Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Baltimore County (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Maryland

Best Pizza in Baltimore County (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

289 Views

Now, let me tell you – I’ve searched far and wide for the best pizza around the world. From Ethiopia to Rome, Brazil to Chicago – I’m always looking for that elusive perfect slice.

But now I’m ready to bring my pizza expertise closer to home and give you a summary of the best places to get pizza in Baltimore County. After visiting 12 different locations, I’ve compiled my list of the best places for pizza in Baltimore County – with a few lighthearted comments along the way. So, loosen your belts and get ready to dig into some deliciousness!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Maryland

#1 Frank’s Pizza & Pasta

My first visit to Frank’s was on a Saturday night and the restaurant was bustling. Everyone seemed to be enjoying their meal, so I knew I had to try it out for myself.

When the pizza arrived, it was love at first bite. The crust was perfectly thin and crispy with that ideal balance of crunch and chewiness. And the sauce! It had the perfect balance of sweetness and acidity that made each slice enjoyable from start to finish.

To top it off, there is an ample selection of toppings available, allowing you to create your own personal pizza pie masterpiece. Whether you’re in the mood for pepperoni or spinach – Frank’s has got you covered.

All in all, if you’re looking for a great slice of pizza in Baltimore County then look no further than Frank’s Pizza & Pasta!

If you’re willing to go an extra 2 miles, you can get to 18 more pizza places in Baltimore!

#2 Pizza John’s

As a food critic, I always have high standards and I am never disappointed when dining at Pizza John’s. The pizza is piping hot and loaded with flavor. And best of all, the toppings are always fresh and full of taste.

When it comes to amenities, Pizza John’s has got you covered! They serve alcohol, so it’s great for date night or catching up with friends. There’s even a kid’s menu, which makes it perfect for families on the go. Best of all – they have insanely good dessert! So don’t forget to save room for something sweet.

One downside is that they don’t offer delivery, so you’ll have to dine-in or take out if you want to experience Pizza John’s deliciousness. But that doesn’t make this any less of a tourist spot; in fact, it only adds to its charm!

All in all, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Baltimore County – then you can stop your search at Pizza John’s!

#3 Gil’s Pizza

When walking into Gil’s Pizza, you can instantly smell the amazing pizza cooking in the oven. The atmosphere is inviting and warm and all of the employees are eager to help. I was truly impressed by their selection of toppings that they offer – everything from olives to bacon!

The crust at Gil’s Pizza is just perfect – light, crispy, and buttery. When biting into a slice, it just melts in your mouth! The sauce is also perfect – not too sweet but still full of tomato flavor. Their cheese is nice and gooey, making each bite oh-so enjoyable!

I love the variety of pizzas they have at Gil’s Pizza. From veggie pies to meat lover’s delights, they have something for everyone! On top of that, the prices are very reasonable and you get a lot for your money.

Overall, I would highly recommend checking out Gil’s Pizza if you want some of the best pizza around Baltimore County! It definitely will not disappoint!

#4 Mario’s Original Pizza & Pasta

The atmosphere is incredible. The staff is friendly and accommodating, the décor cozy and inviting. And you can’t forget about the pizza – it’s cooked to perfection!

My favorite is their signature Calabrese, with its unbeatable combination of spicy salami, pepperoni, roasted peppers, black olives and mushrooms. It’s a classic crowd-pleaser that never fails to impress. There’s also a wide variety of specialty pizzas on the menu, from pesto chicken to eggplant parmigiana.

Not only does Mario’s have some of the best pizza in Baltimore County, but they know how to do pasta right too! Their spaghetti Bolognese is legendary – slow cooked with homemade tomato sauce and fresh herbs. For lighter fare they offer a variety of salads including an amazing caprese salad made with organic tomatoes, fresh mozzarella and basil leaves.

In summary, Mario’s Original Pizza & Pasta has set the bar high when it comes to great Italian cuisine in Baltimore County – it truly lives up to its reputation as one of the best in town!

#5 TinyBrickOven

From the moment I stepped through the door I knew this place was something special. The amazing scent of fresh pizza wafted through the air, and it was unlike anything I had ever experienced before.

The atmosphere was cozy but inviting. The interior had a unique rustic feel to it, with wooden tables and flickering candles. It truly made me feel like I was right back home in my grandmother’s kitchen.

The staff were so friendly and welcoming, they quickly made me feel right at home. They even gave me suggestions on what to order!

I ended up getting the classic cheese pizza which was delightful! The crust had a nice crunchy texture while the inside melted in my mouth like butter. Plus, every bite came packed with flavor from the quality ingredients used to make it.

If you’re looking for a great slice of pizza in Baltimore County then look no further than TinyBrickOven! You won’t be disappointed with the deliciousness that awaits you here!

#6 Zella’s Pizzeria

Upon entering the restaurant, I was immediately met with a warm and inviting atmosphere. The staff were friendly and helpful in recommending their favorite pizzas, which was very much appreciated.

I had the pleasure of trying several of Zella’s specialty pizzas, each one better than the last. Their classic pepperoni pizza was perfectly crisp and had a great flavor to it. The BBQ chicken pizza was also excellent, with a delicious smoky flavor that really made the whole dish. But the highlight of my experience came from their signature “Zella’s Delight” pizza – an absolute masterpiece, combining sausage, pepperoni, onions, peppers, and mushrooms with a delightful tomato sauce. It truly felt like I’d been taken away to Italy while eating this pizza!

In conclusion: If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Baltimore County – look no further than Zella’s Pizzeria! You won’t be disappointed!

#7 Arthouse

The atmosphere at Arthouse is amazing – it’s like being transported to a Tuscan villa. The Italian decor and cozy atmosphere make for a great dining experience.

The pizza here is truly incredible. The crust is perfectly crispy and the ingredients of each topping are fresh and flavorful. Even the simplest of pizzas here are tastier than those found elsewhere! I especially love their traditional Margherita pizza – the combination of mozzarella, basil, tomatoes, and garlic never fails to satisfy my cravings.

The best part about Arthouse though has to be the service – it’s always top-notch! Everyone from the waiters to the chefs make sure that you have an unforgettable experience every time you visit.

Overall, I highly recommend Arthouse for anyone looking for some truly world-class pizza in Baltimore County!

#8 Matthew’s Pizzeria

The first thing that struck me was the smell of fresh-baked dough emanating from the restaurant. The sweet aroma gave me a good feeling about what was to come.

The slices of pizza had generous toppings, not skimping on flavor or ingredients like some places do. Furthermore, they weren’t overloaded so as to overload your taste buds: just the right amount of cheese and pepperoni—perfection!

But even beyond that, I could tell that this pizza was something special. After all, it had just the right amount of charring on the crust—an element most places overlook until it’s too late. Those details make a difference and Matthew’s got it spot on.

The staff at Matthew’s Pizzeria definitely knows their stuff when it comes to making great pizzas. From start to finish, they provide excellent customer service. I would definitely recommend this place to anyone looking for some of the best pizza in Baltimore County!

If you’re willing to go an extra 5 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Towson!

#9 Tov Pizza

I’m no stranger to pizza, having sampled pies from Milan to Montevideo and everywhere in between. Yet nothing prepared me for the deliciousness of Tov Pizza. The crust is perfectly thin and delicate yet also holds up well enough to support the toppings. The cheese, oh the cheese! It’s a perfect blend of creamy and mild that melts in your mouth with each bite.

The toppings are always fresh and varied, ranging from classic favorites like pepperoni and mushrooms to more creative ones like artichoke hearts and olives. Everything is cooked in the state-of-the-art brick ovens that give the pizza a unique flavor and texture that I haven’t found anywhere else.

The service here is also beyond compare; from the moment you arrive at Tov Pizza until you leave, you’re treated like family. The staff is friendly and knowledgeable about their products, making sure every customer is satisfied with their meal.

At the end of it all, Tov Pizza continues to deliver consistently delicious pies every time I visit them, further cementing its status as one of Baltimore County’s best pizzerias!

#10 Squire’s Italian Restaurant and Catering

My first bite of Squire’s pizza was pure ecstasy. The dough was perfectly chewy and soft, the sauce was flavorful and tangy, and the cheese was unbelievably creamy! I think the best part of it all was how generous they were with the toppings – for a small fee you could get an entire pan filled with your favorite ingredients.

To top it off, their customer service was top-notch. My waiter, John, made sure that my experience would be a memorable one by being attentive to my every need. He asked questions about what kind of pizza I wanted, offered helpful suggestions on wine pairings, even went out of his way to ensure that my meal arrived at its optimum temperature.

If you’re ever looking for the best pizza in Baltimore County, I don’t think you can go wrong with Squire’s Italian Restaurant and Catering.

#11 Birroteca Baltimore

I visited on a hot summer day, and couldn’t wait to sample the deliciousness that was in store for me. From the second I stepped into Birroteca’s beautiful interior, with its wooden walls and shiny copper accents, I knew this place was going to be special.

The menu was impressive. From traditional pizzas like Margherita and Pepperoni to more inventive creations like their ‘Calabrian Special’, there really is something for everyone. But what really sealed the deal for me were the quality of ingredients. All of their toppings tasted incredibly fresh and flavorful, with none of that processed taste you get from smaller places with lesser standards.

Birreteca Baltimore gets an A+ from this traveling food critic! Not only do they have some of the best pizza in Baltimore County, but they also deliver an unmatched dining experience.

#12 The Good Guys N.Y. Pizza Kitchen

The ambiance of this restaurant is great. From the classic New York style decor to the bubbly and friendly staff, it’s everything you’d expect from a pizza place in Baltimore County.

But now let’s talk about ‘za. The Good Guys have all your favorite toppings—from pepperoni to mushrooms, and even pineapple—as well as some unique creations like their house-made vegan pesto pies. But what really sets The Good Guys apart are their signature thin-crusted, hand-tossed pies. Each one is carefully crafted with love and attention to ensure that every bite has the perfect ratio of sauce and cheese.

The crust on their pies is especially noteworthy. It’s crispy but not crunchy and holds up to all kinds of delicious toppings without getting soggy or overwhelming the palate. And if you’re feeling adventurous, try their New York style bagel pizzas—it’s an absolute must have!

Overall, I can confidently say that The Good Guys N.Y. Pizza Kitchen serves some of the best pizza in Baltimore County! Be sure to swing by if you’re ever in town!

Best Deep Dish Pizza – Matthew’s Pizzeria

When I heard that Matthew’s Pizzeria served alcohol, including hard liquor, I nearly kissed the ground in gratitude. Finally, a pizza joint that understands the importance of a good drink with your slice! As a traveling food critic, I appreciate a place that offers me both pizza and a pint. It’s like a match made in cheesy heaven.

But here’s the best part: Matthew’s Pizzeria has vegetarian options! It’s a miracle! I almost shed a tear of joy when I discovered they actually cater to us herbivores. Finally, a place where I can bring my vegetarian friends and not feel guilty about shoving a carnivorous pie in their faces.

And let’s not forget dessert! Matthew’s Pizzeria doesn’t just stop at amazing deep dish pizza; they also have sweet treats to satisfy your sugar cravings. It’s like they know that pizza and dessert are a match made in heaven. I can almost hear the angels singing as I dig into a slice of tiramisu after indulging in a heavenly slice of pizza. Pure bliss!

The only downside is that Matthew’s Pizzeria does not accept reservations. But honestly, that just adds to the adventure. You have to be ready for a spontaneous pizza experience that may require a bit of waiting. It’s like a social experiment to test your patience.

All in all, Matthew’s Pizzeria is not just a great pizza place, it’s also a nice tourist spot. So if you find yourself in Baltimore craving the best deep dish pizza in town, head over to Matthew’s Pizzeria and prepare your taste buds for an unforgettable, cheesy experience!