Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Astoria NY (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in New York

Best Pizza in Astoria NY (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

56 Views

This is an area I visited recently and I had the pleasure of sampling some of the delicious pizza this bustling neighborhood has to offer.

After visiting twelve different places in Astoria NY, I am ready to share which ones proved to be the best – and trust me, I have eaten pizza in some pretty exotic locations!

As a food critic with a slightly discerning palate, I rate each one on their crust, toppings, cheese and overall flavor. So in my humble opinion, here is a look at the top contenders for best pizza in Astoria NY in a humorous and lighthearted way.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New York

#1 Reg’z New York Pizza

I’m no novice when it comes to pizza, so I know good pizza when I taste it. Reg’z stands out with its fresh ingredients, authentic New York-style crust, and the perfect amount of sauce. The slices have just the right amount of crunch, while still staying chewy and delicious.

The atmosphere at Reg’z is a big part of the experience too. You walk in and immediately feel like you’re in an authentic New York pizzeria. It’s got that classic “dive” vibe, but with a modern twist – updated furniture and great music make for a truly unique experience.

What really sets Reg’z apart from other pizzerias is their attention to detail. Nothing is ever overlooked – from their high-quality ingredients to their passionate staff who take pride in what they do. It really shows with every bite that you take – you can tell they care about every single slice!

I’ve been around the world tasting different kinds of pizza, and I must say that Reg’z takes the prize for the best pizza in Astoria NY. If you’re looking for something truly special, look no further than Reg’z!

If you’re willing to go an extra 1 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Queens!

#2 Macoletta

When I first walked in, I was taken aback by how cozy and inviting the atmosphere was – they had a great selection of Italian wines and beers, some quality jazz music playing in the background, and even a mural or two on the walls.

But of course what really mattered to me was the pizza. And oh boy! Let me tell you: Macoletta really delivered. Their thin crust pizzas have just the right amount of crunchiness that one wants from a good pizza – no sogginess here! The sauce is bright and flavorful, with enough herbs to make you think your grandmother made it herself. The toppings are generous and an array of flavors without being too heavy on the palate.

All this is served up with a smile from their knowledgeable staff. They never made me feel rushed or like they were trying to get rid of me- they seemed genuinely interested in helping me choose my perfect slice.

Basically, I ate at Macoletta and felt like royalty – so if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Astoria NY, then look no further than Macoletta!

#3 Milkflower

I’m not one to just take others’ word for it either, so let me explain why it’s so good. First of all, the ingredients are fresh and top-notch – their tomato sauce is made with San Marzano tomatoes and their cheese comes from a farm upstate. Secondly, the dough is nothing short of perfect – it’s thin and crispy on the outside but fluffy on the inside.

But what really makes Milkflower stand out is their attention to detail. The presentation of every pizza is nothing short of art! Their signature pies have toppings arranged in beautiful patterns that always turn heads when they come to your table.

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Astoria NY, then look no further than Milkflower!

#4 Sac’s Place

My journey to Sac’s Place began with a whiff of tomato and cheese. When I walked in, I was immediately welcomed with a mix of laughter and excitement in the air. The atmosphere alone made me curious to sample what they had to offer.

Sac’s Place has an incredible selection of pizzas – from classic pepperoni to exotic combinations like prosciutto and arugula. Each pie is hand-crafted and cooked to perfection. I’ve never tasted such delicious pizza crust! The dough is soft yet crispy and there are plenty of toppings to choose from.

The service at Sac’s Place was also top-notch. The waitstaff were friendly and attentive, ensuring that my experience was positive from start to finish. They even provided samples of their signature dishes so that customers could try them before ordering a full-sized pie.

Overall, my visit to Sac’s Place was beyond amazing! If you’re ever in Astoria NY, I highly recommend you stop by this pizza joint and see for yourself why this is the best pizza in town!

#5 Nonnas 1977

The atmosphere was welcoming and inviting, with a cozy Italian vibe. From the moment I stepped inside, I felt like I was in for something special.

The menu boasted a variety of classic Italian toppings to choose from, including my favorite – pepperoni! The crust was perfectly cooked, with just the right amount of crunch. And the sauce was homemade and flavorful. Every bite melted in my mouth!

To top it all off, their prices were extremely reasonable – especially compared to some of the other restaurants I’ve visited around the world. This is definitely one pizza joint that no food critic should pass up! Nonnas 1977 has earned its spot on my short list of top pizza destinations.

#6 Brother’s Pizzeria

The pizza is delicious and the toppings are plentiful. Every slice is loaded with crispy pepperoni, sweet tomatoes, juicy mushrooms, and plenty of gooey cheese. The crust is thin and crunchy on the outside and fluffy on the inside – perfection!

The atmosphere at Brother’s Pizzeria is also worth mentioning. The place may not look like much from the outside, but they sure know how to make it inviting with their rustic decor and cozy Italian music.

The service was outstanding too – my waitress was friendly and efficient, making sure I had everything I needed right away.

In short, Brother’s Pizzeria definitely deserves all five stars! For an incredible pizza experience in Astoria NY, this place can’t be beat!

#7 Retro Pizza Cafe

When I walked in, I was immediately impressed with the vintage atmosphere. The 1950s decor made me feel like I had been transported back in time to an old-school Italian pizzeria. The staff were all very friendly and accommodating – they even took the time to explain the history behind some of their recipes.

The pizza itself was delicious! I loved the combination of flavors and textures, as well as the perfectly thin and crispy crust. Every bite was divine – it was clearly made with care and attention – which is something hard to find these days!

To top it off, my meal ended with a delightful cannoli that was fluffy and filled with sweet cream. It was a great way to finish things off!

In conclusion, Retro Pizza Cafe has clearly earned its place as one of the best places for pizza in Astoria NY. If you’re ever in town, be sure to stop by for a slice (or two).

#8 Basil Brick Oven Pizza

Where do I even begin? The dough was so light, it was almost like a cloud. And the sauce! It was the perfect balance of sweet and savory, with just a hint of spice. The toppings were fresh, plentiful and flavorful – definitely no skimping here!

But what really sets this pizza apart from the rest is their special brick oven. Every slice comes out perfectly cooked and crisp, yet still incredibly melty and oh-so-satisfying.

The service was also top notch. The staff was friendly and accommodating—I’m sure they could tell how excited I was to try their amazing pizza!

Overall, Basil Brick Oven Pizza has some serious bragging rights when it comes to who has the best pizza in Astoria NY. If you’re ever in town, make sure to give them a try – it’s totally worth it!

If you’re willing to go an extra 2 miles, you can get to 26 more pizza places in Brooklyn!

#9 Samaria Pizza

From the moment I walked in, I was welcomed with a warm and inviting atmosphere. The staff was friendly and helpful, while still being professional.

The pizza is the star of the show here at Samaria Pizza. They offer both classic pies and more modern takes on Italian favorites. Each pie is cooked to perfection in their brick ovens and topped with fresh ingredients. Their tomato sauce is made from scratch and has just the right balance of sweetness and tanginess that really ties together all the flavors on a pizza.

They also have an impressive selection of non-pizza dishes like pasta, salads, sandwiches, and desserts. My favorite thing on the menu is their garlic knots – pillowy soft dinner rolls slathered in garlic butter that are absolutely irresistible.

All in all, Samaria Pizza is truly one of my favorite places for great pizza in Astoria NY!

#10 Pronto Pizzeria

When I walked in, the atmosphere was just what I was looking for – warm and inviting, with enough room to accommodate my party of eight. The staff were friendly and helpful – it’s evident that they know their way around a pizza parlor!

As for the pizza itself – well, let me tell you… It was AMAZING! The thin crust was chewy and crispy at the same time; the fresh tomato sauce had sweetness with a hint of garlic; and the toppings were perfectly balanced. We opted for pepperoni with mushrooms and olives – it was delicious! Even hours later, I’m still dreaming about that pizza.

I’d highly recommend Pronto Pizzeria if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Astoria NY. Not only do they have amazing food but friendly staff too! Plus, their prices are very reasonable. What’s not to love?

#11 Taste of Italy Pizza

I’m no stranger to pizza, having tasted more types than I can fit into this review. All my experience and knowledge led me here, to Taste of Italy Pizza.

This place wasn’t hard to find either! It’s smack dab in the middle of Astoria, so it’s easy to get to from anywhere in the city. Once I walked inside I was immediately greeted with a warm atmosphere. The staff were friendly, helpful, and knowledgeable about their menu items.

The star of the show is definitely their pizza! This place boasts some of the best pizzas I’ve ever had. The dough is thin and crisp on the outside, fluffy on the inside and perfectly cooked every time. The sauce has a robust flavor that complements their selection of cheese options perfectly. Whether you’re looking for classic pepperoni or something more adventurous like mushroom truffle oil pesto – they have something for everyone!

In sum, if you’re ever looking for the best pizza in Astoria NY – look no further than Taste of Italy Pizza!

#12 Gaudio’s

I’m not exaggerating when I say this pizza was better than any I had ever tasted before. The crust was perfectly cooked, the cheese had the perfect amount of gooeyness, and the toppings were fresh and flavorful.

The atmosphere in the restaurant was also delightful. They offer a cozy outdoor area with twinkly lights that make it feel like you’re eating in a fairy garden. The staff was also delightful and personable; they interacted with us throughout our meal and made us feel incredibly welcome.

So, if you’re looking for an amazing pizza experience in Astoria NY, Gaudio’s is definitely your spot! I’m telling all my foodie friends about this place—you should too!