And the toppings? All fresh from their very own garden!

The best part about Mama’s Famous Pizza is that they offer several vegan options as well – something you don’t normally see from pizza places. They even have gluten-free pizzas for those with allergies.

I’m convinced that this place offers some of the best pizza in Allentown PA! So if you’re ever in town, be sure to stop by Mama’s Famous Pizza and Grill – you won’t regret it!

If you’re willing to go an extra 4 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Allentown!

#2 Delicioso Pizza & Subs

The crust was perfectly crunchy, the sauce was sweet and savory and the toppings were full of flavor. I had the classic four-cheese with pepperoni which was delectable. I also tried the veggie pie and it was equally delicious!

The atmosphere at Delicioso Pizza & Subs is a pleasant one; you can see right into the kitchen where they are making the pizza. The staff is friendly and welcoming, certainly doing their best to make your experience a good one.

I can’t say enough good things about Delicioso Pizza & Subs! As far as I’m concerned, they’re producing some of the best pizza in Allentown PA. If you have an opportunity to visit, do it! You won’t be disappointed.

#3 The Crust Pizzeria And Restaurant

The first thing that drew me in was the smell of freshly made dough wafting through the air as I entered. The interior is inviting and cozy, with a modern vibe and plenty of seating for large groups.

When it comes to the food, the pizza here is simply divine. Their thin-crust pies are bursting with flavor from the out-of-this-world sauce, the generous toppings, and the perfectly melted cheese. I sampled several different varieties and each one was a winner – my favorite being the White Truffle & Prosciutto pizza. The crust was cooked to perfection and had just enough crunch to make every bite enjoyable.

I have to say, overall The Crust Pizzeria And Restaurant is top notch! Not only do they serve up some of the best pizza in Allentown PA, they also have premium beer and wine on tap which adds an extra layer of sophistication to their menu. With friendly staff and excellent service, this place is not to be missed!

#4 Giovanni’s Pizza

I arrived with expectations high and I was not disappointed. The restaurant is inviting, from the lively Italian music in the air to the cozy atmosphere created by the warm colors used throughout.

The menu was extensive, with a wide selection of signature pizzas as well as the option to customize your own! I chose their signature Margherita pizza and it did not disappoint. The thin crust was perfectly cooked with a crunchy texture on the outside and a chewy interior. The tomato sauce had just enough tanginess and spiciness that it didn’t overpower the delicious cheese or herbs. It was one of the best Margherita pizzas I have ever had!

The staff was friendly and attentive, making sure my meal was exactly what I wanted. They even went out of their way to make me feel welcome when they learned that I was visiting from out of town.

Overall, Giovanni’s Pizza is no doubt one of the best pizza places in town, if not in all of Pennsylvania!

#5 Jack’s Pizza

The pizza crust is thin and crispy, with just the right amount of buttery flavor. The sauce is robust, slightly sweet and perfectly balanced with a variety of flavorful herbs. The cheese has great flavor and melts perfectly on top of the other ingredients.

And then there’s the toppings! Jack’s Pizza takes their toppings seriously, offering a wide array of fresh and unexpected options. Whether you’re looking for a classic pepperoni or something more innovative like feta cheese and figs, they have it all!

Speaking of innovation, I must mention their dessert pizzas as well. Ever had a donut crust pizza? Well, here’s your chance to try it! Their desserts are decadent, delicious and oftentimes surprising.

But if you’re just looking for good classic pizza, Jack’s definitely hits the spot. I highly recommend checking out this Allentown pizza joint next time you’re in town – you won’t regret it!

#6 House of Pizza

The atmosphere at House of Pizza is quite cozy. While I wasn’t expecting much out of a pizza joint in Allentown, I was pleasantly surprised by the inviting and friendly environment. The staff was so accommodating and always had a smile on their face.

Now, let’s talk about the food. As a self-proclaimed pizza connoisseur, I had high expectations for this place – and they did not disappoint! Each bite was full of flavor; from the crispy crust to the gooey cheese and delicious toppings, it’s clear that House of Pizza knows what they’re doing when it comes to pizza.

I would recommend House of Pizza to anyone looking for some tasty pizza in Allentown PA – it’s definitely worth the trip! From start to finish, it was an enjoyable experience – one that I would be happy to repeat!

#7 NY Stromboli Pizza

I walked into NY Stromboli Pizza, and I could tell immediately that the place had been around for a while. The atmosphere was warm, inviting and smelled delicious!

I decided to try their signature stromboli pizza – it was like nothing else I’ve ever tried before! Cheese was perfectly melted, the crust had just the right amount of crunch and the sauce was simply divine. And let me tell you, if you haven’t tried their garlic knots yet – run don’t walk to get them asap!

Overall, my experience at NY Stromboli Pizza was amazing and I would highly recommend it to anyone looking for some of the best pizza in Allentown PA!

#8 MOD Pizza

The atmosphere was warm and inviting, with a fantastic selection of drinks and snacks to choose from. From craft beers to specialty sodas, I had plenty to choose from that added to the overall experience.

The pizza selection was phenomenal, with all sorts of delectable toppings that made me feel like I was in foodie heaven. Whether it was a classic Margarita or a gourmet combination, each slice tasted like I’d just stepped out of an Italian restaurant. Plus, they were unbelievably generous with their portions – two slices were practically enough for a full meal!

The service at MOD Pizza was exceptional as well; the staff were friendly, attentive and eager to make sure I had an unforgettable experience. The wait staff made sure my drink glass never ran empty and kept checking back to see if I wanted something else. They even gave me helpful pointers on what combinations work best together!

All in all, MOD Pizza is definitely one of the best pizzerias in Allentown PA – it’s well worth a visit if you’re ever in town!

If you’re willing to go an extra 6 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Bethlehem!

#9 Jack’s Slice

The decor of this rustic joint might not be world-class, but the pizza is! Every slice I had was perfectly cooked with just the right amount of cheese and crust. The toppings were fresh and flavorful.

My favorite pizza was the special ‘Jack’s Slice’ which had a great blend of sweet, savory and spicy flavors.

Service is always friendly and fast. The staff will help you choose your pizza if you’re not sure what to order. I would definitely recommend having a few friends over so you can sample as many different slices as possible!

Overall, I’d say Jack’s Slice is a must-visit for anyone looking for some of the best pizza in Allentown PA. They have something for everyone, from classic cheese to unique creations like their ‘Jack’s Slice’. So don’t miss out on this one-of-a-kind pizza place!

#10 Picasso Pizza III

From the moment I stepped through the door, the aroma of freshly cooked pizza instantly hit my nose and I knew I was in for a treat. The inside was quaint and cozy; it almost felt like I was in a small Italian pizzeria.

The menu had plenty of options to choose from, including some vegetarian friendly options. After looking over all my choices, I eventually settled on the Picasso Supreme – it was packed with all sorts of toppings!

When the pizza arrived at my table, I couldn’t help but smile – it looked absolutely delicious! The crust was light and airy, while still maintaining that perfect crispiness that is so highly sought after. The cheese melted in my mouth, and all the ingredients were perfectly proportioned and flavorful.

I have to say, this may be the best pizza I’ve ever tasted! Picasso Pizza III has certainly earned its place as one of Allentown’s most beloved restaurants. Highly recommended for any pizza aficionado out there!

#11 Georgie Porgie’s Pudding & Pies

What can I say about Georgie Porgie’s Pudding & Pies that hasn’t been said already? From the moment you walk in, you’re met with a warm atmosphere and delicious aromas of freshly made pizza. Choose from an array of classic flavors like Margherita, pepperoni or my favorite, the spicy Mediterranean.

The pizza is the real highlight here though. Each pie is cooked to perfection in their wood-fired oven and topped with the freshest ingredients like tomatoes, mozzarella, and basil. The crust is light and fluffy yet crunchy enough to give a satisfying bite. Even better, their prices are more than fair for such high-quality food!

What really sets Georgie Porgie’s apart from other pizzerias in Allentown though is their friendly service; they make you feel like family from start to finish. They also have a fully stocked bar with craft beers and wines to round out your meal.

I’m convinced that Georgie Porgie’s has some of the best pizza in Allentown PA…you just have to try it for yourself!

#12 Dino’s Pizza Teria

First of all, their menu is incredibly varied. From classic pies like pepperoni to specialty creations such as a prosciutto and arugula white pizza, there is something for everyone. That being said, I definitely suggest trying out one of their specialty pizzas – they never fail to impress!

But it’s not just the pizza selection that stands out at Dino’s; it’s also the texture and flavor. The crust is always perfectly baked with just the right amount of crispiness and chewiness. And each ingredient is fresh and flavorful, from the cheeses to the meats. In addition, their tomato sauce is rich and vibrant – it really ties together all these wonderful flavors!

I must say, I thoroughly enjoyed my experience at Dino’s Pizza Teria. I highly recommend this spot for anyone looking for great pizza in Allentown PA!

Best Deep Dish Pizza – Giovanni’s Pizza

From the moment you step into Giovanni’s, you know you’re in for a treat. The aroma of fresh dough and sizzling cheese hits you like a gust of wind on a stormy day. The friendly staff welcomed me with open arms and a hearty Buongiorno! (which, by the way, is Italian for get ready to stuff your face with deliciousness).

Now, I must warn you, Giovanni’s is not for the faint of heart (or stomach). Their deep dish pizza is a force to be reckoned with. With each bite, the cheese stretches out like a yoga instructor doing the downward dog. The crust is as thick and fluffy as a Kardashian’s pillow. And the toppings? Oh, don’t get me started! From the classic pepperoni to the exotic pineapple, Giovanni’s has it all.

And here’s the cherry on top of the pizza – they offer some great vegetarian options too! So, even if you’re a herbivore in a world of meat eaters, you can still enjoy the cheesy goodness that Giovanni’s has to offer.

But here’s the downside: Giovanni’s doesn’t accept reservations. So, you better come prepared for a wait. But fear not, my hungry friends, because Giovanni’s has a solution for your impatience – dessert! Yes, they have a wide array of delicious sweets to keep you distracted while your stomach grumbles in anticipation.

In conclusion, if you’re looking for the best deep dish pizza in lehigh valley, Giovanni’s is the place to be. Just don’t forget your stretchy pants and a good sense of humor, because you’ll need both to tackle this cheesy beast. Bon appétit!

Best Thin Crust Pizza – MOD Pizza

But let’s talk about the downsides first because who doesn’t love a good rant? MOD Pizza, my dear friends, does not accept reservations. I mean, come on! As a traveling food critic, I don’t have time to wait hours to get a table. I have pizzas to eat, people! So be prepared to join the pizza-loving hordes and fight for a spot at this joint.

Now, onto the good stuff. MOD Pizza offers a decent selection of vegetarian options. Finally, a place that understands that us veggie lovers want to enjoy a good slice too! Plus, they have dessert options, so you can satisfy your sweet tooth after demolishing a whole pizza on your own. And trust me, you’ll want to. The pizza at MOD is seriously delectable.

Not only is the food amazing, but this place is a nice little tourist spot too. It’s always bustling with locals and out-of-towners alike. You can feel the vibrant energy in the air as you walk into the restaurant, the aroma of freshly baked pizza teasing your senses.

So, if you don’t mind the lack of reservations and want to sink your teeth into the best thin crust pizza in lehigh valley, MOD Pizza is the place for you. Just be prepared to fight for your slice, my pizza-loving comrades. Bon appétit!