Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Amelia Island (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Florida

Best Pizza in Amelia Island (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

173 Views

After tasting slices at 12 different places, I have put together a list of the best pizza in the area. I’m not one for fanfare – just good food!

I’m sure you’ll find something to tickle your taste buds on this list. Consider it a lighthearted guide to some great pizza options in Amelia Island. Let’s get started!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Florida

#1 Townies Pizzeria

The first thing I noticed when entering Townies Pizzeria is the warm, inviting atmosphere. The staff was super friendly and eager to offer suggestions on what their signature dishes were like. I also loved that they had a variety of creative topping combinations so I could customize my pizza how I liked it.

Speaking of toppings, the selection at Townies Pizzeria was absolutely amazing! Whether you want classic pepperoni or something more exotic, like Bianco with pistachio pesto, you can find it here. Additionally, their selection of craft beers makes for the perfect pairing for your meal.

One thing that really sets Townies Pizzeria apart from other pizzerias is the quality of ingredients used in their recipes. They source organic ingredients from local farmers and everything tasted fresh as if it had been made right then and there. The dough is perfectly thin yet still has that delicious crispy texture when cooked in their wood-fired ovens.

After trying some slices of their pizza and washing it down with an ice cold beer, I can confidently say that Townies Pizzeria serves some of the best pizza in Amelia Island. If you’re looking for a delicious slice or two (or three), make sure to visit this local hot spot!

If you’re willing to go an extra 26 miles, you can get to 25 more pizza places in Jacksonville Beach!

#2 Moon River Pizza

From their freshly made dough, to their unique and delicious toppings, Moon River Pizza provides an unforgettable experience. The unique recipes used at this restaurant provide a perfect balance of flavors with every bite.

The atmosphere at Moon River Pizza is fantastic as well. As soon as you enter the restaurant you are welcomed by the warm and friendly staff who take great pride in creating the perfect pizza for each individual customer.

The pizza itself is cooked to perfection; the crust is golden brown on the outside but soft and light on the inside. I had a chance to try a few different varieties of pizzas and each one was more delicious than the last. My favorite was the classic cheese pizza – it had just enough cheese while not being too heavy or greasy.

I have now tried several pizzas around Amelia Island and can honestly say that Moon River Pizza stands out above all others as far as taste and quality go. If you’re ever in this area, be sure to grab a slice (or two!) of this deliciousness!

#3 Coastal Pizza

I was pleasantly surprised as soon as I stepped through the door. The place has a beautiful, rustic charm that made me feel right at home. Plus, the staff was super friendly and accommodating!

As for the pizza itself, it was amazing. The crust was perfectly crispy and had just the right amount of chew. And you can’t forget about their delicious sauce – it has just the right amount of tangy sweetness mixed with smoky flavors that makes your taste buds go wild!

The toppings were fresh and plentiful too. From classic pepperoni to unique creations like shrimp scampi, there’s something for everyone at Coastal Pizza. The combination of flavors worked harmoniously to make some of the most delicious pizzas I’ve ever had in my life.

So if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Amelia Island, I highly recommend heading over to Coastal Pizza! You won’t regret it!

#4 Arte Pizza

I can honestly say that my experience at Arte Pizza was unlike any other pizza restaurant I’ve visited. From the moment we stepped in, the atmosphere was welcoming and lively. The staff was incredibly friendly and helpful, and went out of their way to make sure we were happy.

As for the food itself, it was outstanding! The crust was thin with just the right amount of crispness, and the toppings were fresh and flavorful. It’s apparent that a lot of care goes into crafting these special pies – something that I can appreciate as a hard-core pizza connoisseur.

All in all, if you’re looking for some truly amazing pizza in Amelia Island, Arte Pizza is definitely worth checking out. Don’t believe me? Stop by and try it for yourself – you won’t be disappointed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 27 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Jacksonville!

#5 Domino’s Pizza

I was skeptical at first, wondering how such a big chain could make really good pizza. But I was amazed by the freshness of their ingredients and the warmth of their crust. It almost felt like the pizza had just been delivered from Italy!

The sauces were also incredible. They had the perfect blend of herbs and spices that granted the pizza unique flavors. And they weren’t stingy with the toppings – they gave me loads of cheese, pepperoni, and whatever else I asked for.

The service wasn’t bad either. Their friendly staff took great care to make sure my pizza was properly cooked and cut it into nice slices as soon as it came out of the oven. It’s quite rare to find this level of customer service in a big-name chain like Domino’s Pizza!

Overall, Domino’s Pizza has exceeded my expectations with its top-notch ingredients, sauces, and service – proving that you don’t need to go halfway around the world for delicious pizza! I would definitely recommend it to anyone looking for some good pizza in Amelia Island.

#6 The Loop Restaurant

When I walked into the restaurant, I was immediately hit with a wave of delicious aromas. The decor was bright and inviting, with a modern feel that set a great atmosphere.

The menu had some interesting options to choose from. Given my pizza expertise, I opted for their signature dish – the Loop Pizza! It was incredible! It had the perfect ratio of crust to cheese to sauce, and all of the ingredients were super fresh. I haven’t tasted anything like it in a long time!

Aside from the pizza itself, I believe The Loop Restaurant certainly added some unique touches that made it unforgettable. From the toppings bar where you can pick your own custom topping combinations, to the live music played during dinner hours – it truly made for an experience like no other.

All in all, The Loop Restaurant is definitely my top choice for the best pizza in Amelia Island! Not only does it have outstanding food but also a lively atmosphere that’s sure to please any visitor. Highly recommended!

#7 Natural Slice Pizza And Surf Shop

I stopped by this incredible establishment recently and was completely blown away by the amazing pies they have to offer. I must say, the pizza was quite delicious–the crust was perfectly thin and crispy, and the toppings tastes incredibly fresh. Plus, their unique selection of specialty pizzas really set them apart–I had a hard time deciding between their ‘Surf & Turf’ pizza (topped with shrimp, steak and extra cheese) and their ‘Garden Delight’ pizza (topped with mushrooms, spinach and artichoke).

The environment at Natural Slice Pizza And Surf Shop was also top-notch: the restaurant itself is quite cozy with a warm beach vibe that sets it apart from other pizza joints. The staff were all extremely friendly, knowledgeable about the menu and very accommodating of my dietary restrictions. Lastly, although I didn’t get a chance to try it for myself when I visited, I’ve heard great things about their hand-made gelato available daily – so make sure to save room for some sweet treats!

All in all, Natural Slice Pizza And Surf Shop is definitely one of the best places to grab pizza in Amelia Island: their food is fresh and flavorful and their atmosphere can’t be beat!

If you’re willing to go an extra 28 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Jacksonville!

#8 OPS Pizza Kitchen & Café

My first bite of their pizza was like a flavor explosion in my mouth. The crust was cooked to perfection – golden and crispy on the outside and perfectly chewy on the inside. The sauce was bright, flavorful, and had just the right amount of garlic. To top it off, OPS Pizza Kitchen & Café used only the freshest ingredients when topping their pies. The combination of cheese, vegetables, and meats made for an unforgettable experience!

But what really sets OPS Pizza Kitchen & Café apart from other pizza restaurants is their atmosphere. It’s cozy and inviting yet friendly at the same time – perfect for a date night or simply grabbing a slice with friends. In addition to delicious pizza, they have a great selection of craft beer and wine which definitely adds to the whole experience.

Overall, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Amelia Island then OPS Pizza Kitchen & Café is where it’s at! From amazing food to great atmosphere and friendly staff, this place won’t disappoint. I highly recommend stopping by to get your own slice of heaven!

#9 V Pizza – Fernandina Beach

First of all, the atmosphere is great. V Pizza – Fernandina Beach is a nice tourist spot, so you can appreciate the scenery while enjoying your pizza. Plus, if you’re looking for an establishment with a kid’s menu, V Pizza – Fernandina Beach definitely has you covered.

And best of all, they serve alcohol! So whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or just grabbing some pizza with friends – they’ve got something that will fit your needs. If you’re not in the mood for pizza? Don’t worry! They also offer dessert and other tasty treats.

As far as downsides go? The only one I can think of is the fact that they don’t offer delivery service. But if you have time to make it out to the restaurant, it’ll be worth your while!

To sum it up, if you’re interested in finding some of the best pizza in Amelia Island, then V Pizza – Fernandina Beach should be at the top of your list!

#10 Coastal pizza

From the moment I walked in, I was impressed. The staff was friendly and the atmosphere was inviting. The wood-fired brick oven pizza smelled delicious as I walked up to the counter to order.

I decided to try their signature pizza – a classic cheese pizza with mushrooms, olives, and peppers. To me, it was absolute perfection! The crust had an amazing crunch yet still remained wonderfully chewy in the center. As for the toppings? They were fresh and flavorful! Every bite was mouthwatering!

If you’re looking for great pizza in Amelia Island, look no further than Coastal pizza! If it’s good enough for me, a seasoned food critic who has tasted pizzas around the world – then it’s sure to be a hit for everyone else too!

If you’re willing to go an extra 40 miles, you can get to 21 more pizza places in Brunswick!

#11 la Finestra Italiana, Amelia

The restaurant itself is a nice tourist spot, located in the heart of Amelia Island. You can get a great view of the ocean and it’s a cozy place to relax.

I tried their signature dish, a classic Italian pizza with tomato sauce and mozzarella. This was by far the best pizza I’ve ever had. It was so delicious that I wanted more!

Aside from pizzas, they have other Italian dishes like lasagna, ravioli and spaghetti too. The portions are big and enough to fill any hungry stomach.

The downside to this great pizza place is that they don’t offer delivery service—you have to actually go there to enjoy the amazing food. That seemed like a small price to pay for such amazing food!

#12 Ciao Italian Eatery

I had the pleasure of visiting this spot and I’m so glad I did. Not only do they serve up some delicious pies, but they also have some amazing additional options such as their kid’s menu and vegetarian options. And of course, how could I forget to mention their generous selection of alcoholic beverages (including hard liquor!)?

The dessert was pure bliss -easily some of the best pastry offerings i’ve encountered on my journey. The restaurant has a great atmosphere too; it definitely makes for a nice tourist spot.

The only downside is that they don’t offer delivery service, but if you want to get the best pizza in Amelia Island then skipping out on delivery is totally worth it!