Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Asbury Park (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in New Jersey

Best Pizza in Asbury Park (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

250 Views

I’m here to report on the best of the best. I’ve tasted twelve different pizzas – sampled slices from some of the area’s most acclaimed pizza places. And today, I am ready to name the undisputed champion of Asbury Park pizza!

This won’t be a boring, snobby food critique. I’m keeping things lighthearted and humorous as we take a journey through the pizzerias of Asbury Park. Come along with me and discover why it’s a great place to indulge in cheesy, saucy goodness!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New Jersey

#1 Rewind Pizzarama

First of all, the atmosphere is fantastic. The restaurant has a unique ’80s vibe, with customers being greeted by friendly waiters and waitresses decked out in vintage gear. The sound of classic old-school tunes playing in the background just adds to the nostalgia.

The pizza itself is also top-notch! From margherita to pepperoni, Rewind Pizzarama’s menu offers something for everyone. The crust is always perfect—crispy on the outside and soft on the inside—and they use high-quality toppings that really bring out the flavor of each pie. Be sure to try their specialties like their House Pizza or Truffle Fries Pizza!

To top it all off, Rewind Pizzarama offers great customer service. There’s always someone willing to help you with your order or answer any questions you may have about their menu items. They also accept most major credit cards so you don’t have to worry about having cash on hand. All in all, this place is well worth a visit for anyone looking for some delicious pizza with an old-school flare!

If you’re willing to go an extra 2 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Red Bank!

#2 Del Ponte’s Coal Fired Pizza

The first thing that struck me about this place was the amazing aromas of coal-fired pizza. As soon as I walked in, the smell of freshly baked dough, delicious marinara sauce, and juicy toppings filled the air.

The decor is inviting and cozy; it’s just like walking into a classic pizzeria from the 1950’s. The staff was also very friendly and provided quick service.

The pies here are some of the best I’ve ever had! Every bite was a culinary delight – crispy yet fluffy crust, savory homemade sauces, fresh veggies and meats. They also offer gourmet-style pizzas with interesting combinations inspired by global flavors.

Del Ponte’s Coal Fired Pizza is definitely one of the best places for pizza in Asbury Park. Highly recommended!

#3 Joe’s Rotisseria

My search for the perfect slice of pizza started in India, where I tried some interesting curried pizzas that were a dinner-time game-changer! But nothing compared to Joe’s Rotisseria. From the moment I stepped inside, I knew we had a winner.

The atmosphere was cozy and inviting. The wait staff was friendly and knowledgeable about their menu items – they even gave me some great recommendations on what to order!

When my piping hot Margherita pizza arrived, it was love at first sight. The perfect blend of mozzarella cheese and sweet tomato sauce exploded in my mouth with every bite! The dough was light and fluffy yet crispy around the edges. And don’t get me started on the tangy oregano sprinkled atop the pizza – it was perfection.

It’s no wonder why Joe’s Rotisseria is known as one of the best pizza places in Asbury Park! When you’re looking for delicious pizza made with quality ingredients, look no further than Joe’s Rotisseria – you won’t regret it.

#4 Tino’s Artisan Pizza Co.

The experience at Tino’s Artisan Pizza Co. was nothing short of amazing. From the second I stepped foot in the restaurant I could smell the delicious aroma of pizza baking and it only got better from there! The staff were all very friendly and welcoming, which made me feel right at home right away.

I started out with their traditional margherita pizza – a classic combination of tomatoes, mozzarella cheese, and basil – and it was incredible! The crust was perfectly thin yet crisp and full of flavor. The tomato sauce was just perfect with a hint of sweetness that complemented the tartness of the cheese nicely. And the basil added an amazing herbal flavor to top it off.

The rest of my time at Tino’s Artisan Pizza Co. only got better! I tried their zesty pepperoni pizza – with pepperonis cooked to perfection on a sturdy crust with just enough spice to offer some kick without hiding the other flavors – as well as their unique Italian sausage pizza (with olives, roasted garlic cloves, and aromatic Italian sausage). Both dishes were outstanding!

If you’re ever in Asbury Park looking for the best pizza around, Tino’s Artisan Pizza Co is your place! From its inviting atmosphere to its signature creations, Tino’s has something for everyone and will surely satisfy even the most discerning pizza connoisseur.

#5 Pete & Elda’s Bar / Carmen’s Pizzeria

I arrived at the restaurant with much anticipation, expecting amazing pizza. I wasn’t disappointed! The decor is classic Italian-American – complete with a bar stocked with good beers and wines – which gave the place a homey feel.

The staff are friendly and efficient, which is always nice. But the highlight of my visit was undoubtedly the pizza. I opted for their signature pie, the Chica Donna Special: an ultra thin-crust base topped with vine-ripened tomatoes, freshly sliced onions and peppers, mozzarella cheese and pepperoni sausage. It’s easily one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had in my travels!

From its cozy atmosphere to its delicious pizza, Pete & Elda’s Bar / Carmen’s Pizzeria is definitely one of the best places for pizza in Asbury Park. Highly recommended!

#6 Talula’s

The first thing that grabbed my attention was the inviting atmosphere. The moment I stepped foot in the restaurant, I knew it was going to be a good time! It was bright and airy with a bustling vibe of contented pizza-eaters.

The menu had an impressive selection of pizzas including classic pepperoni, barbecue chicken, veggie supreme, and several house made favorites. Of course I had to try them all so I took the plunge and ordered a slice of each one. The pizzas were cooked to perfection with a crispy crust and melted cheese. Each topping was bursting with flavor and seemed like they were made especially for me.

The service was welcoming and friendly, checking back often to make sure we were doing alright. They even provided us with some special offers that helped make our experience even more enjoyable!

I left feeling full and satisfied; believing this place truly has some of the best pizza in Asbury Park! If you’re ever in town don’t forget to stop by Talula’s for an unforgettable meal.

#7 The Galley Pizza & Eatery

I could tell from the moment I stepped in that this was a place that takes its pizza seriously. The staff were friendly and knowledgeable, which made ordering a breeze. And when my pies arrived – wowee!

The crust was perfectly thin yet fluffy and light; the sauce tasted just like it had been simmered all day with a combination of herbs and spices; and the cheese melted right into the toppings. It was glorious!

I tried the classic Margherita and a few specialty pizzas (which I highly recommend). Every bite was delicious.

The atmosphere at the restaurant contributed to my positive experience as well. There’s mood lighting, contemporary art on the walls, and soft music playing in the background. It really transported me to Pizza Heaven!

In short, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Asbury Park, The Galley Pizza & Eatery is definitely where it’s at.

If you’re willing to go an extra 2 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Paterson!

#8 Tony’s Pizzeria & Restaurant

Upon entering the restaurant, I was immediately smitten by its quaint atmosphere and friendly service. The menu had an extensive selection of pizzas, so after much deliberation, I settled on one of my favorites – a classic pepperoni pizza.

I must say that the pizza exceeded my expectations! The thin crust was perfectly crispy while still retaining a hint of softness; not to mention it wasn’t too greasy. Additionally, the generous amounts of toppings ensured that each bite was filled with flavor.

To top off what was already a great experience, Tony’s also offers customers a wide array of beverage options. I treated myself with a refreshing craft beer which paired perfectly with the pizza.

All in all, if you’re looking for an enjoyable dining experience filled with delicious food and drinks, then look no further than Tony’s Pizzeria & Restaurant! They have some of the best pizza in Asbury Park and well worth checking out!

#9 Crust & Crumble Pizzeria

I’ve tasted pizza in some of the best cities in Italy, France, and even America. But after tasting Crust & Crumble’s delectable brick-oven pizzas, I am certain that this pizzeria is a cut above the rest.

Their pizzas are fresh, flavorful, and baked to perfection. The crust is crispy and bubbly with just the right amount of doughiness, while the toppings are generous and varied. Whether you like classic pepperoni or something more daring like artichokes, they have it all!

The atmosphere at Crust & Crumble is also worthy of note. The staff is friendly and accommodating without being intrusive, and the dining area has that comfortable yet stylish feel that you’d expect from an Italian eatery.

Plus, I’m always impressed by their creative specials. Just recently I tried a pie topped with prosciutto and fontina cheese – definitely one of my favorites!

So if you’re looking for the best pizza in Asbury Park (or anywhere else for that matter!), then definitely visit Crust & Crumble Pizzeria—you won’t be disappointed!

#10 TJ’s Pizza

The pizza crust is light and airy with just the right amount of crunch. It’s not too thick or chewy like some other pizzas I’ve tried. Even when loaded with toppings, it still manages to stay crisp!

The sauce is warm and flavorful, with just the right balance of sweetness and spice. It’s definitely one of my favorite pizza sauces I’ve ever tasted!

The toppings are also top-notch. They have a wide variety of signature topping combinations to choose from that include everything from pepperoni to artichokes. All are fresh and full of flavor – no skimping here!

I was also pleasantly surprised by their delivery service. The pizza arrived hot, fresh, and still crisp even after a 15 minute drive! That’s impressive.

No doubt about it: TJ’s Pizza has earned the title of “Best Pizza in Asbury Park”. If you haven’t had the chance to try it out yet, what are you waiting for? You won’t regret it!

#11 Killer Pies

The atmosphere of the restaurant is cozy and inviting. I felt right at home as soon as I stepped in. As for the pizza, I have never tasted anything like it! The sauce was tangy, the crust incredibly crispy and the cheese melted perfectly.

I had a chance to try several different varieties of pizza, from pepperoni to Hawaiian. They were all delicious, but my favorite was definitely the Margherita. The tomato sauce had just the right amount of kick, while the mozzarella was thick and creamy—it was perfection on a plate!

The staff at Killer Pies was friendly and helpful throughout my visit, making sure that any special requests were met with a smile. If you’re looking for the best pizza in Asbury Park, look no further than Killer Pies!

#12 Johnny Mac House of Spirits

I was a bit hesitant to try this place out at first, since it’s a sports bar and I wasn’t sure how well the pizza would be. But I’m pleased to say that my worries were all for nothing! The pies here are some of the best I’ve ever tasted, with tasty, fresh ingredients and a perfectly crisp crust.

Aside from the amazing pizza, I also have to mention that Johnny Mac House of Spirits is a great spot for anyone who wants something more than just dinner – they serve alcohol (and hard liquor!), so you can turn your dinner into an awesome night out! In addition to that, it’s also located in a popular tourist destination, which makes it an even better place to hang out.

The only downside (if you could call it that) is that they don’t offer delivery service. But honestly, when the pizza tastes this good, why would you want them to deliver? All in all, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Asbury Park – and more – then you definitely can’t go wrong with Johnny Mac House of Spirits.