Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Atlantic City Boardwalk (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in New Jersey

Best Pizza in Atlantic City Boardwalk (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

325 Views

I’ve traveled far and wide, sampling pizza in places as diverse as Italy, Mexico, New York, and more. After extensive research – tasting twelve different pizzas from Atlantic City Boardwalk – I’m ready to share my list of the best pies this famous boardwalk has to offer.

Given my experience with pizza from all around the globe, you can trust that this list is no joke. I’m taking my job seriously, so sit back and enjoy a humorous yet lighthearted look at the best choices for pizza in Atlantic City Boardwalk.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New Jersey

#1 Don Macos Pizza and Grill

When I first walked into Don Macos, I was expecting the typical pizza joint. But what I found instead was an intimate atmosphere, with a wood-burning oven cooking some of the most delicious pizzas I’ve ever had.

The pizzas here are made with fresh ingredients and cooked to perfection. Their signature pies–the Don Macos Specialità and Truffle Prosciutto & Arugula–are two of my favorites. The crust is thin, but not too thin, and is crisp around the edges with just the right amount of chewiness.

One of their unique offerings is their “Grande Margherita”. This pie includes a large host of unique toppings: marinated tomatoes, capers, olives and anchovy filets. The blend of flavors created by these toppings are impeccable! Deliciousness in every bite!

I also have to give props to their staff as they were friendly and accommodating to all my needs. From helping me pair wines to suggesting new variations on classic pies; they know what they’re doing!

If you’re looking for some seriously good pizza in Atlantic City Boardwalk make sure you don’t miss out on Don Macos Pizza and Grill. You won’t regret it!

If you’re willing to go an extra 10 miles, you can get to 22 more pizza places in Ocean City!

#2 Jeni’s Pizza

On my most recent visit, I tried the signature slice, a classic pepperoni pizza topped with onions, green peppers, and black olives. The crust was perfectly thin and crispy just like I love it and the sauce was surprisingly sweet but not overly so. Even more impressive were all of the toppings that somehow evenly dispersed throughout each slice!

The atmosphere at Jeni’s Pizza is also noteworthy. It’s small but cozy and has a great vibe from the moment you walk in. Plus, it’s those little touches like their curated music selection playing in the background that really set it apart from other pizza places.

Overall, my experience at Jeni’s Pizza was fantastic and I’d highly recommend their pizzas to anyone looking for great pizza in Atlantic City!

#3 Rhythm & Spirits

I was pleasantly surprised by their unique menu, which featured some interesting toppings. Their specialties include BBQ chicken pizza with spicy honey mustard and smoked gouda, and pulled pork pizza with pickles and cheddar cheese. The combination of flavors was delicious!

The restaurant itself is a great place to eat. The atmosphere is upbeat and hip, and the staff are friendly and accommodating. Plus, the outdoor seating area is perfect for taking in the sights of the boardwalk while munching on an amazing slice of pizza.

My favorite part about this place though, has to be the overall quality of their pizzas. They use fresh ingredients that make each bite taste like a burst of flavor in your mouth! I’m confident that I have found my new favorite spot for pizza in Atlantic City Boardwalk – Rhythm & Spirits!

#4 Cuzzie’s Pizzeria & Kitchen

The atmosphere was the best I’ve ever experienced in a pizza restaurant. There were cozy couches, modern art on the walls, and the most amazing smell of fresh dough rising in the air.

I started off with an appetizer of Cheese Garlic Knots – so delicious! Then for pizza I tried their signature pie, which consists of pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, black olives and extra cheese. The flavors married together so well, it was like a symphony of taste! The crust was light and fluffy and the cheese was nice and gooey – just perfect.

My experience at Cuzzie’s definitely lived up to all my expectations. If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Atlantic City – this is definitely your spot!

#5 Southside Pizza

The first thing I noticed upon entering was the pleasant aroma of freshly-made pizza. It’s like a little slice of heaven. With my mouth already watering, I eagerly settled into one of the cozy booths and perused their menu. While the prices are on the higher side compared to some other pizzerias, it’s worth every penny.

When my pies arrived, they were loaded with fresh ingredients and delicious toppings — exactly what you’d expect from a five-star pizza place! The thin crust was crispy and flavorful, while the thick sauce had just the right amount of saltiness. Every bite was a tantalizing mix of salty and sweet flavors that put Southside Pizza ahead of its competition in Atlantic City.

I also can’t say enough about the customer service at Southside Pizza. From the moment we walked through the door to the time we left, everyone went above and beyond to make sure our experience was nothing short of fantastic!

In conclusion, Southside Pizza is easily one of the best pizzerias in Atlantic City — make sure you check them out next time you’re in town!

#6 Tony’s Baltimore Grill

The restaurant’s atmosphere is warm and inviting, with exposed brick walls and cozy wooden booths. I’m sure the charming setting adds to the overall pizza-tasting experience!

I couldn’t wait to get my hands on a slice of Tony’s signature pie. From the first bite, I could tell that it had been lovingly crafted with care—it was perfection! The crust was just the right balance of crunchy and chewy, plus it came nicely charred from the wood-fired oven. The sauce was sweet and tangy, while the cheese was perfectly melted. And don’t even get me started on the pepperoni! It was flavorful and juicy without being too greasy. Delicious!

All in all, Tony’s Baltimore Grill is definitely at the top of my list when it comes to finding the best pizza in Atlantic City. I’d recommend this place to anyone looking for an unforgettable pizza experience.

#7 Tony Boloney’s Atlantic City

My first experience at the restaurant was truly unforgettable. Upon entering I was greeted by friendly staff that seemed to know their stuff when it came to pizza.

The atmosphere of Tony Boloney’s was one that I’ll never forget. The decor is unique and inviting, and there’s an excellent variety of seating options. The music they play is great too; it provided the perfect background noise.

Now onto the good stuff: the pizza! Their signature pies are simply sublime – a thick, cheesy crust with a plethora of delicious toppings that offer something for everyone. Not only do they have a wide variety of classic Italian-style pizzas, but their specialty pizzas rise above the rest. From buffalo chicken to barbecue pork, these specialties are packed with flavor and sure to satisfy any craving.

Their prices are also quite reasonable, making it easy to try a few different pies without breaking the bank. And if you really want to splurge, they offer delivery options so you can enjoy your Tony Boloney’s pizza from the comfort of your own home!

If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Atlantic City (or anywhere else!), I highly recommend paying a visit to Tony Boloney’s Atlantic City. You won’t be disappointed – trust me!

#8 Queens Pizza Palace

My initial impression was that their crust was cooked to perfection–crispy, yet chewy and with just the right amount of seasoning. The sauce was also delicious; perfect balance of sweet and savory, and applied sparingly, allowing the toppings (which are always fresh!) to take center stage.

The real showstopper is the cheese. It not only tastes amazing, but forms a perfectly crispy layer between the crust and the toppings. And don’t even get me started on their specialty pies. Whether it’s their unique flavor combinations like the “East Coast-West Coast” or their classic Greek Pie, Queens Pizza Palace never disappoints!

All in all, I’d give Queens Pizza Palace two enthusiastic thumbs up! If you’re looking for a pizza experience that’s out of this world, this is it!

#9 3 Brothers Pizza Palace

The restaurant itself is a nice tourist spot, with a fun, friendly atmosphere and plenty of seating. Unfortunately, they don’t offer delivery services yet – which I’m sure will be remedied soon enough.

The selection of pies at 3 Brothers Pizza Palace is impressive and can satisfy even the pickiest eater. On my visit, I had their signature “Big Brother” pizza. With its extra-thick crust and melted cheese covering ever inch of the top, it was delicious and very satisfying.

I also tried their ‘Little Brother’ pizza, which was even more delicious! It featured some unique toppings that you don’t typically find in other pizzerias around town. That’s why 3 Brothers Pizza Palace is one of the best places to grab a slice in Atlantic City!

#10 Fiesta Pizza

The atmosphere and staff were friendly, making it a great spot to relax and enjoy some delicious pizza. The interior was basic, but cozy, and I think it added to the overall humble vibe of the restaurant.

But enough about the atmosphere—let’s talk about the pizza! Fiesta Pizza offers an incredible selection of pizzas ranging from classic margherita pies to oddball creations like their Baked Potato pie. My personal favorite was the Hawaiian BBQ Bacon—they really packed a punch with flavor! Every bite was a unique journey of taste, and I had a hard time sharing it with my friends.

The service at Fiesta Pizza was exceptional. Our server was prompt, attentive, and helpful when we had any questions about the menu items. We all appreciated her cheerful attitude as well.

Overall, Fiesta Pizza is definitely one of the best places for pizza in Atlantic City. Whether you’re stopping by for lunch or dinner with friends, you won’t be disappointed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 20 miles, you can get to 16 more pizza places in Avalon!

#11 The Original LoPresti’s Pizza & Grill

The atmosphere of the restaurant is inviting, and the service is friendly. The menu features a variety of traditional Italian pizzas with unique toppings like gyro meat, roasted garlic, and pesto. I decided to try their “Signature” pizza which came with a generous helping of fresh mozzarella cheese and savory Italian sausage.

The crust was thin and had a perfect crunch when I bit into it. The flavor was intense but not overpowering – just enough spices to tantalize my taste buds without being too much. And the toppings were cooked perfectly – fresh and flavorful. I kind of felt like a gourmet chef myself!

But what really made this pizza stand out were two things: the sauce and the cheese. The homemade tomato sauce had an intense flavor that brought the entire pizza together in harmony. And the stretchy, melty mozzarella pull was amazing – something you don’t get at other pizza joints in Atlantic City!

Overall, I can confidently say that The Original LoPresti’s Pizza & Grill has some of the best pizza in Atlantic City. If you’re looking for an exceptional meal, this is definitely worth trying out!

#12 Alfredo’s Pizza King

The first thing I noticed was how wonderful the atmosphere is. When I walked in, I felt like the king of the world! The decor was inviting and warm, and everyone working there was so friendly.

The pizza itself was absolutely amazing. The crust was light and crispy, and the toppings were fresh and flavorful. They have a huge selection of toppings to choose from as well, so you can make a truly custom pizza.

And don’t even get me started on their cheese blend! It’s super creamy and full of flavor; definitely something that sets Alfredo’s Pizza King apart from any other pizza restaurant in Atlantic City!

Overall, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Atlantic City, then Alfredo’s Pizza King is a must-try. From its amazing atmosphere to its delicious pizzas, Alfredo’s Pizza King will surely satisfy all your cravings!