I’m no rookie to the pizza game. I’ve had my slice of the pie all over the world, from Naples to New York City. But Beacon is a special place with some unique options for pizza lovers.
I decided to research 11 different places in Beacon in pursuit of the best pizza. My mission was daunting, but despite any missteps – like that uninspired cheese pizza I accidentally ordered – I pushed on through to give you all a comprehensive review.
Ready for an adventure into Beacon’s tasty pizza scene? Then let’s get this party started!
If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New York
#1 Brother’s Trattoria
- Nice tourist spot
- Has insanely good dessert
- Has some vegetarian options
- Serves alcohol (and hard liquor!)
- Has a kid’s menu
From the moment I stepped into the restaurant, I knew it was a special place. The atmosphere was warm and inviting, with cozy leather booths and a beautiful brick oven prominently displayed in the center of the room.
When it came to the food, Brother’s Trattoria went above and beyond to deliver a delicious pizza experience. The crust was cooked perfectly, with each slice of pizza boasting a crispy outer layer and a fluffy interior. To top it off, their homemade sauce combined with the freshly grated cheese gave my taste buds an unforgettable flavor experience.
Additionally, Brother’s Trattoria served up some really tasty sides that were just as good as their pizzas. Their garlic knots were delightful and I could have easily made an entire meal out of them alone!
Needless to say, Brother’s Trattoria definitely lives up to its reputation for having some of the best pizza in Beacon NY. If you’re looking for an enjoyable evening out filled with great food and drinks (or even just a quick pick-me-up snack!), I’d definitely recommend checking this place out!
If you’re willing to go an extra 2 miles, you can get to 25 more pizza places in Newburgh!
#2 Laby’s Pizzeria
- Has some vegetarian options
- Offers dessert
When I walked in the door, the first thing I noticed was the atmosphere. The small pizzeria instantly made me feel like I belonged. The decor was simple but inviting and the people behind the counter were very friendly and welcoming.
The next thing that caught my eye was the menu. Laby’s had a large selection of different types of pizzas and toppings to choose from. From classic combinations like pepperoni and mushroom to unique items like bacon and pineapple, there was something for everyone!
I decided to try their signature pizza, which was made with a light tomato sauce, parmesan cheese, and basil on a thin crust. As soon as the pizza arrived at my table, I could tell it was going to be delicious! The crust had a nice crunch to it and the toppings were cooked perfectly.
Overall, my experience at Laby’s Pizzeria was excellent! It’s no wonder why they have gained such an impressive reputation over time- they definitely know how to make some of the best pizza in Beacon NY!
#3 Enoteca Ama
- Offers dessert
- Serves alcohol
- Has some vegetarian options
- Nice tourist spot
The first thing I noticed when walking into this cozy neighborhood pizzeria was the amazing wood-fired oven that stands in the middle of the restaurant. I knew right away that they were serious about pizza!
When my pizza arrived, it was like a work of art! The dough was crispy and light, with just the right amount of char from their blazing hot oven. Plus, their selection of toppings is second to none – you can tell they take great care in selecting only top-notch ingredients for their pies.
Maybe it’s because Enoteca Ama has been around since 1989, but they have perfected the art of pizza making. From traditional favorites like margherita to inventive creations like their spicy feta pie, it’s clear that this is not your average pizzeria.
Enoteca Ama definitely lives up to its reputation as some of the best pizza in Beacon NY. If you’re on the lookout for a place to get outstanding New York-style pizza, look no further than Enoteca Ama!
If you’re willing to go an extra 15 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Poughkeepsie!
#4 Sal’s Pizza & Pasta
- Nice tourist spot
I’m not sure if it’s the light, airy crust that sets it apart, or the tangy tomatoes in their house-made marinara sauce. Maybe it’s the delicious selection of fresh toppings. Whatever it is, Sal’s Pizza & Pasta has nailed the perfect pizza formula!
The atmosphere at Sal’s is warm and inviting with an old-school Italian pizzeria vibe. The service was also top-notch, always willing to go out of their way to accommodate your needs.
No matter what kind of pizza you order from Sal’s — classic Margherita, Capricciosa, Prosciutto & Arugula — each one will hit the spot!
If you’re in Beacon NY and want to enjoy some of the best pizza around, look no further than Sal’s Pizza & Pasta!
#5 Big Vinny’s Pizza & Donnoli
- Nice tourist spot
- Offers dessert
The first thing that struck me when I walked into Big Vinny’s was the warm and inviting atmosphere. From the rustic decor to the friendly staff, I felt like I was part of the family!
The pizza was nothing less than incredible – loaded with fresh ingredients and cooked to perfection. Whether it was a classic pepperoni pizza or one of the speciality pies (I chose the BBQ chicken), everything had a wonderful flavor. The crust was light and airy, yet crunchy on the edges for added texture. The sauce was also excellent – not too sweet nor too salty.
What really sets Big Vinny’s apart from other pizza places is their wide selection of donnolis. They offer traditional flavors like vanilla & chocolate as well as fun twists like red velvet & salted caramel. Plus, they’re big enough to share with a friend!
Overall, Big Vinny’s Pizza & Donnoli is a great spot if you’re looking for some truly amazing pizza in Beacon NY!
If you’re willing to go an extra 18 miles, you can get to 12 more pizza places in New Paltz!
#6 Pizza Shop
- Serves alcohol
- Has insanely good dessert
- Has a kid’s menu
- Has some vegetarian options
- Nice tourist spot
I’ve been to Italy, tried their classic Margherita pizza, and that was amazing. But Pizza Shop? Absolutely out of this world! Their thin crust is the perfect combination of crunchy and soft. Plus you can choose from a variety of delicious toppings, like pepperoni, mushrooms, olives, or whatever your heart desires.
The atmosphere in Pizza Shop was also great. The restaurant was cozy and inviting, with a friendly staff who were always happy to chat about the different kinds of pizzas available. I must say I felt right at home in the place.
The service was top notch as well. Our order arrived within minutes and everything on the plate was cooked just right – no soggy crust or overcooked toppings here!
In conclusion, if you are ever in Beacon NY looking for some authentic Italian-style pizza then make sure you check out Pizza Shop. You won’t regret it!
#7 Deli & Pizza
The atmosphere of this place is unbeatable. As soon as you enter, the smell of delicious pizza fills the air. The staff greets you with a warm welcome, which makes it clear that they take pride in their work and strive to provide a quality experience for their guests.
As for the pizza itself, what can I say? It’s amazing! The crust is perfectly cooked to perfection and is just the right amount of crunchiness to make it ideal for eating. The sauce is rich and flavorful, and the toppings are all fresh and full of flavor. From pepperoni to veggie, every bite will have you wanting more!
Finally, Deli & Pizza offers an excellent selection of sides like garlic breadsticks and salads. All in all, it’s hard to find an establishment that meets such high standards when it comes to pizza. If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Beacon NY, look no further than Deli & Pizza!
If you’re willing to go an extra 23 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Middletown!
#8 Pizza & Stuff II
- Offers dessert
The crust was crispy on the outside, yet still soft and chewy on the inside. The sauce was rich and flavorful, with just the right amount of spice.
The toppings were fantastic – fresh vegetables, gooey cheese and savory meats – everything you could want in a pizza. My favorite part was that they didn’t skimp on anything; you could really taste the quality in every bite.
The service at Pizza & Stuff II was top notch as well. Our server was friendly, knowledgeable, and attentive to our needs.
Overall, I could not have been more impressed with my experience at Pizza & Stuff II! This is definitely the best pizza place in Beacon NY, and I highly recommend it to anyone looking for an amazing meal.
#9 HomeSlice Pizza
- Nice tourist spot
It has been my go-to spot for cheesy goodness ever since I arrived in town. The pizza itself is delicious, with a perfect balance between the crust and toppings. The pepperoni slices are cooked just right, not too greasy and not too crunchy. The marinara sauce has a nice kick to it without overwhelming the other flavors.
The service at HomeSlice Pizza is top-notch as well! The friendly staff greets you right away, always willing to chat about their favorite pizza toppings or give recommendations on what to order.
But what really sets HomeSlice apart from other pizza places is their unique selection of desserts. From pies with flaky crusts to decadent milkshakes, they offer something for everyone! Even myself, a dessert connoisseur, can find something to satisfy my sweet tooth here.
I’ve never been so impressed by a pizza restaurant before! HomeSlice is the best pizza place in Beacon NY for sure!
#10 The Plump Tomato
The restaurant itself is quite charming and cozy, with a nice terrace to sit outside and enjoy the sun. The staff was friendly and attentive, helping me choose the perfect pizza topping for my tastes.
As for the pizza itself—wow! I was blown away by how fresh and flavorful the ingredients were, from the succulent tomatoes to the amazing crust. The flavors blended together perfectly and it wasn’t too greasy or heavy. Absolutely delicious!
I also got to try some of their other dishes like pasta and garlic bread, which were also really good. The Plump Tomato definitely knows how to cook up some great Italian food.
Overall, if you’re in Beacon NY looking for some delicious pizza, you’ve got to check out The Plump Tomato—it’s absolutely worth it!
#11 Roma Nova
- Nice tourist spot
- Offers dessert
The atmosphere is nothing like what you would expect from a regular pizzeria. The interior is modern, chic and inviting – the perfect place to host a dinner party or just hang with friends. The staff is friendly and always helpful in offering suggestions for whatever pizza I’m considering ordering.
The selection of specialty pies on offer here is astounding! Whether it’s classic cheese, Hawaiian or something more unique like white truffle mushrooms, there’s truly something for everyone here.
But what really stands out to me about Roma Nova is the taste and quality of their food. Every single bite is packed with flavor that’s hard to find anywhere else. Plus, their doughy and crispy crusts have a crunch that just pulls everything together in one delicious meal.
And don’t get me started on the price! I was surprised at how affordable the slices are compared to other places I’ve been to across the world. And they even offer delivery if you’d rather stay at home!
For anyone looking for some amazing pizza in Beacon NY, look no further than Roma Nova! They’ve got some of the best pizza around, and I highly recommend giving them a try as soon as possible!
