Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Appleton WI (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Wisconsin

Best Pizza in Appleton WI (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

559 Views

I’ve eaten my way through twelve different pizza places in Appleton to determine for the citizens of this great city what I believe is their best option. The search has been a delightful one, full of both trials and tribulations as I tasted many different styles of pizza.

You may be wondering, have I missed any good options? Fear not, with my expansive palate and discerning taste buds I am confident that my opinions are trustworthy and will provide you with an excellent guide to the best pizza in Appleton WI. Now roll up your sleeves, pick up a napkin, and let’s get ready for some cheesy goodness!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Wisconsin

#1 Donatos Pizza

The atmosphere is perfect for a casual night out with friends, with super friendly service and some really cool decorations around the restaurant. The pizza itself is absolutely delicious. Perfectly cooked pies topped with crisp veggies and savory meats – what more could you ask for? Plus, they have some really unique toppings like their famous bacon-wrapped crust!

I’ve rarely seen such attention to detail when crafting pizza. Each slice had the perfect ratio of chewy crust to rich toppings. And the flavors were out of this world! The garlic-parmesan sauce was especially good – it tied everything together perfectly.

In short, my time at Donatos Pizza was amazing. I can confidently say that they serve the best pizza in Appleton WI. If you’re ever in town, I highly recommend checking them out and treating yourself to a delicious meal!

If you’re willing to go an extra 18 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Oshkosh!

#2 Ellinor restaurant

The atmosphere of the restaurant is great, with an inviting and friendly staff. Plus, they serve alcohol (hard liquor!) and dessert which is always a bonus.

The pizza itself is out of this world! Every topping was cooked to perfection and the crusts were just crunchy enough. Plus, you can get different sizes so everyone can be happy!

My only complaint about Ellinor Restaurant is that they don’t offer delivery. But it’s worth it to go out and enjoy the atmosphere in person!

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Appleton WI, look no further than Ellinor Restaurant.

#3 Pierri Pizza

Upon entering Pierri, I could tell from the delicious smells that something special was in store. The atmosphere was inviting with dim lights and old-fashioned styling. As I looked around, I noticed several customers enjoying their slices – and it wasn’t long before I was joining them!

My meal at Pierri started off with one of the most exquisite garlic knots I have ever tasted. Tender dough, cooked to perfection and topped with a savory garlic butter; they were the perfect precursor to even more delightfully cheesy pizza goodness.

The pizza itself could only be described as a work of art: a tangy tomato sauce layered over delicious mozzarella cheese and sprinkled generously with herbs. Each slice was full of flavor, leaving me wanting more after every bite.

If you’re ever in Appleton WI looking for great pizza, don’t miss out on Pierri Pizza – it’s truly some of the best pizza I’ve had anywhere in the world!

#4 Pizza King

The restaurant itself looks like something straight out of a pizza-loving traveler’s dreams: the red-and-white stripped walls adorned with photos of Italian landmarks, the checkered tablecloths, and the bustling kitchen full of talented chefs. When I first stepped in, I was overwhelmed by the delicious smells emanating from every corner.

The pizzas here are absolutely magnificent. They come in all sorts of shapes and sizes, and each one is cooked to perfection. The crust is light and fluffy while still being sturdy enough to hold all its toppings. The sauce is flavorful with just the right amount of spice – not too much or too little. And best of all, the cheese! It’s so buttery and creamy that it practically melts in your mouth!

I also must say that the staff at Pizza King were extremely friendly and accommodating. They listened to my requests for custom toppings and made sure everything was perfect before serving it up. Furthermore, their prices are very reasonable – especially considering this was some of the best pizza I’ve ever tasted!

If you’re looking for a great place to get pizza in Appleton WI, look no further than Pizza King!

#5 Christianos Pizza

The restaurant has a great atmosphere and the staff is always friendly and welcoming. The pizza dough is freshly made in-house with the perfect combination of crunchy crust, flavor-packed sauce and cheesy goodness. I especially love their specialty pizzas like the “Wisconsinite,” with lots of Wisconsin’s famous cheese curd, or their spicy “Hot Mama” that really packs a punch.

If you’re looking for something a little different, try one of Christianos’ unique creations like the Mediterranean-style “Greek Goddess”, which is topped with feta cheese and kalamata olives. They even have vegan options if you don’t eat meat!

In short, Christianos Pizza is simply the best pizza in Appleton WI. Whether you’re looking for an amazing gourmet pizza or just craving some classic comfort food, this place has it all! Trust me, it’s worth checking out and will certainly not disappoint!

#6 Home Run Pizza

When I first stepped in the door, I was pleasantly surprised by how inviting and modern the restaurant was. The staff were incredibly friendly and eager to help me find just what I was looking for.

I decided to try their Pepperoni Pizza and it certainly delivered! The crust was perfectly cooked, thin yet still tasty, while the cheese and toppings were cooked to perfection. I especially appreciated how generous they were with the pepperoni — no skimpy servings here!

But what really put a smile on my face was the amazing service. My waiter had an infectious personality that kept me laughing throughout my meal. Not only that, but he was knowledgeable about all of their menu items, which really helped me decide what to order.

My experience at Home Run Pizza is one that I will not soon forget. If you are ever looking for the best pizza in Appleton WI, look no further than Home Run Pizza!

#7 Sal’s Pizza

From the moment I stepped into Sal’s Pizza, the atmosphere was electric. The dimly-lit restaurant had a cozy charm that immediately made me feel at home. The smell of fresh-baked pizza wafted in the air and my mouth was watering with anticipation.

The staff were friendly and eager to serve me up some slices. I asked for their ‘signature’ pizza – and they certainly did not disappoint!

The cheese was melted just right and the dough was light and fluffy. The flavor balance of sweet and savory toppings was perfect. Plus, the prices were more than reasonable; given the quality of pizza, it certainly seemed like a steal!

I would easily recommend Sal’s Pizza over any other place for best pizza in Appleton WI! Heck, it tasted better than some of the best pizzas I’ve had in Rome or New York City. They really know how to make an amazing pie!

#8 Luigis Pizza of Appleton

Upon first entering the restaurant I was overwhelmed with the smell of delicious pizza and cheese. The atmosphere of the restaurant made me feel like I was back in Italy, where I had sampled some of the finest pizzas of my life!

The staff at Luigis Pizza of Appleton is also wonderful. They were friendly and knowledgeable about their product which gave me confidence that the pizza would be top-notch.

Indeed, it was even better than expected! The crust was perfectly crisp, while still having a bit of crunch in it. And the toppings were incredibly fresh and tasty – everything from olives to bell peppers, mushrooms to anchovies. The cheese was what really sealed the deal for me – golden and creamy, it was truly Italian heaven on a slice!

All in all, Luigis Pizza of Appleton has now become one of my favorite spots as far as pizza goes. I highly recommend stopping by if you’re ever in Appleton WI looking for some amazing pizza – trust me when I say you won’t regret it!

If you’re willing to go an extra 23 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Green Bay!

#9 Stuc’s Pizza

The first thing that struck me when I visited Stuc’s Pizza was the atmosphere – it had a fun, laid-back vibe that made me feel right at home.

Next up, the pizza. Let me just say, wow! The crust was perfectly thin and crisp, with just enough cheese to make it ooey gooey delicious. Toppings were plentiful and fresh, and the combination of flavors worked incredibly well together. I definitely got my money’s worth with this one!

The staff at Stuc’s Pizza also deserve a shout out. Everyone was friendly and welcoming – they made sure to answer all my questions about the menu items and assured me that I couldn’t go wrong with whichever pizza I chose. They even gave me some tips on what to order next time – not something you see often in the service industry these days!

I would highly recommend Stuc’s Pizza for anyone looking for the best pizza in Appleton WI!

#10 Pizza King

I arrived at Pizza King expecting the worst, but I was pleasantly surprised. The menu was vast, with all sorts of delicious toppings and crusts to choose from. I ordered a couple of slices – one plain cheese and one pepperoni – and dug in.

My first bite of the cheese slice was absolute perfection. The thin, crispy crust was cooked to perfection and had just the right hint of garlic. The sauce wasn’t too sweet or too acidic and the cheese was perfectly melted and gooey. I couldn’t believe it!

The pepperoni slice was even better; it had that classic NY-style thin crust, loaded with generous amounts of freshly grated mozzarella cheese, savory pepperonis, piping hot sauce, and fragrant herbs. Each bite seemed to get more delicious than the last!

Overall, Pizza King’s thin crust pies have changed my entire outlook on pizza. They’ve earned my title as having some of the best pizza in Appleton WI!

#11 Wiseguys Pizzeria & Pub

The experience at Wiseguys was great – there’s something for everyone, including a kid’s menu and desserts. It also has the added benefit of serving alcohol (including hard liquor!), which is great if you’re looking to have some drinks while you chow down on a delicious pizza.

Plus, it’s a great place to watch sports! Whether you’re an NFL fan or just love your local team, they’ve got plenty of TVs to enjoy the game while you munch on some cheesy goodness.

The one downside I noticed is that they don’t offer delivery – so if you’re feeling too laid back to make the trip out, you’ll have to find somewhere else for your pizza fix. But trust me when I say it will be worth it!

From the atmosphere and service to the fresh ingredients and tasty toppings, Wiseguys Pizzeria & Pub truly deserves its title as the best pizza in Appleton WI.

#12 Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza

The best way to experience this establishment is by trying their specialty pizzas. I had the Mama’s Favorite Pizza which contained pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, and onions. The combination of flavors was bold and delicious! I also tried their Gourmet Veggie Pizza which had a unique blend of vegetables like bell peppers, spinach, black olives, and feta cheese. It was surprisingly flavorful and satisfying.

The crust at Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza is what makes it stand out from other pizzerias in the area. They use the freshest ingredients to create a soft yet chewy crust with just the right amount of oomph. It truly melts in your mouth!

The service at Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza is definitely top-notch as well. From the moment you walk in until you take your first bite, everyone there from the cashier to the cook makes sure you feel welcomed and appreciated.

In my opinion, Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza is hands-down one of the best pizza restaurants in Appleton WI! Their creative combinations of toppings are unparalleled, their crust is amazing, their service friendly and efficient – what more could you ask for?

Best Deep Dish Pizza – Stuc’s Pizza

Now, I know what you’re thinking. Edward, how can you say that? Well, let me tell you, my taste buds have been on a rollercoaster ride, and they had the time of their lives at Stuc’s.

As soon as I walked in, the smell of freshly baked dough hit me like a delicious punch to the face. It was like a symphony of aromas, with hints of oregano, garlic, and cheese weaving through the air. My stomach growled in excitement, and I knew I was in for something special.

I ordered the classic deep dish pizza, and when it arrived, I couldn’t believe the size of it. This pizza was so deep, I could’ve sworn I was looking into a pizza abyss. It was a glorious tower of cheese, sauce, and toppings. I was ready to dive right in.

With the first bite, I could tell that this pizza was prepared with love. The crust was crispy on the outside, yet soft and doughy on the inside. It was like biting into a cloud made of pizza dreams. The sauce was tangy and had just the perfect amount of sweetness. And oh, the cheese! It was melted to perfection, stretching and oozing with every bite. It was a cheese lover’s paradise.

But the real standout was their toppings. They spared no expense, piling on generous amounts of pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, and onions. Each bite was a flavor explosion in my mouth, like a taste party that only the best pizzerias can throw.

So, if you find yourself in Appleton, Wisconsin and craving some deep dish pizza, do yourself a favor and head straight to Stuc’s Pizza. Your taste buds will thank you, and so will your stomach. Trust me, I’ve tasted the world, and Stuc’s holds a special place in my pizza-loving heart.

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Glass Nickel Pizza Co. – Appleton

This place has it all, folks. Not only do they serve up some delicious pies, but they also have the added benefit of serving alcohol. And not just your run-of-the-mill beer and wine, oh no. Glass Nickel goes the extra mile by offering hard liquor too! Because well, sometimes you just need a shot of tequila with your pizza, am I right?

Now, as a self-proclaimed pizza lover and occasional vegetarian, I appreciate that Glass Nickel has some veggie options on their menu. It’s nice to know that I can indulge in a delicious slice of pizza without feeling guilty about my carnivorous habits (or lack thereof).

But wait, there’s more! They even offer dessert! Because why stop at pizza when you can have a sweet treat to top it all off? It’s like the best of both worlds – a pizza and dessert extravaganza!

And let’s not forget that Glass Nickel is a great tourist spot. They’ve got that cozy, family-friendly vibe that makes you feel right at home. Plus, they have TVs plastered all over the place, making it the perfect spot to watch a sports game with friends. Who needs stadium seats when you can have a cold beer, some pizza, and a great view of the game?

Now, I do have one gripe. Glass Nickel doesn’t accept reservations. So if you’re planning on having a big party, you might want to make other plans. But hey, who needs a reservation anyway when you have the best thin crust pizza in Appleton waiting for you? Trust me, it’s worth the wait.