I’ve tasted pizza from all over the world, but there’s something special about a good slice of pizza close to home. That’s why I’m excited to share with you my recommendations of the best pizza in Bethlehem PA after trying out twelve different places.
The journey was long and arduous, but it was worth it for delicious slices of cheesy goodness! I’m here to share my experience with you in a humorous and lighthearted way, so let’s get ready to find out which pizzas reign supreme in Bethlehem PA.
If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Pennsylvania
#1 Paranormal Pizza
- Has some vegetarian options
- Nice tourist spot
I’ve had a lot of pizza, so trust me when I say this is some good stuff. The crust was light and crispy, with a hint of garlic that really kicked things up a notch. The cheese was stretchy and gooey, and the sauce was flavorful and robust.
The toppings were also spectacular – from pepperoni to mushrooms to roasted peppers, each bite was packed full of flavor. And the special topping – ghost peppers for an extra kick! Now that’s something you don’t get anywhere else!
The atmosphere was also great – it had all the hipster vibes you’d expect from a paranormal-themed pizza joint, with interesting music playing in the background and lots of fun decorations.
If you’re ever in Bethlehem PA, be sure to check out Paranormal Pizza – you won’t regret it! It’s definitely our top recommendation for the best pizza in town!
If you’re willing to go an extra 6 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Allentown!
#2 Familia Pizza
The experience at Familia Pizza is unforgettable. From the moment you walk in, the mouthwatering aroma of freshly baked pizza fills the room. Everything looks and smells delicious!
I sampled several slices and was pleasantly surprised by how well they kept their shape while being loaded with toppings. The crust was crunchy on the outside but still soft and chewy in the middle, while also having just enough sauce to cover every bite.
The cheese was gooey and stringy, exactly how I like it! The ingredients were fresh and flavorful – no skimping here. Each slice held its own when it came to taste and texture, proving that each topping is carefully chosen for optimum flavor.
My favorite thing about Familia Pizza was the friendly staff who went out of their way to make sure I had an excellent experience. They welcomed me with open arms and made sure I had everything I needed throughout my visit. That’s something other restaurants could learn from!
All in all, I’d have to say that Familia Pizza is hands down one of the best pizza places around for anyone looking for authentic Italian style pizza in Bethlehem PA! Go ahead, treat yourself – you won’t regret it!
#3 Randy’s Pizzeria
The crust is delicious, with just the right amount of crunch and flavor. The sauce is mostly sweet and tangy with some underlying hints of garlic. And the cheese…oh the cheese! So much gooey goodness that I could eat it with a spoon.
Then there’s the toppings: an array of veggies, meats, and seasonings that complement each other perfectly. Pepperoni is delectable and classic; roasted peppers give it a punch of flavor; and then there’s my favorite: mushrooms! So many variations to choose from, you can never get bored.
Randy really knows how to make a pizza—the best around! Believe me, I’ve been around the world tasting all sorts of pizzas, but this one stands out above all others in Bethlehem PA. Stop by Randy’s Pizzeria for some amazing pizza tonight!
#4 Sorella’s Pizza & Pasta
- Offers dessert
- Has some vegetarian options
The first thing I noticed when I walked in was the inviting and cozy atmosphere. The pizza ovens in the back started to heat up as soon as I stepped through the door, so you can really feel the passion that goes into making every pie.
I decided to go with their classic Margherita pizza – and it did not disappoint! The tomatoes were fresh, the mozzarella was delicious and overall it was just cooked perfectly. Plus, it was nice to get away from all the processed ingredients so many places seem to use these days.
The restaurant also offers a variety of other options that made me want to come back for more. From classic Italian dishes like spaghetti carbonara and lasagna to more gourmet pizzas like their Chorizo and Goat Cheese Pie, there’s something for everyone. Plus, they have vegetarian options too!
Overall, my experience at Sorella’s Pizza & Pasta was great. If you’re ever in Bethlehem PA looking for some quality pizza, this is definitely your spot!
#5 Fratelli Pizzeria
- Has some vegetarian options
- Offers dessert
- Nice tourist spot
I love their classic Italian-style pizza, which always has the perfect ratio of cheese to toppings. The crust is perfectly thin and crispy, yet still chewy enough that it doesn’t feel like cardboard in your mouth.
The restaurant itself is cozy and inviting with a great atmosphere that makes it easy to relax and enjoy your meal. The staff are friendly and helpful, always happy to answer any questions you may have about their menu or specials.
I also appreciate that all their ingredients are fresh, never frozen – a sign of the care they take in preparing food for their customers. Plus, they offer gluten-free options, which is something I really appreciate since I’ve been trying to reduce my gluten intake lately.
All in all, if you’re looking for some delicious pizza in Bethlehem PA then Fratelli Pizzeria is definitely the place to go!
#6 Martellucci’s Pizzeria
- Has a kid’s menu
- Offers dessert
The moment I walked in the door, I could smell the heavenly scent of freshly-made pizza. The atmosphere was warm and inviting, which only made me more eager to try Martellucci’s specialty – the gourmet pie.
The dough was thin yet with a crunchy texture on the edges. It was cooked perfectly and lightly oiled, giving it that delicious golden color. The sauce was sweet and tangy at the same time, while the cheese was creamy and flavorful without being overpowering. To top it off, Martellucci’s signature blend of herbs gave it an amazing flavor profile that rounded out each bite.
My experience at Martellucci’s Pizzeria has solidified my opinion that it is indeed the best pizza in Bethlehem PA! If you’re looking for an amazing pizza experience, then look no further than this Italian gem!
#7 Pats Pizza & Bistro Bethlehem
- Has a kid’s menu
- Offers dessert
- Has some vegetarian options
- Nice tourist spot
The atmosphere is relaxed and inviting, with a modern decor and cozy vibes. The staff was friendly and attentive – they even brought out a “pizza of the day” for me to sample, which was delicious!
The pizza itself was like no other I’ve ever tasted. The crust was perfectly crispy and buttery, while the toppings were fresh and flavorful. The sauce had just the right amount of spice, and the cheese was gooey and melted in my mouth. It is certainly one of the best pizzas I’ve had!
I highly recommend Pats Pizza & Bistro Bethlehem for anyone looking for an amazing pizza experience. For me, it’s easily the best pizza in Bethlehem PA!
#8 NYC Village Pizza
- Nice tourist spot
- Offers dessert
- Has some vegetarian options
On my visit to this amazing little pizza joint, I had the pleasure of trying their classic pepperoni pizza. The thin crust was crispy yet chewy, and the flavors blended perfectly. The fresh-made mozzarella was rich and creamy, while the pepperoni added just the right amount of spicy kick.
Not only did NYC Village Pizza provide me with exceptional pizza, but they also provided great customer service. The staff was friendly and attentive, and willing to answer any questions about their menu items or ingredients. Their efficient ordering process made it easy for me to get my meal quickly without sacrificing quality or taste.
Overall, NYC Village Pizza is a top-notch pizza joint that serves up some of the best pizza in Bethlehem PA. I highly recommend this place for anyone looking for an authentic experience featuring quality ingredients and delicious pizzas.
If you’re willing to go an extra 9 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Allentown!
#9 Napoli Pizza and Italian Cuisine
- Has a kid’s menu
- Offers dessert
I’d heard about this place from some of my food-expedition colleagues, so I had to see it for myself. When I arrived, the first thing that caught my eye was the wood-fired oven. It’s massive! After spending a few moments admiring the oven and inhaling the aroma of baked pizza dough, I decided to venture inside to try out some of the pies.
To say the least, I wasn’t disappointed! Napoli Pizza has a wide range of delicious choices ranging from classic favorites like margherita and pepperoni to more adventurous creations topped with eggplant and artichokes. The pies are cooked in their 800-degree woodstone ovens, giving them a unique flavor – one that you won’t find anywhere else!
The atmosphere is top notch too! The decor is quite homely, with beautiful Italian-themed art adorning the walls and cozy seating areas set up around the room. We were also treated to live music while we ate which made for a truly enjoyable experience.
To sum it up, Napoli Pizza and Italian Cuisine has earned its reputation as one of Bethlehem’s best pizzerias for good reason! If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in town (or even in Pennsylvania!), then this is definitely a spot that shouldn’t be missed.
#10 Buona Cucina Italiano
The pizza is no ordinary run-of-the-mill kind. Instead, it’s made with only fresh ingredients and unique toppings that add depth and flavor to each pie. Plus, the crust is perfectly thin and crisp, making it a pleasure to eat.
The restaurant itself is cozy and inviting, making me feel like I’m part of the family. The staff are friendly and attentive, always willing to make sure that my dining experience was positive.
If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Bethlehem PA, then look no further than Buona Cucina Italiano. It’s a great place to bring friends or family out for dinner or if you just want to pick up something tasty on your way home. Trust me – you won’t be disappointed!
#11 Stefko Pizza
- Offers dessert
The atmosphere of the restaurant is fantastic – it’s cozy, inviting and old-school, making me feel right at home.
The pizza itself is divine. I’ve never tasted such delicious pizza in my life! The crust is perfectly crunchy, with an intriguing hint of flavor from their secret ingredient. The toppings are fresh and flavorful; the cheese just melts in your mouth, and the sauce packs a punch.
I tried other menu items as well – all of which were scrumptious. From their classic garlic knots to ravioli in a creamy sauce, every dish was cooked to perfection.
Overall, I have to say that Stefko Pizza has earned its place as one of the best pizzerias in Bethlehem PA! Their pizza is unbeatable and I can’t wait for my next visit!
#12 Vincenza’s Italian Pizzeria & Trattoria
The pizza crust was perfectly cooked, the sauce was incredibly flavorful, and the toppings were just right. I had the house special with pepperoni, sausage, onions, and mushrooms – and it was simply amazing!
The atmosphere of the restaurant is cozy and inviting – it reminds me of my nonna’s kitchen. The staff is very friendly, and you can tell they take pride in their craft. They have a great selection of beers and wines to pair with your pizza if you’re looking for something to drink.
Overall I’m giving Vincenza’s Italian Pizzeria & Trattoria five stars! The pizza is truly some of the best I’ve tasted anywhere in the world, so if you’re in Bethlehem PA looking for a delicious slice (or two!), make sure to stop by Vincenza’s Italian Pizzeria & Trattoria!
