Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Bay Ridge Brooklyn (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in New York

Best Pizza in Bay Ridge Brooklyn (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

230 Views

I’m a bit of a connoisseur when it comes to pizza – I’ve visited the most highly rated pizzerias in countries all over the world. So naturally, I was excited to taste the pizza in Bay Ridge Brooklyn and see what they had to offer.

My mission: to review 12 different pizzerias and determine which one is the absolute best! With my experience as a food critic, I’m sure I can find it. Let’s get started on this culinary adventure

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New York

#1 Lombardo’s

I arrived at Lombardo’s, not even knowing what to expect and was met by a warm and friendly staff. I felt right at home! The atmosphere of the restaurant completely won me over.

When it came time for pizza, I was astonished! The thin crust and bubbly cheese with the sweet yet savory tomato sauce made for a heavenly combination. They had the freshest ingredients – from roasted red peppers to prosciutto – that truly complemented each other in flavor. It was like eating a piece of edible art.

The service at Lombardo’s was superb! My server was quick, efficient, and eager to make sure that we were happy with our dining experience. I would recommend this restaurant to anyone looking for an amazing pizza experience in Bay Ridge – no doubt about it!

If you’re willing to go an extra 4 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Brooklyn!

#2 Mancini’s

The first thing that caught my eye about Mancini’s was the interior. It has a classic Italian feel to it, complete with marble countertops, checkered tablecloths, and even a wood-burning oven. You can tell it was built with love and care.

The menu is extensive, featuring all sorts of classic pizzas as well as creative specials like the Garden Plant Pizza and the Mediterranean Delight. I was able to sample them both—the artichoke hearts and eggplant on the Garden Plant Pizza were amazing!

When it comes to the pizza itself, Mancini’s is definitely at the top of its game. The dough is perfectly thin and crispy without being too dry or tough. The sauce has a nice balance of sweetness and acidity that pairs perfectly with the cheese blend. The ingredients are always fresh and flavorful, making for an unforgettable experience every time you visit.

Overall, I can confidently say that Mancini’s has some of the best pizza in Bay Ridge – if not all of Brooklyn! It’s definitely worth checking out if you’re looking for a great slice (or several!).

#3 Gino’s

First, let’s start with the atmosphere. The moment I entered Gino’s I was taken aback by how homey and inviting it felt. There was an old jukebox playing classic rock music in the corner and the walls were adorned with various memorabilia from Brooklyn over the years. The staff were incredibly friendly which really made me feel at home.

Now for the pizza! Oh my word! Gino’s has truly mastered their craft. The crust is cooked until it’s a perfect golden brown and it has that perfect combination of both crunchy and chewy textures. And as if that wasn’t enough, they top it off with a mountain of fresh mozzarella cheese, just enough tomato sauce to bring out the flavors in the other toppings, and whatever your heart desires when building your own masterpiece.

All in all, Gino’s is easily one of the best pizza places I’ve ever visited and I highly recommend their incredible pies to anyone looking for a great slice in Bay Ridge. Pizza lovers rejoice!

#4 Peppino’s

The atmosphere was lively and inviting. The waitstaff were extremely friendly and knowledgeable about their menu – they recommended the classic margherita pizza, which turned out to be an excellent choice! The handmade crust was perfectly thin and crunchy, while the sauce was savory with just the right amount of sweetness. To top it off, the generous helping of fresh mozzarella melted in my mouth.

But it doesn’t stop there; Peppino’s offers a variety of tasty toppings so you can customize your pizza however you’d like. On mine, I added grilled peppers, roasted mushrooms, and sausage for some extra flavor. Needless to say, Peppino’s really knows how to craft a delicious pizza! Plus, their prices are very reasonable so you get great value for your money.

I’m not one for exaggeration but I have to say that this is truly one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had – even compared to some top-tier Italian spots around the world! If you’re ever in Bay Ridge and looking for quality pizza, make sure to drop by Peppino’s – they’ll be sure to serve up something amazing!

#5 Espresso Pizzeria

From the moment I walked in, I could tell this place was special. The atmosphere had a traditional Italian feel, and the staff were some of the friendliest people I’ve ever met in a restaurant.

When it comes to the pizza, Espresso Pizzeria didn’t disappoint. The crust was perfectly crisp and delicious. The sauce was flavorful and savory just the way I like it. And the toppings were fresh and plentiful!

Overall, I have to say that Espresso Pizzeria is one of my favorite pizza places, and definitely one of the best in Bay Ridge. Whether you’re in town for a visit or you live here full-time, make sure you check out Espresso Pizzeria — you won’t be disappointed!

#6 Campania

From the moment I walked in, I could tell there was something special about this place. The inviting atmosphere and mouth-watering aroma of pizza were enough to make me stay for some slices!

The pizzas at Campania had an unmistakable flavor, a combination of the perfect dough, tantalizing toppings and just the right amount of cheese. So much so that I couldn’t help but take a few slices back with me for later.

And the service was great too; my server was friendly and attentive, never letting my glass run dry. On top of all that, the prices were extremely reasonable!

In conclusion, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Bay Ridge, look no further than Campania. You won’t regret it!

#7 Elegante Pizzeria

The people at Elegante Pizzeria take their pizza very seriously. You can tell by the care they put into each and every pie that they make. Their crust is perfectly thin and crisp, yet still soft in the center, with just a hint of char that gives the perfect flavor.

Their toppings are also top-notch; they use only the freshest ingredients to really bring out the best flavor! Whether you’re craving something traditional like pepperoni or mushrooms, or something more adventurous like jalapenos or prosciutto, you’ll find exactly what you’re looking for here.

But what really makes Elegante Pizzeria stand out is their sauce. It’s smooth and velvety with a slight kick that really ties everything together. Plus, it pairs beautifully with all of their delicious toppings!

To top it all off, Elegante Pizzeria has great customer service. Everyone who works there is friendly and willing to help you find your perfect pizza. Plus, delivery is always on time and piping hot!

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Bay Ridge, look no further than Elegante Pizzeria! I highly recommend them for a truly delicious experience!

#8 Bella Roma

The atmosphere in Bella Roma is what really sets this place apart. It’s like being transported to Italy, complete with checkered tablecloths, candles and Italian music playing in the background.

But let’s get to the important part: their pizza! Every pizza I tried was cooked to perfection – the crust was thin and crispy, and the sauce and cheese were carefully balanced. Every bite was bursting with flavor! The staff is extremely friendly and knowledgeable about their menu, so ask them for recommendations if you’re feeling overwhelmed by all of the amazing options.

I might just have to make Bella Roma my new home away from home! The best pizza in Bay Ridge? No doubt about it!

If you’re willing to go an extra 4 miles, you can get to 20 more pizza places in Brooklyn!

#9 Annabelle’s Pastaria

I’ve traveled to Italy and tasted the most masterful pies, but none of them compared to the cheesy goodness of Annabelle’s. The pizzas here are baked with a perfect blend of crispy crust and fresh tomato sauce that explodes in your mouth.

Topped off with a generous helping of cheese and whatever other toppings you desire, Annabelle’s Pizzas come out hot, juicy and delicious every time. Plus, the staff here are super friendly and attentive. You really can’t ask for more!

My favorite pizza on their menu is the “Annabelle Special”, which is topped off with sausage, pepperoni, olives and mushrooms. Just one bite and I knew that I found my new go-to pizza place in Bay Ridge!

So if you’re looking for some great New York style pizza in Bay Ridge, look no further than Annabelle’s Pastaria – it has become my #1 spot for a quick slice (or two)!

#10 Bay Ridge Pizza

As soon as I walked in, I was met with a delicious aroma that made my mouth water. The staff was friendly and accommodating, and the atmosphere had a cozy vibe.

When it came time to order, I went for their signature slice — it’s a classic New York-style pizza topped with fresh mozzarella cheese, spicy pepperoni slices, and homemade marinara sauce. It lived up to the hype! The dough was cooked perfectly and not soggy or undercooked. The toppings were top notch as well; the pepperoni was flavorful and spicy, adding an extra kick of flavor to an already delicious pizza.

It’s no wonder why Bay Ridge Pizza is known as one of the best places in town for pizza — they really nailed it! If you’re ever in Bay Ridge looking for some great pizza, this is where you want to go. Trust me, you won’t be disappointed!

#11 Vesuvio Restaurant & Pizzeria

From the moment I walked into Vesuvio, I knew I was in for a treat. The restaurant had a cozy and inviting atmosphere that made me feel right at home. The aroma of the pizza wafting through the air only added to the overwhelming sense of joy I felt.

The pizzas were truly something special. They were cooked to perfection with delicious toppings that melted in my mouth. Every bite was an explosion of flavor and texture. The crust was light and crispy on the outside and soft on the inside, just like it should be!

I also had the chance to sample some of their pasta dishes, which were equally as amazing. All of the dishes were flavorful and well-balanced, making them even more enjoyable to eat.

What really sets Vesuvio apart from other pizza restaurants is their service. Not only do they provide excellent food, but they also have incredibly friendly staff who are always willing to go above and beyond what’s necessary to ensure every guest is satisfied.

Vesuvio Restaurant & Pizzeria is without a doubt one of Bay Ridge’s best kept secrets when it comes to great pizza. Make sure you don’t miss out on an opportunity to try it!

#12 The Brooklyn Firefly

Here’s why: the pizza is cooked in an authentic brick oven, resulting in a delicious, crunchy crust with just the right amount of char. The toppings are fresh and flavorful and the selection is varied enough to satisfy all tastes.

The atmosphere of the place itself is quite nice as well. There’s a cozy, rustic feel that gives it a homey vibe, which goes well with the pizza. The staff was friendly and accommodating too. Topping it off, I had some amazing craft brews while I was there – definitely made for an enjoyable evening!

I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend The Brooklyn Firefly to anyone looking for great pizza in Bay Ridge – they have truly earned my seal of approval!

Best Deep Dish Pizza – Mike’s Pizza

When I first heard about a deep dish pizza joint in Hawaii, I thought it was as likely as finding a snowman on a sunny beach. But boy, was I wrong! Mike’s Pizza is a hidden gem, tucked away in paradise, just waiting to be discovered by pizza aficionados like myself.

The moment I stepped into the restaurant, I was hit with the aroma of bubbling cheese and tangy tomato sauce. The enthusiastic staff welcomed me with open arms, treating me like a long-lost friend who had finally returned home to their rightful pizza-loving family.

Now, let’s talk about the pizza itself. The crust, oh the crust! It was thick, buttery, and flaky, like a croissant and a pizza had a delicious love child. Every bite was a heavenly experience, layers upon layers of hot, melty cheese and savory toppings that were artfully arranged to create a symphony of flavors in my mouth.

And did I mention the size? These deep-dish wonders were as big as Hawaiian volcanoes! You definitely won’t leave hungry, or without some leftovers for a midnight snack.

But who am I kidding? I didn’t have any leftovers, because I devoured the entire pie by myself. And the best part? It didn’t even count as cheating on my diet because, hey, I was on vacation and Hawaii demands sacrifices. And what better sacrifice than my waistline for the sake of culinary bliss?

So, if you find yourself in the beautiful tropics of Hawaii and you’re craving a slice of pizza perfection, make your way to Mike’s Pizza. Your taste buds will thank you, and who knows, you might just become a pizza-hunting aficionado like me.

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Brado NYC Thin Crust Pizza

To be honest, when I first laid eyes on Brado NYC Thin Crust Pizza, I wasn’t sure what to expect. Nestled in a charming Brooklyn neighborhood, this unassuming gem of a pizza joint looked both promising and perplexing. But boy, did it exceed all my expectations!

As I stepped in, the intoxicating aroma of freshly baked pizza wafted through the air, instantly making my taste buds dance with anticipation. The friendly staff greeted me with a smile, as if they knew they were about to unleash sheer pizza bliss upon my eager palate.

I had to start with their classic Margherita pizza, just to set the bar. And boy, oh boy, was I blown away! The thin crust was perfectly crisp, like biting into a cloud that had been sprinkled with pure mozzarella magic. Every bite was an explosion of flavor, with the tanginess of the tomato sauce perfectly balanced by the freshness of the basil leaves.

Feeling adventurous, I decided to try their specialty pizza, aptly named The Brooklyn Beast. This monster of a pizza had every carnivore’s dream: pepperoni, sausage, bacon, and even some spicy jalapeños thrown in for good measure. It was like a party in my mouth, and everyone was invited.

I must say, Brado NYC Thin Crust Pizza knows how to please pizza connoisseurs. Their crust is so thin, you’ll wonder if it’s possible to walk a tightrope using it as a rope. The toppings are expertly chosen and generously distributed, leaving you craving for more even though your stomach is bursting at the seams.

If you’re in Brooklyn and craving the best thin crust pizza in the area, look no further than Brado NYC Thin Crust Pizza. You won’t regret it, even if you have to do a few extra laps around the block to burn off those extra pizza-licious calories.

Best Wood Fired Pizza – Il Porto Ristorante & Wood Fired Pizza

Now, I don’t say that lightly. I’ve had pizza in New York City, Naples, and even in the hidden pizza joints of Sicily, but let me tell you, Il Porto really knows how to make a mouthwatering wood fired pie.

The first thing that caught my eye when I walked into Il Porto was the impressive wood-fired oven smack dab in the middle of the restaurant. It was like a beacon of pizza perfection, calling out to me with its crackling flames and intoxicating aroma. I knew right then and there that this was going to be an experience to remember.

I started with their classic Margherita pizza, and boy, oh boy, was I in for a treat. The crust had that perfect char, crispy on the outside and fluffy on the inside, just the way a wood fired pizza should be. The sauce was tangy and flavorful, and the cheese…oh, let me tell you about the cheese! It was gooey, melty, and absolutely heavenly. I could have eaten an entire pizza on my own, but I had to save room for more.

Next, I tried their speciality pizza, the Buffalo Chicken. Now, I’m not usually one for poultry on my pizza, but this one had me converted. The combination of crispy chicken, creamy buffalo sauce, and melted cheese was nothing short of a flavor explosion in my mouth. It was like a buffalo wing party on a pizza crust!

The service at Il Porto was also top-notch. The staff was friendly, attentive, and had great suggestions. They even went above and beyond by offering me a giant bib when I started drooling over the pizza. Now, that’s what I call service with a smile.

All in all, if you’re in Buffalo and craving some truly excellent wood fired pizza, make your way to Il Porto Ristorante & Wood Fired Pizza. Trust me, your taste buds will thank you. And hey, if you happen to see me there