Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Bloomington IL (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Illinois

Best Pizza in Bloomington IL (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

110 Views

I’ve sampled pizza all over the world, and now I can confidently say that I know my way around a great pie. After tasting 12 pizzas in Bloomington, IL, I’m ready to let you know which ones are worth your time.

Get ready for a hilarious journey through the best pizza places in Bloomington! I’ll rank each one on taste, atmosphere, and affordability. So if you’re looking for an amazing slice of pizza around Bloomington IL – look no further!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Illinois

#1 Pizza Payaa

I’m not exaggerating one bit. This place truly has some of the best pizza I’ve ever tasted. From their crust to their sauce, every bite is loaded with flavor and a simply divine texture. The toppings are just as fantastic and each one adds something special that helps bring out the overall flavor and make it even better than before.

The atmosphere is also top-notch. It’s a casual environment that feels comfortable no matter who you are. The staff are extremely friendly and always willing to assist in any way they can. Plus, there’s always good music playing in the background which adds an extra layer of fun to this already enjoyable experience!

All in all, Pizza Payaa gets 5 stars from me for being an all-around great pizza joint! If you’re looking for the best pizza in Bloomington IL, look no further than Pizza Payaa — you won’t regret it!

If you’re willing to go an extra 38 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Peoria!

#2 The Original Pinsaria

The atmosphere was lively and inviting, with a great outdoor patio seating area. The wait staff were friendly and accommodating and they had a wide selection of beers to choose from.

The pizza is just simply fantastic. They offer thin crust and deep dish pizzas with a variety of toppings. I had the pepperoni-mushroom pizza and it was one of the best I have ever tasted – no exaggeration! The dough was light, crisp, and full of flavor. The sauce was flavorful with just the right amount of sweetness. The cheese was melted to perfection. And the pepperoni-mushroom topping combination provided an incredible balance of sweet and savory flavors.

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Bloomington IL, then make sure to check out The Original Pinsaria! You definitely won’t be disappointed!

#3 Flingers Pizza Pub

No matter what toppings you like, they’ll have something that fits your craving. From the classic pepperoni to the exotic pesto and artichoke combo, their selection of pizzas will definitely make your mouth water.

The crust is almost always perfectly cooked – just enough crispiness to hold up all the toppings without being too crunchy. Their sauces are full of flavor and their cheese choices are varied, so you can get exactly what you’re looking for in every slice.

But perhaps the best part about Flingers Pizza Pub is the atmosphere; it’s one of those places where everyone knows you by name and doesn’t even need to ask what type of pizza you want when you walk in. The waitstaff is friendly and attentive, which makes the experience even more enjoyable.

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Bloomington IL, then look no further than Flingers Pizza Pub!

#4 The Lucca Grill

I ordered a pepperoni pizza, and the crust was light and airy – like a cloud! The mozzarella cheese was perfectly melted over the top – not too much and not too little. And the pepperoni was so flavorful, adding just the right amount of salty zing to every bite.

What really puts The Lucca Grill’s pizza above others is their delicious homemade tomato sauce. No canned sauce here! It was freshly made and had a sweet tang that set it apart from all other pizzas I’ve ever tasted.

The staff were also incredibly friendly. When I asked for extra cheese, they didn’t charge me extra, or act like I was inconveniencing them! It really made the experience even better.

All in all, I’d give this place 5 stars out of 5 for having some of the best pizza in Bloomington IL! If you’re looking for an amazing slice of pie, look no further than The Lucca Grill.

#5 Anju Above

From the moment I walked in the door, I knew this place was special. The cozy atmosphere and friendly staff made me feel right at home. Plus, they have one of the coolest pizza ovens I’ve ever seen!

The menu is full of delicious options, but it’s their signature pizzas that really make this place stand out. From their classic Margherita to their daring Mac & Cheese, each specialty slice is crafted with care and precision. The ingredients are top-notch, and there’s something for everyone.

I particularly enjoyed the Vegetarian Delight – it was flavorful without being too overwhelming. Topped with eggplant and spinach in a creamy garlic sauce – yum! And all their pizzas come out piping hot and perfectly crisped around the edges – just how pizza should be!

If you’re visiting Bloomington IL, make sure you check out Anju Above for some of the best pizza around. You won’t be disappointed!

#6 La Gondola Spaghetti & Pizza House

I love going to La Gondola. It’s a cozy spot with some of the best pizza around. I’m talking authentic Italian wood-fired pizzas with the perfect crust, flavorful and unique toppings, and ample portions served up hot and fresh. Everything here is handcrafted with care and attention to detail, so you know you’re getting the real deal.

Of course, no pizza experience would be complete without their signature garlic knots. They are truly in a league of their own! Soft and chewy with just enough garlic flavor (not too much), they make for an awesome side dish and are just as good when dipped in ranch or marinara sauce. And don’t forget about their selection of beers – they have some great craft beers on tap that perfectly complement any kind of pizza you order!

In short: La Gondola Spaghetti & Pizza House is my pick for the best pizza in Bloomington IL. If you’re looking for an unforgettable dining experience, definitely head over there soon!

#7 Marco’s Pizza

The crust at Marco’s is just the right ratio of crunchy on the outside and soft on the inside, which is a must for any great pizza. The sauce was perfect: tomato-y with enough herbs to keep things interesting. And finally, the toppings were plentiful and fresh, from thick slabs of pepperoni to crunchy sweet peppers.

My favorite part was definitely the service though; every single employee I interacted with was not only friendly but had an obvious love for what they do and their restaurant in general. They took my order quickly with a smile, making sure they got everything right despite me wanting to try two different pizzas.

When I finally got my order it was spectacular! It arrived piping hot after only a few minutes. The presentation was simple yet effective, reinforcing that this is anything but your average family chain restaurant.

To sum it up, Marco’s Pizza might just be the best pizza in Bloomington IL—definitely worth a visit if you’re ever in town!

#8 Lu Lu’s Pizza

I didn’t think my taste buds could handle another delicious pizza, but here I am, raving about this place after just one bite! For starters, their crust is perfectly cooked – not too crunchy, not too doughy. And the cheese! Oh my goodness. The cheese is divine and so creamy!

The variety of toppings they offer is also noteworthy. Everything from bell peppers to extra spicy pepperoni can be found here and all of them pair perfectly with the gooey cheese. Plus, they have some unique varieties like spinach and garlic that really elevate the pizza experience.

The atmosphere at Lu Lu’s Pizza is also welcoming and fun! The staff are friendly and fast so you can get your pizza fix in no time! They even have an outdoor patio for those wanting to enjoy their ‘za al fresco.

All in all, this place has quickly become my favorite spot for pizza in Bloomington IL. Lu Lu’s Pizza has amazing flavors and textures that make it a must-try for everyone looking for the best pizza around town.

If you’re willing to go an extra 46 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Champaign!

#9 Tobin’s Pizza

I’m a pretty picky pizza critic, so it takes a lot to win me over. Tobin’s Pizza did just that! The smell of the fresh pizza alone was enough to make my mouth water. Not only was the atmosphere welcoming, but their selection of toppings left me feeling spoiled for choice.

The crust at Tobin’s Pizza is thin and perfectly crispy, and their unique sauces give each slice its own unique flavor. The pepperoni topping was particularly delightful: juicy and flavorful, with just the right amount of spice.

To top it all off, the staff at Tobin’s Pizza are friendly and always willing to go the extra mile to make sure you’re satisfied with your meal.

All in all, I’d highly recommend this establishment for anyone looking for an outstanding pizza experience! And it goes without saying that no review of mine would be complete without mentioning that this is undoubtedly one of the best pizzas around Bloomington IL!

#10 Monical’s Pizza

The pizza is not only delicious but also diverse. There’s something for every flavor palette, from traditional cheese and pepperoni to unique creations like the Chicken Bacon Ranch Pie. Even if you have a picky eater in the family, they will find something on the menu that suits their tastes!

The atmosphere at Monical’s is great too; it’s comfortable and inviting – perfect for kicking back after a long day of exploring all that Bloomington has to offer. And the staff are helpful and attentive – they really go above and beyond to make sure your experience is top-notch.

In my opinion, Monical’s Pizza goes beyond just good pizza, it truly is “the best pizza experience in Bloomington.” Take it from me, an experienced food critic who knows a thing or two about great pizza!

#11 Avanti’s Italian Restaurant

I mean, it’s not like I’m biased or anything – Avanti’s really does have the best pizza! The crust is always perfectly crisp and golden brown, the sauce is flavorful and fresh, and the toppings are always plentiful. Plus, they make all their dough in-house!

I love their signature pies like the classic Margherita and their signature specialty pizzas. The flavors they offer are absolutely delicious and richly flavored – it’s like eating an Italian masterpiec

#12 Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza

The concept is simple: you pick your favorite dough, toppings, and cheese (or go for one of their specialty pizzas) and take it home to bake. I think this is a genius idea because it lets you customize your pizza without having to wait around for them to make it. Plus, you get the satisfaction of baking it yourself!

As far as taste goes, Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza definitely delivers. The crust is fluffy and flavorful; the cheese melts perfectly on top; and the toppings are fresh from the garden. It really is like eating a warm, delicious hug.

The best part? Their prices aren’t bad either – they offer great deals like “two media pizzas for $10” which really helps me stretch my hard earned money further.

So if you’re ever in Bloomington IL and looking for some seriously good pizza, make sure to check out Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza – I can guarantee that you won’t be disappointed!

Best Deep Dish Pizza – Giordano’s

I mean, who needs the Eiffel Tower or the Great Wall of China when you can have a slice of cheesy heaven? The moment I walked into Giordano’s, the scent of freshly baked dough and melting cheese hit me like a brick. And let me tell you, it was love at first sniff.

I ordered their famous deep dish pizza and I was not disappointed. It was like an explosion of flavors in my mouth. The crust was thick and buttery, just the way a deep dish should be. It had the perfect balance of crispy and chewy, like a well-cooked waffle that never went stale. And the cheese! Oh, the cheese! It was like a blanket of melty goodness, stretching for miles with every bite.

Now, I’ve had my fair share of deep dish pizzas, but nothing compared to Giordano’s. It was so big, it could have been mistaken for a small child’s trampoline. I couldn’t help but laugh as I struggled to fit a slice into my mouth. It was like a workout for my jaw, but trust me, it was worth every ounce of effort.

The staff at Giordano’s were also a hoot. They seemed to have a sixth sense of when I needed more napkins because by the time I finished one slice, a fresh stack appeared magically beside me. Talk about pizza telepathy!

So, if you find yourself in Bloomington, IL, and you’re a fan of deep dish pizzas, do yourself a favor and head straight to Giordano’s. It’s a slice of heaven that will leave you rolling out of the restaurant with a big smile on your face.