Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Boynton Beach (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Florida

Best Pizza in Boynton Beach (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

337 Views

My job as a food critic has taken me all over the world in search of the best pizza, and I’m excited to share my findings from Boynton Beach. I’ve tasted pizza from twelve different pizza places in the area, and I’m sure you’ll find something you love!

The tone of this article will be humorous and lighthearted. I’ll give you my honest opinion on the quality of the pizza and other factors that make it worth trying. So here we go – let’s find the best pizza place in Boynton Beach!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Florida

#1 Alfa Pizzeria

With an impressive variety of pizzas on the menu, I was spoiled for choice. The “Alfa Special” is definitely worth a try – a delightful combination of pepperoni, mushrooms, and jalapenos that had just the right amount of kick. A close second was the “Veggie Lovers” pizza – with fresh tomatoes and peppers, it’s a perfect choice for those who want to enjoy their veggies without compromising on flavor.

But what’s really unique about Alfa Pizzeria is their commitment to providing quality ingredients. They take pride in selecting the freshest ingredients and making sure everything is prepared correctly. And it shows in the taste!

The atmosphere at Alfa Pizzeria was warm and inviting – it felt like being part of a large family gathering. The staff were friendly and knowledgeable; they were happy to answer all my questions and go out of their way to make sure I enjoyed my experience.

All in all, if you’re looking for some delicious pizza in Boynton Beach then you can’t go wrong with Alfa Pizzeria! It’s one of the best pizza places I’ve discovered on my travels, and I’d highly recommend it to anyone looking for great food in a welcoming atmosphere.

If you’re willing to go an extra 5 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Delray Beach!

#2 Boynton Pizza

The first time I visited Boynton Pizza, I was a bit skeptical. The restaurant had an unassuming exterior and the interior wasn’t particularly impressive either. That all changed when I took my first bite of the pizza. Wow! It was simply divine – the crust was perfectly charred, the sauce was flavorful and the cheese melted like butter in my mouth.

I can honestly say that every single pizza at Boynton Pizza is outstanding. Their specialty pizzas are to die for – they’re packed with flavor and have just the right amount of toppings. My favorite is their Chicken Bacon Ranch Pie – it’s loaded with fresh ingredients and comes piled high with smoky bacon and juicy chicken.

But perhaps most importantly, the service at Boynton Pizza is top notch. Everyone on staff is friendly, knowledgeable, and willing to make sure you get exactly what you want – whether it be an off-menu special or a simple Coca Cola.

All in all, if you’re looking for great pizza in Boynton Beach, look no further than Boynton Pizza!

#3 Danny’s Pizza Kitchen

The atmosphere at Danny’s Pizza Kitchen was simply delightful; the hardwood floors, vintage Italian décor, and the aroma of freshly-baked pizza all had me feeling like I was in Italy.

The menu features classic Italian flavors like Marinara and Margherita, but they also have some truly inventive and delicious options. My personal favorite is their Dr. Pepperoni – a mix of sweet and salty that’s sure to satisfy any pizza craving!

The staff at Danny’s Pizza Kitchen were friendly and professional; they were quick to take my order and knew exactly what I wanted before I even asked! The pizza arrived hot, cheesy, and delicious – easily one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had the pleasure of eating.

For those looking for a unique experience with authentic Italian flavors combined with modern twists, look no further than Danny’s Pizza Kitchen. From the inviting atmosphere to the delectable fare, you won’t regret spending your time here!

#4 A1 Pizza Kitchen

Upon my first bite, it was obvious this place knows their craft. The crust was perfectly cooked, with a light crunch and delicate flavor that you don’t find elsewhere. The sauce had an intense, robust flavor that tantalized my taste buds in ways I’d never experienced before!

The topping selection is amazing; from the classic favorites to more inventive combinations like the ‘Taco Pizza’. And the quality of their ingredients exceeds all expectations; from the fresh mozzarella cheese to locally-sourced vegetables.

But it’s not just about the food; the staff are friendly, knowledgeable and always happy to talk pizza with me. Plus, their prices are reasonable without compromising on quality. All in all, A1 Pizza Kitchen is an absolute house of flavour! Clearly they deserve a visit from even the most experienced pizza connoisseurs. This is truly some of the best pizza in Boynton Beach!

#5 Detroit Eats

When I first walked in, the atmosphere was warm and inviting. The decor was modern and the staff were all very friendly. I knew immediately that I had come to the right place.

The menu is full of interesting options, but after much deliberation, I chose a classic pepperoni pizza with cheese. As soon as my pizza arrived, I could tell by just one look that it was going to be extraordinary! Not only did it look delicious but it smelled like heaven!

I took my first bite and wow, it was phenomenal! The thin crust was perfectly cooked and crispy around the edges while still having the perfect amount of chewiness in the center. The sauce had just enough sweetness to make it balanced and tasty. But what really put this pizza over the top was the cheese – it was gooey and flavorful without being too greasy or heavy.

And let’s not forget about the toppings – they were fresh and flavorful, plus they added great texture to each bite. Detroit Eats really understands how to make a great pizza!

Overall, Detroit Eats has some of the best pizza in Boynton Beach! If you’re ever in town, you must stop by for a slice (or two). You won’t regret it!

#6 PIZZA ROX

When I first stepped into PIZZA ROX, I was greeted with a warm smile and an even warmer slice of cheesy goodness. The staff was friendly and the atmosphere was relaxed and inviting.

The menu had all the familiar classics like pepperoni, margherita, and Hawaiian – but it also boasted some unique creations that made my mouth water. I decided to go for the “Smokey Mountain Pizza” which featured smoked Gouda, smoky bacon, roasted red peppers, caramelized onions, and garlic cream sauce. It was heaven on a plate!

I washed it down with their house-made root beer float made with rich vanilla ice cream and finished off with a hand-tossed cinnamon sugar cookie pizza. Talk about delicious!

All in all, PIZZA ROX really lives up to its name as “the best pizza in Boynton Beach.” The atmosphere is cozy and comforting, the staff is friendly and helpful, and the food is truly out of this world. Don’t miss out – head over to PIZZA ROX today for an unforgettable pizza experience!

#7 Rudi’s Pizza

The first thing that struck me about Rudi’s Pizza was the inviting atmosphere. From the moment you walk in, you can smell the delicious aroma of freshly-baked pizza and feel the energy of the people enjoying it. The seating area is comfortable enough that you can linger and savor every bite.

The menu at Rudi’s Pizza is abundant with delicious offerings, from classic pies like cheese and pepperoni to deluxe masterpiece pizzas such as the Seafood Delight or Meat Lover’s Dream. I opted for a traditional slice of Cheese Pizza, which was cooked to perfection with a crispy crust and gooey topping. The generous portion size meant that there was more than enough to satisfy my hunger!

Rudi’s Pizza really goes out of their way to make sure their customers are happy. They offer great specials throughout the week and have an impressive selection of craft beers on tap. On top of that, they provide exceptional customer service, with staff always willing to answer any questions and help make your experience enjoyable.

After experiencing Rudi’s Pizza firsthand, I am confident in declaring them as having some of the best pizza in Boynton Beach! Here you will find fantastic food combined with fun atmosphere and great customer service – I highly recommend this joint if you’re ever looking for an amazing meal out!

#8 Josie’s Ristorante

I was skeptical at first as I had heard mixed reviews from locals, but after tasting their signature margherita pizza, I can confidently say that Josie’s Ristorante has perfected the art of pizza making. The dough was light and fluffy and the tomatoes were the freshest I’ve ever tasted.

The atmosphere of the restaurant is quite charming. It’s a cozy spot that feels more like an Italian family home than a restaurant. The friendly wait staff make you feel welcomed and taken care of – they even showed me how to order like a local!

If you’re looking for amazingly fresh pizza in Boynton Beach, then look no further than Josie’s Ristorante – it truly is one of the best pizzerias I have visited!

If you’re willing to go an extra 5 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Lake Worth!

#9 Cafe Frankie’s

The pizza joint is located off the beaten path, which only seems to add to its charm. When you walk in, the decor is classic Italian-style – from the checkered tablecloths to the framed photographs of Italy. I felt like I was in a real pizzeria in Rome!

But as with any review worth its weight, it’s all about the pizza. And let me tell you, Cafe Frankie’s could easily compete with some of the best pizzerias I’ve ever visited. The crust was perfectly thin and crispy, just how I like it.

One thing that really stood out about their pizzas was the amount of creative toppings they offered. They had everything from artichoke hearts and roasted garlic to spicy pepperoni and ham & pineapple! Plus, all their ingredients are locally sourced – so you can trust they’re fresh and delicious!

Overall, if you’re looking for great pizza in Boynton Beach, look no further than Cafe Frankie’s. It’s definitely one of my favorite places for pizza!

#10 Two Tomatoes

Their classic Margherita Pizza is a delight. The cheese melts in your mouth and the tomatoes are perfectly juicy. Not too many restaurants get their sauce right, but Two Tomatoes definitely nailed it.

I’m also a fan of their special Pepperoni Pizza. With its lightly spiced, crispy pepperoni and creamy cheese, it’s truly indulgent! Not to mention that the pizza dough is incredibly light and airy – made with just the right amount of yeast to make every slice melt in your mouth with every bite.

Additionally, no matter what specialty pizza you get from Two Tomatoes, you won’t be disappointed – they use only high-quality ingredients and their cookstaff prepares each pizza with care and expertise. In fact, I think I can confidently say that this restaurant serves the best pizza in Boynton Beach!

#11 Motor City Pizza & Coney

The atmosphere at Motor City Pizza & Coney is truly unique. It’s like stepping into a time portal. From the vintage decor to the classic rock playing in the background, it’s like you’ve gone back in time and you’re hanging out with your best friends in an old-school pizzeria.

The pizza is every bit as amazing as you’d expect from a place claiming to have some of the best pizza around Boynton Beach. The crust is perfectly crispy, with just enough chewiness to give it a great texture. The sauce is flavorful and really stands out against the cheese and other toppings. And they don’t skimp on toppings–each slice is generously topped with your favorite ingredients.

You can also find some tasty coney dogs – Detroit style hot dogs – at Motor City Pizza & Coney. These come smothered in chili, onions and cheese, giving them that extra classic flavor that I can only get when I am visiting Detroit or eating at this great restaurant in Boynton Beach.

It’s clear that Motor City Pizza & Coney is one of the best pizza places around Boynton Beach! I highly recommend trying all their delicious food if you get the chance!

#12 Marco’s Pizza

My experience with this restaurant was nothing short of spectacular. The moment I stepped through the door, I knew I had stumbled upon something special. The inviting atmosphere and friendly staff were a great start to the evening.

I ordered the classic cheese pizza and took my first bite – it was love at first sight! The perfect balance of cheesy goodness and crunchy crust created a heavenly combination that left me feeling satisfied.

The menu also included a variety of unique options such as Thai-style chicken pizza, BBQ pulled pork pizza, and Mexican-style spinach and chorizo pizza. All were delicious but the classic cheese pie won by a landslide!

The price point was reasonable, making Marco’s Pizza an accessible treat for everyone in Boynton Beach looking for some truly amazing pizza. Even better, the staff were attentive and accommodating – they even suggested some great topping combinations if I wanted to switch things up on my next visit (which I definitely will!).

In conclusion, Marco’s Pizza is the best pizza in Boynton Beach. If you’re looking for a delicious meal without breaking the bank, then head over to Marco’s now! You won’t regret it!