I’m here to rate the twelve best pizza places in the area. From deep dish to Sicilian, I’ve experienced it all and I’m excited to show you the top contenders.
In this article, I’ll present a humorous and lighthearted review of each one. So come with me on a culinary adventure as I search for the ultimate slice of Arroyo Grande!
If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of California
#1 Beach Pizza
I’ve spent months exploring the globe, trying out different regional pizzas and taking on the challenge of finding the very best in every place I’ve visited. But Beach Pizza has taken the proverbial pizza-cake!
The atmosphere is delightful, with cheerful beach decor and friendly staff who know exactly how to make a fabulous pie. The crust was perfectly thin and crispy. The sauce was a delectable combination of herbs and spices that gave a delightful flavor boost to each bite. And the topping selection is superb – from classics like pepperoni, to exotic choices like jalapeños and pineapple!
Beach pizza also offers up some unique specialty pies. For example, you can get a seafood lovers’ pie with shrimp, zucchini and mushrooms, or the creative “Healthy Warrior” loaded with kale, spinach and sun-dried tomatoes. Yum!
The bonus was that after all that savory indulgence I didn’t even feel guilty as I washed it down with their delicious yet low-calorie cocktails (or mocktails). All in all, Beach Pizza gets two big thumbs up from this tired but satisfied food critic!
If you’re willing to go an extra 10 miles, you can get to 24 more pizza places in San Luis Obispo!
#2 Palo Mesa Wood Fired
- Nice tourist spot
- Offers dessert
- Serves alcohol
- Has some vegetarian options
The first thing I noticed about Palo Mesa is their commitment to fresh ingredients. From the pepperoni and sausage that go on top of their delicious pies, to the freshly grated Parmesan that’s sprinkled on top, you can taste the quality in every bite.
The crust at Palo Mesa is truly something special. They use a combination of wood-fired ovens to create a crispy yet chewy crust that’s full of flavor. I also appreciated how they had several different types of pizza available – from Hawaiian to vegetarian – so there’s something for everyone!
My favorite dish at Palo Mesa is their Bianco pizza with smoked mozzarella and ricotta cheese. This simple but flavorful pie has definitely earned its place as one of my all-time favorites.
If you’re looking for the best pizza in Arroyo Grande, then look no further than Palo Mesa Wood Fired! The fresh ingredients, amazing crust, and wonderful selection make it an unforgettable dining experience.
#3 Gino’s Pizza
- Has a kid’s menu
- Serves alcohol
- Nice tourist spot
- Has some vegetarian options
When I walked in, I was greeted by a friendly staff and the smell of fresh pizza. The decor gave off a laid back vibe that made me feel like I was at home.
The menu has something for everyone, from classic favorites to specialty pies. Their specialty is the “Gino’s Pie” which is loaded with pepperoni and sausage. It was delicious! The crust was perfectly thin and crispy, yet hearty enough to hold all the toppings without getting soggy.
The price is fair for the quality you get – definitely worth it for a treat every now and then. And if you’re looking for even more of a bang for your buck, they have great deals like their lunch specials and family-sized pizzas.
I give Gino’s Pizza two thumbs up. If you’re in the area, this should be your go-to spot for the best pizza around!
#4 Klondike Pizza
- Nice tourist spot
- Serves alcohol
The restaurant itself is quite charming. It has a rustic vibe and a welcoming atmosphere. Plus, the staff was warm and friendly.
The pizza was delicious! The crust was perfect – crispy on the outside but light and fluffy inside. The ingredients were of the highest quality, fresh and flavorful. I even asked for an extra topping, and they said yes without any trouble! Also, they had some pretty creative topping combinations to choose from.
Overall, Klondike Pizza is definitely worth visiting if you’re ever in Arroyo Grande looking for some great pizza. I highly recommend it!
If you’re willing to go an extra 10 miles, you can get to 24 more pizza places in San Luis Obispo!
#5 Fatte’s Pizza of Grover Beach
I was especially impressed with the cheese pizza. I’m talking about ultra-gooey, stringy mozzarella that sticks to your lip like no other. The crust was light, crisp and flavorful without being too thick or undercooked.
The toppings were also on-point. From pepperoni to sausage, everything was cooked perfectly and provided a delicious combination of textures and flavors. Even the anchovies—a favorite of mine—were sweet and salty at the same time!
One thing I really must commend Fatte’s Pizza on is their accommodating staff. They made me feel right at home and were full of suggestions for which pizzas I should try. They even did me a solid by offering half-priced slices!
All in all, I’d definitely recommend Fatte’s Pizza to anyone looking for some of the best pizza in Arroyo Grande. Don’t just take my word for it though—check it out yourself!
#6 Palo Mesa Pizza II
- Nice tourist spot
From the moment I entered the restaurant, I knew it was special. The inviting atmosphere and the tantalizing smells of baking pizzas set a great mood for my experience.
The staff was very friendly and helpful, offering me suggestion on what to order. After much deliberation, I ordered a classic pepperoni pizza with extra cheese and mushrooms. I was not disappointed! The crust was perfectly cooked – golden brown on the bottom but still soft and chewy on top – while the toppings were fresh and flavorful.
Beyond just a great pizza, Palo Mesa Pizza II also offers an extensive selection of beers and wines to accompany your meal. Whether you’re looking for a local craft beer or something imported from Italy, they have something to satisfy every palette!
I had such a wonderful experience at Palo Mesa Pizza II it is clear why it is considered to have some of the best pizza in Arroyo Grande. If you are in town and looking for delicious pizza, don’t hesitate – make your way to Palo Mesa Pizza II!
#7 Doughboys Pizzeria and Gluten Free
- Serves alcohol
- Has some vegetarian options
- Offers dessert
The crust was so thin and crunchy, it practically dissolved in my mouth. The cheese was gooey and delicious with just the right amount of spices. The toppings were fresh and flavorful—I especially enjoyed their unique take on the classic Italian sausage and pepperoni combination. Plus, they offer a great gluten-free option that rivals even the best pizzas I’ve had in Italy!
The atmosphere of Doughboys Pizzeria was relaxed and inviting, with friendly staff always willing to answer any questions I had about the menu. And even better, their prices are very reasonable for such high quality pizza.
Overall, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Arroyo Grande then look no further than Doughboys Pizzeria and Gluten Free! You won’t be disappointed!
If you’re willing to go an extra 17 miles, you can get to 26 more pizza places in Santa Maria!
#8 Palo Mesa Pizza
- Offers dessert
- Has some vegetarian options
The atmosphere is vibrant and inviting, with a lively brick oven in the center of the pizzeria. I made sure to take a look at the pizzas being prepared before selecting which one I wanted to try.
The dough is made fresh daily with locally sourced ingredients, and it’s clear that a lot of care goes into making each pizza. The crust was thin and crisp with just the right amount of chewiness – you can really taste the quality!
I chose their signature Marinara pizza, topped with tomatoes, garlic, oregano and parmesan cheese, and it was simply delicious! The balance of flavors was perfect, from the sweetness of the tomatoes to the saltiness from the cheese. Plus, you can watch them assemble each pizza as its baking in their wood-fired ovens!
Reasonable prices combined with excellent taste make this spot my top pick for best pizza in Arroyo Grande. Stop by Palo Mesa Pizza for an unforgettable culinary experience!
#9 Blaze Pizza
- Serves alcohol
- Nice tourist spot
- Has some vegetarian options
- Offers dessert
I’d heard good things about Blaze Pizza before arriving, but I’m always a bit skeptical. Well, I’m happy to report that the pizza exceeded all my expectations. The crust was perfectly cooked, with just the right amount of crunch and flavor. The toppings were fresh and flavorful – not too much, not too little – creating a perfect harmony of tastes. And the cheese! Oh the cheese! It was gooey, melty and incredibly decadent – like no other pizza I’ve ever had before.
The atmosphere was also top-notch. The restaurant itself is cozy yet modern and inviting; it’s easy to feel right at home when you walk through the door. Additionally, the staff was extremely friendly and helpful; they went out of their way to ensure our experience was enjoyable from start to finish.
All in all, if you’re looking for an amazing pizza experience in Arroyo Grande, Blaze Pizza is absolutely worth checking out!
#10 Sam’s Giant Manhattan Pizza
From the moment I stepped in the door, I was immediately struck by the atmosphere. The charming decor, lively music, and friendly staff created a welcoming ambiance that made me feel right at home.
Now, on to the pizza! The crust was the perfect balance of crispy and chewy – like a cloud of doughy goodness. The sauce was flavorful and had just the right amount of tangy sweetness. And when it comes to toppings, Sam’s Giant Manhattan Pizza offers an impressive selection of premium ingredients like peppers, mushrooms, onions, olives and more.
Speaking of toppings – wow! Talk about generous portions. Every slice you order is practically overflowing with toppings! There wasn’t a single bite that lacked flavor or texture.
I’d also like to note that their pizzas are served piping hot and out in minutes. That’s definitely something worth praising considering how quickly I can devour one whole pie by myself!
When all is said and done, if you’re ever looking for the best pizza in Arroyo Grande – look no further than Sam’s Giant Manhattan Pizza!
If you’re willing to go an extra 19 miles, you can get to 7 more pizza places in Morro Bay!
#11 Round Table Pizza
- Serves alcohol
- Has a kid’s menu
- Nice tourist spot
- Has some vegetarian options
The atmosphere is so inviting! It’s like stepping back in time. The décor is simple, yet playful with their iconic knight logo proudly displayed on the walls.
The pizza itself is top notch! You can taste the freshness of the ingredients right away. The dough is perfectly crispy, and the cheese melts perfectly in your mouth. My favorite part has to be the savory sauce that they use. It’s so flavorful and stands out among all other pizzas I’ve tried so far.
I also love Round Table Pizza’s generous amount of toppings! Every bite has something different in it. And you can’t forget about their creative specialty pies like BBQ Chicken or Four-Cheese Medley – these have definitely become a permanent staple for me whenever I’m in Arroyo Grande!
Overall, I highly recommend Round Table Pizza for anyone looking for an amazing pizza experience!
#12 Little Caesars Pizza
On my visit, I sampled many of their signature pizzas and the crust was simply divine. The toppings were bold and flavorful, with a great balance of flavors that left me wanting more. The marinara sauce was tangy and had a delightful kick that was just perfect.
My favorite find of the visit was definitely the “Crazy Bread,” which is thin strips of Italian-style bread smothered in butter, garlic, and cheese. Talk about addicting! It’s a must have if you ever visit Little Caesars Pizza.
The service here is also top-notch, with friendly staff that are always willing to go above and beyond for their customers. They even allow you to make custom orders if you like your pizza a certain way!
All in all, I recommend Little Caesars Pizza to anyone looking for some delicious pizza in Arroyo Grande. Whether you’re looking for something traditional or something more inventive, they’ve got it here! So what are you waiting for? Head on over to Little Caesars Pizza and get the best pizza in Arroyo Grande!
