Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Bayonne NJ (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in New Jersey

Best Pizza in Bayonne NJ (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

267 Views

I don’t say this lightly. After traveling the world and sampling pizza from all over, I know a good slice when I see one – or should I say taste one!

That’s why this time around in Bayonne NJ, I set out to find the best pizza around with a detailed review of 12 places.

This journey across Bayonne has been an adventure – and some pies have definitely been more adventurous than others. However, through all these slices, some standouts have amazed me with their flavor and texture.

Let’s get ready to identify who deserves the title of “Best Pizza in Bayonne NJ”!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New Jersey

#1 Brothers Pizza & Pasta

I’m not exaggerating when I say that the pizza here is out of this world. From the first bite, you can tell they put a lot of love into making each pie. The crust is perfectly crisp and chewy, and the toppings are always fresh and generously applied. Plus, their menu has tons of specialty pies that you won’t find anywhere else.

The service at Brothers Pizza & Pasta is also top-notch. They make sure your order is correct, and they’re always willing to make suggestions if you’re looking to try something new. Their attention to detail makes it feel like home.

In conclusion, Brothers Pizza & Pasta serves some of the best pizza you’ll ever have in Bayonne NJ! From the delicious pies to the attentive service, I could easily eat here every day if I had a chance!

If you’re willing to go an extra 3 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Staten Island!

#2 Crispy Pizza

I arrived to find myself in a cozy and inviting atmosphere. The friendly staff made me feel right at home, and the delicious smells coming from the kitchen had my mouth watering before I even took my first bite!

The pizza itself is simply amazing. The thin crust has just the right amount of crunch, while the cheese melts perfectly into each slice. Adding to this are delightful toppings—nothing overpowering, but enough to make each bite its own unique experience.

My favorite part of Crispy Pizza is the fact that their pizzas are made using only fresh, locally sourced ingredients that really add to the pizzas unique flavor. It’s clear when eating here that they take pride in every meal they create, which makes for a truly unforgettable experience.

Overall, I can confidently say Crispy Pizza serves up some of the best pizza in Bayonne NJ! If you’re looking for genuine Italian-style pizza served up with love and care, then look no further than Crispy Pizza—you won’t regret it!

#3 Luciano’s San Vito Restaurant

My recent trip to Luciano’s was a real treat. From the moment I stepped through the door, I was welcomed with an atmosphere of warmth and hospitality. The decor is authentically Italian, and I could immediately tell by the aromas coming from the kitchen that they take their pizza-making seriously.

When it came time to order, I opted for the classic Margherita pizza – and boy am I glad I did! It was simply delicious! From the freshly made dough to the salty Perfection of the cheese, this pizza hit every mark. Even after taking my first bite, all I wanted was more!

The service at Luciano’s is also top-notch; friendly and knowledgeable waitstaff were eager to answer any questions about their pizzas or other menu items. They even gave us some tips and tricks on how to make a great pizza at home!

If you’re looking for one of the best pizzas in Bayonne NJ, look no further than Luciano’s San Vito Restaurant. Trust me – you won’t be disappointed!

#4 Three Brothers From Italy

I’m a big fan of thin, crispy pizza and Three Brothers From Italy delivered on that front. The crust was perfectly golden brown, cooked to perfection and full of flavor. The cheese was also very flavorful, and it didn’t lose its taste even once I had gone through several slices.

The sauce was the star of the show here. It had a strong, robust flavor that made me continuously want more. It had just enough sweetness to balance out the savory flavors in each bite.

I also have to give a shout out to the toppings they used here – each one tasted fresh and juicy, adding texture and taste to every bite. My favorite combination was the pepperoni, mushrooms and olives – they blended together so well!

All in all, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Bayonne NJ then Three Brothers From Italy is definitely worth checking out!

#5 Pompei Pizza

From the first bite, the dough was perfectly cooked and chewy. The cheese was gooey in all the right places and tasted like it had been freshly made that day. The tomato sauce was flavorful without being overly acidic.

The topping combinations were creative and delicious. From classic pepperoni to sweet pineapple and jalapeños, everyone in our party found something to love about the pizza options at Pompei Pizza.

Most importantly, though, was the service we received from this restaurant. The wait staff were accommodating without being overbearing, answered all of my questions about the menu with a knowledge base far beyond what I expected—especially considering this is New Jersey!

In conclusion, whatever you order at Pompei Pizza will undoubtedly be one of the best pizzas you’ve ever tasted! Highly recommended for pizza lovers everywhere!

#6 Pizza Masters

The first thing that strikes me is the welcoming atmosphere. As soon as you enter the restaurant, you feel like family. The staff is warm and inviting, and their knowledge of pizza making is impressive.

The menu selection has something for everyone – from the classic Margherita to innovative combos like BBQ chicken with roasted jalapeños! Best of all, I can’t get enough of their signature house-made pizzas. From the garlic and herb crust to the gooey cheese topping, they really know what they are doing when it comes to pizza-making!

The service here is also top-notch. They take their time to make sure your order is right and that you’re happy with your meal after each visit.

If you’re looking for a delicious slice of pie, I suggest ordering up a large pie at Pizza Masters. Whether it’s for lunch or dinner, you’ll be sure to leave satisfied by what they have on offer here! This place really serves up some of the best pizza in Bayonne NJ and beyond – don’t miss out!

#7 Buon Appetito

The restaurant’s atmosphere is charming and cozy, with dim lights and a decor that sets the perfect stage for a romantic dinner. The staff are friendly and attentive – you can tell they really care about their customers.

The pizza at Buon Appetito is simply divine! The crust is perfectly thin and crispy, while the sauce is flavorful and savory. Each bite is bursting with flavor, beginning with the tangy cheese and ending with the sweet tomato sauce. I tried out several different pizzas during my visit, all of which were delicious!

I must say that after sampling so many pizzas around the world, Buon Appetito truly lives up to its reputation as having some of the best pizza in Bayonne NJ. So if you’re ever in town craving a delicious slice or wanting to share a romantic dinner, head over to Buon Appetito – you won’t be disappointed!

#8 Mama Rosa’s Cucina & Pizzeria

It was like a dream when I walked in; the smell of freshly baked dough and melted cheese had me salivating before I even saw the pizza. The restaurant was warm and inviting, with an old-fashioned Italian charm that made me feel right at home.

Once I got to the counter, I discovered their amazing selection of pizzas. From traditional New York style pizzas to creative specialty pies, they had something to suit every taste. After much deliberation (I mean, who can decide on just one!), I opted for a pepperoni and mushroom slice and it was delicious! The crust was perfectly cooked – golden brown on the bottom and fluffy on top – and the topping combination was perfection.

Overall, Mama Rosa’s Cucina & Pizzeria serves some of the best pizza in Bayonne NJ (in my opinion). If you’re ever in town, be sure to check it out!

If you’re willing to go an extra 5 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Newark!

#9 La Guardiola Gourmet Pizzeria & Bistro

The atmosphere is lively and energetic, and the staff are friendly and welcoming. I couldn’t help but marvel at the selection of toppings for my pizza– everything from classic pepperoni to artichoke hearts, roasted red peppers and more! I chose a classic mushroom, pepperoni and green peppers combo, which was cooked perfectly with just the right amount of crunch. The cheese was a blend that melted so nicely it made me close my eyes in delight.

The best part about La Guardiola has to be their unique menu items. From the crusts filled with gooey mozzarella to the creative pizza flavors like Hawaiian BBQ Chicken or Mediterranean Veggie Pizza, there’s something to please everyone. Plus they have creamy gelato for dessert!

Overall, La Guardiola Gourmet Pizzeria & Bistro definitely lives up to its name: they offer some of the best pizza in Bayonne NJ! Don’t miss out on this local gem– go grab yourself a slice!

#10 Bayonne Patio Bar & Grille

The atmosphere of the place is great, and there’s always something to do. You can watch your favorite sports team while enjoying a delicious pizza. Or, you can hang out at the bar with some friends and grab a slice or two.

The pizzas here are truly unique. The crust is thick and slightly crunchy, as if it were baked in a brick oven. Toppings range from classic pepperoni to exotic eggplant parmesan – which I highly recommend! Every bite leaves me wanting more.

But let’s face it: pizza isn’t complete without cheese. The cheese at Bayonne Patio Bar & Grille is simply delicious. It’s creamy, gooey and flavorful in every bite!

All in all, Bayonne Patio Bar & Grille gets an A+ for pizza and an A+ for atmosphere! If you’re craving delicious pizza in Bayonne NJ, this is definitely the place to go!

#11 Mona Lisa Pizzeria Ristorante

The first time I stopped in, I wasn’t sure what to expect. But once I stepped foot in the door, I knew I was in for a treat. The atmosphere was warm and inviting, and it smelled like heavenly pizza.

The menu was full of delicious options with something for everyone – from classic margherita pizzas to exotic recipes with unique ingredients. We decided on a simple pepperoni pizza, and let me tell you – it was the most amazing pepperoni pizza I’ve ever had! The crust was perfectly thin and crispy and the toppings were fresh and flavorful. It truly was something special.

I also tried one of their specialty pastas dishes – a fettuccine carbonara – which was creamy, rich and oh so satisfying!

Overall, Mona Lisa Pizzeria Ristorante exceeded my expectations. In fact, after sampling all the pizzas around Bayonne NJ there is no doubt in my mind that this is the best pizza in town!

#12 Fontana Pizza & Restaurant

My experience at Fontana Pizza & Restaurant was a delight. From the charming atmosphere, to the friendly service, it was truly one of my most pleasant experiences.

The pizza here is out of this world. Every slice I had was cooked to perfection, with the right amount of cheese and spices. The crust was chewy yet crisp, and held up well to all the toppings that adorned it. I had a spicy pepperoni pizza that left me wanting more!

On top of all that, the prices here are very reasonable and will fit anyone’s budget. So don’t break your wallet trying to find great pizza – come to Fontana Pizza & Restaurant for an unbeatable combination of quality and value.

I’m so happy that I discovered Fontana Pizza & Restaurant – it’s definitely one of the best pizzas in Bayonne NJ!