I’m on a mission to find the best pizza in this city and, after scouring the streets for 12 different places, I’m here to give you my take.
Do I have any professional qualifications? Well, I like to think that I know good pizza when I taste it! My motto is, why go to Paris when you can have Parisian pizza? Even if it’s half a world away…
So follow me on my journey through Ardmore as I share which pizzerias are worth going out of your way for. Not all places are created equal, but don’t worry – I’ll make sure you don’t get stuck with an old cold slice. Toppings down – let’s get started!
If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Pennsylvania
#1 Mark Anthony’s Paisano’s
- Has a kid’s menu
I recently visited the restaurant for lunch and was blown away by the experience. The staff were friendly, attentive and helpful – very welcoming!
The pizza itself was delicious. I had the classic margherita with additional pepperoni and sausage, and it was one of the best pies I’ve ever had! The fresh mozzarella added an extra layer of flavor to the pizza, and the crust was perfectly crisp yet soft.
One of my favorite things about Mark Anthony’s Paisano’s is their selection of toppings. You can mix-and-match whatever toppings you want and they’ll get it right every time – no matter how exotic your combination is! They even offer vegan options too.
I highly recommend visiting Mark Anthony’s Paisano’s if you’re in Ardmore looking for some excellent pizza. It truly is some of the best pizza in town!
If you’re willing to go an extra 6 miles, you can get to 20 more pizza places in Conshohocken!
#2 Original Eagle Pizza
- Has some vegetarian options
- Offers dessert
The pizza crust is light and crispy, but still chewy in the middle. It’s just the right amount of doughyness and flavor without being too bready. The sauce was incredibly flavorful as well – just a hint of spice that lingered on my taste buds long after I’d finished my slice.
The toppings were generous and fresh. I could tell that all of the ingredients had been carefully sourced to create the perfect combination — nothing felt out of place or overdone, which can often be an issue with pizzas that are overloaded with toppings.
It’s hard not to appreciate how great the staff at Original Eagle Pizza is as well — they’re incredibly friendly and accommodating, offering recommendations if you’re unsure what you want to order. Plus, they’ve got some pretty awesome deals going on, so you won’t have to break your budget for a delicious dinner!
I’m definitely looking forward to coming back to Original Eagle Pizza again soon! They may just be serving up the best pizza in Ardmore!
#3 Cenzo’s Pizzeria
- Has a kid’s menu
As soon as I arrived at Cenzo’s, I was in pizza heaven. The smell of fresh, delicious dough wafted through the air and it was clear that something amazing was in store for me.
When I stepped inside, I saw a vast selection of different pizzas being cooked to perfection. From classic pepperoni and cheese to more exotic toppings like roasted vegetables and feta, there was a pizza flavor to please everyone’s taste buds.
The crust is made with plenty of love and care and has just the right amount of crunch. And the sauce has just enough zing to tantalize your taste buds without overpowering them.
The topping combinations were top-notch – you could tell each one was put together with skill and creativity to ensure maximum flavor satisfaction. My personal favorite was their combination featuring garlic, spinach, and artichokes – it was truly magical!
In addition to the amazing pizza offerings at Cenzo’s Pizzeria, they also have an extensive selection of salads and appetizers that are perfect for a light snack before or after your meal. With such an array of savory treats, there really is something for everyone here!
All in all, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Ardmore then look no further than Cenzo’s Pizzeria! Their delicious pizzas combined with their friendly staff make this spot a must-visit when you’re in town.
#4 Jules Thin Crust
- Has some vegetarian options
I arrived at the restaurant expecting nothing more than a small take-out joint. Instead, I was delighted to find an airy and inviting pizzeria, with artfully painted walls and cozy seating.
The menu offered a tantalizing selection of thin-crust pizza options, all made with fresh ingredients. As instructed by my host, I opted for the signature white pizza, topped with provolone, ricotta and basil. It was cooked to perfection in Jules’ wood-fired oven, which added just the perfect amount of smokiness to the crust!
If that wasn’t enough to make me swoon, they also offer deep-dish and stuffed pizzas as well as salads and sandwiches – all crafted with a commitment to quality that you can taste in each bite. The staff was always friendly and incredibly helpful in helping us pick out the perfect pizza for our party.
A trip to Jules Thin Crust is one of those must-do activities when visiting Ardmore – no doubt the best pizza around!
#5 Marrone’s Pizzeria
- Has a kid’s menu
- Offers dessert
- Serves alcohol (and hard liquor!)
- No delivery
When I arrived at Marrone’s, I was impressed to find out they serve alcohol, including hard liquor! It was nice to be able to have a stiff drink with my pizza.
The food itself was fantastic. The crust was the perfect combination of crunchy and chewy, and the sauce and cheese were top-notch. They also offer a kid’s menu for those picky eaters in the family. Even better, they offer dessert as well – try their tiramisu, it will not disappoint!
Unfortunately, there is one downside: no delivery service. If you’re looking for great pizza but can’t make it to Marrone’s Pizzeria in person, you’ll have to find another option.
Overall, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Ardmore, head on over to Marrone’s Pizzeria – you won’t be disappointed!
If you’re willing to go an extra 6 miles, you can get to 23 more pizza places in Manayunk!
#6 Sam’s Brick Oven Pizza
- Has a kid’s menu
- Great place to watch sports
- Offers dessert
- Serves alcohol (and hard liquor!)
The atmosphere of the restaurant is a perfect combination of quaint and modern–and the pizza master’s ovens are an impressive sight to behold. The smell of dough baking in the brick ovens filled my nostrils as soon as I walked in, and I knew that whatever I ordered was going to be superb.
I had the classic pepperoni pizza, with extra red pepper flakes for a kick. The crust was cooked to perfection–it was both crunchy on the outside and tender on the inside. The sauce was tangy and flavorful, and there were just enough toppings so it didn’t overpower the crust.
To top it off, I also enjoyed their signature garlic breadsticks which were delicious dipped in their special creamy garlic dipping sauce. It tasted like heaven!
All-in-all, Sam’s Brick Oven Pizza definitely lives up to its name: it serves some of the best pizza in Ardmore! Highly recommend if you’re in the area and looking for delicious Italian style pizza!
#7 Papa Johns Pizza
- Offers dessert
I had the pepperoni and it was absolutely delicious. The crust was cooked to perfection, with a nice crunchy outer edge and a chewy center. The Pepperoni was piled high and full of flavor, nothing like those skimpy little slices you get at other places.
The service at Papa Johns Pizza was also top notch. After I ordered online they texted me when my pizza was ready and had it ready right on time. Plus, the staff were all super friendly and helpful throughout the whole process.
All in all, Papa Johns Pizza is a great place for some good old-fashioned pizza in Ardmore. Highly recommend it!
#8 Real Pizza Narberth
The moment I walked in, I was immediately impressed by the cozy atmosphere and friendly staff. The menu features a wide variety of specialty pizzas that make it hard to pick just one! After a lot of deliberation, I decided on the “Meat Lovers” pizza. It was absolutely delicious! The crust was perfectly chewy and every single topping was cooked to perfection.
What really sets Real Pizza Narberth apart from other pizza places is their use of fresh ingredients. From the homegrown tomatoes to the handmade mozzarella cheese, everything tasted so much better than anything I’ve had before!
All in all, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Ardmore – look no further than Real Pizza Narberth! You won’t be disappointed!
#9 Narberth Pizza
- Has some vegetarian options
The atmosphere is welcoming and inviting. The chefs are friendly and make sure that you have the best experience possible. The pizza dough is made fresh daily, with the perfect blend of herbs and spices to give it a unique flavor.
The toppings are top notch! From classic pepperoni to unusual combinations like prosciutto and fig, every ingredient is bought locally and always fresh. The pizza crust is wonderful–thin but not too thin, so it holds up well to all the deliciousness on top.
The finish of each pie is crisp and delicious. I especially enjoyed their famous White Pizza – made with mozzarella, garlic, spinach and ricotta; it was out of this world!
At Narberth Pizza, they live by their motto: “Where quality comes first”. And that’s absolutely true – from the warm atmosphere to the delicious food, I had an amazing experience every single time I visited Narberth Pizza! It truly is the best pizza in Ardmore!
If you’re willing to go an extra 6 miles, you can get to 22 more pizza places in Wayne!
#10 Crust Pizzeria
I’m a bit of a pizza connoisseur and I can tell you that this place takes the cake when it comes to great tasting pies. The crust is thin and chewy, just like it should be, and they use high-quality ingredients in their sauces and toppings. Plus, their prices are very reasonable – you’ll definitely get your money’s worth here!
The atmosphere at Crust Pizzeria is second to none – with its cozy interior, friendly staff and upbeat music playing in the background, you’ll feel right at home while enjoying some of the best pizza around. And if you’re looking for something extra special, you definitely need to try their signature deep dish pizza – it’s like eating a piece of heaven!
So if you’re ever looking for the best pizza in Ardmore (or anywhere else for that matter), look no further than Crust Pizzeria!
#11 Bella Italia Pizza
- Serves alcohol
Their thin crust pizzas are always cooked to perfection, and their secret sauce is something that must be tasted to be believed. The ingredients are well-selected and fresh, so each bite is filled with flavor. The staff at Bella Italia Pizza really knows their stuff when it comes to pizza-making.
The atmosphere is also spot on. Not too noisy or rowdy, but still lively enough for an enjoyable evening out. Prices are fair, and the portion sizes are generous – definitely enough to feed more than one person!
If you’re looking for the best pizza in Ardmore, then look no further than Bella Italia Pizza! Highly recommended!
#12 Oath Pizza – Suburban Square
- Has some vegetarian options
- Offers dessert
I was immediately taken aback by the incredible selection of toppings on offer. Their signature Doughborn Pizza comes with a unique cheddar and tomato blend, along with mozzarella cheese and a variety of other fresh vegetable toppings. If you’re looking for something a little more out there, their Peperoncini Pepperoni packs some serious heat – perfect for those who like it hot!
The real star of the show however was the hand-crafted dough. It’s cooked in a brick oven, using Oath’s secret recipe to give it an extra crispy crust. The way that each slice of pizza has its own unique texture is truly amazing! The sauce is also out of this world – bursting with flavor from tomatoes directly imported from Italy.
To top off my experience, Oath’s range of homemade desserts are second-to-none. Their strawberry cheesecake is definitely worth saving room for – trust me!
All in all, I feel I can say with confidence that Oath Pizza – Suburban Square has some of the best pizza in Ardmore. Whether you’re looking for something simple or something adventurous, there’s sure to be something here to delight your taste buds.
