Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Athens GA (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Georgia

Best Pizza in Athens GA (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

97 Views

I’ve had the privilege of tasting pizza all over the world, so when it comes to finding the best pizza in Athens GA, there’s no one better qualified to give my opinion. I’ve tried 12 different places and can confidently say that there are some real gems out there!

It’s time for an honest review about which pizza places serve up a slice that stands out from the rest. This lighthearted but surprisingly insightful article will highlight the top three pizzerias in Athens GA – let’s get started!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Georgia

#1 Automatic Pizza

The atmosphere at Automatic Pizza was surprisingly pleasant. The walls were adorned with colorful paintings and the music selection was right on point.

The pizza itself was a masterpiece. The crust was crunchy but had just the right amount of softness to make it perfect. The toppings were all fresh, flavorful, and abundant! I liked how they offered lots of different topping choices and combinations so there’s something for everyone. The sauce was nicely balanced between sweet and savory – not too tangy or tart like some other pizzas I’ve tried.

Overall, I can honestly say that Automatic Pizza is one of the best pizza places in Athens. If you’re looking for a great meal without breaking the bank, this is definitely the spot to check out!

If you’re willing to go an extra 34 miles, you can get to 25 more pizza places in Gainesville!

#2 Peppino’s Pizzeria

With a variety of options on the menu, there’s something for everyone here. Whether you’re in the mood for pepperoni and sausage, or you only want veggies, you can get it at Peppino’s. And with their kid’s menu, even the pickiest of eaters will find something to love!

Aside from the awesome food choices, another great thing about Peppino’s is that they serve alcohol! I’m a sucker for craft beer and pizza – what could be better?

What I didn’t like was that they don’t offer delivery. But if you have time to sit down and enjoy your meal (which I recommend!), then this won’t be an issue. Plus, they make up for not delivering by offering some seriously delicious dessert options when you’re done eating pizza.

Overall, I give Peppino’s Pizzeria two big thumbs up! If you’re looking for the best pizza in Athens, look no further than this restaurant!

#3 Fully Loaded Pizza Kitchen

When I first walked in, I was greeted immediately by the friendly staff. Then, when I saw the huge selection of pizzas on their menu, it was impossible for me not to order one. Of course, my eyes were instantly drawn to the specialty Fully Loaded pizza: a double-decker behemoth piled high with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms and olives.

I was lucky enough to get a seat out front and still get a good view of the bustling kitchen. Every time an order came out of the ovens– mouthwateringly fragrant– I would swear that this must be the best pizza in Athens!

Fortunately, my hypothesis was proven correct– with every bite of creamy cheese and delicious toppings, it was confirmed again and again that Fully Loaded Pizza Kitchen is truly Athens’ finest.

And don’t even get me started on their famous garlic knots! They are tender yet crunchy and covered in herbs, parmesan and just enough garlic to make them unforgettable. Trust me, you’ll be ordering seconds before you know it.

Needless to say, if you’re ever in Athens looking for the best pizza around– look no further than Fully Loaded Pizza Kitchen!

#4 DePalma’s Italian Cafe – Eastside

Visiting DePalma’s Italian Cafe – Eastside was like entering a little slice of Italy. The atmosphere was cozy, yet modern and contemporary.

The pizza itself was nothing short of amazing! Each bite had the perfect combination of cheese, sauce and crust that left me wanting more. The ingredients were fresh and flavorful, and it was hard to pick a favorite topping, since all of them were delicious.

The staff at DePalma’s Italian Cafe – Eastside were also very friendly and helpful. They went out of their way to make sure I had an enjoyable dining experience.

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Athens, look no further than DePalma’s Italian Cafe – Eastside! You won’t be disappointed!

#5 Mama Sid’s Pizza

When I arrived at Mama Sid’s, the first thing that struck me was the delicious smell of pizza dough rising in the oven. The staff was also very friendly and welcoming, which only added to my anticipation of tasting their pies.

The first pizzas I tried were the pepperoni and classic pepperoni pizzas. Both were cooked to perfection – the crust was crispy and golden with a great cheese-to-sauce ratio. This might be common in many other pizza places but it certainly isn’t something you see often these days!

I also tried their signature creation: a deep-dish pizza with an extra layer of cheese, olives, jalapenos, and sausage all around it. It was some of the best pizza I’ve ever had! The toppings were fresh and flavorful and there were just enough flavors going on to make each bite interesting.

And if that wasn’t enough, Mama Sid’s makes all of its own sauces too so you know they’re always fresh. The garlic sauce is especially tasty — not too garlicky, but still full of flavor.

All in all, Mama Sid’s is definitely worth a visit if you’re in Athens looking for some of the best pizza around!

#6 Little Italy Pizzeria

This place serves up classic Italian-style pizza with a unique twist – they only use the freshest, locally-sourced ingredients. From the moment I stepped in, I knew this place was special. The aroma of melted cheese and herbs wafted through the air, and I was instantly drawn to it.

The pizzas are cooked to perfection in their wood-fired ovens that create a nice char and smoky flavor on the crust. Topping offerings include fresh mozzarella, roasted tomatoes, mushrooms, pepperoni and more – all with the perfect amount of seasoning to enhance the flavor of each individual ingredient.

And let’s not forget about their signature sauces! Their house-made red sauce is truly amazing – slightly sweet with a hint of spice that adds an extra layer of complexity to each bite. And their olive oil-based white sauce is equally delicious (but lighter than traditional tomato sauce). Both are excellent vehicle for all their toppings!

Overall, Little Italy Pizzeria gives you an authentic taste of Italy without having to leave Athens – making it hands down the best pizza spot in town!

#7 Ted’s Most Best

As you walk in, you can’t help but admire the traditional Italian restaurant setting – from the checkered tablecloths to the large brick oven in the back, it’s clear that Ted is serious about his pizza.

I decided to try their signature dish – the Most Best Supreme – and I was not disappointed! The combination of mozzarella, pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, and peppers really brought out all of the flavors from each topping. Even better, they managed to get a nice crispy crust while still keeping it light and fluffy.

The best part though? The price! For what I got it was surprisingly affordable – definitely worth every penny.

In conclusion, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Athens then look no further – Ted’s Most Best is your place!

#8 Cicis Pizza

I’d heard great things about the restaurant and finally got to experience it for myself. The cheesy aroma that greeted me as I walked in was heavenly. The options of delicious, fresh toppings made my mouth water. I had a hard time deciding what to get—the possibilities were endless!

When my pizza arrived, it was like a work of art. Each slice had the perfect amount of cheese and just the right crunchy crust. It was honestly the most delicious pizza I’ve ever tasted!

The atmosphere at Cicis Pizza is also top-notch. From the warm customer service to the inviting decor, this place definitely knows how to make someone feel welcome. Even better, the prices are extremely reasonable too!

All-in-all, Cicis Pizza is an exceptional restaurant that serves some of the best pizza in Athens. I would recommend it to anyone who has a hankering for some yummy slices!

If you’re willing to go an extra 38 miles, you can get to 25 more pizza places in Lawrenceville!

#9 Amici Athens

When I stepped into Amici Athens, the first thing I noticed was how inviting the atmosphere was. Not only does it make a great tourist spot, but you can also watch sports games and bring your kids – they have a kid’s menu!

The pizza selection is incredible – they serve eight different options and you can choose between traditional or deep-dish crusts. And to top it off, they even serve alcohol (including hard liquor)! And don’t forget the desserts – they have several options that are just as delicious as the pizzas.

On the downside, Amici Athens doesn’t offer delivery service. But if you’re within walking distance, this isn’t much of an issue.

All in all, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Athens, Amici Athens is definitely worth a visit!

#10 Johnny’s New York Style Pizza

I’m a picky pizza critic, so I was hesitant to give a favorable review. But after my first bite of their classic cheese pie, I knew I had to shout it from the rooftops: Johnny’s is the best pizza in Athens!

The crust was perfectly thin and crisp, yet still fluffy. They don’t skimp on quality ingredients either – the sauce was amazing! And the cheese – oh, that cheese – creamy and flavorful. Their slices hit all the right notes in terms of flavor and texture.

But what really impressed me was their service. Despite being extremely busy during my visit, they never lost their cool or failed to deliver top-notch customer care. Everyone from the counter staff to the pizza maker made sure to provide me with an enjoyable experience.

So if you’re looking for the best pizza in Athens, head over to Johnny’s New York Style Pizza! You won’t be disappointed!

#11 Athens pizza

I was skeptical at first, especially when I saw the cheesy Greek-style decorations and heard the tinny Greek music playing in the background. But after biting into my first slice of cheese pizza, I was sold. The crust was light and fluffy, the sauce was perfectly seasoned, and the cheese was melted just right.

Before leaving, I decided to try something a little more adventurous – a gyro pizza! It had all of the traditional Greek toppings you’d expect – lamb, tomatoes, feta cheese, and loads of oregano – stacked on top of a perfect base of dough and sauce.

Overall, Athens Pizza is the real deal and definitely worth trying out if you’re ever in Athens. They even have an extensive selection of craft beers to go with your pizzas! Now that’s what I call a complete dining experience!

#12 DePalma’s Italian Cafe – Westside

The atmosphere at DePalma’s is cozy and inviting, and the staff is friendly and accommodating. The restaurant has a great selection of traditional pizzas, as well as some unique creations. My personal favorite was the Italian Sausage and Olive pizza – it was packed with flavor!

I also tried the Barbecue Chicken Pizza, which had a great smoky-sweet combo. And let me tell you – DePalma’s crust is amazing…it was crunchy but still light and airy.

I would definitely recommend DePalma’s Italian Cafe – Westside for anyone looking for some of the best pizza in Athens. They have something for everyone!