Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Bentonville AR (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Arkansas

Best Pizza in Bentonville AR (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

247 Views

I’m always up for a challenge and I recently took it upon myself to sample the twelve best pizza places in town. From thin crusts to deep dish, and everything in between, I’m ready to report back with my findings on the best pizza that Bentonville AR has to offer.

In this article, you can expect a lighthearted take on the great competition over who makes the best pizza in town. I’ll also sprinkle in some tips from my years of experience as a food critic, so you can trust that I know what I’m talking about. Read on for an entertaining and informative article about all the juicy details of Bentonville’s top dozen pizzas!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Arkansas

#1 Simple Simon’s Pizza

To start, their crust is the perfect balance between thin and thick. It’s light with just enough crunch that it doesn’t fall apart within minutes of being delivered. Moreover, they use the freshest ingredients which really makes a difference in the flavor of their pies.

The toppings are what really set Simple Simon’s Pizza apart from other pizza places. Every bite is loaded with flavor and interesting combinations – from pepperoni and jalepenos to pineapple and bacon, this place has some truly unique topping options.

As for atmosphere, Simple Simon’s Pizza does a great job at making sure you’re always feeling welcome in their restaurant. The staff is friendly and knowledgeable, plus they even offer delivery if you don’t feel like leaving the house!

Overall, I’d highly recommend Simple Simon’s Pizza for anyone looking for delicious pies made with fresh ingredients at an affordable price. It definitely won’t disappoint!

If you’re willing to go an extra 21 miles, you can get to 53 more pizza places in Fayetteville!

#2 Barley & Vine

The atmosphere at Barley & Vine is great. You can sit down, enjoy a delicious beer, and watch sports with your friends. It’s the perfect place to go grab a bite to eat and relax with some of your favorite people.

The pizza itself is amazing. The crust is crispy yet chewy, the toppings are always fresh, and the flavor combinations are unique and always leave me wanting more! I’m pretty sure they put something magical in their pizzas because no matter how much I eat, I just can’t get enough!

My only complaint is that they don’t offer delivery service. But honestly, it’s worth leaving my house every time for this kind of pizza!

In short, Barley & Vine has earned its title as the best pizza in Bentonville. If you’re looking for an enjoyable evening out or if you just have a craving for some truly delicious pizza, then Barley & Vine should definitely be your number one choice!

#3 Casey’s

From the moment I walked in, I could tell that this was going to be something special. The atmosphere was cozy and inviting and the staff were friendly and helpful.

I decided to sample the classic cheese pizza—it certainly did not disappoint. The flavor of the cheese was perfect, with a wonderfully crisp crust, and it had just the right amount of sauce for the ideal balance.

The menu also offers several unique options such as spicy Italian sausage, mac & cheese, and even Greek-inspired options like feta and olives! The toppings all felt fresh and delicious; they seemed to have chosen every single ingredient carefully.

In a word, Casey’s has perfected their pies! From the taste to presentation, everything is excellent quality. The service is also top-notch—the staff goes out of their way to make sure you are pleased with your meal.

Overall, I highly recommend Casey’s Pizza if you’re ever in Bentonville looking for some of the best pizza around!

#4 Gusano’s Pizzeria

As soon as I stepped in, the aroma of fresh baked pizza overwhelmed my senses. The restaurant was clean, and the staff were friendly and welcoming – all things that make for a great dining experience.

The pizzas at Gusano’s Pizzeria are nothing short of amazing. The crust is perfectly cooked and full of flavor, while the toppings are cooked to perfection with just the right amount of cheese. There’s always something new to try on the menu, so I’m never bored.

One thing I really appreciate about this pizzeria is that they offer gluten-free options too. So even if you can’t eat wheat or gluten-rich foods, you can still enjoy a delicious slice (or two)!

All in all, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Bentonville, Gusano’s Pizzeria should be your go-to spot! Delicious food with great service – what more could you ask for?

#5 Priato Pizzeria

The first thing that jumped out to me was the atmosphere of the restaurant—it was an ideal spot for tourists. It had a cozy environment with friendly staff, delicious pizza aromas in the air, and some wonderful decorations.

The pizza itself was incredible! Each slice had a wonderfully-crispy thin crust and plenty of cheese, sauce, and toppings. It tasted like straight-up Italian cuisine! I’m not sure if it’s actually homemade or not but it certainly tasted like it was!

The only downside to Priato Pizzeria is that they don’t offer delivery. But hey, when you can have such amazing pizza right there in the restaurant, who needs delivery?

All in all, I highly recommend Priato Pizzeria as THE spot for the best pizza in Bentonville!

#6 Marco’s Pizza

I was extremely impressed with the quality of the pizzas they serve. Every slice has just the right amount of cheese and flavorful toppings. The crust is cooked to perfection, so it’s always light and crispy. And Marco’s is generous with their portion sizes – you won’t leave feeling like you have to scavenge for more food afterwards!

The atmosphere at Marco’s Pizza is wonderful. The furnishings are modern and tasteful without being stuffy, making it a great place for families, friends, or even romantic dates. The staff are some of the friendliest I’ve ever encountered when dining out, which adds to the relaxed feeling in the restaurant.

Overall, I’d recommend Marco’s Pizza over any other pizza joint in Bentonville! They have fresh ingredients, expertly crafted pies, great service and a cozy atmosphere that can’t be beat. If you’re looking for some truly outstanding pizza, look no further than Marco’s Pizza!

If you’re willing to go an extra 21 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Fayetteville!

#7 Domino’s Pizza

From the moment I stepped through the doors of Domino’s, I was welcomed with extraordinarily warm and friendly customer service.

The restaurant itself was very clean and modern, with a great atmosphere for enjoying some of the best pizza I’d ever tasted. After browsing their extensive menu, I decided to order their signature Classic Hand-Tossed Pepperoni Pizza.

The pizza was absolutely delicious! It had just the right amount of cheese, sauce, and pepperoni to make it mouthwateringly good. The perfect balance between these components made it likely the best pizza in Bentonville that I’ve encountered!

To top off my experience, they offered me some complimentary desserts that were delicious as well! Their prices were also quite affordable which made this pizza dining experience even more enjoyable.

All in all, if you’re looking for some truly delectable pizza at a reasonable price, Domino’s should be your go-to destination in Bentonville!

#8 Gusano’s Chicago-Style Pizzeria

I stopped in one night, hungry and exhausted from my long travels, and was absolutely delighted by what I found. From the moment I walked into the restaurant, I knew I was in for a treat. The inviting décor and bustling atmosphere immediately set me at ease.

The friendly staff quickly took my order and soon presented me with a delicious deep-dish pizza topped with succulent vegetables, gooey cheese, and tangy sauce. It was an unforgettable experience which made me instantly fall in love with their food.

To top it off, the prices were incredibly reasonable! For an amazing pizza experience that won’t break the bank, Gusano’s is the place to go.

If you’re ever looking for a great pizza experience in Bentonville, be sure to check out Gusano’s Chicago-Style Pizzeria – they serve up some of the best pizza around!

#9 Johnny Brusco’s New York Style Pizza

I had the pepperoni pizza and it was delicious! The crust was thin and crispy, and just the right amount of sauce and cheese added the perfect balance of flavors. The pepperoni had a great smoky flavor, which is usually hard to find in some pizzerias.

The atmosphere of Johnny Brusco’s cannot be overlooked either. It was very cozy and inviting with posters of New York scattered around the walls, along with Italian music playing in the background. I felt like I had stepped into an authentic Italian pizzeria.

The service at Johnny Brusco’s was also top notch! Everyone was very friendly and helpful. They took their time to explain all the different types of pizzas that were available, and made sure to give me recommendations for other toppings. In addition to this, they frequently checked up on me throughout my meal which was a nice touch!

Overall, Johnny Brusco’s New York Style Pizza is one of the best pizza restaurants I’ve come across in Bentonville – definitely worth checking out if you’re in town!

#10 Casey’s

Let me tell you, the crust is the perfect texture – not too thick, not too thin. It’s just right! When you take a bite of their pizza, you can tell that it’s made with a lot of love, attention to detail and premium ingredients.

The toppings are always fresh and delicious. The pepperonis have great flavor and the cheese is always melted perfectly. I literally can’t get enough of their pizza!

Plus, they give generous portions so that everyone will be full afterwards.

If you’re ever in Bentonville looking for the best pizza around, make sure to give Casey’s a try – I guarantee you won’t be disappointed!

#11 Slice Pizza Bar

The atmosphere is cozy, with a casual vibe and great music playing in the background. The staff was friendly and accommodating, which made my dining experience even more enjoyable.

As for the pizza, it was mouthwateringly delicious! The crust was thin and crunchy and the topping flavors were bold yet balanced. I highly recommend the Margherita – it’s just the right amount of cheesy, creamy goodness!

Of course I can’t forget to mention their signature alcoholic beverages. Let’s just say they pair perfectly with the pizza! If you’re looking for an adult beverage that will take your pizza-eating experience to the next level, Slice Pizza Bar is definitely where you want to be.

All in all, I’d give Slice Pizza Bar two thumbs up for being some of the best pizza in Bentonville! Whether you’re stopping by for lunch or dinner, I’m sure you’ll have a great time indulging in some delicious slices.

If you’re willing to go an extra 21 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Fayetteville!

#12 Bariola’s Pizzeria – Rogers

Upon arriving, I was greeted with a warm welcome from one of the owners. He presented me with a quick tour of their establishment and then invited me to enjoy some of their renowned pizza. I immediately agreed!

The pizza was cooked to perfection – crispy on the outer rings and the perfect, gooey texture in the middle. The toppings were bursting with flavor and every bite was truly divine! From pepperoni and sausage to olives and peppers, it’s no wonder why Bariola’s Pizzeria is known for having some of the best pizza in Bentonville.

I’d highly recommend Bariola’s Pizzeria – Rogers for anyone looking for an unforgettable pizza experience. With friendly staff, handmade pizzas, and delicious flavors, you won’t be disappointed!