Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Auburn AL (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Alabama

Best Pizza in Auburn AL (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

92 Views

I’m always on the lookout for delicious pies to sample, and after traveling all over the world for some of the best pizza that money can buy, I’m excited to review my picks for the 12 best pizza places in Auburn.

Time to get serious about pizza! Along with my trusty notebook, taste buds, and eagle eye for detail, I’ll be assessing these pizzerias on criteria like crust quality, sauce flavor, cheese ratio, topping selection and overall presentation. You better believe I won’t settle until I find the ultimate slice of pie!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Alabama

#1 HUNTS BROTHERS PIZZA

My experience at HUNTS BROTHERS PIZZA was nothing short of extraordinary. From the moment I stepped in the door, I was greeted with a friendly and welcoming smile from their staff. The atmosphere was cozy and relaxed, with plenty of seating for those looking to dine-in. But what truly sets this place apart is the quality of their pizza.

The crust was perfectly thin and crunchy; just the way I like it! It held up to every toppings piled on top, making each slice as flavorful as the next. The cheese was also top notch; melted to perfection without being soggy or greasy – something that’s hard to find nowadays! And if you’re into something a bit more unique, they also offer specialty pies such as deep dish and stuffed crust.

Overall, HUNTS BROTHERS PIZZA has easily earned their title as one of the best pizza restaurants in Auburn AL! In a world where amazing pizza can be hard to find, it’s comforting to know that somewhere out there is an establishment dedicated to crafting pies that are delicious from start to finish. If you ever get a chance to stop by, do yourself a favor and try it out – you won’t regret it!

If you’re willing to go an extra 30 miles, you can get to 26 more pizza places in Columbus!

#2 Your Pie Pizza Auburn

When I stepped inside, the aroma of cooked pizza dough and freshly made sauce welcomed me in, and immediately my mouth was watering. The staff were helpful and knowledgeable when it came to helping me decide what toppings to choose, both traditional and non-traditional.

The pizzas themselves were excellent: the crust was thin but not too thin and had plenty of flavor; the tomato sauce was just right in terms of acidity, sweetness and consistency; and the cheese they used was top-notch. Add to that a variety of topping choices that ranged from traditional favorites like pepperoni and mushrooms to more exotic flavors like feta cheese and pine nuts – you really can’t go wrong with Your Pie Pizza Auburn!

And if that wasn’t enough, their prices are very reasonable for the quality of pizza that you’re getting. You definitely get a lot for your money here.

In conclusion, I highly recommend Your Pie Pizza Auburn for anyone looking for some of the best pizza in Auburn AL – it’s worth every single penny!

#3 Mellow Mushroom Auburn

The atmosphere is inviting and relaxed, so I’d recommend it for a casual dinner or hangout with friends. The menu includes an array of specialty pizzas that are sure to satisfy all types of palettes. They also have some unique, interesting topping options too – like blackberries and balsamic vinegar!

I’m a huge fan of their classic cheese pizza with crushed red pepper. It’s one of the best I’ve had, and the crust was perfectly cooked. And although it’s not pizza related, they also offer some delicious wings which were definitely served up hot and fresh.

The service was great as well – friendly staff that are willing to accommodate whatever modifications you want on your order. On top of that, my order came surprisingly fast, making sure my pizza was still warm when it arrived at the table!

If you’re looking for good pizza in Auburn AL, look no further than Mellow Mushroom Auburn! Delicious food and attentive service make this restaurant a must-visit in town.

#4 Dough Pizzeria

The atmosphere of their restaurant is inviting and instantly makes you feel at home. The staff are friendly and knowledgeable, but most importantly they make the most delicious pizza.

Their signature pies are some of the best I’ve ever had: crusty, airy, with just the right amount of char. The toppings they use are fresh and flavorful, adding just the perfect amount of flair to each slice. I can honestly say that this pizza has surpassed my expectations in every way.

Plus, the pizzas come with a variety of additional sides such as garlic knots and salads — all good enough to stand up to any amazing pizza.

At Dough Pizzeria, you will definitely find some of the best pizza in Auburn AL! I highly recommend stopping by for a slice (or two) if you’re ever in town!

#5 Little Italy Pizzeria

Let’s start with the pizza itself: a delectable blend of fresh ingredients and an Italian-style flavor. The crust was perfectly cooked, with just enough crunch to hold my toppings in place. As for the toppings, they were cooked to perfection! Everything from the bright vegetables to the savory meat had a burst of flavor that filled my mouth with satisfaction.

The atmosphere at Little Italy Pizzeria was great too. The staff was friendly and helpful, and even offered suggestions on what to order that I hadn’t thought of yet. I tried their house special – it was delicious!

If there’s one thing that sets Little Italy Pizzeria apart, it has to be their attention to detail. Every single slice was cut evenly, allowing all of my guests to get an equal share of toppings (no arguing here!). Not only that, but each slice had its own character – it almost felt as if every piece had been handcrafted for me!

Little Italy Pizzeria is definitely the best pizza in Auburn AL and I highly recommend them for a night out or just a quick bite between classes. Come hungry!

#6 Johnny Brusco’s New York Style Pizza

I was immediately impressed with the atmosphere when I walked into Johnny Brusco’s. The decor perfectly captured the spirit of the Big Apple. It felt like I was in a New York Pizza shop!

Another great thing about Johnny Brusco’s is that they serve alcohol and have a kid’s menu. That means you can bring your family or friends to enjoy some good pizza! Plus, they also offer some vegetarian options as well as dessert, so there is something for everyone.

Unfortunately, Johnny Brusco’s doesn’t offer delivery service, which is a bit of a bummer. But if you’re visiting Auburn AL and looking for the best pizza experience around, this is definitely the place to go – it makes for a nice tourist spot too!

#7 Johnny Brusco’s New York Style Pizza

This place had all of the benefits I want from a pizza joint: they serve alcohol, have an inexpensive kids menu, several vegetarian options, and even dessert.

The only downside is that they don’t offer delivery so you’ll need to come in person or call for takeout. But trust me — it’s worth the effort!

Johnny Brusco’s New York Style Pizza offers a great combination of authenticity and deliciousness. The pizza is cooked in a high-temperature wood-fired oven to give it that classic New York flavor. The dough is light and crispy, with just enough sauce and cheese to bring out the flavor without being overpowering. Plus, their toppings are top notch, with creative combinations like sun-dried tomatoes and smoked mozzarella sure to tantalize your taste buds.

So if you’re tired of the same old generic pies around town, then make sure to grab a slice at Johnny Brusco’s — their pizza is definitely amongst the best in Auburn AL!

If you’re willing to go an extra 48 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Montgomery!

#8 Marco’s Pizza

I’ve tried some truly amazing pizza around the world, from fluffy Neapolitan crusts to thin, crispy Roman slices. But after one bite at Marco’s Pizza, I’m convinced it serves up some of the best pies in town!

The first thing that stands out is the chewy and flavorful crust – they’ve perfected the recipe here! It’s crisp on the outside, with a nice balance of fluffy and dense texture on the inside. And underneath those delectable toppings lies a foundation of perfectly cooked dough.

Next are the toppings – generous portions of flavorful ingredients like pepperoni, sausage, olives, bell peppers, mushrooms…you name it! Every bite brings fresh bursts of flavor that create a perfect harmony on each slice.

And finally there’s the sauce – absolutely divine! It has just the right amount of tang from tomatoes melded with herbs and spices for an unbelievably savory sensation.

Overall, I’m giving Marco’s Pizza five stars for its quality and taste. If you’re looking for a great pizza experience in Auburn AL, you can’t go wrong at Marco’s Pizza!

#9 Marco’s Pizza

The first time I went, I ordered a simple pepperoni pizza. It was cooked to perfection, with a perfectly crispy crust and just the right amount of sauce and cheese. The pepperonis were also cooked just right – not too much where it was greasy and not too little where it tasted bland.

I’ve been to Marco’s Pizza many times since then, trying all kinds of their different pizzas and specials. Every time I’ve been satisfied! Their menu is extensive, filled with interesting combinations of ingredients that make for unique flavors that you can’t find anywhere else.

Their customer service is also outstanding – the staff are friendly and helpful, always willing to answer questions and help you decide what kind of pizza would be best for your particular taste.

In short, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Auburn AL, look no further than Marco’s Pizza. They combine top-notch ingredients with excellent customer service to make an experience that will keep you coming back again and again!

#10 Hungry Howie’s Pizza

When I took my first bite of their “original” thin crust pizza smothered in an aromatic sauce and sprinkled with just the right amount of pepperonis, I was sold! The crust is thin and light but still has a great crunch to it, while the sauce is sweet and savory.

Their cheese pizza isn’t shabby either. This time around I ordered the Grande which was overflowing with cheese and large enough for about 4 people—a great deal for your money.

The specials don’t just stop at their various pizzas options though; Hungry Howie’s also offers subs, wings, salads, wraps and much more. Plus you can always get creative by build-your-own pizza or try out one of their unique creations like the Hawaiian BBQ Chicken pizza—yum!

To top off the delicious food they have amazing customer service that truly make you feel welcome every single time. On top of that, they offer delivery services so that you can enjoy their tasty food from the comfort of your own home.

If you’re looking for some good eats here in Auburn AL then pay a visit to Hungry Howie’s Pizza; you won’t be disappointed!

#11 Fratelli’s Ristorante Italiano

The restaurant is a classic Italian eatery, complete with checkered tablecloths and the freshest ingredients. The pizza dough was perfectly thin and crispy while the toppings were flavorful and surprisingly generous. It was truly a work of art!

My favorite pizza flavor had to be the pepperoni & mushroom, with its delicious blend of sauces and spices. The cheese was melted perfectly and the crust was wonderfully crunchy. I could not get over how good it tasted!

The service at Fratelli’s Ristorante Italiano is second to none. Our waiter was friendly, attentive, and informative when it came to the menu selection. The atmosphere was inviting and upbeat – perfect for enjoying a relaxing evening out with friends or family.

If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Auburn AL, Fratelli’s Ristorante Italiano is your place! Everything from their authentic decor to their flavorful pies makes this spot one of my top recommendations for pizza aficionados everywhere.

#12 Brick Oven Pizza Co.

Their pizzas are wonderfully unique – they have an array of toppings that range from the classic pepperoni to more exotic options like grilled chicken, spinach, and feta.

The crust is always to perfection. Flaky on the outside and soft on the inside, it’s a great combination of textures. Plus, each pizza is cooked in their brick oven which adds a lovely smoky flavor.

The service here is top-notch too – my waitress was very friendly and attentive! She recommended the daily special – roasted red peppers, zucchini, and mozzarella with basil pesto – which was absolutely divine!

Brick Oven Pizza Co. is certainly a place worth checking out if you’re looking for the best pizza in Auburn AL – it definitely lives up to its reputation!